Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
4:00
They spent time during youth group together,
4:02
they hung out outside of the church.
4:04
They really were each other's ride or
4:06
die friendships. And each one of them
4:09
had a little bit of a different
4:11
personality. Kelly was known to be
4:13
more on the quiet side. She was a little
4:15
bit more reserved. And then you
4:17
had Heidi, who was much more
4:20
outgoing. She definitely was the
4:22
one who was friends with everyone. She
4:24
was a little spunky. She had a
4:26
little bit of an edge to her,
4:28
but she was always including and welcoming
4:30
to everyone around. And
4:32
then you had Rachel, who has
4:35
described herself as almost the wild
4:37
child of the group. And like
4:39
I said, the three of them
4:41
were inseparable. They actually called themselves
4:43
Charlie's Angels. They were always spending
4:45
time together with one another and
4:47
making new memories. Sometimes it
4:49
is very difficult as a trio of a
4:51
friend group, especially a trio of girls to
4:55
not get jealous of one another or
4:57
to not, you know, feel like other
4:59
people might have closer friendships than you
5:01
do. The bonds sometimes tend
5:03
to get threatened in a trio
5:05
friend group, but this one did
5:08
not have that. The
5:10
three of them, like I said, were
5:12
inseparable and all had that same bond
5:14
and love for each other and their
5:17
friendship. Now while the girls
5:19
were teenagers, they ended up going to
5:21
a summer camp one year. And
5:24
this was called Discovery Country
5:26
Camp in Columbus, Texas. Now
5:29
this was a church summer camp. So
5:31
they were all going to go to
5:33
church camp and Kelly, Heidi, and Rachel
5:35
were all very excited to hear that
5:37
they had the opportunity to go to
5:39
this church camp. Because again, not only
5:41
was their faith really important to them,
5:43
and if they were going to go
5:45
to camp, they wanted it to be
5:47
somewhere where they can continue practicing their
5:49
faith and instilling those Christian values. It
5:51
was again, very, very important to them,
5:53
but also they were excited because it
5:55
meant the three of them got to
5:57
go together. They got to create new
5:59
memories. she
10:00
was pregnant with their first
10:02
child. Now as I mentioned
10:04
earlier, Heidi was very, very
10:07
passionate about her faith and so
10:09
because she found out she was
10:11
pregnant without being married, she was
10:14
very worried about how the public
10:16
was going to perceive this pregnancy.
10:18
She didn't know if she was
10:20
going to be judged, she didn't
10:22
know how people were going to
10:24
react, however she herself was so
10:27
excited to become a mom. Once
10:29
Heidi had her son, she felt
10:31
like her true purpose was being
10:33
a mother. She loved her son
10:35
more than anything and she was
10:37
completely dedicated and devoted to being
10:39
the best mom that she possibly
10:41
could. Now after her son was
10:43
born, Heidi and Shane decided that
10:46
they were going to take a
10:48
move and move to Austin, Texas.
10:50
A big reason for this was because Heidi
10:52
and Shane really just wanted to start a
10:55
new chapter in their lives. Heidi specifically had
10:57
lived in Louisiana all of her life and
10:59
she wanted something new. She wanted something
11:01
different, she wanted her son to be
11:03
able to grow up in a different
11:05
environment that she did and so because
11:07
of that, that is why they moved
11:09
to Austin, Texas. But even though everything
11:11
was looking picture perfect on the outside,
11:14
as we all know, typically that
11:16
is not the case behind closed
11:18
doors. When Heidi and Shane moved
11:21
to Austin, Texas, their relationship really
11:23
started to get a little bit
11:25
rocky. They had a tumultuous relationship.
11:28
It was very on and off.
11:30
They were breaking up and making up
11:32
time and time again. They really were
11:34
the epitome of the on and off
11:36
couple that I'm sure most of us
11:38
know. We all know that one couple,
11:40
they were consistently on and off, however
11:43
the love was always there and Heidi
11:45
and Shane were both dedicated to making
11:47
their family work for the sake of
11:49
their son but also for the sake
11:51
of themselves. They really truly did love
11:53
each other and they were fighting for
11:55
their relationship. Now Heidi did become pregnant
11:57
a second time after moving to Austin.
