Podchaser Logo
Home
HAP 134 - The Marx Brothers - Cedric J. Robinson

HAP 134 - The Marx Brothers - Cedric J. Robinson

Released Sunday, 5th November 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
HAP 134 - The Marx Brothers - Cedric J. Robinson

HAP 134 - The Marx Brothers - Cedric J. Robinson

HAP 134 - The Marx Brothers - Cedric J. Robinson

HAP 134 - The Marx Brothers - Cedric J. Robinson

Sunday, 5th November 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:14

Hello, and welcome to the History of Africana

0:16

Philosophy, by Tchiki Jeffers and Peter Adamson,

0:19

brought to you with the support of the King's College

0:21

London Philosophy Department and the LMU

0:23

in Munich, online at historyofphilosophy.net.

0:27

Today's episode, The Marx Brothers,

0:30

Cedric J. Robinson. The

0:34

Scottish philosopher David Hume's 1740

0:36

Treatise of Human Nature is widely

0:39

appreciated today as a masterwork of modern

0:41

European philosophy,

0:42

but when Hume first published the book, it did

0:45

not receive much attention. He famously

0:47

described it in a later writing as having fell

0:49

dead-born from the press.

0:52

Our subject in this episode, the African-American

0:54

historian and political theorist Cedric

0:56

J. Robinson published a book in 1983

0:59

titled Black Marxism, the Making

1:01

of the Black Radical Tradition.

1:04

In ways that are somewhat camouflaged by the

1:06

book's title, this was a very philosophically

1:08

ambitious work, just as was Hume's treatise.

1:11

It is perhaps fitting, then, that the book initially

1:14

issued forth from the London-based publisher Z.

1:16

Press to a similarly lifeless

1:18

reception. Some of the first scholars

1:21

to draw attention to the book's value in the late

1:23

1980s were professional philosophers.

1:26

Leonard Harris, who appeared on the podcast back in episode 79,

1:30

drew on Robinson's notion of a black radical

1:32

tradition in his 1987 article

1:34

Historical Subjects and Interests, Race,

1:37

Class, and Conflict.

1:38

Cornel West, who we will be discussing

1:41

in an upcoming episode, published a review

1:43

essay on Black Marxism in 1988, aiming

1:46

to interrupt the silence surrounding the book.

1:49

He lamented that it had already fallen through

1:51

the cracks and argued that it should now be acknowledged

1:53

as a towering achievement, even as

1:55

he went on to make serious criticisms of the book

1:58

over the course of his review.

