Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to
0:02
60 Minutes ad-free right now. Join
0:05
Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or
0:07
on Apple Podcasts. Do you
0:09
ever wonder where all your money went? Like
0:11
every single time you look at your bank
0:13
account? Honestly, it's probably
0:16
all those subscriptions. I
0:18
felt that way, too, until I got Rocket Money. Rocket
0:21
Money helped me see all the
0:23
subscriptions I'm paying for. And it
0:25
was eye opening between streaming services,
0:27
fitness apps, delivery services. It all
0:29
adds up so quickly. Rocket
0:31
Money is a personal finance app that
0:34
finds and cancels your unwanted subscriptions, monitors
0:36
your spending, and helps lower your bills.
0:39
Rocket Money has over 5 million users and has
0:41
helped save its members an average of $720 a
0:43
year with over $500 million in canceled subscriptions. Stop
0:49
wasting money on things you don't use. Cancel
0:52
your unwanted subscriptions
0:55
by going to
0:57
rocketmoney.com/Wondery. That's rocketmoney.com/Wondery.
1:00
rocketmoney.com/Wondery. We
1:02
all have busy lives these days
1:04
and we don't want to waste
1:06
a day recovering after a night
1:08
out. That's why Z-biotics is the
1:10
answer we've all been looking for.
1:13
Their probiotic was invented by PhD
1:15
scientists to tackle rough mornings after
1:17
drinking. Here's how it works. When
1:19
you drink, alcohol gets converted into
1:21
a toxic by-product in the gut.
1:23
It's this by-product, not dehydration. That's
1:25
to blame for your rough next
1:27
day. Pre-alcohol produces an enzyme to
1:29
break this by-product down. This is
1:31
a proactive go
1:42
to zbionics.com/CBS to get 15% off
1:44
your first order when
1:47
you use code CBS at checkout. Z-Bionics
1:49
is backed with a 100% money back
1:51
guarantee. So
1:53
if you're unsatisfied for any reason,
1:55
they'll refund your money. and
2:01
use the code CBS at checkout
2:03
for 15% off. Thank
2:06
you, Cbiotics, for sponsoring this episode
2:08
and our good times. The
2:18
United Nations says a catastrophic
2:20
humanitarian crisis is unfolding in
2:23
Gaza. But
2:25
Israel has barred journalists from
2:27
independently accessing the Gaza Strip.
2:30
We have mass casualties coming in and waves at
2:32
a hospital. That's happening at least three
2:34
or four times a night. In one night? So,
2:37
you know, a regular day for me was seeing
2:39
children with shrapnel injuries I
2:41
have never in my life seen before. Death
2:44
happening in a fully treatable situation because
2:46
the supplies are not available. Getting
2:51
into China is all but impossible
2:53
for most Western journalists. This
2:55
is the financial and economic capital
2:58
of China. But when the
3:00
U.S. Ambassador Nicholas Burns invited us
3:02
to come for a visit and an
3:04
interview, we were granted visas.
3:07
Is it our most competitive
3:09
relationship in the world right now? This
3:12
is the most important, most
3:14
competitive, and most dangerous relationship
3:16
that the United States has in the world right now, and
3:19
I will, I think for the next decade or so. I'm
3:24
Leslie Stahl. I'm Bill Whitaker. I'm
3:26
Anderson Cooper. I'm Sharon Alphonse. I'm
3:28
John Wertheim. I'm
3:31
Cecilia Vega. I'm Scott Pelli. Those
3:33
stories and more tonight on 60 Minutes.
3:43
Well-being isn't just a once-a-year
3:45
moment. It's a personal, multifaceted
3:47
journey. Get closer to the
3:49
best you all year round with Audible. Audible
3:51
offers a rich variety of content that gets
3:53
you closer to the voices and sounds that
3:55
can change your life, like bedtime
3:58
stories with Evo Longoria and Sturtis. Sterling
4:00
K. Brown, or best sellers
4:02
such as Atomic Havoc by James
4:04
Clear. As an Audible member, you
4:06
can choose one title a month
4:08
to keep from their growing selection
4:10
of included audiobooks, Audible originals, and
4:12
podcasts. New members can try Audible
4:14
free for 30 days. Visit
4:17
audible.com/wonderepod or text
4:19
wonderepod to 500-500 to try Audible free for
4:24
30 days. Listen to the 48
4:26
hours podcast for shocking murder cases
4:28
and compelling real life dramas from
4:32
one of television's
4:34
most watched true crime shows. Go
4:37
behind the scenes of each episode with
4:39
award winning CBS News correspondence and free
4:42
podcasts. The show is a series of shows
4:44
that are available on the website. The show
4:46
is a series of shows that are available
4:49
on the website. Go behind the scenes
4:51
of each episode with award winning CBS
4:53
News correspondence and producers in
4:56
Postmortem, a weekly deep dive.
4:59
Listen to 48 hours wherever
5:01
you get your podcasts. When
5:06
the terrorist group Hamas unleashed its
5:08
barbaric attack inside Israel last October,
5:11
the response by the Israeli government was
5:13
swift. The
5:15
Hamas launched thousands of troops, tanks,
5:18
and more than 45,000 bombs into
5:20
Gaza, decimating entire cities. The
5:23
Hamas run Gaza Ministry of Health says
5:25
more than 29,000 people have been killed
5:27
and nearly
5:29
2 million displaced. Numbers
5:31
many in the Israeli press and the
5:33
United Nations are reporting. Israel
5:36
has barred journalists from independently
5:38
accessing the Gaza Strip to
5:41
find the longstanding precedent
5:43
of allowing reporters into war zones. Aid
5:46
workers say a catastrophic humanitarian
5:48
crisis is unfolding in Gaza,
5:51
but reporting on it has been challenging.