12:00
Austin, Texas. And this was also
12:02
an unexpected pregnancy. Now in the
12:04
beginning of this pregnancy, Heidi was
12:06
very anxious. She didn't know what
12:08
the future of her and Shane's
12:10
relationship was going to look like
12:12
at that point because again, they
12:14
were very on and off at
12:16
that time. And at this time
12:18
when she got pregnant, she wasn't
12:20
surrounded by her family. During her
12:22
first pregnancy, she had her friends,
12:25
she had her parents, and this
12:27
time she was in Austin, Texas
12:29
really by herself. And so because
12:31
of this, she really decided that
12:33
she needed to lean on other
12:35
friends in her life. She needed
12:37
to be able to have that
12:39
support considering she was outside of
12:41
where she was comfortable in. So
12:43
because of this at this time,
12:45
Heidi really turned back to Carissa
12:47
and Meghan, the two friends from
12:49
summer camp. Now Carissa and
12:52
Meghan at the time were still
12:54
living in Texas and the three
12:56
of them got very close. Carissa
12:58
was a little bit further out.
13:00
She wasn't as close physically to
13:02
Heidi as Meghan was. However, the
13:05
three would always chitchat. They were
13:07
always talking, but Meghan and Heidi
13:09
were seeing each other very, very
13:11
frequently. And after some
13:13
time passed and Heidi was really spending
13:15
a lot of time with Meghan doing
13:17
different activities, hanging out all the time,
13:20
she really started to feel better. Her
13:22
spirits were lifted and she began feeling
13:24
very, very excited and hopeful for the
13:26
future. At this point, her and Shane
13:28
were back in a really, really great
13:30
spot. All of Heidi's friends said that
13:33
at this point, Shane really stepped up
13:35
to the plate in their relationship and
13:37
became the man that Heidi always wanted
13:39
him to be. He was there for
13:41
her, he supported her, and it seemed
13:43
like their relationship was now on a
13:46
very good and healthy track. So they
13:48
were in a really great spot. So
13:50
everything seemed to be going very, very
13:52
well at this point. Heidi had her
13:54
girls, she had her friends who were
13:56
supporting her. She was pregnant. They were
13:58
expecting another baby. She had her son.
14:01
And now her and Shane are doing
14:03
very well too. But the good news
14:05
didn't stop there because Heidi was thrilled,
14:08
absolutely over the moon, when
14:10
she heard that Meghan was
14:12
also pregnant. Meghan announced her
14:14
pregnancy only a few weeks
14:16
after Heidi announced hers. And
14:18
the biggest shock with all
14:20
of it was when Meghan
14:23
said that her and Heidi
14:25
actually had the same due
14:27
date. Now, you might be
14:29
sitting here wondering, who was the
14:31
father of Meghan's baby? Well, Meghan
14:33
had an on and off boyfriend
14:36
at the time named Chris. And
14:38
the two were not dating for
14:40
very long, so it was unexpected
14:42
that Meghan was now pregnant. However,
14:44
everyone was still very, very excited
14:46
for her in this new chapter
14:48
of their lives. And Meghan and
14:50
Heidi were especially excited because this
14:52
meant that not only were they
14:55
best friends, but they were about
14:57
to have babies at the same time.
14:59
They got to experience being pregnant together.
15:01
It was just a lot of excitement
15:03
filling the air. Now, despite all of
15:05
this excitement that was going on, the
15:08
relationship between Meghan and her boyfriend Chris
15:10
was definitely a rocky one. The two
15:12
of them were together technically, but they
15:14
really didn't spend a lot of time
15:16
together. They even lived on opposite sides
15:19
of the house, so they didn't see
15:21
each other very often. And Chris traveled
15:23
a lot for work, so he was
15:25
not a home a lot to begin
15:27
with. And so because
15:29
of this, Meghan really started leaning on
15:31
Heidi. There was times where Heidi leaned
15:33
on Meghan. Meghan was now leaning on
15:35
Heidi for support because she claimed that
15:37
she was scared about what the future
15:39
was going to look like if she
15:41
was going to be a single mother,
15:44
how she was going to navigate that.
15:46
She really confided in Heidi during all
15:48
of this and turned to Heidi for
15:50
support. And Heidi felt a
15:52
lot of compassion for Meghan. She knew what
15:54
it felt like to be in a rocky
15:56
relationship. And Heidi really tried to be there
15:58
to support Meghan in every way. she could.