2:00

Someone else who early on recognized the importance

2:02

of black Marxism is the historian

2:05

Robin D. Telly, who provided

2:07

a foreword when the book was republished in a new edition

2:10

by the University of North Carolina Press in

2:12

the year 2000. The story

2:14

of his encounter with the book is indicative of the

2:16

power of its title to intrigue and

2:18

potentially mislead. Affirming

2:21

in no uncertain terms that this book changed

2:23

his life, Telly explains that he was just

2:25

a few months into his graduate studies at UCLA

2:28

when a review copy was sent to Ufa

2:30

Hamu, a graduate student journal published

2:33

by the University's African Studies Center. Telly

2:35

had previously heard missing about the book or its

2:38

author, who was then director of the Center

2:40

of Black Studies at the nearby UC Santa

2:42

Barbara. The book's title automatically

2:44

attracted Telly. His interest in historical

2:46

research at that point was primarily motivated

2:49

by his concern too, as he put it, know

2:51

how to build a left-wing movement among people

2:54

of color so that we could get on with the ultimate

2:56

task of making revolution. Given

2:59

this interest, the book titled Black Marxism,

3:01

the Making of the Black Radical Tradition, seemed

3:04

almost heaven-sent. Telly excitedly

3:06

set himself the task of reviewing it for Ufa

3:09

Hamu. He never did manage

3:11

to write that review, something he admits meant

3:13

contributing unwittingly to the conspiracy

3:15

of silence that has surrounded the book since its

3:17

publication. The problem

3:20

was that Telly felt so overwhelmed by reading

3:22

Black Marxism that he suffered a crisis

3:24

in confidence, which he managed to fix only

3:26

by calling Robinson on the telephone and begging

3:29

to be taken on as a student. It

3:31

was an understandable reaction. It is indeed

3:33

an overwhelming work. The footnotes alone

3:36

could make for a whole separate book. It's

3:38

also a surprising book. Given

3:40

the title, one might expect a sympathetic or

3:42

at least constructively critical account of

3:44

Black Marxist thought and activity. What

3:47

Telly and readers since have found instead

3:49

is a searing critique of Marxism's limitations

3:52

and a definition of Black radicalism grounded

3:54

not in Marxism, but in a unique interpretation

3:57

of indigenous African traditions. Here

4:00

is how Kelly sums up the work. Robinson

4:02

literally rewrites the history of the rise of

4:05

the West from ancient times to the mid-20th century,

4:07

tracing the roots of Black radical thought to

4:10

a shared epistemology among diverse African

4:12

people and providing a withering critique

4:14

of Western Marxism and its inability

4:16

to comprehend either the racial character

4:19

of capitalism and the civilization in which

4:21

it was born or mass movements outside

4:23

Europe. Especially

4:26

since its republication in 2000, Black

4:28

Marxism has become much more widely appreciated

4:31

and has even attained a level of influence among

4:33

activists beyond the academy. The

4:35

phrase racial capitalism, for instance,

4:37

has become widely used in many activist circles,

4:40

mainly through Robinson's influence. The

4:42

phrase had already been used before him by South

4:45

African historians Martin Leitgastik and

4:47

David Hemson in their 1976 pamphlet,

4:50

Foreign Investment and the Reproduction of Racial Capitalism

4:52

in South Africa, but Robinson denied

4:55

having learned the phrase from them. Indeed,

4:57

while Leitgastik and Hemson sought merely

4:59

to show how apartheid and capitalism worked

5:02

hand in hand in the case of South Africa, Robinson's

5:04

claim in the first chapter of Black Marxism was

5:07

much broader and much bolder, namely

5:09

that capitalism is always inextricably

5:11

intertwined with racism. All capitalism

5:14

is racial, according to Robinson, because

5:16

it grew out of a proto-racist context

5:18

and, as he goes on to show in later parts of the book,

5:21

developed in lockstep with the racism of the

5:23

Atlantic slave trade. In

5:26

an essay published more than a decade later called

5:28

Slavery and the Platonic Origins of Anti-Democracy,

5:31

Robinson went so far as to trace the patterns of

5:33

thought we associate with modern slavery right

5:36

back to Plato's Republic. He

5:38

finds in that dialogue an oppressive slave-owning

5:41

ideal society that can justify itself

5:43

only with a racial myth. This

5:46

refers to the infamous noble lie, according

5:48

to which the people of the city are divided into classes

5:51

and told that this assignment is due to the different

5:53

metals in their blood. Robinson

5:56

points out that even Plato's diagnosis of how

5:58

cities go wrong is fun. fundamentally elitist.

6:02

Despite the many popular revolts that occurred in

6:04

his own time, Plato assumes that corruption

6:06

of the political system can only spread from the

6:08

top down. It is as if,

6:10

comments Robinson, the rest of Greek humanity

6:13

was not real time. Robinson

6:16

goes on to connect what he views as Plato's proto-racism

6:19

to a classic example of modern racism we have

6:21

had occasion to mention a number of times on this podcast,

6:24

Thomas Jefferson's Thoughts on Black Inferiority,

6:27

in his Notes on the State of Virginia. Connecting

6:30

this with other forms of elitism expressed by

6:32

America's sounding fathers, Robinson concludes,

6:35

In its anti-democratic, budacronic prejudice,

6:38

the republic provides an authority rich in

6:40

intellectual stratagems, apropos

6:42

to the political discourse embedded in the American

6:44

political order.