5:53
So we asked aid workers, including two Americans, to
5:56
share their view from inside Gaza over the last
5:58
decade. last 142
6:00
days. A warning? It is difficult to watch. This
6:08
was the scene at Nassar Hospital in southern
6:10
Gaza in late January. For
6:17
weeks, the hospital had been surrounded by fighting.
6:22
But another battle played out inside
6:25
its crowded corridor. Doctors
6:28
and nurses, short on supplies and
6:30
beds, knelt on the floor as they
6:32
tried to save bombing victims. Deeper
6:35
in the hospital, we saw Dr.
6:37
Narita Med, a critical care specialist
6:39
from Pennsylvania. Our
6:41
CBS producer, based in Gaza, shot
6:43
this video. He has a small
6:45
amount of free fluid. His
6:48
doctor, Med, checked on the young victims of
6:50
an airstrike she treated the night before. This
6:54
13-year-old boy did not survive. The
6:56
nurses noticed his eyes. Pupils are
6:58
fixed and dilated, which is a sign
7:00
of brain death. The
7:04
Gaza Ministry of Health estimates 12,000 children
7:07
have died here since the war began. There's
7:10
no room for that. We met
7:12
Dr. Med days after she left
7:14
Gaza, exhausted after working a two-week
7:16
stretch at Nassar. We have
7:18
mass casualties coming in and waves at a hospital.
7:21
That's happening at least three or four times a night. In
7:23
one night. So, you know,
7:25
regular day for me was seeing children
7:28
with shrapnel injuries I
7:30
have never in my life seen before, with
7:33
traumatic brain injury, death
7:35
happening in a fully treatable situation because
7:38
the supplies are not available. Dr.
7:40
Med is the daughter of Bangladeshi immigrants.
7:43
She grew up in Philadelphia and works
7:45
at a hospital there. She
7:47
is also the medical director of Med
7:49
Global, a U.S.-based NGO
7:51
that trains local healthcare workers
7:53
in disaster and conflict zones.
7:57
39 years old, she's worked in a half-dozen...
8:00
in war zones, including six trips to
8:02
Ukraine in the last two years. She
8:05
told us supply and medicine shortages have
8:07
deepened the suffering in Gaza. It's
8:10
basic medications. It's pain
8:13
medication. There are people getting limbs
8:16
amputated without any anesthesia. That's
8:21
what we're seeing on a day-to-day basis. I
8:24
can tell you that things that
8:26
we have put into the pipeline
8:28
to get to Gaza can often
8:30
take weeks to months. Weeks
8:32
to months. And you need them yesterday.
8:36
How does what you're seeing in Gaza compare
8:38
to what you've seen in these other war zones
8:40
and conflicts? It
8:43
is incomparable, I would
8:45
say. I
8:49
don't think I've seen this many children
8:53
affected in any of the other war zones I've ever been
8:55
to. I don't think
8:57
I've seen this many people squeezed in a
8:59
small area without any ability to
9:02
leave. I
9:04
don't think I've been this close to the
9:06
sound of missile strikes with
9:09
the house shaking or the
9:11
hospital shaking while I'm trying to operate
9:13
in the ICU. How do you
9:15
function and operate when you can
9:18
hear gunfire and explosions at
9:20
your doorstep? We go into
9:23
medical mission mode. So
9:25
bombs going off or not, we
9:28
are absolutely focused on what's in front
9:30
of us. Is it terrifying? Yes,
9:32
of course. Do
9:34
we think about it after the fact? Absolutely.
9:37
There are hospitals that are under siege. This
9:39
happened with Shifa Hospital. It
9:41
happened with Nasser Hospital, Al Amal Hospital.
9:44
Just to name a few. The UN
9:46
reports more than 300 health care workers have
9:49
been killed since the war began. In
9:52
late January, Dr. Ahmed and four
9:54
of her colleagues evacuated Nasser. Ten
9:58
days ago, Israeli troops were sent to the U.S. stormed
10:00
the hospital, claiming
10:03
Hamas was hiding inside. Patients,
10:06
staff, and thousands sheltering in the
10:08
hospital spilled onto the street. You
10:11
know that the IDF is accused Hamas of
10:13
hiding and operating in these hospitals. Did
10:16
you see that at all? I
10:18
can really just talk about what I know. And what I
10:20
know is that the healthcare
10:22
catastrophe in these hospitals, that's what
10:24
I saw. Even
10:27
as explosions surrounded the hospital last week,
10:31
teams from the World Health Organization made
10:33
their way in, negotiating
10:36
through the dark to evacuate 32
10:39
critical patients, some of them children.
10:42
Aid workers say there are still
10:44
patients and staff inside the hospital
10:46
with no running water or
10:48
electricity. The international humanitarian
10:50
law is clear. Healthcare
10:53
workers, humanitarian ambulances,
10:55
and hospitals should be respected
10:57
and protected in all situations.
11:00
But unfortunately, this is not
11:02
the case in Gaza. Nabel
11:06
Farsik is the spokesperson for the
11:08
Palestinian Red Crescent. It's
11:11
part of the international Red Cross. We
11:14
met her in this call center in
11:16
Ramallah in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. Here,
11:20
operators dispatch emergency workers in Gaza 50
11:22
miles away. This
11:29
is a recording of one of the calls the
11:31
Red Crescent responded to the week we were there.
11:34
On January 29th, the Israeli military ordered parts of
11:37
Gaza City to evacuate. So
11:40
15-year-old Leanne Hamada and her family piled
11:44
into their car to try and get to safety.
11:49
They're shooting at us, she tells the operator.
11:52
The tank is next to me. Are you hiding?
11:54
Yes, in the car. We're next to the tank.
11:57
Okay, okay, okay, okay, okay, okay, okay, okay, okay.