16:00
She told her that no matter what,
16:02
she always had a place to stay,
16:05
she always had somewhere to go. Heidi
16:07
would always be there for her no
16:09
matter what the future looked like, whether
16:11
she was with Chris or not with
16:13
Chris. So now we move
16:15
on to nine months later, November 26, 2019,
16:19
Heidi gave birth to her daughter. She
16:21
was a healthy baby and everyone was
16:24
thrilled. Now Megan, who was very far
16:26
along in her pregnancy at this point,
16:28
because like I said, her and Heidi
16:30
had the same due date. She was
16:32
very far along, but she really wanted
16:35
to be there for Heidi when she
16:37
gave birth to her daughter. So she
16:39
drove down from Houston to Austin to
16:41
be there for Heidi when she had
16:43
her baby. Now Heidi was
16:45
very appreciative of the fact that Megan
16:47
came. She really loved the fact that
16:49
her friend was there to support her.
16:51
And because of this, Heidi and Shane
16:53
decided that they wanted Megan to stay
16:56
at their apartment for the night while
16:58
they were at the hospital because the
17:00
two of them didn't want Megan to
17:02
have to worry about driving back to
17:04
Houston that night while she was so
17:06
pregnant. They thought it would be better
17:08
if Megan just stayed the night at
17:10
their apartment. And that is exactly what
17:12
Megan did. Now two weeks later, two
17:14
weeks after Heidi had her daughter on
17:16
December 6, 2019,
17:19
Megan herself announced that she had
17:21
also given birth to her daughter
17:23
named Luna. Now this was very
17:25
exciting because if you think about
17:27
it, it's very picturesque. It's very
17:29
storybook. The fact that Megan and
17:32
Heidi, who are best friends, now
17:34
have two daughters who they get
17:36
to raise and they're going to
17:38
be best friends, it all seemed
17:40
almost too good to be true.
17:43
But regardless, everyone was so thrilled
17:45
for this new chapter. But things
17:47
began to change several days later
17:49
on December 12, 2019, when Heidi
17:51
never made it to pick her
17:53
son up from school. On
17:56
the afternoon of December 12, 2019, Shane
17:58
began calling for a call. calling around
18:00
to different friends in the area asking
18:02
if anyone had seen or heard
18:05
from Heidi because it was very unlike her
18:07
to not pick up their son.
18:09
That was something that she always did. She
18:11
would have never missed picking up her son
18:13
from school. Heidi's mom, Tammy,
18:16
also began calling around asking the
18:18
same thing. However, no one had
18:20
heard from Heidi. Now, this was
18:22
obviously very worrisome for several factors.
18:25
However, the biggest one being not
18:27
only could no one find Heidi,
18:29
but no one could find their
18:32
newborn daughter either. Heidi's
18:34
daughter was only about three weeks old
18:36
at this time. So her and Heidi
18:38
did everything together. Heidi was taking her
18:40
everywhere. If she needed to drop her
18:42
son off at school or pick her
18:44
son up from school, anything that Heidi
18:46
was doing, she was at the phase
18:48
where she was constantly bringing her daughter
18:50
with her. So the fact that no
18:52
one had heard from Heidi meant that
18:54
no one knew where her and Shane's
18:56
daughter were either. So now both of
18:58
them are missing. At this point, Shane
19:00
decided not to waste any time. And
19:02
he called the police department to file
19:04
a missing persons report on
19:06
Heidi and his daughter. Now the following
19:09
day, the police brought Shane in to
19:11
conduct a more in-depth interview with him.
19:15
Imagine an app designed to make
19:17
you use it less. Seems a
19:19
little counterproductive, right? Well, apartments.com's instant
19:21
alert feature works exactly that way.
19:24
Instead of scanning rental listings a million
19:26
times a day, simply set and forget
19:29
your search to whatever you're looking for
19:31
in a place and let apartments.com do
19:33
the rest from pet friendly apartments to
19:36
balconies to in unit ACs, apartments.com's powerful
19:38
search tools that you know when the
19:40
perfect combination of features you're seeking is
19:43
listed. So you don't have to power
19:45
through rental descriptions one by one with
19:47
more rental listings than anywhere else. apartments.com's
19:49
instant alerts mean that you can spend
19:52
less time looking for the perfect place
19:54
and more time on just doing you.
