Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
Hey there! Did you know Kroger always gives
0:02
you savings and rewards on top of our
0:04
lower than low prices? And when you download
0:06
the Kroger app, you'll enjoy over $500 in
0:09
savings And when you download the Kroger app, you'll enjoy over $500 in savings every
0:11
week with digital coupons. And don't forget FuelPoints
0:13
to help you save up to $1 per
0:15
gallon at the pump. Want to
0:17
save even more? With a Boost membership, you'll
0:20
get double FuelPoints and free delivery! So
0:22
shop and save big at Kroger today! Kroger,
0:24
fresh for everyone! Savings may vary
0:27
by state. Restrictions apply. Seasight for
0:29
details. Ohio,
0:32
Ohio. Ready for some good
0:34
mental health facts? Let's go. Nearly two
0:36
million Ohioans live with a mental health
0:38
condition In the U S. More than
0:41
fifty percent of people will be diagnosed
0:43
with a mental illness in their lifetime.
0:45
Depression is a leading cause of disability
0:48
worldwide, so why are some of us
0:50
still stigmatising. People living with a mental
0:52
health condition. When we know all of
0:54
this, let's listen to the facts and
0:56
beat the stigma. Ohio. Challenge what you know
0:58
about mental health at the The Stigma. Dot org.
1:35
Police believe Matthew Pike knew his
1:37
killer. They're now examining the possibility
1:39
that they met on the internet.
1:45
Nottingham, which is located in the
1:47
East Midlands region of England, has
1:50
a rich history that dates back to at
1:52
least the 6th century. It
1:55
gained prominence in medieval times as a
1:57
centre for the production of textiles on
1:59
lease. contributing significantly
2:01
to England's economy. It
2:05
progressed over the years, becoming a
2:08
hub the both of a vibrant
2:10
cultural scene with theatres, music venues
2:12
and art galleries. One
2:15
of the key institutions of the city is
2:17
Nottingham Trent University, a dynamic
2:20
and fast-forward thinking university with
2:22
a strong reputation for excellence
2:24
in teaching and research. The
2:28
university traces its origins back to
2:30
the 19th century but has evolved
2:32
over the years to become one of
2:34
the UK's leading universities. Students
2:37
in Nottingham reside in a variety
2:39
of accommodations scattered throughout the city,
2:42
ranging from university halls to
2:44
privately rented apartments. The
2:48
city boasts a plethora of bars and restaurants,
2:51
ensuring that there's always something happening at night
2:53
from local pub quizzes to karaoke nights.
2:57
For those who opt for local rentals, proximity
3:00
to the city centre is always a
3:02
key factor. North
3:04
Sherwood Street in particular was
3:07
a favoured location amongst students due
3:09
to its affordable Victorian era flats
3:11
and close proximity to both the
3:13
university and the bustling city centre.
3:16
On the 19th of September 2008 Naomi
3:18
Rogers was making her
3:21
way back to her shared flat on
3:23
North Sherwood Street. Having
3:25
recently relocated from St. Ann's, Naomi
3:28
had chosen North Sherwood Street with
3:30
the belief that it offered a safer
3:32
environment. Her decision
3:35
had stemmed from a scary experience in
3:37
St. Ann's where she had been mugged.
3:40
The streets popularity among students was
3:42
evident but as Naomi neared the
3:44
Orange Tree pub, she
3:46
was met by a scene of disarray. Flashing
3:50
lights illuminated the area with
3:52
police cars lining the streets
3:54
and cordons preventing access. Matthew
4:12
Pike was born to parents Kim and William on the
4:14
23rd of August in 1988. The family
4:20
chose to settle down in Stowmarket, acclaimed
4:22
in picturesque town, Nestled in Suffolk,
4:24
England. As the
4:27
youngest member of the family, with an older brother
4:29
named Adam, Matthew brought joy
4:31
and laughter into their lives from the very
4:33
beginning. Described by
4:36
his parents as an easy-going baby, child
4:38
and teenager, Matthew possessed a
4:40
quiet and reserved demeanor, yet
4:42
his sharp wit and infectious
4:44
humour never failed to brighten the atmosphere
4:46
at home. His magnetic
4:49
personality extended beyond the confines of
4:51
his family, as he was
4:53
known among his friends as the ultimate joker, somebody
4:56
who was always ready to lighten the mood. One
5:00
of his closest friends, Andy, fondly recalled,
5:03
This guy was one of my best friends at school.
5:06
He was a great and very intelligent guy, a wicked
5:08
sense of humour and friends who loved him.
