Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:13
Imagine it's late evening on Saturday, February
0:16
Twenty Fourth, Nineteen Seventeen and your the
0:18
Special Advisor for the State Department. You've
0:20
just rushed over to the White House
0:22
with for type sheets of paper in
0:25
your hand Information you are certain and
0:27
will knock the world off. It's Axis.
0:31
Almost breathless you enter President Woodrow Wilson's
0:34
office Mr. President Thank you for seeing
0:36
me on such short notice! Wilson
0:39
beckons you to take a seat. At
0:41
Santa. Extremely urgent when you telephoned yesterday
0:43
as we've just received this from the
0:46
British. it's a message from the German
0:48
Foreign Minister to the German ambassador in
0:50
Mexico City. The British intercepted it and
0:53
decoded it. President
0:55
gives you a disbelieving look as
0:57
you hand him the papers. He
0:59
repositions his spectacles and then begins
1:01
to read. His eyes flip back
1:03
and forth and is now falls
1:05
open and his eyes widen Exist
1:07
genuine. Our ambassador and London
1:09
and experts in the State Department believe
1:12
it is. Yes, the Germans are offering
1:14
to let Mexico take back the Southwest
1:16
if they declare war on us. That's
1:19
right, sir. I doubt the Mexicans would
1:21
entertain the offer, but it's proof of
1:23
Germany's hostile intentions. The President's nostrils flair
1:25
and anger. This is an outrage. I'm
1:28
doing everything I can to avoid war,
1:30
even as they continue to sink our
1:32
ships. And in the meantime they plot
1:35
this how do you wanna response or
1:37
President goes quiet. It's clear
1:39
he's trying to contain his rage
1:41
and not let anger cloud his
1:43
decision. The American people must be
1:45
informed of this treachery. Are you
1:47
suggesting we make this public? Yes,
1:49
I am in. The sooner the
1:51
better. You
1:54
know this means that all the Presidents efforts
1:56
to keep the Us out of the war
1:58
could be finished. He looks. at
2:00
the prospect, but he seems determined to
2:02
move forward. So you take a deep
2:04
breath. Seems that war with
2:07
Germany is now inevitable. Okay,
2:13
it's time to commit. 2024
2:16
is the year for prioritizing yourself. Begin
2:19
your new smile journey with Bite, and you could
2:21
start seeing results in just two to three
2:24
weeks. Just order your
2:26
at-home impression kit today for only $14.95 at bite.com.
2:30
Bite clear liners are doctor-directed and delivered
2:33
to your door. Treatment costs
2:35
thousands less than braces, plus they
2:37
offer financing options, accept eligible insurance,
2:39
and you could pay with your
2:41
HSA, FSA. Get 80%
2:44
off your impression kit when you
2:46
use code WONDERY at bite.com. That's
2:48
b-y-t-e.com. Start
2:51
your confidence journey today with
2:53
Bite. This podcast
2:55
is supported by FedEx. FedEx
2:57
offers fast delivery, more visibility, simple
3:00
returns, and weekend home delivery to
3:02
98% of the US population on
3:04
Saturday and 50% on Sunday. With
3:08
FedEx, you get picture-proof of delivery,
3:10
ensuring you always know where your
3:12
package is. Returns are simple with
3:14
package lists and paperless returns. Plus,
3:16
FedEx Ground is also faster to
3:18
more locations than UPS Ground. See
3:20
the FedEx service guide for delivery
3:23
information. So, what are you waiting
3:25
for? See what FedEx can do
3:27
for your business. Absolutely,
3:29
positively, FedEx. From
3:38
WONDERY, I'm Lindsey Graham, and this
3:41
is American History Teller's Our History
3:43
Yours. Appreciate
3:53
it, everyone. Hit thewants. Hit
3:59
the In 1917, Germany
4:01
resumed its submarine attacks on American
4:03
ships delivering supplies to Britain and
4:05
France. And in February,
4:08
Britain shared with the U.S. an
4:10
intercepted telegram written by German Foreign
4:12
Minister Arthur Zimmerman. Zimmerman's
4:14
telegram was intended for the German
4:16
ambassador in Mexico, and it contained
4:18
an explosive revelation. Germany
4:21
was inviting Mexico into a military
4:23
alliance against the United States. These
4:26
provocations backed President Woodrow Wilson into
4:28
a corner. Since the
4:30
outbreak of fighting in Europe, Wilson had sought
4:32
to remain neutral, but with American
4:35
territory and countless lives at stake,
4:37
he was now finally beginning to heed
4:39
calls for intervention. The president
4:42
was under no illusions. Preparing the United
4:44
States for war was a formidable task.
4:47
The nation's military was undermanned and
4:49
outmoded, and if Wilson was
4:51
to shore up public support for the war,
4:53
he'd also have to suppress dissent, even
4:56
if that meant curbing civil liberties. This
4:59
is episode two. The Yanks are
5:01
Coming. On
5:05
March 20, 1917,
5:08
President Woodrow Wilson entered the cabinet room at
5:10
the White House to hear what his top
5:12
advisors had to say about how he should
5:14
handle Germany's latest aggressions. The mood
5:16
was grim. In the past
5:18
week, German U-boats had sunk three American
5:21
ships, and the public was furious about
5:23
the Zimmerman telegram. Wilson
5:25
had managed to keep the U.S. out of
5:27
the war for two and a half years,
5:29
but now any hope of maintaining American neutrality
5:32
seemed lost. But still,
5:34
Wilson stubbornly hoped to find some way
5:36
to avoid U.S. entry into the conflict,
5:38
even though now it seemed unavoidable. He
5:41
asked his cabinet to put aside their emotions
5:43
about the recent German outrages and think about
5:45
the bigger picture. He noted
5:47
that Russia's Tsar Nicholas II had just
5:49
been ousted by a democratic revolution. It
5:52
was unclear if Russia would continue to fight
5:54
for the Allies. Wilson also
5:57
noted the reports of growing discontent
5:59
inside Germany. Food shortages and
6:01
massive casualties had left the German people
6:03
weary of the war. He
6:05
worried if the U.S. got involved now, it
6:07
might only strengthen their resolve to fight on.