19:56
apartments.com the place to find a place.
20:01
Hey, it's Hey, it's Kaylee Cuoco for
20:03
Priceline. Ready to go to your happy place for a
20:05
happy price? Well, why didn't you say so? Just download
20:08
the Priceline app right now and save up to 60%
20:10
on hotels. So, whether
20:12
it's Cousin Kevin's Kazoo concert in Kansas
20:14
City, go Kevin! Or Becky's Bachelorette Bash
20:16
in Bermuda. You never have to miss
20:18
a trip ever again. So download the
20:20
Priceline app today. Your savings are waiting.
20:23
Go to your happy place
20:25
for a happy price. Go
20:29
to your happy price, Priceline. Start
20:31
your summer road trip at Midas and get up to
20:33
$30 off your next repair service. Plus, get a free
20:35
closer look vehicle check to make sure you're road trip
20:38
ready. If you need brake service, an alignment check, or
20:40
tune up, hit up Midas for up to $30 off.
20:43
For more details, request your appointment
20:45
at midas.com. Now
20:48
during this interview, Shane gave his timeline
20:50
of events from the day before, the
20:53
12th, which was the last day that
20:55
anyone saw or heard from Heidi. According
20:58
to Shane, he claimed that this morning started
21:01
off like any normal morning. He woke up
21:03
at 6.30am and left the
21:05
apartment for work. Heidi left
21:07
to take their son to school and
21:10
called Shane when she got back to
21:12
the apartment around 8.30 and nothing seemed
21:14
out of the ordinary. After
21:17
Shane got off work, Shane tried calling
21:19
Heidi, but he wasn't getting an
21:21
answer. He then went back
21:23
to the apartment after work and
21:25
noticed that Heidi's car was still
21:28
in the parking spot, which definitely
21:30
made him feel a little uneasy.
21:32
When he went up to the apartment,
21:35
he realized that the apartment door was
21:37
unlocked. He claimed that when he got
21:39
into the apartment, no one was in
21:42
there. Heidi was gone and
21:44
their daughter was gone as well. Now
21:46
even though the two of them were gone, nothing
21:48
seemed out of place in the apartment.
21:51
It wasn't ransacked, it didn't seem in
21:53
any sort of disarray, and everything was
21:55
in the apartment that needed to be
21:58
all of the baby bottles. the
22:00
baby clothes, the diapers, the wipes, everything
22:02
was there. So Shane initially thought
22:04
maybe Heidi took the baby for
22:06
a walk, maybe she's walking around
22:08
the apartment complex with the baby,
22:10
maybe she went to go talk
22:13
to a neighbor, show the neighbors
22:15
the new baby. There were other
22:17
things that were running through his
22:19
mind before he started to really,
22:21
really worry that something could be
22:23
wrong. It really wasn't until
22:25
sometime later when Shane started to get
22:27
worried because Heidi was not coming back
22:29
to the apartment and her car again
22:32
was still in the parking spot. It
22:34
was getting closer and closer to the
22:36
time where her son would need to
22:38
be picked up from school and Shane
22:40
noticed that the only things that were
22:43
missing from the apartment were Heidi's purse
22:45
and her car keys. But even though
22:47
the car keys were gone, the car
22:49
again was still in that parking spot.
22:51
Shane wondered if maybe there was some
22:54
mix-up, some misunderstanding. So he decided that
22:56
he was going to go to his
22:58
son's school himself and pretty much stake
23:00
out there during the time that his
23:02
son was supposed to be picked up
23:04
to see if Heidi was going to
23:06
come and get their son. So he
23:08
got there and waited for some time.
23:11
However, Heidi still never showed up. And
23:13
this is when the concern really started
23:15
to set in because this has been
23:17
Shane realized that he did not know
23:19
where Heidi was and he did not
23:21
know where his daughter was. And
23:24
he also knew as did everyone
23:26
else that Heidi would not miss
23:28
picking up her son from school
23:30
unless something was very, very wrong.