5:12
Matthew attended Combs Middle School in
5:14
Stowmarket, where he left a
5:16
lasting impression on both his peers and
5:18
teachers alike. The
5:21
school's head teacher, Ian Crissell, fondly
5:23
remembered Matthew, describing him as a
5:25
very conscientious student, unlike
5:27
by all members of staff. Dennis
5:30
Matthew entered his teenage years,
5:32
his fascination with computers deepened.
5:36
He delved into web design and
5:38
developed a keen interest in journalism, as
5:42
his mother recalled. We didn't
5:44
know anything he did on the computer, we
5:46
just know he was good on anything to do
5:48
with computers. He was obsessed with
5:50
it really. Matthew had
5:52
always been drawn to video games, from
5:55
classics like Game Boy and PlayStation,
5:57
to computer-based games. However,
6:00
his true obsession ignited when he
6:02
discovered Advance Wars, a video game
6:05
that debuted on the Game Boy
6:07
Advance in 2001 and rapidly gained
6:09
popularity. In
6:12
Advance Wars, players command various
6:14
military units on grid-based maps,
6:16
engaging in strategic battles against
6:18
enemy forces. The
6:21
gameplay involves capturing cities and bases,
6:24
deploying units strategically, managing
6:27
resources and exploiting terrain
6:29
advantages to gain victory. If
6:32
you could span hours immersed in the game, lagging
6:35
it to a more technical version of
6:37
chess. The
6:39
player takes on the persona of a
6:41
commanding officer and then chooses from a
6:43
lineup for different characters, each
6:45
with their own special abilities and weaknesses.
6:49
Matthew relish the challenge of playing against
6:51
opponents from across the world, gradually building
6:54
up his army and honing his strategic
6:56
skills. The
6:58
game boasted a substantial fanbase, and
7:01
Matthew actively engaged with various online
7:03
forums dedicated to it. Under
7:06
the Elias shade, he eagerly shared
7:09
his insights and strategies with
7:11
fellow enthusiasts. Alongside
7:14
his gaming pursuits, Matthew showcased his
7:16
prolific writing skills in the
7:18
field of science fiction by contributing
7:20
to fanfiction.net. Then
7:24
at the age of 16, Matthew crossed paths
7:26
with a girl his own age on
7:28
a forum dedicated to Advance Wars. Her
7:32
name was Joanna, and she came from Selby
7:34
in Yorkshire. Instantly
7:37
hitting it off, Matthew eagerly anticipated
7:39
their daily online conversations, often
7:42
rushing home from school to connect with Joanna
7:44
online. Their
7:46
connection flourished, prompting Matthew to
7:48
make the journey to Selby under the guise
7:51
of meeting a friend for a concert. He
7:54
was a little bit embarrassed to admit the truth to
7:56
his parents. However,
7:58
upon meeting Joanna, he was a very good friend. in person,
8:00
their chemistry was undeniable, and
8:03
they quickly transformed their relationship
8:05
from virtual to real world.
8:08
As their bond deepened, they introduced each
8:10
other to the respect of families, both
8:13
sets of parents unanimously declaring them
8:15
the perfect match. Much
8:18
like Ma, Hujuana shared a passion for
8:20
computers, and they often spent late nights
8:23
immersed in advance wars together. As
8:26
the first three years of their relationship
8:28
flew by, the couple found themselves graduating
8:31
and preparing to embark on their university
8:33
journey. They wanted
8:36
to be together permanently, so made
8:38
the decision to both enrol at
8:40
Nottingham Trent University. So
8:44
by 2008, life
8:46
was brimming with promise for 20-year-old
8:48
Matthew Pike. He
8:51
and Hujuana had recently settled in two
8:53
Grade 2 listed Victorian flat above the
8:55
Orange Tree pub on North Sherwood
8:57
Street, in the city of Nottingham.
9:01
Matthew had also just taken the leap to
9:03
pursue a degree in computer science at Nottingham
9:05
Trent University, which was scheduled to begin in
9:07
October of 2008. He
9:12
had previously studied physics, but realised that it
9:14
wasn't for him, and that computer science
9:16
would be a much better fit. As
9:20
for Hujuana, she was studying environmental science,
9:23
and she worked part-time as a sales
9:25
assistant at Rohan. In
9:28
Nottingham, Matthew and Hujuana enjoyed a
9:30
simple, yet fulfilling life. They
9:33
both held part-time jobs, with Matthew
9:35
working as a teaching assistant as
9:38
part of a placement under the
9:40
University Student Dissociates Scheme. While
9:43
they lived above a bar and just a stone's
9:45
throw away from many others, they preferred to stay
9:47
at home. They
9:49
sometimes went for walks during the day, but
9:52
they much preferred to be in each other's
9:54
company rather than partying. At
9:57
night, the young couple liked to read books, or
9:59
current up in front of the
10:01
television to watch Top Gear and QI.