6:46

Plato survives, because if he had not

6:48

existed, he would have had to be invented.

6:52

This rather critical interpretation of ancient

6:54

and modern Western thought, usefully illustrates

6:56

Robinson's methods, themes, and historical

6:59

and intellectual range. It

7:01

presumably also helps to make it clear that his critique

7:03

of Marxism in black merchism was

7:05

not born out of conservatism or

7:07

a desire to defend capitalism. A

7:10

look at his life story will provide further confirmation

7:12

of that. Robinson

7:15

was born in 1940 and grew up in Oakland. The

7:17

family's story, illustrative of the drama

7:19

and heartache of the Great Migration, was that

7:21

his grandfather had fled to California from Alabama

7:24

after beating a white man for attempting to have

7:26

his way with Robinson's grandmother. Robinson

7:29

attended UC Berkeley, where he was a student

7:32

activist with the NAACP. He

7:34

worked to bring iconic leaders like Robert

7:36

F. Williams, who we discussed in Episode 110, to

7:39

speak on campus. An attempt

7:42

to bring Malcolm X to the campus

7:44

was blocked by the university, but Robinson

7:46

and his fellow organizers were still able to hear him

7:48

speak at a local YMCA. That

7:51

encounter with X made a major impact

7:53

on another figure we've discussed before, Donald

7:55

Morden, who founded the Afro-American

7:58

Association.