23:33
So at this point, Shane claims that
23:35
he grabbed his son from school and
23:37
brought him back to the apartment. And
23:39
that is when he began making phone
23:41
calls around asking if anyone had seen
23:44
or heard from Heidi. However, no one
23:46
had. When Heidi's friends
23:48
began hearing that no one knew where
23:50
Heidi was, it definitely caused a lot
23:52
of concern because everyone knew that this
23:54
was very much unlike Heidi. She
23:56
would not just ignore everyone's calls
23:59
or texts. Her social media
24:01
seemed completely fine and no one
24:03
ever really questioned the theory of
24:05
Heidi just up and leaving without
24:07
telling anyone because they knew she
24:09
wouldn't leave behind her son. In
24:11
an alternate universe, if Heidi was
24:13
to leave, if she decided she
24:15
just wanted to get away, something
24:18
happened and she just wanted to
24:20
go, she would have taken her
24:22
son with her. Like I mentioned
24:24
earlier, being a mom was incredibly
24:26
important to Heidi. She wouldn't have
24:28
left behind her son. Now,
24:30
even though Shane was the one who
24:33
filed the missing persons report and he
24:35
was the one who staked outside of
24:37
the school to see if Heidi would
24:39
show up, people really started to point
24:42
their fingers at Shane when questioning who
24:44
would do something to Heidi. Heidi did
24:46
not have any known enemies. She was
24:49
not in any feuds with anyone. Heidi's
24:51
priorities in life were her friends, her
24:53
faith, and her family. She was not
24:55
one who was involved in drama or
24:58
starting feuds. Again, no one didn't like
25:00
Heidi. Heidi liked everyone and she had
25:02
tons and tons of people who loved
25:04
and supported her. So no one really
25:06
knew who would want to do something
25:08
like this to Heidi, who would want
25:10
to hurt Heidi. But again, time and
25:12
time again, as we see in these
25:14
types of cases, whenever anyone goes missing,
25:16
the first person that is automatically looked
25:18
at is the spouse, because that is
25:20
the pattern of behavior that we're used
25:22
to seeing. When a husband or a
25:24
wife or a boyfriend or a girlfriend
25:26
goes missing, the pattern that we see
25:28
is that the spouse or the
25:31
partner more often than not had
25:33
some sort of link, some sort
25:35
of connection. And because Shane and
25:38
Heidi had a previously tumultuous relationship,
25:40
people began to wonder if Shane
25:42
could have been responsible for this.
25:45
Police began looking more and more into
25:47
Shane's alibi. They looked to see when
25:49
he clocked in at work, when he
25:51
clocked out of work, they looked to
25:53
see if Heidi did in fact drop
25:56
their son off at school that morning
25:58
and everything seemed to check out. Everything
26:00
seemed to match the story that Shane
26:02
was saying. Now the one
26:04
thing that Shane was doing, which
26:06
was not helping his case, was
26:08
being very active in the media.
26:10
He was doing a lot of
26:12
interviews, he was doing a lot
26:14
of press, and a big reason
26:16
for this was because police were
26:18
encouraging everyone who knew Heidi to
26:21
get her name out there, get
26:23
her picture out there, get her
26:25
name out there, let people see
26:27
who Heidi is, because more than
26:29
likely someone knows something and they
26:31
may not even know it. So make
26:33
sure you're talking about her, make sure
26:35
you're getting the news out there for
26:37
her, make sure everything is being posted
26:40
out about Heidi. And for Shane, that
26:42
included doing interviews, it included doing press
26:44
and media. However, Shane's behavior in front
26:46
of the camera was definitely off-putting. While
26:49
being interviewed, Shane was doing things like
26:51
laughing. He just didn't seem very genuine,
26:53
he didn't seem very engaged, and people
26:56
were really tearing him down because of
26:58
this, because it was easy to
27:00
see that and think that he had to have something
27:02
to do with it. And again, you have to look
27:04
at the timeframe here. We're looking at 2019. Just
27:08
about a little over a year before
27:10
this is when the Chris Watts case
27:12
took place and people were starting to
27:14
see the similarities. They were seeing Chris
27:16
doing media interviews, now they're seeing Shane
27:19
doing media interviews, they're seeing Shane's behavior
27:21
be a little dicey. It seems a
27:23
little bit suspicious. So it was easy
27:25
for everyone to point the finger at
27:27
Shane. But regardless of his behavior in
27:30
the interviews, other than that,
27:32
there was really no other
27:34
evidence that was linking Shane
27:36
to Heidi's disappearance. There was
27:38
no physical evidence, there was
27:40
no circumstantial evidence, there was
27:42
nothing at all that linked
27:44
Shane to Heidi being missing.