12:00
Then the line goes dead. When
12:07
the operator called back, a
12:10
child answers. Six-year-old Hen
12:12
Rajab, the girl's cousin. The
12:17
tank is next to me, she says. I'm
12:21
so scared, please come. Please
12:24
call someone to come and take me. The
12:28
red crescent says this is the ambulance
12:30
they sent. It was
12:32
discovered along with the bodies of
12:34
two medics 12 days after they were
12:36
dispatched when Israeli Defense Forces left the
12:39
area. Hen Rajab
12:41
was also killed. The six-year-old's body
12:43
was found inside this car, alongside
12:46
five members of her family. The
12:49
IDF told us that the incident is
12:51
still under review, but has accused
12:53
Hamas in the past of using
12:55
ambulances to transport its fighters. The
12:58
story of Hen, it's not the
13:00
only story. It's absolutely dozens of
13:03
calls we're getting since the beginning
13:05
of the war in Gaza where
13:07
we fail helpless because we are
13:09
completely denied access to many areas
13:11
in Gaza to only provide our
13:14
emergency medical services. So what you're
13:16
describing is these people can't leave,
13:18
it's not safe for them to
13:20
leave and you can't get to
13:23
them. Exactly. This
13:25
is what Hen Rajab and her family were
13:27
trying to escape. We obtained
13:30
this video from a UN worker who
13:32
was with one of the first teams
13:34
allowed into northern Gaza. Across
13:37
this apocalyptic landscape, images show
13:39
two-thirds of Gaza has been
13:41
flattened. Satellite
13:44
images reveal how densely populated
13:46
the 25-mile strip was before
13:48
the war. Today,
13:50
most of the nearly two million
13:53
residents displaced from their home have
13:55
evacuated to the south. Here,
13:58
40 or more people. The whole
14:00
pack into a room at a
14:02
makeshift shelters. hundreds share one bathroom.
14:05
Those who can't find space. In
14:07
the shelter, settle in the sprawling sand
14:09
kids of Gaza's ten city in Rafah,
14:11
on the border with Egypt. For.
14:13
Gardens There is no way out. Whereas.
14:17
The arrest border crossing if he
14:19
were travelling between dogs and Israeli
14:21
would come through this terminal. And.
14:23
October seventh Hamas storm the terminal.
14:26
You can see the damage all
14:28
around Us. Obviously the terminal has
14:30
been closed since. As now there
14:33
is only one border crossing from
14:35
Israel into Gaza and deaths for
14:37
humanitarian aid. That
14:39
crossing is known as Kerem Shalom. The
14:42
idea of would not allow us to
14:44
zoom this. Before the war,
14:46
more than five hundred trucks carrying goods
14:48
came. Through the crossing every day. To.
14:51
Day on average about eighty five
14:54
trucks obeyed get through. What
14:56
are the top three things that you
14:58
need? Scott Anderson is trying to get
15:00
any a that does come in distributed.
15:03
Anderson is an army that from
15:06
Iowa who did two tours in
15:08
Afghanistan for lot like of. Sixty.
15:11
Minutes First met him in Gaza
15:13
in Twenty Four see when he
15:15
says as the Deputy Director of
15:17
Operations for the Un Relief and
15:19
Works Agency known as unruffled Five
15:21
Hour Years after the war began
15:24
in October, Anderson retired. Return to
15:26
the job is you know as
15:28
American journalist we can't get. In
15:30
there. What is it The see? what? is
15:32
it like every day. What you mostly see
15:34
from people everyday for and fried foods are
15:36
trying to stay warm and try to find
15:38
some use. Bathroom. And that's
15:41
what people wise consist of
15:43
to very much a pressure
15:45
cooker environment can feel neared
15:47
stamps. There is no commercial.
15:49
Food available in Gaza and the
15:51
Un says seventy percent of people
15:53
don't have access to clean. Water
15:56
since early two. Million Dollars
15:58
as are dependent on a. for
16:00
all their food and water. Last
16:03
week, UNICEF reported that one in
16:06
six children under the age of
16:08
two in Northern Gaza is severely
16:10
malnourished. Everybody's reliant on
16:12
the international community, the international humanitarian
16:14
community, to provide their basic
16:16
necessities. In an ideal world,
16:18
there'd be 600 trucks a day coming
16:21
into Gaza. You're nowhere close to that number. We're
16:23
nowhere close to that number. What's the problem, is
16:25
to hold up the inspections? You have two governments
16:27
in the UN, and a lot of people involved.
16:30
There are the security inspections of the
16:32
goods, which I understand. The Israelis have
16:34
said the problems on the UN side.
16:36
I would say that is entirely not
16:38
true. It's not
16:41
just the UN. Every day, there's a
16:43
couple hours where nothing moves. And
16:45
that's not us. There's just nothing to get. For
16:48
70 years, UNRWA has been the
16:50
largest aid organization in Gaza, providing
16:52
food, education, and
16:55
medical care. But to
16:57
its critics, including some Israelis, the
16:59
agency is corrupt. Last
17:03
month, Israel accused 12 of UNRWA's
17:05
13,000 employees of
17:08
helping to plan and carry out the
17:10
October 7th attacks. The
17:12
UN fired those employees. But
17:15
16 countries, including the US,
17:17
have stopped funding the organization
17:20
while investigations are ongoing. I'm
17:23
shocked that somebody associated with the UN could
17:25
do that. That's what, unfortunately, throughout
17:27
history, many individuals have
17:29
betrayed organizations that they work
17:31
for, betrayed the values. We
17:33
do uphold UN values, humanitarian principles.
17:37
And we are responding to the best of our
17:39
ability in Gaza right now. If UNRWA
17:41
collapses, who would
17:43
do the work that you're doing? There's nobody that can
17:46
do the work we do. UNRWA
17:48
is the backbone of the operation. And
17:50
without us, the operation will collapse. On
17:54
Thursday, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
17:56
said he wants to completely shut
17:58
down UNRWA. Can only the
18:00
first time. Netanyahu outlined his plan
18:03
for Gaza after. The. War which.