6:10
But one by one, every Cabinet member
6:13
told the President they believed the time
6:15
for neutrality was over. The
6:17
Cabinet also encouraged Wilson to present
6:19
the war to the American people
6:21
as a global fight to defend
6:23
democracy against autocracy, an argument strengthened
6:25
by Russia's new democratically-leaning government. But
6:28
the Cabinet was divided over what exactly the
6:30
U.S. contribution to the war should be. Some
6:33
members worried that the army was too small and
6:35
weak to be any real help on the battlefields
6:37
of Europe. Instead, they suggested the
6:40
U.S. focus on providing financial and economic
6:42
support to the Allies. After
6:44
listening to the view of every Cabinet member, Wilson
6:47
thanked them and left without giving any clue as
6:49
to whether he was ready to take America to
6:51
war. The President wrestled with
6:53
this decision for the next two weeks. While
6:56
he was down, he still hoped to remain
6:58
neutral, but he knew the national mood had
7:00
shifted and eventually he accepted reality. It
7:03
was time for war. On
7:08
the evening of April 2, 1917,
7:11
President Wilson left the White House in a
7:13
limousine accompanied by his new wife, Edith. He
7:16
was headed to the Capitol to ask
7:18
the nation's elected representatives to authorize a
7:21
declaration of war against Germany. Through
7:23
the window of the limousine, he could see
7:25
crowds of supporters standing in the rain waving
7:27
flags. But Wilson knew the nation
7:29
was on edge. Pacifist
7:31
protesters were also out in force
7:34
wearing white armbands and chanting anti-war
7:36
slogans. And in the
7:38
Capitol, some of these protests became violent.
7:41
Earlier that same day, a fight had
7:44
broken out between pro-peace activists and Republican
7:46
Senator Henry Cabot Lodge. The
7:49
67-year-old Lodge had become a leading critic
7:51
of Wilson's policy of neutrality. He
7:53
viewed the war as a fight for democracy
7:55
and felt strongly that America belonged in it
7:57
after learning that Wilson And Ted were the only
7:59
ones to be in the Senate. the to ask
8:02
for permission to declare war largest spent a day
8:04
urging his fellow republicans to back to President. Outside
8:07
a committee room large was confronted by
8:09
a band of activists led by thirty
8:11
six year old Alexander Ban Bart. Bands.
8:14
Aren't was a Swiss, American and Princeton
8:16
graduates who had become a committed campaigner
8:18
in the Pacifist movement. He'd idolized
8:20
Wilson since his Princeton days, but now
8:22
fear the President was about to make
8:24
a terrible mistake. And. On
8:26
seeing the pro War launch bands are
8:29
charged over and demanded he vote against
8:31
the war. Andras used and
8:33
center snared. Bands. Are called
8:35
launch soured and large dismiss been
8:37
barred as alive. The. When Been
8:39
barred, made a move toward Lot. The frail
8:42
Senator stunned everyone by delivering a punch that
8:44
not a younger man flat on his best.
8:47
While. Large had managed to hold his
8:49
ground. The Secret Service feared that anti
8:51
war activists might endanger the President's office.
8:54
And assassination attempt couldn't be ruled out.
8:57
So. As Wilson headed to the capital that
8:59
he thinks his limousine was accompanied by the
9:01
cavalry who position their horses around the vehicle
9:03
to seal the President. And. On
9:05
the roof of the cattle, Army and
9:07
Navy sharpshooters stood ready to take out
9:09
any threat. Despite. A
9:11
concern. President Wilson arrived without
9:13
insist. And it has passed. A
9:16
He entered the House of Representatives to deliver
9:18
the most momentous speech of his career. The.
9:21
Chamber was pissed with the entire
9:23
congress, each Supreme Court, justice and
9:25
every diplomat in Washington Dc except
9:27
the German diplomatic staff who are
9:29
back of their embassy burning secret
9:31
documents and case war was declared.
9:34
As the chamber sell client, Wilson took a
9:36
deep breath and began the speech he had
9:38
hope never to does. He
9:40
told the Chamber that America's coral was
9:42
with the Kaiser's government, not the German
9:44
people, And he stressed that most
9:46
German Americans were loyal. But. He followed
9:49
that with a warning. That. If any were
9:51
found to be disloyal, stern repression would
9:53
follow. Then. Wilson declared that
9:56
for the United States, this was not
9:58
a war of conquest. he made
10:00
clear that the goal was to safeguard
10:02
the world for democracy, stating, It
10:04
is a fearful thing to lead this
10:07
great, peaceful people into the most terrible
10:09
and disastrous of all wars, civilization itself
10:11
seeming to be in the balance. But
10:14
we shall fight for the things which we
10:16
have always carried nearest our hearts for democracy,
10:18
for the rights of those who submit to
10:20
authority to have a voice in their own
10:23
governments, for the rights and liberties of small
10:25
nations, to such a task we
10:27
can dedicate our lives and our fortunes, everything
10:29
that we are and everything that we have.
10:32
When Wilson finished, the chamber responded
10:34
with cheers of approval. And
10:37
as the president left the Capitol, the
10:39
crowds of supporters gathered outside shaking his
10:41
hand. Even Alexander Banvard,
10:43
the pacifist campaigner sucker-punched by Senator
10:46
Lodge, was won over. On
10:48
hearing Wilson's reasoning for joining the war,
10:50
he dropped his opposition and resolved to
10:52
support the president instead. And
10:55
not everyone, and certainly not every member of
10:57
Congress, had been won over. Imagine
11:03
it's April 4th, 1917 in the
11:05
U.S. Senate chamber and you're a
11:07
Republican senator from Wisconsin. Unlike
11:10
most of your party, you are still opposed
11:12
to the U.S. joining the conflict overseas. With
11:15
a vote just minutes away, you're determined
11:17
to reject Wilson's request for permission to
11:19
declare war on Germany. But
11:21
as you wait for the roll call, you
11:23
can see fellow Republican Senator Henry Cabot Lodge
11:25
storming over. He looks annoyed, so
11:28
you rise to your feet as he approaches. Senator
11:30
Lodge, I trust you are not about to assault
11:32
me. Word is you have a mean right hook.