7:59

episode 111, Gordon's

8:02

Afro-American Association was a campus

8:04

reading group that gradually moved toward off-campus

8:07

activism and in the process provided an

8:09

intellectual training ground for both the Black Panthers

8:11

and Malana Karenga. Robinson

8:13

was part of the group, as was his good friend, a graduate

8:16

student from India named Shyamala Gopalan,

8:19

and the man she married, a graduate student from Jamaica

8:21

named Donald Harris. The

8:23

fact that Gopalan and Harris met through the Afro-American

8:26

Association is a rather significant historical

8:28

event given that the first child produced

8:30

by their marriage is the current Vice President

8:32

of the United States, Kamala Harris. We're

8:35

not sure whether the Vice President has read the network

8:37

system, and we wouldn't be surprised. After

8:40

all, her mother is listed in the books preface as

8:42

among those with whom the project had

8:44

its beginnings. In 1962,

8:48

Robinson went to Africa as part of a government project

8:50

called Operation Crossroads Africa. He

8:53

spent the most time in what is now Zimbabwe,

8:55

but was then still Southern Rhodesia, and he

8:57

was struck by his encounter with Ndaba Ngingi

8:59

Sitole, whose 1959 book

9:02

African Nationalism was a pioneering work

9:04

of autobiography and anti-colonial political

9:07

analysis. Upon his return,

9:09

he was drafted, but fortunately never deployed

9:11

to Vietnam. From then on,

9:13

his life was lived within academia. He

9:16

attained a master's degree in political science from

9:18

San Francisco State, and then a PhD

9:20

in the same discipline from Stanford, enjoyed

9:22

a fruitful research stay in England, funded by

9:24

a previous supporter of this podcast, the

9:26

Liberium Trust, and then held close

9:28

at the University of Michigan, and SUNY Binghamton,

9:31

before taking up leadership of the Center of Black Studies

9:34

at UC Santa Barbara, as previously

9:36

mentioned. If

9:38

it isn't the most eventful of biographies in

9:40

political terms, in contrast with the life

9:42

of his fellow California academic Angela

9:44

Davis, Robinson's life was plenty stimulating

9:47

on the intellectual front. It

9:49

can seem like every figure who has come up in this podcast

9:51

series is either mentioned in Black Marxism or

9:54

met Robinson personally or both. The

9:56

book sites, among others, Shaykh Antatayev,

9:58

Oliver Cox, Eric Williams, and James, Emile Codd Cabral,

10:01

Alexander Cromwell, Mary Church Terrell, Ida

10:03

B. Wells, Carter G. Woodson, and returner

10:06

Edward Blige, J.J. Thomas, and the American

10:08

Negro Academy. As for his

10:10

personal contacts, they included C.L.R. James

10:13

and Walter Rodney, who came to speak at Michigan

10:15

while Robinson was there. At a single

10:18

event held at the Center of Black Studies in 1989, Robinson

10:20

spoke alongside Stuart

10:23

Hall, Paul Gilroy, Cobina Mercer,

10:25

and Sylvia Winter. We'll be covering her

10:27

next time. This man's address book,

10:29

good with light editing, be used as the table

10:31

of contents for a book on Africana thought in the

10:33

late 20th century. He

10:36

used his connections with other intellectuals to bring

10:38

attention to current events, at home or abroad.

10:41

For example, he worked on finishing Black Marxism

10:43

during the 1981-1980 school year in England,

10:46

funded by a postdoctoral fellowship. This

10:49

brought him to London not long after the black community

10:51

there was rocked by the mysterious New

10:53

Cross house fire, which killed 13 black

10:56

young people, and a series of riots

10:58

in response to racial discrimination. During

11:01

his day, Robinson worked with the Institute of Race

11:03

Relations, the British think tank, to bring

11:05

over Tony Cade Bambara, whom we have

11:08

recently covered as a pioneering black

11:10

feminist of the 1970s. Cade

11:12

Bambara was based in Atlanta at the time and

11:15

had been consumed with the horror of the infamous

11:17

child murders that took place in that city between 1979

11:19

and 1981. By

11:22

bringing her to speak in England, Robinson

11:24

grabbed an opportunity to draw attention, as

11:26

his biographer Joshua Myers put it, to

11:29

the global vulnerability of black children and

11:31

the need for transnational resistance to racial

11:34

capitalism. On the topic

11:36

of his collaborations with women thinkers, we

11:38

must also mention Robinson's wife Elizabeth, who

11:40

was born in the US to Lebanese parents

11:43

and was very much his intellectual partner. She

11:46

was instrumental in encouraging the project of

11:48

Black Marxism and collaborated with

11:50

him on a long-running series produced for local

11:52

Santa Barbara radio and then public access

11:54

television called Third World News

11:57

Review. On October of 1983, The

12:00

Robinsons reacted to the major events of the moment,

12:02

the bombing of military barracks in Beirut and

12:05

the US invasion of Grenada by appearing

12:07

at a rally, with Elizabeth speaking about

12:09

Lebanon and Cedric focusing on Grenada.

12:13

This same year, 1983 saw the publication

12:15

of Black Marxism. Dissilling

12:17

the argument of this book into one sentence is

12:19

no easier than it was with Gilroy's Black Atlantic,

12:22

but let's give it a shot. Robinson

12:24

wants to argue that, despite its revolutionary intent,

12:27

classical Marxism was itself a manifestation

12:29

of racialized European thinking and that

12:31

black radical thought offers a vital alternative.

