Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
4:00
If subscribing isn't possible, an
4:03
easy way to help is simply by
4:05
leaving a review and rating in
4:08
your podcast app. Even
4:10
one sentence really helps out. If
4:13
you would like to say hello, you
4:15
can always connect with me at
4:18
theboytosleep.com website. Sharing
4:22
the podcast with a friend who may need
4:24
it is also a fantastic
4:26
way to show your appreciation while
4:29
helping others. Your
4:32
support in spreading the word is
4:34
the greatest compliment I can receive.
4:38
In the meantime, lie back, relax
4:40
and enjoy the readings. Memoirs
4:44
of a Revolutionist by
4:47
Peter Kropotkin With
4:49
a preface by George Brands and
4:52
a preface to this edition by
4:54
Peter Kropotkin dealing with events
4:56
in Russia up to 1906. This
5:01
book would probably not have been written
5:03
for some time to come were
5:05
it not for the kind invitation and
5:08
the most friendly encouragement of the
5:10
editor and the publisher
5:13
of the Atlantic Monthly to
5:15
write it for a serial publication in
5:18
their review. I
5:20
feel it a pleasant duty to
5:22
acknowledge here my very best thanks
5:24
both for the hospitality that
5:27
was offered to me and
5:29
for the friendly pressure that was
5:31
exercised in order to induce me
5:33
to undertake this work. It
5:36
was published in the Atlantic Monthly September
5:38
1898 to September 1899 under
5:44
the title of Autobiography
5:46
of a Revolutionist. Preparing
5:49
it now for publication in book
5:51
form, I have considerably
5:53
added to the original text in
5:55
the portions relating to my youth
5:58
and my stay in Soviet Russia. Siberia, and
6:01
especially in the sixth part in which
6:04
I have narrated my life in Western
6:06
Europe. Preface The
6:10
autobiographies which we owe to great
6:12
minds have in former times generally
6:14
been of one of three types.
6:18
So far I went astray, thus
6:20
I found the true path, St
6:22
Augustine. Not so
6:25
bad was I, but who dares to
6:27
consider himself better, Rousseau.
6:30
This is the way a genius has
6:32
slowly been evolved from within and
6:35
by favorable surroundings. In
6:38
these forms of self-representation, the
6:41
author is thus mainly preoccupied
6:43
with himself. In
6:46
the 19th century, the autobiographies of
6:48
men of Mark are more often
6:50
shaped online such as these. So
6:54
full of talent and attractive was I. Such
6:57
appreciation and admiration I
6:59
won. A
7:01
life lived once more in reminiscence.
7:05
Or I was full of talent and
7:07
worthy of being loved. But
7:09
yet I was unappreciated. And
7:12
these were the hard struggles I went
7:15
through before I won the crown of
7:17
fame. Hans Christian Andersen.
7:20
The Tale of a Life. The
7:23
main preoccupation of the writer in
7:25
these two classes of life records
7:28
is consequently with what his fellow men
7:31
have thought of him and
7:33
said about him. The
7:35
author of the autobiography Before
7:38
Us is not preoccupied with
7:40
his own capacities, and
7:43
consequently describes no struggle to
7:45
gain recognition. The
7:48
less does he care for the opinions
7:50
of his fellow men about himself. What
7:53
others have thought of him, he dismisses
7:56
with a single word. There
7:59
is in this world. work, no gazing,
8:01
upon one's own image. The
8:04
author is not one of those who
8:06
willingly speak of themselves. When
8:08
he does so, it is
8:11
reluctantly and with a certain shyness.
8:14
There is here no confession that
8:16
divulges the inner self, no
8:19
sentimentality and no cynicism.
8:23
The author speaks neither of his
8:25
sins nor of his virtues. He
8:28
enters into no vulgar intimacy with
8:30
his reader. He
8:32
does not say when he fell in love,
8:35
and he touches so little upon
8:38
his relations with the other gender,
8:41
that he even omits to mention his
8:43
marriage. And it
8:45
is only incidentally we learn that
8:48
he is married at all, that
8:50
he is a father and a very
8:53
loving one. He finds
8:55
time to mention just once in the
8:57
rapid review of the last sixteen
8:59
years of his life. He
9:02
is more anxious to give the
9:05
psychology of his contemporaries than of
9:07
himself, and one
9:09
finds in his book The Psychology
9:11
of Russia, The
9:13
Official Russia, and The Masses Underneath.
9:17
Russia struggling forward and Russia
9:19
stagnant. He strives
9:21
to tell the story of his contemporaries
9:24
rather than his own, and
9:27
consequently the record of
9:29
his life contains the history of Russia
9:32
during his lifetime, as
9:34
well as that of the labor movement in
9:36
Europe during the last
9:38
half century. When
9:41
he plunges into his own inner world,
9:43
we see the outer world reflected in
9:46
it. There
9:48
is nevertheless in this book an effect
9:50
such as God he aimed in the
9:52
dish tongue and vahite, the
9:56
representation of how a remarkable mind
9:58
has been shaped. the
20:00
information already gained rather
20:03
than to work at making new discoveries.