11:35
No, of course not. But I have come
11:37
to try and persuade you to change your mind. You're
11:39
wasting your breath. Besides the mood and this room is
11:41
clear. With or without my vote, the Senate
11:44
will support the war. Your vote still
11:46
matters. It's important we're united on this. How will
11:48
it look to the young soldiers in your state
11:50
to know they're heading to a war that your
11:52
own senator opposes? I thought you said this was
11:54
a war for democracy. And it is. And
11:57
defending my right to disagree is part of the fight.
12:00
Besides, if you're so concerned with democracy, start
12:02
with the Allies. France is the
12:04
only true democracy among them. Japan is ruled
12:06
by an emperor. Russia's new government is barely
12:08
a month old. Great Britain is run by
12:10
a monarch in a chamber of unelected lords.
12:14
Maj throws up his hands in frustration. Well, damn
12:16
it, what do you propose we do? Continue
12:18
cowering as German U-boats bring terror to
12:21
American sailors? If we go to war,
12:23
we'll be the subject to even more U-boat attacks. The
12:25
British left Germany with no choice. Their
12:27
blockade is illegal. We should
12:29
continue applying pressure on both Germany and
12:32
England to behave within the bounds of
12:34
international law. If we go
12:36
to war, think of the lives that'll be lost.
12:38
Millions of French and British soldiers already lie rotting
12:40
in the trenches. Do we really want our sons
12:42
and brothers to lie beside them? Senator
12:45
Lodge stares at you for a moment, and
12:47
shakes his head and returns to his seat. A
12:50
few minutes later, true to your word, you
12:52
cast your vote against the declaration of war.
12:55
But it is no use. Only five
12:57
other senators vote with you. You
12:59
know the president's request will be granted, and
13:01
you shudder to think of the bloodshed to
13:03
come. Two
13:08
days after Wilson's speech, the Senate gathered to
13:10
debate his request for a declaration of war.
13:14
During the debate, Republican Senator Henry
13:16
Cabot Lodge urged Democrats and Republicans
13:18
to put party differences aside and
13:20
come together to support America's entry
13:22
into the war. But he
13:24
also warned that as it stood, the U.S.
13:26
Army lacked enough troops and resources to be
13:29
an effective fighting force. While
13:31
Britain and France had more than 12 million
13:33
troops, the United States had just 133,000. Fewer
13:37
men than had been killed in just three days
13:39
during the Battle of the Marne. And
13:41
the death toll at several later battles far
13:43
surpassed that. For over a
13:46
year, the president had talked about preparedness for
13:48
the war, but little progress had actually been
13:50
made. So Senator Lodge believed
13:52
it was imperative that the U.S. rapidly grow
13:54
the size of the Army, and
13:56
almost everyone in the Senate agreed. When
13:59
the vote came... 82 senators voted
14:01
to approve a declaration of war. Just
14:04
six senators opposed, including Wisconsin Senator
14:06
Robert La Follette. Two days
14:08
later, on April 6, 1917,
14:11
the House of Representatives followed suit, voting 373 to
14:13
50 in favor of
14:16
war. President Wilson had won
14:18
the support he needed. The United States
14:20
was now officially at war with the
14:22
German Empire, but it wouldn't be
14:24
joining Britain, France, Russia, Italy, and Japan
14:27
as a member of the Allies. Instead,
14:29
the U.S. announced it was joining the
14:31
war as an associated power. This
14:34
meant the U.S. did not have to work in lockstep
14:36
with the Allies. The military insisted they
14:38
would retain their sovereignty, and American troops
14:41
would not be subject to the orders
14:43
of European powers. Additionally, the
14:45
U.S. had only declared war against
14:47
Germany, not the other members of
14:49
the Central Powers, Austria-Hungary, Bulgaria, and
14:51
the Ottoman Empire. But
14:53
limiting the country's America was at war
14:55
with did nothing to alleviate the concerns
14:57
raised by Senator Lodge about America's readiness
14:59
to fight. The intensity of
15:01
trench warfare had ignited a technological
15:04
arms race among the European powers.
15:06
When the war began, tanks didn't exist,
15:08
but now Britain and France were sending
15:11
hundreds of these metal machines onto the
15:13
battlefields in hope of breaking through German
15:15
defenses. Artillery guns also
15:17
fired powerful shells further and more
15:20
precisely than ever before. The
15:22
Germans were armed with flamethrowers, and the
15:24
French had developed light machine guns. In
15:27
addition to all this deadly mechanical
15:29
weaponry, the use of poison gas
15:31
was also widespread. These advances
15:33
brought a new era of terror to the
15:35
battlefield and sent us to the soaring. Not
15:38
even the skies above could escape the war. For
15:41
the first time, aircraft also played a
15:43
critical role. In addition
15:45
to planes used for reconnaissance and
15:48
artillery spawning, airships dropped bombs on
15:50
cities and other targets, and biplanes
15:52
strafed ground targets and engaged in
15:54
aerial dogfights. Soon, the
15:56
first anti-aircraft guns were also being
15:58
deployed. But this rush
16:01
of military innovation had so far
16:03
bypassed the United States whose army
16:05
wasn't just undermanned, it was also
16:07
stuck in the pre-war era of
16:09
riflemen and cavalry. To Wilson and
16:11
US military leaders, it was clear that millions
16:13
of American men would need to be recruited
16:16
and trained to fight. The country
16:18
needed to modernize its weaponry at the same
16:20
time. There were non-military challenges
16:22
too. The US now had
16:24
a pivot to mobilize industry and transport networks
16:26
to supply the needs of the military. And
16:29
that meant domestic food supplies needed to
16:31
be conserved and secured. There
16:33
was also a pressing need to find ways
16:35
to deal with potential threats from German spies
16:37
and domestic militants who opposed the war. And
16:40
all of these challenges required money. Somehow,
16:43
the US Treasury would have to raise billions
16:45
of dollars to finance the conflict. America
16:48
had yet to fire a single shot.