12:35

To establish this, he begins, as we've said, with

12:37

a lengthy historical narrative. He

12:39

argues that medieval slavery already anticipated

12:42

the Atlantic slave trade by subjecting certain groups

12:44

to unfreedom. Not for nothing

12:47

does the word slave have an etymological

12:49

link to the word slav. And

12:51

from the very beginning of capitalism in Italian

12:53

city-states, racialized slavery was part

12:55

of the story. Modern cargo was transported

12:58

in the ships of these early capitalists. Furthermore,

13:01

Europe never developed independently but was always

13:04

developing through interactions with non-European

13:06

peoples, whether this meant fighting the armies

13:08

of Islam or exploiting the resources

13:10

and population of Africa. These

13:12

interactions were fundamental to the development of

13:15

modern European states and their economies, so

13:17

a myopic focus on Europe's inner history

13:20

can never discern the true patterns of that

13:22

history. Washington

13:24

detects just such myopia in the thought of Marx

13:26

and Engels. Much as it just didn't

13:29

occur to Plato that the lower classes might be

13:31

the potential revolutionaries in classical Greece,

13:33

it just didn't occur to the classical Marxists that

13:36

anyone but the European proletariat could

13:38

be the historical engine of revolution. The

13:41

root of the methodological and conceptual

13:43

flaws, says Robinson, is the presumption

13:45

that the social and historical processes

13:48

that matter, which are determinative, are

13:50

European. As it overlooked

13:53

the crucial racial part of racial

13:55

capitalism, Marxism's critique of capitalism

13:57

was doomed to be at best incomplete. As

14:00

Robinson puts it, Marxism is its state

14:02

western construction that incorporated

14:05

theoretical and ideological weaknesses that

14:07

stemmed from the same social forces that

14:09

provided the basis of capitalist formation.

14:12

So that's the gist of the first half of black

14:15

Marxism. It paves the way for the

14:17

second half, in which Robinson shows how black

14:19

radicals have done exactly what classical Marxism

14:21

could not have expected by posing a more

14:24

adequate critique from outside the traditional

14:26

European theme. Robinson

14:28

retains enough of a Marxist outlook to imply

14:31

that the emergence of such a critique was inevitable.

14:34

Black radical ideology was, he says, the

14:36

historical antilogic to racism,

14:38

slavery, and capitalism, and informing

14:41

that ideology, black thinkers of the 19th

14:43

and 20th centuries were discovering their theoretical

14:46

task. There's a resonance

14:48

here with Robinson's doctoral thesis, later

14:50

published under the title The Terms of Order,

14:53

Political Science, and the Myth of Leadership. Again,

14:55

this is an ambitious and complicated work, but

14:58

we can just note one of its central themes,

15:00

which is that political leaders do not come up with ideas

15:03

or projects and then take the people with them,

15:05

as usually assumed. Rather, they emerge

15:07

as more or less inevitable crystallizations

15:09

of the concerns the people already have. Robinson

15:12

thus writes, it is in truth the charismatic

15:15

figure who has been selected by social circumstance,

15:18

psychodynamic peculiarities and tradition, and

15:20

not his followers by him.

15:23

One example Robinson discussed in depth was

15:25

Malcolm X, who had been the subject of his very

15:27

first academic publication.

15:29

In a subsequent lecture, Robinson said, it

15:31

was not important that he say something new, it was

15:34

not important that he articulate novel insights,

15:36

it was important that he reflect the historical

15:39

experiences, the understanding, the comprehension

15:41

of the masses of black people in this country and

15:43

in the Caribbean. He did not say anything

15:46

new, it was the organized presentation

15:48

which was new. Something

15:51

similar could be said of the radicals at the center of black

15:53

Marxism. No, classical Marxism

15:55

was flawed. Its proponents were ripe

15:57

to discern a dialectical historical process.

16:00

that would generate resistance to capitalist

16:02

oppression. In fact, Marxism

16:05

even implies its own critique, pointing

16:07

beyond itself toward a further line of analysis

16:09

that it was too limited to grasp because

16:11

of its European roots. But

16:13

just as leaders are selected by their followers, so

16:16

radical theorists do not create potentially

16:18

revolutionary forces, they only notice

16:20

and describe them.

16:22

Enormous angles were not members of the proletariat,

16:25

they were educated into rituals,

16:27

and likewise the Black radicals, who most powerfully

16:29

articulated an anti-racist, anti-European

16:32

ideology, were almost without exception

16:34

members of what we might nowadays call the Black-no-claps.

16:37

Robinson instead uses the Marxist

16:39

technical term petit bourgeoisie and

16:42

observes that a long line of Africa thinkers

16:44

belonging to this group, like George Padmore,

16:46

C.L.R. James, Edric Williams, and Oliver Cox.