27:47
Now at this point, the days are passing
27:49
and Heidi is missing for a week. Now
27:52
during that week of Heidi's disappearance, that
27:55
first initial week, police were speaking to
27:57
everyone who knew Heidi. They were talking
27:59
to her family, they were talking to
28:02
her family. friends and they started to
28:04
notice that there was a concerning pattern
28:06
in some of the things that the
28:09
family and the friends were saying. The
28:11
family and the friends were bringing up
28:13
Heidi's friend Megan. They claimed that Megan
28:16
was there for the birth of Heidi's
28:18
daughter and while she was there, she
28:20
was acting oddly possessive over Heidi and
28:23
the baby. It was said
28:25
by friends and family who were at
28:27
the hospital as well as the nurses
28:29
who were at the hospital that Megan
28:31
continuously tried to interject herself between the
28:33
baby and everyone else, whether that was
28:35
Shane, whether that was Heidi's parents. She
28:38
tried to be the one holding the
28:40
baby at all times. Anytime anyone else
28:42
wanted to hold the baby, she would
28:44
say a passive aggressive comment. She would
28:46
try and get them to change the
28:48
subject. She would try and keep holding
28:50
on to the baby. The behavior was
28:52
very, very strange. Other
28:54
people who were at the hospital claimed
28:57
that Megan was holding a pillow over
28:59
her stomach the entire time, which people
29:01
thought to be very strange because again
29:03
she was nine months pregnant but no
29:05
one really questioned it. It was just
29:07
something that was like, oh, that's
29:09
weird. Now when police were
29:12
talking to Shane, Shane said that in regards
29:14
to Megan, the day that Megan spent the
29:16
night at their apartment when she came to
29:18
see Heidi and she came to see the
29:20
baby, they gave her a key
29:22
to their apartment because again Shane was staying at
29:24
the hospital with Heidi. Shane gave Megan the key,
29:26
said go stay the night at the apartment. You
29:28
don't need to drive all the way back to
29:31
Houston tonight and Megan seemed very appreciative and said
29:33
that she would leave the apartment key on
29:36
the counter. However, Shane claimed that
29:38
the following day the key was
29:40
not there and he never saw
29:42
it again. Now the things that
29:44
people were saying about Megan were
29:46
definitely raising alarm bells for police
29:49
and they definitely were starting to
29:51
hone in on the idea that
29:53
Megan could have somehow been tied
29:55
to this case. They ended up
29:57
talking to And
30:00
on the day that Heidi went
30:02
missing, on December 12th, one neighbor
30:05
claimed that they saw Heidi hugging
30:07
a woman who matched Meghan's description
30:09
outside of Heidi's apartment. There
30:12
was also another neighbor who
30:14
claimed that they saw Heidi
30:16
and her newborn daughter get
30:18
into a light colored four-door
30:20
vehicle with the woman who
30:22
matched Meghan's description. Now
30:25
at this point, police knew that they wanted to
30:27
talk to Meghan. They began looking more into Meghan
30:29
and who she was and learned that
30:32
she had a four-door light
30:34
colored car, so the dots are
30:36
beginning to connect. Meghan
30:38
became the primary suspect at this
30:40
point in this investigation. While
30:43
police are trying to gain as much
30:45
information as they can on Meghan, they
30:47
decide to put surveillance on Meghan's home
30:50
in Houston, Texas. Now when
30:52
they did that, one specific day,
30:54
they saw Meghan's boyfriend Chris leave
30:57
the home. He got into his car and
30:59
he left the home and he drove
31:02
to a Target store. Now
31:04
police stayed in the parking lot as
31:06
they saw Chris walk into the store
31:08
and then walk out with bags filled
31:11
of baby supplies. Now while Chris was
31:13
putting the bags into the back of
31:15
his car, police saw their in and
31:17
they took it. They ended up approaching
31:20
Chris and really explained what was going
31:22
on. When police explained
31:24
that Meghan's best friend Heidi was
31:26
missing, explained that Meghan and Heidi
31:29
were very close, and really was
31:31
just asking him about his newborn
31:33
daughter, Chris's daughter in general, Chris
31:35
was very, very confused. Chris
31:38
told police that he had just had
31:40
a baby with his girlfriend, however he
31:42
was not there for the
31:44
birth. He claimed that Meghan had their
31:47
daughter while he was out of town
31:49
and she just brought the baby home.