16:50
But already, the demands of war threatened
16:52
to overwhelm the government. To
16:54
rise to the challenge, an entire
16:56
nation would have to embrace radical
16:59
changes that would permanently reshape America.
18:00
exclusions may apply. Offer ends July 31st,
18:02
2024. See
18:04
site for details. Do
18:06
you ever feel like you're settling? For your
18:09
foundation, that is. Maybelline's new
18:11
Instant Age Rewind Eraser
18:13
foundation doesn't settle into
18:15
fine lines and wrinkles. With SPF
18:17
20 and moisturizing ProVitamin B5, this
18:19
foundation not only provides medium coverage
18:21
in a natural finish, but also
18:23
protects and nourishes your skin. And
18:27
the best part? The Blurring Sponge
18:29
Tip Applicator makes application a breeze.
18:32
Say goodbye to cakey, uneven foundation
18:34
and hello to a flawless,
18:37
radiant complexion. Try
18:39
our new foundation today and see the
18:41
difference for yourself at
18:43
amazon.com/Instant Eraser Foundation.
18:54
On April 13th, 1917, with
18:57
America now at war with Germany, President
18:59
Woodrow Wilson turned his focus to the
19:01
battle at home by taking bold steps
19:03
to ensure public support. Executive
19:06
Order 2594 created
19:08
a propaganda and censorship agency called
19:10
the Committee for Public Information. It
19:13
was part of a flood of new
19:15
wartime policies, laws and federal agencies designed
19:17
to prepare the U.S. for war. To
19:20
head the Committee, Wilson tapped a 40-year-old
19:22
journalist from Missouri named George Creel. Creel
19:25
had begun his career as a reporter in
19:27
Kansas City, before hopping freight trains to New
19:29
York where he wrote jokes for newspapers. After
19:32
returning to the Midwest, Creel built a
19:34
reputation as a progressive columnist and worked
19:36
on Wilson's 1916 re-election campaign. But
19:40
as the nation crept towards war, senior
19:42
people in the military began to advocate
19:45
for strict censorship of war criticism. Creel
19:48
felt that silencing dissidents wasn't the way to
19:50
win the hearts and minds of the American
19:52
public. So he wrote to President
19:54
Wilson and proposed an alternative, a
19:56
government agency that would sell the war to the
19:58
nation, much like an ad. agency would sell
20:01
a product like soap or soda pop. Creel
20:04
believed that by using the techniques of
20:06
advertising and journalism he could, as he
20:08
put it, weld the people of the
20:10
United States into one white-hot mass instinct.
20:13
Then he could harness that patriotic fervor to instill
20:15
in the public the will to win the war.
20:18
Creel was ultimately proposing a government
20:20
propaganda machine and President Wilson embraced
20:22
the idea. He immediately ordered
20:25
the creation of the Committee for Public Information
20:27
and put Creel in charge of it. And
20:30
as chairman of the committee Creel moved
20:32
fast. He knew the war was
20:34
about to change daily life for every American
20:36
and without sustained public support there would be
20:38
no hope of victory. So
20:41
his first targets were the newspapers.
20:43
He formed a team to send
20:45
them a deluge of government-approved war news.
20:47
For newspaper editors it was a
20:49
lifeline. Their readers craved updates
20:51
about the war but their reporters
20:53
were being denied access to military
20:55
personnel and munitions manufacturers in the
20:57
name of national security. So
21:00
with their own journalists struggling to
21:02
deliver stories editors filled their papers
21:04
with reports provided by Creel's committee.
21:07
And newspapers were just the start. Creel
21:10
soon had multiple teams fighting the information
21:12
war on every front. They published
21:14
school books promoting American ideals while trashing
21:16
Germany and blocked the export of movies
21:19
that portrayed the US in a bad
21:21
light. The committee's artists churned out
21:24
posters depicting monstrous German soldiers
21:26
with bloodied hands coming for
21:28
America's women. They also
21:30
created a powerful symbol of the American
21:32
war effort when they released posters based
21:34
off a bridge line I want you
21:36
for the US Army. The
21:38
committee also deployed hundreds of recruits
21:40
to deliver rousing speeches of public
21:42
venues. Known as the four-minute
21:44
men they would show up at cinemas
21:46
during the intermission or at church events
21:48
encouraging the audience to do their patriotic
21:50
duty. They urged Americans to conserve
21:53
food by observing meatless Tuesday or wheatless
21:55
Wednesdays and encourage them to buy Liberty
21:57
bonds to help fund the cost of
21:59
the war. But in addition
22:01
to churning out this wartime propaganda,
22:03
Creel's committee also monitored the contents
22:06
of hundreds of non-English newspapers around
22:08
the country, especially the
22:10
German ones. The United
22:12
States' entry into the war with Germany had left the
22:14
nation's 2.8 million German
22:16
Americans caught between heritage and country.
22:19
Many German-language newspapers had favored the central
22:21
powers over the Allies since the start
22:23
of the war. Now they
22:26
had to distance themselves from Germany to avoid
22:28
being shut down or censored. Many
22:30
also lost advertisers, leading several newspapers to
22:32
close their doors before the war was
22:35
over. But Creel's committee wasn't
22:37
their only worry, because they
22:39
were also being watched by America's new
22:41
secret police. Imagine
22:46
it's the summer of 1917 and you're
22:49
visiting St. Louis, Missouri. You
22:51
were born in Germany, but now you live and work
22:53
in Kansas City. Today you're taking a
22:55
break from your job at an ice manufacturer to
22:57
see the size of St. Louis. A friend from
22:59
Warwick recommended you visit the zoo. And
23:02
as you stroll into the city center, you spot a
23:04
men's clothing store and wander over to see what's on
23:06
display. But just then, someone taps
23:08
you on the shoulder. You
23:10
turn to see a serious-looking man holding
23:13
out a badge. Excuse me, sir, I
23:15
am an operative in the American Protective League.
23:17
We're a secret service of volunteers endorsed by
23:20
the Department of Justice. Our job
23:22
is to defend America from enemy aliens, and
23:24
that's you, isn't it, pal? What's
23:26
an enemy alien? I'm sorry, English is
23:28
not my first language. Don't give me
23:31
that. An enemy alien is someone like you.