16:50

All of them, says Robinson, illustrate Frans

16:52

Fanon's phrase, Black skins under white

16:54

masks. We've seen this point before,

16:56

albeit in a rather different context, when

16:58

Émile-Cain-Cambrales posited that petit bourgeois

17:01

men like himself were called to leave the popular

17:03

uprising in Guinea-Bissau in an act

17:06

of last suicide. The

17:08

point was also made by C.L.R. James, with

17:10

reference to M.A. Césaire, who went to the

17:12

Sorbonne and taught Latin, Greek,

17:14

and French literature in Martinique. Césaire,

17:17

observed James, was able to make this

17:19

ferocious attack upon Western civilization

17:21

because he knew it inside out. He

17:23

had spent some 20 years studying it. Three

17:27

Black radicals in particular received especially

17:29

extensive attention in Black Marxism. They

17:32

are W.E.B. Du Bois, C.L.R.

17:34

James, and Richard Wright, all of whom were

17:36

attracted to Marxist thought but eventually, according

17:38

to Robinson, saw its weaknesses. All

17:41

three pointed to the fact that Black people, and

17:43

non-Europeans more generally, are not fated

17:46

to be the inert subject matter of history,

17:49

but agents, who can be producers

17:51

of ideologies, epistemologies, producers

17:53

of history. Robinson

17:55

recognizes Du Bois as especially pioneering,

17:58

because he was the first to discern deep connections

18:00

between racism and capitalism to

18:02

see that racial oppression was a long-standing part

18:04

of the economic system and not an aberration

18:07

or a mistake. James then

18:09

added something new with his account of the Haitian

18:11

Revolution. Here was a concrete

18:13

demonstration that the revolutionary proletariat

18:16

did not have to be European factory workers.

18:19

Instead, the Africans had constructed their

18:21

own revolutionary history. The

18:23

lesson drawn by Robinson is that it was

18:26

the materials constructed from a shared philosophy

18:28

developed in the African past and transmitted

18:30

as culture from which revolutionary consciousness

18:33

was realized and the ideology of struggle

18:35

formed.

18:37

As he says here, Robinson sees the cultural

18:39

heritage of Africa and the diaspora as

18:42

an important counterweight to capitalist imperialism.

18:45

The imperialists know this too, which is

18:47

why they always try to undermine indigenous

18:49

culture, the point we've seen and heard in

18:51

Gugiwa-Chango making eloquently.

18:54

Robinson writes that French colonialism always

18:57

attempted to destroy the people's culture

18:59

in order for those people to become appropriate

19:01

citizens in the French Empire. Thus,

19:04

a favorite line of Robinson's, the first

19:06

attack is an attack upon culture. Since

19:09

the best defense is a good offense, Black

19:12

radicals have responded with a cultural attack

19:14

of their own, subjecting white power structures

19:16

to withering criticism.

19:18

A good example is the third hero of Black

19:20

Marxism, Richard Wright, who was

19:22

unusual in not coming from a middle class background.

19:25

Perhaps for this reason, he saw in all Black

19:28

people the potential for challenging Western civilization

19:30

itself. Wright is also

19:32

important to Robinson because he most obviously

19:35

went from embracing Marxism to transcending

19:37

it. As you might remember, Wright

19:39

joined but then split from the communists. In

19:42

episode 94, we quoted him saying that they could not help

19:44

him realize the ambition of uniting scattered

19:47

but kindred peoples into a whole. Robinson

19:50

summarizes Wright's realization in the following terms,

19:53

Though immersed in the American radical movement

19:55

with its Eurocentric ideology, it

19:57

had not taken Wright very long to reach the conclusion

20:00

that the historical development of black people in

20:02

the United States constituted the most

20:04

total contradiction to Western capitalist

20:06

society. How

20:09

would Robinson have seen his own contribution within

20:11

the radical tradition of Du Bois, James and Wright?