18:05
Included. Allowing the Israeli
18:07
military to operate in Gaza
18:09
indefinitely. for double. The idea
18:12
has begun in. Internal review of
18:14
it's shortcomings before and during
18:17
the October Seventh Attacks. Amid
18:19
ongoing negotiations, a member of Israel's
18:21
war cabinet announced it is the
18:23
one hundred and thirty four hostages
18:25
are not home. In two weeks,
18:27
Israel will launch a. ground. defenses
18:29
in Rafah were more than a
18:31
million and. A half people are
18:34
sheltering less Urged his real to
18:36
refrain morning it could worsen and
18:38
already had a straw thick situation.
18:47
Survivors back and so is on fire. The
18:49
only official about the far south them we
18:51
have a twist a new go. The were
18:53
a suburb horrified by it or as. Listed
18:57
on Fire The official Survivor podcast thirty
18:59
Seven or twenty Years Wherever he gives
19:01
you. Hi,
19:09
Hi, this is is Jill Schlesinger, CBS News
19:11
Business Analyst, certified financial planner and
19:13
host of the the Money Watch
19:16
Podcast. This This is the show
19:18
where your money is is not scary
19:20
and it's not boring. It It is a
19:22
show that's all about you. It's your
19:24
questions that make it it
19:26
possible for me to provide
19:28
unconventional and entertaining insights on
19:30
your money and maybe more
19:32
importantly, on your life. I'm
19:34
going be your financial coach,
19:36
someone who brings common sense
19:38
and an insider's perspective on how
19:41
to manage your money and your
19:43
emotions. And I promise we are are going
19:45
to have a little bit of fun along the way.
19:48
Have a a question from retirement to
19:50
career changes to college funding? Just us
19:52
an an email at askjill
19:54
at jillonmoney.com. Follow Money
19:56
Watch wherever you get your podcasts.
19:59
You can listen ad on the
20:01
Amazon Music or Wondery app. American
20:04
CEOs used to swoon over
20:07
China. Its vast pool
20:09
of consumers has been a magnetic
20:11
draw for decades. But
20:13
doing business there has become so
20:15
fraught and risky with
20:17
intellectual property theft and
20:20
an expanded espionage law used
20:22
to intimidate the business community
20:25
that US companies have pressed the
20:27
pause button. On top
20:29
of that, the US-China relationship has
20:32
become contentious due partly
20:34
to Beijing's belligerent activity toward
20:36
Taiwan and in the South
20:38
China Sea, the
20:40
balloon spy incident of last year,
20:43
and the list goes on. Making
20:46
matters worse, the Chinese economy
20:48
has hit a wall. Export
20:51
growth is slowing. The country's
20:53
drowning in debt and
20:55
youth unemployment has soared. Looking
20:59
into China to tell that story
21:01
is all but impossible for most
21:04
Western journalists. But
21:06
when the US Ambassador Nicholas Burns
21:08
invited us to come for a
21:10
visit and an interview, we
21:12
were granted visas. We spoke
21:14
with him at his residence in
21:16
Beijing. More
21:18
money is leaving China for
21:21
the first time in 40 years than
21:23
is coming in from American,
21:25
from Japanese, European, and Korean
21:27
investors. Now, why is that and
21:29
how much of a problem is that for
21:32
them? That's a real problem for
21:34
this economy. They're 1.4 billion people here. They've
21:36
got to keep it growing. And
21:39
foreign capital's important. US- How
21:44
much of a problem is that for them?
21:46
That's a real problem for this economy.
21:48
They're 1.4 billion people here. They've got to
21:51
keep it growing. And foreign
21:53
capital's important. You ask why. I
21:56
think there's been a contradiction in the messaging
21:59
from the government. government here in China to the
22:01
rest of the world. On the one hand, they
22:03
say, we're open for business. We want American, Japanese
22:06
businesses here. But on the other
22:08
hand, they've raided six
22:12
or seven American businesses since last
22:14
March. Rated? Rated. They've
22:16
gone into American companies and shut them
22:19
down and made accusations we
22:21
believe are very much unwarranted. The
22:24
American companies include Bain &
22:26
Company and the Minsk
22:29
Group, a company that does due
22:31
diligence for other companies that might
22:33
want to invest here, was raided
22:35
last year. Five of
22:37
its Chinese employees were taken into
22:39
custody and they're still there. Another
22:43
firm, Cat Vision, was raided. Plus
22:45
the message wasn't loud and clear.
22:48
A report about it was put
22:50
on state-run television. It
22:53
accused Western consulting firms
22:55
of espionage and stealing
22:58
national security and military
23:00
secrets. They want the investment to
23:02
come back and they're raiding
23:04
American companies. They
23:06
passed an amendment to their counter
23:08
espionage law. It's written in such
23:10
a general way that it could be
23:13
that American business people could
23:15
be accused of espionage for
23:18
engaging in practices that are
23:20
perfectly legal and acceptable everywhere
23:22
else in the world, collecting
23:24
data to due diligence so that
23:26
you can decide whether you want to invest in
23:28
a company or form a joint venture. What
23:31
do you think the Chinese are afraid that
23:33
these companies are going to find
23:36
out, these due diligence companies? What
23:39
are they worrying about? I think they want to control
23:41
data about the Chinese people,
23:44
about Chinese companies. And
23:46
so that I think is at the heart of
23:48
the problem with those American companies operating in that
23:50
sphere. Senator Burns
23:52
told us that's just one of the concerns
23:54
he hears about. There is
23:57
still intellectual property theft from
23:59
American companies. companies here. Is every American
24:01
company afraid of that? Yes.
24:05
All kinds of U.S. companies began flocking
24:07
to China in the early 1980s after
24:09
the country opened
24:12
to the West under then-leader
24:14
Deng Xiaoping. And
24:16
now U.S. banks operate here.