23:34
Born in Germany, but now living here pretending
23:36
to love America. Well, yes, I was
23:38
born in Germany, but I am certainly not an enemy.
23:41
The operative smirks, and you regain
23:43
your composure. Hold on, have you
23:45
been following me? We have agents everywhere.
23:48
One of our informants told us of your little trip.
23:50
What are you doing in St. Louis? I'm just
23:52
visiting. I wanted to see the city, maybe
23:55
the zoo. I've done nothing wrong. Oh, really?
23:57
Then explain why you're standing in a no-alien
23:59
zone. Since the
24:01
war started, cities have been designating
24:03
areas where German nationals can only
24:05
go by permit. But you didn't
24:08
see any signs saying that this was one of those areas. You're
24:11
not sure what powers, if any, this American
24:13
protective league has, but you're not keen to
24:15
find out. Look, sir, I
24:17
didn't mean to violate any rules. I'm unfamiliar with
24:19
St. Louis. As I said, I'm just a tourist.
24:22
But you didn't think to learn where you can and can't
24:25
go before just wandering around? Yes,
24:27
sir, I should have done that. And
24:29
I am very sorry it was a silly mistake. But
24:32
believe me when I say that whatever my
24:34
national duty, America is my home now. The
24:37
operative eyes you for a while, then puts his badge
24:39
away. Very well, then. I'll let
24:41
you off the hook this time. But I
24:43
suggest you get the first train back to
24:45
Kansas City, before I find a good reason
24:47
to have you arrested. You
24:51
nod and hurry away toward the station. But
24:54
it's not the encounter with his operative that unnerved
24:56
you the most. Only
24:58
three people knew you planned to be in St.
25:00
Louis today. All colleagues from work,
25:02
people you've known for years. Your
25:04
heart sinks as you realize those you
25:07
thought were your friends are
25:09
now reporting your every move. The
25:15
American Protective League formed in April 1917, just before
25:17
war was declared. Its
25:21
founder, Albert Briggs, a Chicago advertising
25:23
executive, felt the federal government's intelligence
25:25
service was under-resourced and wanted to
25:27
help clamp down on German espionage.
25:31
But the league wasn't part of the federal
25:33
government. It was a secretive
25:35
private organization that had been granted semi-official
25:37
status by the Department of Justice. And
25:41
once so sanctioned, the league set
25:43
to work recruiting 250,000 agents and
25:45
informants, tasking them with rooting out
25:47
disloyalty in more than 600 American
25:49
cities. But despite
25:51
the gravity of their mission to protect
25:53
America from enemy aliens, agents were
25:55
simply volunteers, who paid a membership fee of
25:58
75 cents to receive the free money. a
26:00
batch. Officially, agents of the
26:02
protective league had no police powers and
26:04
were not allowed to carry firearms or
26:07
make arrests. Nevertheless, some members
26:09
simply ignored these restrictions, carrying
26:11
out illegal searches or delivering vigilante
26:14
justice. In Denver, members
26:16
of the protective league punished a man who
26:18
refused to kiss the American flag. They
26:20
put a noose around his neck, tied it to
26:23
a truck, and dragged him by the neck
26:25
through the streets. Others who didn't
26:27
donate to the Red Cross or were
26:29
considered un-American were tarred and feathered or
26:31
beaten in the streets. Despite
26:33
being illegal, few of these incidents resulted
26:36
in the arrest of a protective league
26:38
member, and even when they did, jurors
26:40
often hesitated to hand down a guilty
26:42
verdict, fearing it could make them the
26:44
league's next target. And the
26:47
league didn't stop with Germans either. Their
26:49
watch list also included trade
26:51
unions, socialists, and pacifist groups.
26:54
Soon, members of the league
26:56
would focus on another target,
26:58
too, draft dodgers. On May
27:00
18, 1917, Congress gathered to debate
27:02
what was said to be the
27:05
most controversial piece of wartime legislation
27:07
yet, a bill introducing military conscription.
27:09
When President Wilson declared war, he instructed
27:12
the army to recruit a million men,
27:14
but after six weeks, just 73,000 had
27:17
volunteered. Wilson knew this was
27:20
nowhere near enough troops. In France,
27:22
the Battle of Arras that spring had left 159,000
27:24
soldiers from across the British Empire dead, wounded, or
27:28
missing. On average, 5,000 soldiers
27:31
were dying on the Western Front every
27:33
day, and at that rate, America's volunteers would
27:35
be wiped out in a matter of weeks. This
27:38
left the U.S. government with little choice but to
27:40
enact a draft. So Secretary of
27:42
War Newton Baker persuaded the president to back
27:45
the introduction of the Selective Service Act, which
27:47
required all American men between the ages of
27:49
21 and 30 to register
27:52
for military service. But both
27:54
Wilson and Baker were nervous about the move.
27:57
Americans had not been conscripted since the
27:59
Civil War. And at the
28:01
time, the Union Army's draft law had allowed
28:03
the wealthy to pay their way out of
28:05
service, provoking fury and riots in northern cities.
28:08
To avoid a similar debacle, the Wilson
28:10
administration ensured the Selective Service Act did
28:12
not give people the option to buy
28:15
their way out. The administration also
28:17
knew many citizens distrusted the federal
28:19
government, which they saw as remote
28:21
and disconnected from their daily lives.
28:24
So it offloaded the task of
28:26
deciding who'd be sent to war
28:28
to thousands of local selection boards
28:30
composed of influential businessmen and civic
28:32
leaders. But still, conscription
28:34
remained controversial for a variety of
28:37
reasons. Despite the
28:39
army being segregated, some southern Democrats
28:41
opposed the idea of drafting African-Americans.