20:14

Well, for one thing, he was no ivory power

20:16

academic.

20:17

As a theme, he was active in the NAACP

20:19

as a student, and at UCSB,

20:22

he supported such actions as a strike in 1998.

20:25

But in terms of his intellectual workfare, it

20:27

would be fair to stress above all his leadership of

20:29

the center of black studies. Nowadays,

20:32

when many universities have programs, degrees

20:34

and centers in black, African, African-American studies,

20:38

one can easily take such institutions

20:40

for granted.

20:41

But their establishment was hard won.

20:43

And in the early stages, their project needed to

20:45

be explained and theorized.

20:47

One of Robinson's UCSB colleagues, Brad

20:50

Moten, has done this in rather blunt terms

20:52

and in the process made it clear that the enterprise

20:54

was never a narrowly academic one. If

20:57

black studies is a critique of Western civilization,

21:00

you challenge the metaphysical foundations of

21:02

the goddamn civilization. And

21:04

that actually manifested itself at the level

21:06

of your own ethical compartment in the world. For

21:10

a take on this discipline that is more typical of Robinson

21:12

himself, we can turn to another of his essays,

21:15

David Walker and the Precepts of Black Studies.

21:18

It's one of a number of pieces, many of them previously

21:21

unpublished, collected in a volume entitled

21:23

Cedric J. Robinson on racial capitalism,

21:25

black internationalism, and cultures of resistance.

21:29

The essay on Walker, delivered in 1997

21:31

at a black studies conference at Ohio State University,

21:34

is typical, firstly, in that his discussion is

21:36

framed historically, and also because

21:38

Robinson was rarely happy to do just one

21:40

thing at a time. He wants simultaneously

21:43

to highlight the pioneering radicalism of Walker's

21:45

incendiary appeal, show that Walker,

21:48

in a sense, was already calling for something like black

21:50

studies and draw lessons for current

21:52

day practitioners. His historical

21:55

sensibility leads him to contest attempts to connect

21:57

Walker to black nationalism

21:59

as targets

21:59

appear include Wilson Moses, yet another

22:02

former podcast interview guest, and Sterling

22:04

Stuckey. Robinson's dispute

22:06

with Stuckey is particularly interesting because

22:09

Stuckey's 1987 book, Slave

22:11

Culture, Nationalist Theory and the Foundations

22:13

of Black America has striking thematic

22:15

and structural similarities with Black Marxism.

22:19

Against these interpreters, Robinson argues that Walker

22:21

cannot be easily appropriated because he is

22:24

non-modern. His ideas

22:26

were embedded in a religious worldview and ended up

22:28

with ideas of divine providence and retribution

22:31

in ways that few Black thinkers in the later 20th

22:33

century would recognize as live options.

22:36

Yet Walker still provides a model to imitate

22:39

because he glimpsed the idea of Black Studies.

22:41

That is, he envisioned an intellectual

22:43

project that was a massive victory

22:45

and populist, employing inquiry

22:47

for the purpose of mobilizing for deliberate

22:49

and informed social action. Walker's

22:52

appeal urged Black people to understand

22:54

their own history and the achievements of their

22:56

people, imploring his readers, go

22:59

to work and enlighten your brethren,

23:01

which is when you boil it down exactly

23:03

what Robinson did.

23:06

This very podcast can be considered as a contribution

23:08

to Black Studies, and so in our own way,

23:11

we are following in Walker's and Robinson's footsteps.

23:13

And of course, we're far from the only ones.

23:16

Next time, we'll look at another pioneering figure

23:18

of this academic field. As they say

23:20

on Game of Thrones, next time, winter

23:22

is coming. Sylvia Winter, that is, here

23:25

on The History of Africana.

23:27

Ooh, ooh, ooh, ooh, ooh,

23:29

ooh, ooh, ooh.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features