24:19
Walmart has more than 300 stores
24:22
across the country. Companies
24:25
here in Shanghai can buy Levi's,
24:28
browse in an Apple store, and
24:31
get a Caramel Frappuccino. Starbucks
24:34
has 6,000 stores in China, 1,000 stores
24:37
in Shanghai, and they want to
24:39
keep building because coffee, this
24:41
was a tea culture. For
24:43
hundreds of years, it's now becoming, at
24:45
least with the young Chinese, a coffee
24:48
culture. And they love Starbucks?
24:50
They love Starbucks, and I'll buy you
24:52
a cappuccino. I'll take one. Thank you.
24:55
Boeing's here. So is Tesla,
24:58
Pfizer, Chevron, Intel.
25:01
But while some businesses are thriving,
25:03
many of the foreign companies are
25:05
worried about the business climate under
25:07
President Xi Jinping. If you
25:10
track China from the death of Mao
25:13
to the opening of China to
25:15
the world, we've seen a
25:17
closing of sorts. We've seen a centralization of
25:20
power of the party. We've
25:22
seen increased repression of
25:24
the people of China here. That's
25:27
a very significant trend just over the
25:29
last decade. With Xi?
25:31
Under his leadership. Part of
25:33
that trend includes President
25:35
Xi's reversing many of
25:37
the market reforms that
25:39
unleashed China's economic miracle.
25:42
They've been growing over 40 years, the fastest
25:44
growth rate in recorded economic history. 8,
25:47
9, 10, 11% growth rates. They've
25:50
lifted 800 million people out of poverty. But
25:53
what's happening is that growth rate is slowing down. Most
25:56
economists are now projecting there'll be a 2%, 3%, 4% growth.
26:00
Maybe even lower in the next decade.
26:02
Can they support their society if it's that low?
26:04
That's going to be difficult for them. If
26:06
there was so much explosive growth,
26:10
if so many people were lifted
26:12
out of poverty, why is he turning
26:14
away from what worked? Well,
26:16
I think they've got maybe competing
26:18
priorities. The government here
26:21
in China certainly wants the economy to grow,
26:24
but they also have a national security mindset.
26:26
They want to control data. But
26:29
that's more important, the control,
26:31
right, than economic growth.
26:34
It seems that way. I think it's open for
26:36
debate. You're hearing, we are
26:38
hearing, both messages. It
26:40
sounds as if you yourself don't
26:42
know the direction it's going. What
26:45
I perceive here is that
26:47
the greater energy is with those on the
26:50
national security side of
26:52
the government of China. Good morning. How are you?
26:55
On a train trip from Beijing to Shanghai,
26:57
the ambassador pointed out that
26:59
in the decades before President
27:01
Xi, China powered
27:03
its economy by investing in
27:06
these high-speed trains, roads,
27:10
factories and skyscrapers
27:12
that light up Shanghai, the
27:15
financial capital of China. But
27:18
under President Xi, China lost more than
27:20
$120 billion worth
27:22
of long-term foreign investments
27:24
last year because of the weakening
27:27
economy and the harsh government tactics
27:30
which have left American companies
27:32
uncertain of the future there.
27:34
There are a lot of American companies here. Have
27:37
a lot of them just picked up and left
27:39
because of this current business environment? You
27:42
know, that's interesting. Not many.
27:45
Not many. Not many. Why
27:47
not? China is the second largest economy in the world.
27:49
It's a big market. A
27:51
few American companies have left, but
27:54
most have stayed. Some American
27:56
companies are moving at least some
27:58
of their operations. to
28:00
Singapore, Vietnam, Mexico.
28:03
But they're not leaving China.
28:05
The market's so irresistible
28:08
to American business people.
28:10
It's gigantic. Maybe they're not
28:12
leaving, but they're not investing.
28:14
They're not making major investments until they can
28:17
see exactly where the government is
28:19
headed. Yet, because of the
28:21
1.4 billion potential
28:23
consumers, some companies,
28:25
like Disney, are increasing
28:28
their investment. It
28:32
recently expanded its Shanghai
28:34
Disneyland that they told us
28:36
is thriving. Aptar,
28:39
a $9 billion company headquartered
28:42
in Crystal Lake, Illinois,
28:44
is another American firm bucking the
28:47
trend of capital flight. President
28:50
of Aptar Asia, Shunhui
28:52
Gong, a Chinese-born U.S.
28:54
citizen, showed us around
28:57
one of their five manufacturing
28:59
sites in China. We are
29:01
manufacturing for some of the
29:03
largest U.S. brands, actually, the
29:05
U.S. consumer brands. This
29:07
factory makes the packaging and
29:09
dispensing devices for food, pharmaceutical,
29:12
and beauty products sold in
29:14
Asia. All of our
29:17
customers, like C&G, Laurier,
29:19
Esterloda, they're all here doing business.
29:22
Aptar, in China for nearly 30 years,
29:25
recently invested $60 million in a new factory.
29:30
Shunhui Gong says even in
29:32
a slowing economy, the company
29:34
is doing well. American
29:36
companies here, as the ambassador well
29:39
knows, are pausing or
29:41
cutting back on investment, but
29:43
not this firm. You're expanding.
29:45
Well, because we are
29:48
here for the long term and we
29:50
believe in the consumption power of the
29:52
rising middle class. It's 1.4 billion
29:55
people here. And imagine,
29:57
for example, health care. with
30:00
them, cosmetics and beauty and beverage,
30:02
all those sectors, packaged foods, these are
30:05
really the biggest markets. And
30:07
so we are very confident about
30:09
the long term. What does it
30:12
say about the confidence really
30:14
in the U.S.-China relationship?
30:17
It seems to say you
30:19
believe that things will what?