20:07
For my part, I do not think he
20:09
was right. With
20:11
such conceptions, pasture would not have
20:14
been the benefactor of mankind that
20:16
he has been. After
20:19
all, everything in the long run
20:22
is to benefit of the mass of the
20:24
people. I
20:26
think that a man does the utmost
20:28
for the well-being of all, when
20:31
he has given to the world the
20:33
most intense production of which he is
20:35
capable. But
20:37
this fundamental notion is
20:39
characteristic of Kropotkin. It
20:42
contains his very essence. And
20:45
this attitude of mind carries him
20:47
farther. In Finland,
20:50
where is he going to make a
20:52
new scientific discovery? As
20:55
he comes to the idea, which
20:57
was hearsay at the time, that
21:00
in prehistoric ages, all northern
21:02
Europe was buried under ice. He
21:05
is so impressed with compassion for the poor,
21:09
the suffering, who often
21:11
know hunger in their struggle for bread,
21:13
that he considers it his highest.
21:17
Absolute duty to become a teacher
21:19
and helper of the great working
21:21
and destitute masses. Soon
21:25
after that, a new world opens before
21:27
him, the life of
21:29
the working classes, and
21:32
he learns from those whom he intends
21:34
to teach. Five
21:36
or six years later, this crisis
21:39
appears in its second phase. It
21:42
happens in Switzerland. Already
21:44
during his first stay there,
21:46
Kropotkin had abandoned the group
21:48
of state socialists, from
21:51
fear of an economical despotism, from
21:54
hatred of centralization, from
21:57
love for the freedom of the individual.
22:00
and the commune. Now,
22:02
however, after his long
22:04
imprisonment in Russia, during
22:07
his second stay omits to the
22:09
intelligent workers of West Switzerland, the
22:12
conception which floated before his eyes
22:14
of a new structure of society
22:17
more distinctly dawns upon him
22:19
in the shape of a
22:22
society of federated associations, cooperating
22:25
in the same way as the
22:27
railway companies, or
22:29
the postal departments of separate
22:31
countries cooperate. He
22:34
knows that he cannot dictate to the
22:36
future the lines which it will have
22:38
to follow. He is
22:40
convinced that all must grow out of
22:42
the constructive activity of the masses. But
22:45
he compares for the sake of illustration
22:48
the coming structure with the guilds
22:51
and the mutual relations, which
22:54
existed in medieval times and were
22:56
worked out from below. He
22:59
does not believe in the distinction between
23:01
leaders and led, but
23:04
I must confess that I am
23:06
old-fashioned enough to feel pleased when
23:09
Kropotkin by a slight inconsistency
23:12
says once in praise of a friend that
23:14
he was a born leader of men. The
23:18
author describes himself as a
23:20
revolutionist, and he is
23:22
surely quite right in doing so. But
23:26
seldom have there been revolutionists
23:28
so humane and mild. One
23:31
feels astounded when, in alluding
23:33
on one occasion to the possibility of
23:36
an armed conflict with the Swiss police,
23:40
there appears in his character the
23:43
fighting instinct which exists in all of
23:45
us. He cannot
23:47
say precisely in this passage whether
23:49
he and his friends felt a
23:51
relief at being spared a fight,
23:55
or a regret that the fight
23:57
did not take place. This expression of
23:59
fear is not a feeling stands alone. He
24:02
has never been an Avenger, but
24:05
always a martyr. He
24:08
does not impose sacrifices upon others.
24:11
He makes them himself. All
24:14
his life he has done it, but in
24:16
such a way that the sacrifice seems to
24:18
have cost him nothing. So
24:21
little does he make of it. And
24:23
with all his energy he is so
24:25
far from being vindictive. That
24:28
of a disgusting prison doctor he
24:30
earned the remarks. The
24:32
less said of him, the better. He
24:36
is a revolutionist, without emphasis
24:38
and without emblem. He
24:41
laughs at the oaths and ceremonies
24:43
with which conspirators bind themselves in
24:46
dramas and operas. This
24:49
man is simplicity personified. In
24:52
character he will bear comparison with
24:54
any of the fighters for freedom
24:57
in all lands. None
24:59
have been more disinterested than he.
25:02
None have loved mankind more than
25:04
he does. But
25:07
he would not permit me to say in
25:09
the forefront of his book all
25:11
the good that I think of him.