31:52
Chris also claimed that he just had to assume
31:54
that Meghan was pregnant because he took her word
31:56
for it. He claimed that the two were living
31:58
at the opposite sides of the house. the
32:00
house, they were not sexually involved
32:02
so he never saw her bare
32:04
stomach. He never saw her without
32:06
clothes on, so he just assumed
32:09
that she was pregnant because again
32:11
that's what she told him. Now
32:14
police at this point showed Chris
32:16
a picture of Heidi and Shane's
32:18
newborn daughter and that is when
32:20
Chris confirmed that the daughter and
32:22
the girl in the picture was
32:25
the same baby that was at
32:27
his house, the same baby that
32:29
Megan claimed to be theirs. Now
32:32
at this point police knew that they
32:34
needed to act fast so they stopped
32:36
Chris from going home. They
32:39
told him do not go back to the
32:41
house, you're staying here and you're actually coming
32:43
down to the police station to answer more
32:45
questions but pretty automatically from the very beginning
32:47
police were confident in the fact that Chris
32:50
was not involved in this, they never thought
32:52
that Chris had anything to do with this,
32:54
they never believed that he was somehow tied
32:56
to this, he seemed just as confused as
32:58
everyone else if not more confused when he
33:01
was being told what was going on. Now
33:03
at this point back at Megan's home,
33:06
the officers who were surveillanceing the house
33:08
storm through the doors and
33:10
arrest Megan. Now quickly
33:13
when they do that they discover
33:15
the baby as well. They
33:17
remove the baby from the home
33:19
and the entire time Megan is
33:22
kicking and screaming saying that that
33:24
is her child, that is her
33:26
daughter. However DNA tests confirm that
33:28
the baby that was in Megan's
33:31
house was in fact Heidi and
33:33
Shane's daughter. Regardless of what DNA
33:35
was saying, Megan said
33:38
it's not true. Megan claimed that that
33:40
was still her daughter, that was still
33:42
her baby, the tests were wrong, she
33:44
was adamant in the fact that this
33:46
was her daughter. Now when police began
33:48
asking Megan some questions like when was
33:50
the baby born, where did you have
33:52
this baby, can we see the birth
33:55
certificate? Megan claimed that she had the
33:57
baby in a birth center, however she
33:59
claimed she did not remember what the
34:01
name of the birth center was. She
34:03
also claimed that she didn't know where
34:05
the birth center was. She
34:07
claimed that the only person that
34:09
was there for the birth of
34:11
her daughter were the doctors and
34:13
nurses, which she also claimed she
34:16
did not know the names of.
34:18
So everyone was pretty SOL when
34:20
it came to Meghan giving any
34:22
information about where she had her
34:24
baby. But of course everyone knew
34:26
that the reason for that was
34:28
because that this was not Meghan's
34:30
baby. Now,
34:33
while there were some officers who were
34:35
talking to Meghan and having this conversation
34:37
with her, other officers were canvassing the
34:39
rest of the home to try and
34:41
see if they could find Heidi. Now,
34:44
while some officers were walking through
34:46
the driveway of the home and
34:48
passing Meghan's car, they were
34:51
stopped in their tracks by a pungent
34:53
smell of what they knew to be
34:55
a decaying body.
34:58
The police requested a search warrant
35:00
for Meghan's vehicle. And once that
35:02
was obtained, they opened the trunk
35:05
and inside of the trunk was
35:07
a duffel bag. And inside of
35:09
the duffel bag was Heidi's body.
35:12
It was clear to police almost immediately
35:14
that Heidi had been strangled to death.