30:22
I'm asking, get better? That's
30:25
a great question for the ambassador. I
30:28
believe so, I hope so. You
30:30
know, we'll see. Actually, Byrne
30:33
says he's wary of the future, as
30:36
the fundamental rivalry and mistrust between
30:38
the U.S. and China is shaking
30:40
the confidence of the business world
30:43
and has pushed our relationship to
30:45
its lowest point in half a
30:48
century. Is it our
30:50
most competitive relationship in the world
30:52
right now? This is
30:54
the most important, most competitive
30:57
and most dangerous relationship that the United States has
30:59
in the world right now and will, I
31:01
think for the next decade or so. I
31:04
want to quote you back to you and tell
31:06
us what you meant. You
31:08
have said divorce is not an
31:10
option. Right. Our
31:13
two countries have to live together. And this I
31:15
think is the greatest tension in
31:18
the U.S.-China relationship. China
31:20
is our most significant competitor. And
31:23
at the same time, China is
31:25
our third largest trade partner, 750,000 American
31:27
jobs at stake. Agriculture.
31:32
China is the largest market for U.S.
31:34
agriculture. One fifth of all
31:36
of our export products from
31:38
agriculture are sent to China. That
31:40
was $40.9 billion last year. So
31:44
we can't afford really to have
31:46
a real break here. Well, it's complicated.
31:48
Some people are saying, well, we're so
31:51
competitive with China, we should end the economic relationship. Well,
31:53
the consequences of that would be 750,000 American families. wouldn't
32:01
be able to put dinner on the table. And
32:03
so this makes for
32:05
an extraordinarily difficult balancing act in
32:07
my job. You're a well-linder
32:09
brother. I've never thought of myself
32:11
that way, but high wire, right? Well,
32:14
we have competing interests here. And
32:17
balancing those interests is the reality in
32:19
the U.S.-China relationship. We're going to compete.
32:21
We have to compete responsibly and keep
32:23
the peace between our countries. But
32:26
we also have to engage. More
32:29
about the balancing act and the
32:31
biggest economic problem in China today
32:34
when we come back. Family
32:58
members, victims, and colleagues for the most
33:00
comprehensive telling of who Robert Hanson really
33:02
was. Binge the entire series now. Agents
33:05
of Betrayal, the double life of Robert Hanson
33:07
is available on the Wondering app, Amazon Music,
33:09
or wherever you get your podcasts. Get
33:12
one of the most successful broadcasts
33:14
in television history on your schedule
33:17
with the 60 Minutes
33:19
podcast. Hard-hitting investigative reports, news,
33:21
and culture maker interviews, and
33:24
in-depth profiles are waiting for you
33:26
in every episode. Listen to 60
33:29
Minutes ad-free on Wondery Plus. One
33:38
in every five people in the world
33:40
is Chinese. China's population
33:42
is four times that of the
33:45
U.S., and the country is
33:47
vast, 3.7 million square miles. It
33:51
overlooks the Taiwan Strait, where
33:53
half the world's trade flows every
33:56
day, and is located about
33:58
100 miles away. from
34:00
Taiwan. President Xi
34:03
likes to say that the East is
34:05
rising, the West is declining. But
34:08
economically, the U.S. is thriving
34:10
compared to China. In
34:13
December, Moody's, the credit rating
34:15
agency, cut its outlook for
34:17
China to negative. And
34:20
it's facing a long-term demographic
34:22
bind, a decline in
34:24
the birth rate that experts say
34:26
is irreversible, meaning the
34:28
country is both aging and
34:30
shrinking. Ambassador Nicholas
34:33
Burns took us on a tour starting in
34:35
Beijing. The
34:41
ambassador and his wife Libby like
34:43
to take early morning walks through
34:45
a park near their residence. This
34:49
is a 600-year-old Ming Dynasty park called Ritan Park.
34:51
It's a place for a lot of retirees and
34:57
a lot of young people, and it's tremendously active. It's
35:02
where the locals come for their
35:04
early morning routines, like Tai Chi,
35:06
Yo-Yo Wing, and
35:12
Ping Pang. You
35:20
couldn't tell from these scenes that
35:23
China, where the COVID pandemic began, is
35:25
still emerging from
35:28
the trauma of President
35:30
Xi Jinping's oppressive zero-COVID
35:33
policy. Burns, 68,
35:35
a career diplomat who has
35:38
served in both Republican and
35:40
Democratic administrations, got
35:42
to China at the height
35:45
of the zero-COVID lockdowns and
35:47
quarantines. When my wife Libby and
35:49
I arrived here in early March of 2022,
35:51
we were quarantined in this
35:54
house for 21 days for three weeks.
35:56
Shanghai, a city of 26 million
35:58
people, was completely locked
36:01
down for 63 days. What
36:03
was that like in the city?
36:06
We had women who needed to give birth and we had
36:08
to find a way to get them to the hospital. We
36:11
had Americans who wanted to get out but
36:13
had to find a way out of their
36:15
locked compounds to the airport.
36:17
So zero COVID worked for a while.
36:20
In 20 and 21, they had very low or
36:22
relatively lower infection rates. But by
36:25
2022, it had really
36:27
divided this society. It
36:29
set off rare widespread protests.
36:32
Then in December of 2022, President
36:35
Xi ended the policy
36:37
abruptly. The last thing
36:39
this government is gonna accept here is volatility.