28:44
Mississippi Senator James Vardeman argued that
28:46
making black men soldiers, even in
28:48
non-combat units, would embolden them and
28:50
leave the region's plantations short of
28:52
workers. Other Democrats opposed
28:54
conscription on principle and argued that there
28:56
was little difference between a conscript and
28:59
a convict. But the
29:01
Republicans had already decided to give the
29:03
Selective Service Act near unanimous support, ensuring
29:05
it would sail into law. Nevertheless,
29:08
Secretary Baker knew that simply passing a
29:10
law did not guarantee that the American
29:12
citizens would embrace the draft. There
29:15
was no threat of a German invasion
29:17
to rally around, and the idea of
29:19
compelling people into service felt at odds
29:21
with American ideals of individual liberty. To
29:24
his concerns about a possible public backlash,
29:26
Baker set June 5th as the draft
29:29
registration day and held his breath. And
29:32
as that day approached, George Creel's Committee
29:34
on Public Information stepped up its efforts
29:36
to convince the nation to do their
29:38
duty. Local selection
29:40
boards organized parades, pageants, and festivities
29:42
to make registering for the draft
29:45
feel like a moment of celebration.
29:48
But there was an undercurrent of danger, too. There
29:50
was talk of organized resistance to the draft in
29:53
major cities and the rural counties of the South.
29:56
Police stood ready to arrest anyone who tried
29:58
to disrupt the registration process. The
30:00
American Protective League was also on the watch
30:02
for any hint of opposition, and
30:05
in several states, national guardsmen were on alert,
30:07
ready to put down any trouble on the
30:09
big day. But ultimately
30:11
fears of mass apathy or resistance
30:14
were overblown. On June 5, approximately
30:16
10 million American men headed to
30:18
their local selection boards to register
30:20
for the draft. While
30:23
the law did allow draftees to
30:25
claim conscientious objector status, fewer than
30:28
1% requested it, and many of those
30:30
who did agreed to serve in non-combat roles.
30:33
But despite the encouraging turnout, not everyone
30:35
was ready to fight for their country.
30:38
An estimated one in ten men failed
30:40
to register, becoming draftee dodgers. The
30:43
authorities and the public dubbed them slackers,
30:45
and within weeks they were being hunted.
30:48
Secret Service and American Protective League agents
30:50
teamed up with local police to hold
30:52
slacker raids where squads would roam the
30:55
streets to catch suspected draftee dodgers. These
30:58
squads would storm into saloons, dance halls,
31:00
sporting events, workplaces and pool rooms, demanding
31:02
men of military age show them the
31:05
blue cards that proved they registered for
31:07
the draft. Anyone without
31:09
a card would be jailed. In
31:11
the meantime, the U.S. Army now needed to
31:13
work out how to get the millions of
31:15
young men on the draft register trained, armed,
31:18
and transported to the battlefront of Europe. But
31:21
even with more soldiers, the United States
31:23
military would soon discover they were still
31:25
far from ready to face the might
31:27
of the German Empire. Everything
31:51
costs more, so to reduce costs
31:53
and headaches, switch to NetSuite, the
31:55
number one cloud financial system bringing
31:57
accounting, financial management, inventory, and more.
31:59
HR all into one platform and
32:02
one source of truth. With NetSuite,
32:04
you'll reduce IT costs because NetSuite
32:06
lives in the cloud, no hardware
32:08
required. You cut the cost of
32:10
maintaining multiple systems because you've got
32:13
one unified business management suite and
32:15
you improve efficiency by bringing all
32:17
your major business processes into one
32:19
platform, slashing manual tasks and errors.
32:22
Over 37,000 companies have already
32:24
made the move, so do the math. See
32:26
how you'll profit with NetSuite this year. Now
32:28
through April 15, NetSuite is
32:31
offering a one-of-a-kind
32:33
flexible financing program.
32:35
Head to netsuite.com/tellers.
32:37
That's netsuite.com/tellers. netsuite.com/tellers.
32:42
Ophthalmologist Dr. Strauss has seen firsthand
32:45
how the metaverse is helping surgeons
32:47
practice the procedures to treat cataracts.
32:50
Cataracts are the primary cause of
32:52
avoidable blindness. He works with a
32:54
virtual reality training platform developed by
32:57
FundamentalVR and Orbis International to help
32:59
surgeons develop the muscle memory they
33:01
need. The result? More
33:03
confident, capable surgeons. And even more
33:06
importantly, patients who can see. Explore
33:08
more stories like Dr. Strauss's
33:10
at meta.com/metaverse impact. On
33:21
the afternoon of May 24, 1917,
33:24
General John Pershing entered the Oval Office with
33:26
Secretary of War Newton Baker at his side.
33:29
Pershing was there to be formally named
33:31
Commander-in-Chief of the American Expeditionary Forces, as
33:33
the U.S. forces on the Western Front
33:35
were to be called. Pershing
33:38
had a distinguished military career, having been one
33:40
of the first officers to lead an all-black
33:42
regiment to fight Native Americans on the frontier.
33:45
He'd also led successful campaigns in
33:47
both Cuba and the Philippines during
33:50
the Spanish-American and Philippine-American wars. During
33:53
their brief meeting in the Oval Office that
33:55
day, Pershing got little direction from Wilson who
33:57
said nothing about how U.S. forces were to
33:59
cooperate. with the Allied armies. Wilson
34:01
simply told the General he had full confidence
34:03
in him. A few days
34:06
later, Secretary of War Newton Baker offered
34:08
Pershing a little more guidance. Pershing
34:10
was to cooperate with the Allied forces,
34:12
but the United States military had to
34:14
remain a separate and distinct force. Armed
34:17
with these brief instructions, Pershing and his staff
34:19
left for France on May 28, 1917, but
34:24
on arrival he soon realized America would need
34:26
even more manpower than anticipated to make a
34:28
difference in the war. Based
34:30
on his calculations, Pershing cabled Washington
34:33
and asked for one million men,
34:35
but only nine days later he cabled
34:37
Washington again. He changed his
34:40
mind. One million was too few.
34:43
He needed three times that. Pershing
34:46
knew that these men still needed to be drafted,
34:48
and before they could be sent overseas they would
34:50
need training. The best he could hope for
34:52
now was to get 500,000 troops prepared
34:54
and shipped to Europe by the end of 1917. But
34:58
just training that many was still going to be
35:00
a major undertaking. So soon
35:02
construction teams all over the United States
35:04
set to workbuilding training facilities and barracks
35:06
to house the troops. These
35:09
facilities were erected so fast that in
35:11
some instances the conscripts found themselves living
35:13
in tents while helping the construction. Equipment
35:17
was also in short supply. U.S.