35:16
The medical examiner did confirm this by
35:19
concluding that the cause of death was
35:21
strangulation. And it is believed that Heidi
35:23
was strangled with some sort of leash
35:26
or rope, as well
35:28
as hands. So she was strangled
35:30
with both. Now Meghan
35:32
was immediately arrested that day and she
35:35
was charged with two counts of kidnapping
35:37
and one count of tampering with a
35:39
corpse. Now on February 22nd, which
35:43
was just last year Meghan pled
35:45
guilty to first degree murder. And
35:47
she was sentenced to 55 years
35:50
in prison. Now
35:52
this sentence, if you think that it is
35:55
a little too short, why didn't she get
35:57
life in prison? The sentence was the result
35:59
of a plea deal. Meghan basically just took
36:01
a deal to get a lesser sentence. Now
36:04
Meghan herself has never publicly talked
36:06
about this case. She's never talked
36:08
about what her motive was or
36:10
why she did what she did.
36:12
She's never been public with the
36:14
details surrounding this case. However, police
36:17
have their own set of theories
36:19
as well as the public as
36:21
well. The public has their own
36:23
set of theories. The police believe
36:25
that Meghan kidnapped Heidi's baby in
36:27
order to continue having Chris as
36:30
her boyfriend. It's believed that she
36:32
kidnapped the baby and murdered Heidi
36:34
in order to keep Chris. Whether
36:37
this was because Meghan simply wanted to
36:39
become a mother and felt like this
36:42
was the only way that she could
36:44
do it or if this is because
36:46
she felt like having a baby would
36:48
keep Chris around, that is what is
36:51
believed to be the motive. However, Heidi's
36:53
friends believe that from the very beginning,
36:55
Meghan had a certain possessiveness and obsessiveness
36:58
about Heidi. Whether that's she wanted to
37:00
be Heidi or wanted the life
37:02
that Heidi had, there was something
37:04
in Meghan that always sought out Heidi
37:06
and this goes all the way
37:08
back to church camp. And when you
37:11
think about it, going back that many
37:13
years, the eeriness that comes about from
37:15
thinking that Meghan could have been
37:17
plotting and planning for God knows how
37:20
long to do this to Heidi. Police
37:22
believe that when Meghan went down to
37:24
see Heidi give birth to her
37:26
daughter, that is when she initially began
37:29
planning the murder of Heidi. However, others
37:31
believe that this has been in the
37:33
works for much longer than that because
37:35
as we know, Meghan
37:37
was never pregnant. Meghan
37:40
was never pregnant. So for those
37:42
nine months of pretending to be pregnant with
37:44
Heidi, she knew that at some
37:47
point she was going to have to have
37:49
some sort of baby to prove that she
37:51
was in fact pregnant, to prove that she
37:53
was having a baby. She wasn't lying. She
37:55
was going to be a mother. So she
37:58
knew she needed to produce. for the
38:00
lack of a better word, some baby.
38:02
She needed to show up with a
38:04
baby. She needed to show everyone that
38:07
she did have a daughter. And in
38:09
her mind, she felt like the only way
38:11
to do that was to go after the
38:14
one woman who had been there for her
38:16
all of her life. The one woman who
38:18
stood up for her, the one woman who
38:20
defended her, the one woman who wanted her
38:23
to feel included and loved and supported. That
38:25
is the woman that Megan went after. I'm
38:28
very interested to hear what you guys have to
38:30
say about this one. And with that being said,
38:32
you guys, that is all for me today. Thank
38:35
you so much for tuning into another episode of
38:37
Killer Instinct. Again, if you're new here, hi, my
38:39
name is Savannah and I am your host of
38:41
Killer Instinct. Again, make sure you go ahead and
38:43
hit the subscribe button. That way you never miss
38:45
an episode. We post weekly on the podcast every
38:48
single Wednesday and you're not going to want to
38:50
miss it. I'll be back next week with a
38:52
brand new one for you guys. And until then,
38:54
stay safe. Bye guys. We're
39:15
all builders. The question is,
39:18
what are we building? At
39:20
Ferguson, we work with people transforming the world
39:22
we live in. We
39:25
have the products and tools they need to
39:27
help them move faster. We
39:29
bring our partners the knowledge, experience
39:32
and scale to make complex projects
39:34
simple, successful and sustainable. Ferguson
39:37
helps build the things that make
39:39
things better. Ferguson.
39:42
Together we build better.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More