36:42
Volatility is something Jorg Woodka,
36:45
a German businessman who's lived
36:47
and worked in China for
36:49
over 30 years, hadn't seen
36:51
since the Tiananmen Square uprising
36:53
in 1989. He
36:57
represents BASF, the world's
36:59
largest chemical producer. You
37:02
have said this is a
37:04
PTSD country, post-traumatic stress disorder
37:06
country. What do you mean? Well,
37:09
everybody has been traumatized by the lockdowns that
37:12
took place in many cities across China. And
37:14
the kind of messaging that came out of
37:17
the leadership, it's for your own safety. And
37:19
then the lockdown was lifted. Actually, it was
37:22
more a capitulation from the government. The lockdown
37:24
basically left and like a tsunami- They said
37:26
they were wrong, we're gonna lift it? They
37:28
never said they were wrong. That's not the
37:30
system. Admit that they did something
37:32
wrong. And then you basically, like
37:34
a tsunami, COVID was rolling across the
37:36
country. After they lifted it? December,
37:39
January, I would say a billion people were
37:41
infected and certainly lots of
37:43
people died. Independent analysts
37:46
say that an estimated 1.4 million people
37:48
died. This
37:51
kind of environment really changes your attitude
37:53
towards life. And in business, we thought
37:55
we're gonna have a comeback story. And
37:57
we had a good couple of
37:59
weeks. and then the economy basically has
38:01
been flat since. You
38:03
know, after COVID in the West,
38:05
in the United States particularly, we
38:08
did have a huge quick rebound.
38:11
Why didn't it happen here? Well,
38:13
I think that COVID also has covered up
38:15
a couple of long-term problems that China has
38:17
been building up, for example, in the real
38:19
estate sector. We reported on
38:21
the real estate sector 10 years
38:23
ago, with astonishing sites like
38:25
this, of empty buildings
38:28
in city after city across the
38:30
country. This
38:32
is today, similar hollowed
38:35
out wastelands of unoccupied
38:37
and unfinished apartments known
38:39
as ghost cities. When
38:42
I was here 10 years ago, I
38:44
never expected to see these
38:46
buildings still here. But
38:49
was a housing bubble back then grew and
38:53
finally exploded. This
38:55
real estate crisis lies at the
38:58
heart of China's economic decline. Has
39:01
anybody counted up the number of
39:04
empty units? I mean, across the
39:06
whole country? Well, the whole of
39:08
Germany, we have 82 million people, could move in
39:10
here right away, 80 to
39:12
90 million apartments are empty. 80
39:15
to 90 million apartments
39:17
are empty. Right, unfinished.
39:20
Over the years, Chinese banks
39:23
readily loaned money to the
39:25
developers, as the building
39:27
boom created millions of jobs
39:29
and propelled China's growth. But
39:33
in 2020, the government under President
39:35
Xi clamped down on the rampant
39:37
borrowing, causing the major developers
39:39
to default on their loans and run
39:42
out of money. Look
39:44
at that, the facade isn't even finished.
39:47
He says they couldn't even afford to
39:49
take down the cranes. In
39:52
January, Evergrande, once China's largest
39:54
developer, was ordered to liquidate
39:57
its remaining assets. Left
40:00
in the lurch are millions of
40:02
Chinese citizens who bought these apartments
40:04
before they were built. The
40:07
developers owe their customers that paid
40:09
up to the magnitude of
40:11
US$1 trillion. So if
40:14
I did a down payment on
40:16
one of these apartments, will I
40:18
ever see that money? No,
40:20
you will not see the money. It's gone,
40:22
it's vanished. It's finished. So I mean, it's
40:25
really dramatic. Ten years ago,
40:27
we were told that this was the
40:29
way people put money down for their
40:32
nest day. Right. For their retirement home.
40:34
Is that still the case? The
40:36
66%, two-thirds of a family
40:39
household average wealth is
40:41
in an apartment. That loss
40:43
of wealth has depressed consumer
40:45
spending and dragged down the
40:48
economy. We wondered if
40:50
the people blamed President Xi for
40:52
that or for the COVID death.
40:55
But it was impossible for us to
40:57
gauge public opinion or if it even
40:59
matters. While no one from the
41:01
government would give us an interview, we
41:03
were able to learn, as Jorg Witka, who's
41:05
lived here for 30 years, told us, it's
41:09
not a good idea to bet against
41:11
the Chinese people. What are some of
41:13
the positive aspects of
41:16
the economy here? They do
41:18
have a strong manufacturing base
41:20
still. Well, the big part is we,
41:22
between the ears of people, the brains
41:24
of the Chinese entrepreneurs that actually made
41:26
this success story happen. China
41:28
is not really good in basic research, but
41:31
they are fantastic in development. They're world champion
41:33
in actually making products better, faster and cheaper.
41:35
Are they better? Yes,
41:38
they are in some areas. Our Chinese
41:40
competitors are breathing down our neck and
41:42
basically drive some of us out the market. For
41:45
instance, China now makes over 80% of all
41:47
the solar panels in the world. It
41:51
dominates the wind turbine market.
41:53
It's poised to overtake Japan
41:55
as the world's biggest exporter
41:57
of cars and more.
42:00
They're the leading trade partner of twice as
42:02
many countries in the world as
42:05
the United States. So they have global range.
42:07
They're the leading trade partner. With over 60
42:09
countries in the world. And
42:11
now, with heavy government subsidies,
42:13
it is fast becoming the
42:15
leader in electric vehicles. Last
42:18
quarter, the carmaker BYD
42:21
surpassed Tesla as the
42:23
best-selling EV maker in the
42:25
world. Shanghai-based NIO
42:27
is trying to break through
42:30
with high-tech innovations. In
42:33
December, the company unveiled a new battery
42:35
with a driving range of 620 miles,
42:39
more than 200 miles further
42:41
than Tesla's top-end model. William
42:47
Lee, the CEO and founder of
42:49
NIO, says its battery
42:51
swap technology allows owners to
42:53
swap out their depleted battery
42:55
for a fully charged one
42:57
in under three minutes. Exactly.
43:01
It's two and a half
43:03
minutes. Two and a half
43:05
minutes. Yes. We already installed
43:07
2,200 swap stations all
43:09
around China. China
43:14
is also developing a humanoid
43:17
robot industry. Look
43:20
at that. The loss of year is coming true. Alex
43:24
Gu is the founder and
43:26
CEO of Fourier Intelligence. Last
43:29
year, he launched the GR1. Arm,
43:32
you can swing the arm. Yeah, you see?