25:13
And should I say it, my
25:15
words would outrun the limits of
25:17
a reasonable preface. George
25:20
Brand's. When
25:23
the first edition of this book was brought
25:25
out at the end of 1899, it was
25:27
evident to those who
25:31
had followed the development of affairs in
25:33
Russia, that owing to
25:35
the obstinacy of its rulers in
25:38
refusing to make the necessary concessions in
25:40
the way of political freedom, the
25:43
country was rapidly drifting towards
25:45
a violent revolution. But
25:48
when everything seemed to be so calm on
25:51
the surface, that when a
25:53
few of us expressed this idea, we were
25:56
generally told that we merely took
25:58
our desires for reality. At
26:02
the present moment, Russia is in
26:04
full revolution. The
26:06
old system is falling to pieces, and
26:09
amidst its ruins, the new one is
26:11
painfully making its way. Meanwhile,
26:14
the defenders of the past are
26:16
waging a war of extermination against
26:18
the country, a
26:20
war which may prolong their rule for
26:22
a few additional months, but
26:24
which raises at the same time the
26:27
passions of the people, to
26:29
a pitch that is full of menaces
26:31
and danger. Looked
26:33
upon the light of present events, the
26:37
early movements for freedom which are
26:39
related in this book acquire a
26:41
new meaning. They
26:43
appear as the preparatory phrases of
26:45
the great breakdown of a whole
26:47
obsolete world, a breakdown
26:49
which is sure to give a new life
26:51
to nearly 150 million
26:54
people, and to
26:56
exercise at the same time a
26:58
deep and favorable influence upon the
27:00
march of progress in
27:02
all Europe and Asia. It
27:05
seems necessary therefore to complete the
27:07
record of events given in this
27:09
book by a
27:11
rapid review of those which have
27:13
taken place during the last seven
27:15
years, and were
27:18
the immediate cause of the present
27:20
revolution. The
27:22
thirteen years of the reign of Alexander III in
27:24
1881 to 1894 were perhaps the gloomiest portion
27:30
in the nineteenth century history
27:32
of Russia. Reaction
27:35
had been growing worse and worse during
27:38
the last few years of the
27:40
reign of his father, with the
27:42
result that a terrible war had
27:44
been waged against autocracy by
27:47
the executive committee, which
27:49
had inscribed on its banner political
27:51
freedom. After
27:53
the tragic death of Alexander II,
27:56
his son considered it his duty
27:58
to make no consent. sessions whatever,
28:01
to the general demand of
28:03
representative government, and
28:06
a few weeks after his advent to the
28:08
throne, he solemnly
28:10
declared his intention of remaining
28:13
an autocratic ruler of his empire,
28:17
and then began a heavy
28:19
silent crushing reaction against
28:22
all the great inspiring ideas of
28:24
liberty, which our generation
28:26
had lived through at the time of
28:28
the liberation of the serfs, a
28:32
reaction perhaps the more terrible on
28:34
account of its not being accompanied
28:37
by striking and revolting acts
28:39
of violence, a
28:41
bit slowly crushing down all
28:43
the progressive reforms of Alexander
28:45
II, and the
28:47
very spirit that bred these reforms, and
28:51
turning everything, including education,
28:54
into tools of a general reaction. Sheer
28:58
despair got hold of that generation
29:00
of Russian intellectuals who had to
29:02
live through that period. The
29:05
few survivors of the executive committee
29:07
laid down their arms, and
29:10
their spread in Russian intellectual
29:12
society, that helpless
29:14
despair, that loss of
29:17
faith in the forces of the
29:19
intellectual, that general
29:21
invasion of commonplace vulgarity,
29:25
true that Alexander III, since his
29:27
advent to the throne, had
29:29
vaguely understood the importance of
29:32
several economic questions concerning the
29:34
welfare of the peasants, and
29:36
had included them in his program. But
29:40
with the set of reactionary advisers whom
29:42
he had summoned to his aid, and
29:45
whom he retained throughout
29:47
his reign, he could accomplish nothing
29:50
serious. The reactionaries
29:52
whom he trusted did not at all
29:54
want to make those serious improvements in
29:56
the conditions of the peasants, which
29:59
he can see considered it the mission
30:01
of autocracy to accomplish, and
30:04
he would not call in other men because
30:07
he knew that they would require
30:09
a limitation of the powers of
30:11
autocracy, which he would not admit.
30:15
When he died, a general feeling
30:17
of relief went through Russia and
30:20
the civilized world at large. However,
30:24
Hadazar ascended the throne under
30:26
more favorable circumstances than Nicholas
30:28
II. After
30:31
these thirteen years of reaction, the
30:34
state of mind in Russia was such
30:36
that if Nicholas II had only mentioned,
30:39
in his advent manifesto, the
30:42
intention of taking the advice of his
30:44
country upon the great questions of inner
30:46
policy, which required
30:48
an immediate solution, he
30:51
would have been received with open arms.
30:54
The smallest concession would have been
30:57
gladly accepted as an asset. In
31:00
fact, the delegates of Zemstoff
31:02
assembled to greet him, asked
31:05
him only, and this in the
31:08
most submissive manner, to
31:10
establish a closer intercourse between
31:12
the emperor and the provincial
31:14
representation of the land. But
31:18
instead of accepting this modest
31:20
invitation, Nicholas II
31:22
read before the Zemstow
31:25
representatives the insolent
31:27
speech of reprimand, which
31:29
had been written for him by
31:32
Pobenovstoff, and which
31:34
expressed his intention of remaining an
31:37
autocratic ruler of his subjects. A
31:40
golden opportunity was thus lost.
31:44
Distrust became now the dominating note in
31:46
the relations between the nation and the
31:48
Tsar, and it
31:50
was striking to see how this
31:53
distrust in one of those indescribable
31:55
ways in which popular feelings develop,
31:58
rapidly spread from the Winter Palace.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More