Colleagues in Crime

In our first post-Halloween episode, Jenn tells the spooooky tale of the Greenbriar Ghost, and how this scary spirit helped solve her own murder! We then jump to the story of the wrong kind of anti-virus - John McAfee, namesake of, yep, that an

Part 2 - Death and Destruction at Action Park

Oct 21st, 2020 40m 4s

In Part 2 of our extra looong episode, Jenn recounts the twisty tale of New Jersey's Action Park, one of the most dangerous and deadly theme parks ever. On Action Park's dangerous thrill rides, bones were broken, people got electrocuted, and se

Part 1 - The Madeleine McCann Case and a New Person of Interest

Oct 15th, 2020 57m 14s

This week's episode is a 2-Parter! In Part 1, Melissa nerds out about the fact there's a new person of interest in the Madeleine McCann Case - after 13 years. Madeleine went missing while on vacation with her parents in Portugal, just shy of he

H.H.’s Hellish Hotel and Bad Bad Buildings

Oct 7th, 2020 1h 16m

You guys! After a loooong hiatus, we are thrilled to be back! Jenn first tells the story of H.H. Holmes and his multiple old-timey crimes, from horse thievery to owning what appeared to be a murder hotel - complete with soundproof rooms, doors

Bonus

Seedy Subjects and a Cruise Ruse

Apr 3rd, 2020 37m

Join Jenn and Melissa as we tell the tale of a roadside murder solved using - of all things - plant DNA! We then discuss a woman’s mysterious disappearance at sea and her extra fishy husband.

Death House Dorothy and Killer Coca Cola

Mar 19th, 2020 59m 20s

Imagine your sweet ol’ grandmotherly neighbor is caught with seven bodies buried in her backyard...and is suspected of killing even more. Come hang with us as we discuss the case of Dorothea Puente, dubbed ‘The Death House Lady.’ Next, a famil

Dirty Deeds in Dallas and Real Killer Clowns

Mar 13th, 2020 1h 16m

Tune in for a true tall Texas tale filled with twists and turns as we discuss the mysterious murder of Beverly Jean Hope. Is it really always the husband that did it? We then jump to the story of a real killer clown that showed up on Marlene Wa

Budweiser Bridezilla and Two Kra(z)y Kids

Mar 5th, 2020 1h 2m

Lucky number Episode Seven! Jenn tells the tale of a dentist’s premonition that ultimately leads police to investigate one of their own. Then Melissa covers the Kra(z)y story of Kray twins Ronnie and Reggie, two brazen gangsters who wined and d

Bonus

Teenysode Time

Mar 3rd, 2020 27m 56s

As a special thanks for all the support we've received so far, we want to thank YOU, our beloved Colleagues, with a bonus 'lil Teenysode! We discuss the merits of cat hair 'fur'ensics, and a case that happened in Melissa's hometown neighborhood

The Noho Bank Heist and Killer Grandparents

Feb 27th, 2020 1h 15m

Join us for the biggest cops and robbers story you’ve probably never heard of...but changed modern policing forever. And it happened right down the street from us!Next, we cover the case of Ray and Faye, a killer couple not nearly as cute as t

Ascots, Aliases, and Mysteries Unsolved

Feb 20th, 2020 1h 17m

Five Golden Episodes! Listen in for a story full of FAN-CEE twists and turns, following "Clark Rockefeller" (a.k.a. Christian Karl Gerhartsreiter, a.k.a. too many other aliases to list), who mingles with the social elite, but isn’t who he seem

Lover in a Cupboard and Singing Canaries

Feb 12th, 2020 1h 6m

Tune in for a forbidden love story where teenage Natasha Ryan seemingly vanishes, and we share the great lengths she took to hide her romance with Scott Black. Then we “hit” a story about a famous mob boss, Paul Castellano, who is responsible f

Jane Does and Chatroom Weirdos

Feb 6th, 2020 1h 5m

In celebration of our third episode, we’ve got three crimes comin’ atcha! We discuss the story of a long-cold case that was recently solved, the mysterious disappearance of Brianna Maitland, and finally, a killer the media dubbed “the Internet’

Creeps and Barrels

Jan 30th, 2020 59m 54s

On today’s episode, Jenn and Melissa discuss a criminal with one of the longest outstanding felony warrants on record – a woman named Sharon Kinne. We then jump to ‘The Hungarian Vampire’ Bela Kiss and his penchant for collecting barrels – and