43:34
Oh, look at the fingers. Oh,
43:36
my word. Can
43:39
you play the piano? Yeah, future.
43:41
Definitely. Also in
43:43
the future, he says, the robots
43:45
could provide health care for
43:48
China's rapidly aging population. Maybe
43:51
we can, for example, we can
43:53
remotely control such kind of robots
43:55
and help my grandpa,
43:58
for example. Yeah, I think. President
44:01
Xi, who visited this company
44:03
last year, has called for
44:05
the mass production of humanoids
44:07
by 2025. In
44:11
his annual New Year's speech, he
44:13
talked about the country's economic woes
44:16
and for the first time acknowledged
44:18
the high unemployment rate. Still,
44:21
he has laid out a long-term
44:23
goal of doubling China's economy by
44:25
2035 and surpassing the
44:29
West in technology. Our
44:31
companies and tech experts are
44:33
competing on AI and biotech
44:35
and quantum mathematics. All
44:38
those technological advances will
44:40
lead to a new generation
44:42
of military technology. Our two
44:44
militaries are vying for military supremacy.
44:47
Who's going to be the most powerful and
44:49
the most important strategic part of the world,
44:51
which is the Indo-Pacific. President
44:54
Biden and Xi met in
44:56
San Francisco in November in
44:59
hopes of re-establishing military communications
45:01
between our two countries, which
45:04
China had cut off. I
45:06
think we're back to a more settled
45:08
and stable relationship between the two countries,
45:10
but it's been a rollercoaster. The
45:12
low point, he says, was the
45:14
spy balloon incident last year. But
45:17
there's also been the buildup of military
45:19
bases in the South China Sea. The
45:23
increase of air sorties near
45:25
Taiwan and the buzzing
45:27
of U.S. military planes. Do
45:29
you see a lowering of the temperature
45:31
in the South China Sea? No.
45:35
And that's a problem. You don't. And
45:37
then in Taiwan, following Speaker Pelosi's
45:39
visit, we've seen now for 16 months
45:41
a much higher rate of Chinese
45:44
both air activity and naval activity.
45:46
That's very intimidating, meant
45:48
to intimidate the Taiwan authorities. They
45:52
haven't pulled back on that. And I think
45:54
ultimately they want to become and overtake the
45:56
United States as the dominant
45:58
country globally. and we don't want
46:01
that to happen. We don't want to live in a world
46:04
where the Chinese are the dominant country. When
46:06
the Cold War ended, we
46:09
all thought our system had won. Their
46:13
system failed. Our system rose
46:15
up. Now he's
46:17
come back and said, no, no,
46:19
the communist system's the right way. I
46:22
guess we didn't bury that after all. It's
46:26
interesting to compare the old Cold War
46:28
with this time. What
46:30
distinguishes this time versus the
46:32
old Cold War, the Soviet Union
46:34
had a strong military and nuclear
46:36
weapons. It had a very
46:39
weak economy, which in no way
46:41
competed with ours. China's
46:43
economy is very strong.
46:46
We're dealing with an adversary,
46:48
a competitor in China, stronger
46:51
than the Soviet Union was in
46:53
the 1940s, 50s, 60s, 70s, and 80s. So
46:56
if that was a Cold War, what are you calling
46:58
this? It's a competition
47:01
of ideas, a battle of
47:04
ideas. Our idea,
47:06
America's big idea of
47:08
a democratic society and human freedom versus
47:11
China's idea that a communist state
47:14
is stronger than a democracy, we don't believe
47:16
that. So there's
47:18
a battle here as to whose ideas
47:21
should lead the world, and we believe those
47:23
are American ideas. Many
47:27
put their hope in Dr. Serhat. His
47:29
company was worth half a billion dollars.
47:32
His research promised groundbreaking treatments
47:34
for HIV and cancer. Scientists,
47:37
doctors, renowned experts were saying
47:39
genius, genius, genius. People that knew
47:41
him were convinced that he saved
47:43
their life. But the
47:45
brilliant doctor was hiding a secret.
47:58
This was a person who was willing to... to
48:00
cold-heartedly just lie to people's
48:03
faces. We're dealing with an
48:05
international fugitive. From
48:08
Wondery, the makers of Over My
48:10
Dead Body and the shrink next
48:12
door comes a new season of
48:14
Dr. Death, Bad Magic. You can
48:16
listen to Dr. Death's Bad Magic
48:19
ad-free by subscribing to Wondery Plus
48:21
in the Wondery app or on
48:23
Apple Podcasts. Catch
48:26
every episode of 60 Minutes,
48:28
America's most watched news magazine
48:31
show as a podcast, here,
48:33
in-depth investigations across politics, news
48:35
and entertainment on your schedule.
48:37
Listen to 60 Minutes ad-free
48:39
on Wondery Plus. Now
48:42
an update on our story this month on
48:44
the southern border called A Hole in the
48:47
System. About an hour
48:49
east of San Diego, we found migrants
48:51
entering the United States illegally. What
48:53
was remarkable was where many were coming
48:56
from. Through a gap between
48:58
the 30-foot steel border fence and rock.
49:02
We were surprised to see the number of
49:04
people coming through from China nearly
49:06
7,000 miles away. Careful,
49:10
watch. Our
49:14
cameras and at one point, this armed
49:16
border patrol agent standing 25 feet away
49:19
did not deter them. But
49:21
now, 60 Minutes can
49:23
report the Mexican government
49:26
has placed new outposts near that gap, blocking
49:29
the Chinese and other migrants. I'm
49:32
Ciaran Alfonsi. We'll be back
49:34
next week with another edition of 60 Minutes. You
49:51
can listen.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More