35:19
factories were struggling to keep pace with
35:21
wartime demand, a task made harder as
35:24
workers began being called up for military
35:26
service and new restrictions were placed on
35:28
immigration. The resulting labor
35:30
shortage forced employers to seek out
35:33
alternatives, and they soon began to
35:35
recruit more African-American workers and women.
35:38
Large numbers of African-Americans had already
35:40
begun to migrate from the South
35:42
to Northern and Midwestern cities seeking
35:44
better jobs and less racist oppression.
35:47
The war only accelerated the trend.
35:49
Still, many African-Americans found that they were
35:52
not welcomed with open arms. In
35:54
many cities, white workers opposed working
35:57
alongside black workers, and some turned
35:59
to violence. On July
36:01
2, 1917, in East St. Louis, a
36:03
mob of more than a thousand white
36:05
residents went on a rampage attacking black
36:08
families and burning their homes. This
36:10
massacre left around 100 African Americans dead
36:12
and as many as 6,000 homeless. In
36:16
response, 10,000 African Americans marched
36:18
in New York in silent
36:20
protest. But it wasn't
36:22
just an influx of African American workers that
36:25
changed American industry as the U.S. geared up
36:27
for war. Facing a lack
36:29
of labor as young men went
36:31
off to battle, traditionally male workplaces
36:33
began to hire women from positions
36:35
like operating cranes, driving trucks, and
36:37
building ships. But even
36:40
as these women began to fill the ranks and
36:42
power production, U.S. factories could not
36:44
meet demand from the military. The
36:47
backlog in orders for uniforms and
36:49
boots stretched into months. And
36:51
the U.S. Army did not have enough guns to arm
36:53
their soldiers either. So instead
36:55
of training with rifles, many men found
36:58
themselves practicing for war armed with broomsticks.
37:01
By the time they reached France, as
37:03
many as 40% of the troops had
37:05
not yet fired a standard-issue army rifle.
37:08
But despite their lack of training, U.S.
37:10
troops were a welcome sight for Allied
37:12
commanders. On June 24, the first 14,000
37:14
U.S. troops arrived in France. With
37:18
the Americans now in the fight, Germany's
37:20
defeat seemed more certain. Then,
37:23
as the summer went on, the initial
37:25
dribble of U.S. troops became a steady
37:27
stream. For the first few
37:29
months, the American Expeditionary Forces spent their
37:31
time setting up bases, being drilled in
37:33
trench warfare by British and French instructors.
37:37
But as summer turned to fall, the
37:39
first American soldiers headed to the front
37:41
lines. Imagine
37:45
it's just before dawn on November 3, 1917.
37:50
You're a soldier in the 1st Division of
37:52
the American Expeditionary Forces. You're
37:54
in the trenches in northeastern France, just a
37:56
few miles from the border with Germany. Stand
37:59
on tiptoe. Carefully raise your head to
38:01
peek over the trench wall. In
38:03
the gloom, you can make out No Man's
38:05
Land. The roughly hundred yards of land that
38:08
separates you from the enemy. It's
38:10
eerie. A pockmarked wasteland of
38:12
barbed wire, mud, unexploded shells, pools
38:14
of fetid water, and the decaying
38:17
bodies of the fallen. Then
38:19
at the far end, you can see the German
38:21
trenches. A lone sniper
38:23
shot pierces the air. You duck
38:26
back into your trench. Well, that was close. You
38:28
are an idiot. You turn to
38:30
see your friend Johnny, a fellow First Division soldier.
38:33
He's leaning against the muddy trench wall,
38:35
rolling a cigarette. Hey, I almost got
38:37
shot there. That's exactly my point, idiot.
38:40
Didn't you listen when they told us the quickest way to die
38:42
here is to stick your head up above the trench? Yeah,
38:45
I heard that, but I'm sick of staring at nothing
38:47
but these dirt walls. I wanted to get
38:49
a glimpse of what it was like up there. Besides,
38:52
that instructor was a sourpuss. All
38:55
doom and gloom. It's no wonder they haven't beaten the Germans
38:57
yet. Johnny strikes
38:59
a match and lights a cigarette. Or
39:04
maybe they've just been here long enough to know what's
39:06
what. I mean, look at this place. Nothing
39:09
but mud and rats. And Jesus,
39:11
Mel. Maybe that Brit wasn't joking when
39:13
he said the best thing you could hope for is a bullet
39:15
in the rear. You frown,
39:17
because sure, it's bad, but having Johnny complaining
39:19
doesn't help. Well, look, I came here to
39:21
fight, teach the Kaiser a lesson. I'm tired
39:24
of waiting around. That's not what they trained
39:26
us for. At least they gave you
39:28
a gun to train with. I was twirling around a
39:30
broomstick. I only got a gun the day we
39:32
left for France. Just like the song.
39:35
What? Just like the song.
39:37
Over there. Over there. Oh,
39:39
yeah, I guess. You pause and think
39:41
about your brief glimpse of no man's land. You
39:44
know, it's creepy up there. Up where? No
39:47
man's land. It's a little shadowy like
39:49
there's ghosts or something. I know
39:51
my eyes were full of me, but I swear
39:53
I saw something move out there. You saw something move?
39:56
Johnny springs up and crawls his rifle. Before
40:00
you can react, the noise of grenades and
40:02
guns is a trench
40:04
ring. The Germans are already right on to the
40:07
border. The
40:11
German raid near the French village of
40:13
Batlemont was the first time U.S. troops
40:16
faced direct combat. The fighting lasted
40:18
an hour, and by the time the Germans
40:20
returned to their lines, they had taken several
40:22
prisoners with them. Three American servicemen
40:24
died in the fighting, becoming the first
40:26
U.S. soldiers to fall in battle during
40:28
the war. The next day,
40:30
General Pershing arrived in Paris for a
40:32
morning meeting with David Lloyd George, the
40:34
British Secretary of War. The
40:37
mood was solemn. American troops were
40:39
arriving in growing numbers, but both Pershing
40:41
and Lloyd George were worried about Italy.
