Author, actor and comedian Dave Holmes was given a task that he thought he would be terrific at: run a trivia night for your friends and family. But Dave, a man of vast trivial knowledge himself, made an error: no one could get any of his questions right. Dave accidentally made a completely infuriating quiz.

In this episode, we see how Dave's questions do against two contestants: a 12-time-winning Jeopardy champion and a normal guy who likes trivia.