40:44
Before the war, Italy had made a
40:46
defensive pact with Germany and Austria-Hungary, but
40:48
when the fighting began, it declared itself
40:50
neutral. Then, in April 1915,
40:52
the Allies persuaded Italy to join
40:54
their side by promising to give
40:56
it parts of Austria-Hungary and the
40:58
Ottoman Empire once the Central Powers
41:00
were defeated. Italy's entry
41:03
into the war had boosted the Allies' forces
41:05
by more than five million men, but
41:07
now, in late 1917, Italy was informal. Austria-Hungary
41:11
had just inflicted a major defeat
41:13
on the Italians at Caporetto. More
41:16
than a quarter million Italian soldiers had
41:18
been taken prisoner, and Italy's prime minister
41:20
was forced from office. Italy's
41:23
continued commitment to the war was now
41:25
looking shaky. And there was
41:27
also another issue for General Pershing and
41:29
Lloyd George to chew over that morning,
41:31
the coordination of American and Allied troops.
41:34
Britain and France wanted the American forces
41:36
rolled into their armies. They felt
41:38
the U.S. was wasting valuable time and
41:40
resources trying to build their own divisions,
41:43
as the U.S. troops were inexperienced, badly
41:45
equipped, and untrained. Even General
41:47
Pershing had to concede that without British
41:49
and French support, the American Expeditionary forces
41:52
couldn't function. But his orders
41:54
were clear. The American army was
41:56
not to be absorbed into the Allied forces.
41:59
This was was in part because Pershing
42:01
doubted the Allies' tactics. For three
42:03
long years Britain and France had been
42:06
sending hundreds of thousands of men to
42:08
their deaths and getting nowhere. The
42:10
ongoing battle in Passchendaele, Belgium, only
42:13
seemed to underscore the futility. Since
42:15
July the British had been trying to break
42:17
through the German defenses there, but
42:19
the offensive had failed, leaving more than a
42:22
quarter of a million British soldiers dead, injured
42:24
or missing. Pershing had no
42:26
intention of allowing the British and French to
42:28
use American soldiers as more cannon fodder. But
42:31
he and Lloyd George did agree that the
42:33
Allied forces needed to get better aligned. So
42:36
three days later, on November 7, 1917, the
42:39
British, French and Italian governments agreed to
42:42
form a Supreme War Council. Soon
42:44
after President Wilson approved American participation
42:46
as well. This council would
42:49
coordinate the war effort, but the armies
42:51
of each nation would remain separate and
42:53
under their own leadership. But
42:55
even as the council prepared for its
42:57
first planned meetings, the tide of the
42:59
war turned in Germany's favor. First,
43:02
Austria-Hungary inflicted another crushing defeat
43:05
on Italy. The Italians were
43:07
now threatening to drop out of
43:09
the war entirely unless the US
43:11
also declared war on Austria-Hungary. The
43:13
news from Russia was even worse. Back
43:16
in the spring, Germany had helped
43:18
the exiled Marxist revolutionary Vladimir Lenin
43:20
return to Russia. They
43:22
hoped as leader of the Bolshevik revolutionaries, he
43:24
would cause enough trouble to force Russia's new
43:27
democratic government to pull out of the war,
43:29
and they were right. On
43:31
November 7, Lenin and the
43:33
Bolsheviks overthrew the Russian government and
43:35
seized power. Now it was
43:37
just a matter of time before Russia withdrew from
43:39
the war. And when it
43:41
did, Germany's battle-hardened forces on the Eastern
43:44
Front would be free to turn
43:46
west toward France, just as American forces
43:48
were headed straight into the fight. Wilson
44:00
presents his plan for a new
44:02
world order. General Pershing considers letting
44:04
Paris fall as Germany stages a
44:06
massive spring offensive and more American
44:08
troops land in Europe just in
44:10
time. Wondery
44:15
Plus subscribers can binge American History
44:18
Tellers early and ad-free right now.
44:21
Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app
44:23
or on Apple Podcasts. And if you
44:25
enjoy American History Tellers, be sure to
44:27
give us a five-star rating and leave
44:29
a review. I read every one of
44:31
them. I also have two other Wondery
44:33
podcasts you might like, American Scandal and
44:35
Business Movers. Follow American History Tellers on
44:37
the Wondery app, Amazon Music, or wherever
44:39
you get your podcasts. You can binge
44:41
all episodes of American History Tellers early
44:43
and ad-free right now by joining Wondery
44:45
Plus in the Wondery app or on
44:47
Apple Podcasts. And before you go, tell
44:49
us about yourself by completing a short
44:52
survey at wondery.com/survey. And to
44:54
find out more about me,
44:56
including my other podcasts, go
44:58
to notthatlindseygram.com. That's
45:01
notthatlindseygram.com. American
45:06
History Tellers is hosted, edited, and produced
45:09
by me, Lindsey Graham for Airship. Audio
45:11
editing by Tristan Peraga. Sound
45:13
design by Molly Bach. Music by
45:15
Lindsey Graham. This episode is written
45:18
by Tristan Donovan of Yellow Ant.
45:20
Research by Louisa Byrne, Marina Watson,
45:22
and David Walensky. Edited by Dorian
45:24
Marina. Produced by Oliva Rizanski.
45:27
Our production coordinator is Desi Blalock.
45:29
Managing producer Matt Gant. Senior
45:31
managing producer Ryan Lohr. Senior
45:34
producer Andy Herman. Executive
45:36
producers are Jenny Lauer-Bekman and
45:38
Marsha Louis for Wondery. The
45:47
wait is over. So far
45:49
you're not losing. The only thing you're losing
45:51
is my patience. Quickly, I see that. Bing!
45:54
The queen of the courtroom
45:56
is back. I didn't do
45:58
anything. I wouldn't know the truth if
46:00
it came up and slapped you in the face. I
46:03
see it's not intimidated by anything.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More