10:05
But life for Matthew and Joanna would soon
10:07
take a dramatic turn. On
10:22
the evening of the 19th September 2008, Joanna
10:26
was returning to the flat she shared with
10:28
Matthew after her work day. Turning
10:31
the corner, her eyes caught the side of the
10:33
familiar facade of the pub below, its lights
10:36
and activity brightening up the otherwise
10:38
dark road. She walked
10:41
up the staircase to the first floor and
10:43
fumbled in her handbag for her
10:46
case. She inserted the key into
10:48
the lock and turned it. When
10:52
she opened up the door, she was surprised
10:54
to see that the flat was engulfed in
10:56
darkness. Matthew
10:58
should have been at home, but the darkness
11:00
and quietness told her otherwise. It
11:04
wasn't like Matthew to not let her know if she
11:06
was going out somewhere. The
11:08
only sound that Joanna could hear was
11:10
distant murmurs of voices from the pub
11:12
below. Joanna
11:15
switched on the lights, but
11:17
the illumination unveiled a trail of
11:20
blood. Joanna's
11:22
heart pounded in her chest as
11:24
she called out to Matthew, but was
11:26
met by silence. Joanna
11:29
stepped forward with her gaze
11:32
fixed on the trail of blood. He
11:35
led her towards the bedroom where blood
11:37
was spattered on the walls and smeared
11:40
across shoes and trainers. As
11:44
Joanna drew closer to the bedroom, her
11:46
eyes were drawn to the crumpled figure on the floor. It
11:51
was Matthew, dressed only in
11:53
his dressing gown, his body surrounded by
11:55
a pool of blood. Joanna
11:58
rushed to his side and saw the light of the night. and reached out to touch
12:01
him, only to recoil at
12:03
how cold his body was. Her
12:06
eyes frantically searched for any sign of
12:08
life, but it quickly became
12:11
clear that Matthew was dead. There
12:14
were stab wounds peppered all across his
12:17
body. Joanna
12:19
reached for her mobile phone and
12:21
immediately called 999. The
12:28
paramedics were the first to arrive, but it
12:30
was clear that nothing could be done for
12:32
Matthew. He had evidently
12:35
been dead for some time. The
12:38
police arrived shortly thereafter, followed
12:40
by forensic experts. Matthew's
12:44
body was documented and photographed before
12:46
he was transported to the mortuary,
12:49
where it was discovered that he had sustained 86 stab wounds.
12:54
The flat was cordoned off with crime scene tip,
12:56
while two uniformed officers stood guard
12:59
outside. The perimeter
13:01
was extended from the junction of Shakes,
13:03
securing the area from prying
13:05
eyes. Inside
13:08
the flat there was no forced entry, indicating
13:10
that the killer had been let in by
13:13
Matthew himself. The
13:15
living room had been ransacked, and
13:17
it appeared as though several items had been
13:19
stolen. On the
13:22
side of the computer, the forensic
13:24
experts noticed something written in blood.
13:27
It was the letters D, A, and
13:29
V. Based
13:35
on the blood evidence inside the flat, it
13:37
appeared as though Matthew had been attacked as soon as
13:40
he opened up the front door. He
13:43
was then pursued throughout the flat by the
13:45
killer, as he fought desperately for
13:47
his life. As
13:49
he collapsed close to the bedroom, the
13:51
killer appeared to kneel beside him
13:54
and continue their attack. Initially
13:57
there was speculation of a robbery.
14:00
gone wrong, but as
14:02
detectives meticulously pieced together the
14:04
evidence, doubts began
14:06
to surface. The
14:08
ransacking, although
14:10
chaotic, seemed haphazard, with
14:13
valuable items left untouched. It
14:17
became increasingly clear to detectives that
14:19
Massey had been deliberately singled out
14:21
and the chaos within the home
14:23
was a calculated attempt to
14:25
mislead detectives. Chief
14:28
Inspector Tony Hayden, who
14:30
was leading the investigation,
14:33
commented, ''We are exploring all
14:35
possible avenues to establish who is
14:37
responsible for Massey's murder. While
14:39
nine of inquiry is that this was not
14:42
a random attack and that Massey
14:44
may have known the person who
14:46
attacked him.'' As
14:48
the investigation intensified, detectives diligently combed
14:50
through CCTV footage from the vicinity
14:53
of the flat. They
14:55
were hopeful that a camera might have
14:58
captured the movements of Matthew's killer, either
15:00
approaching the scene or hastily departing from
15:02
it. Given the
15:04
frenzied nature of the murder, which included
15:06
86 stab wounds, the
15:09
killer would likely be drenched in blood. In
15:12
a bid to broaden their search, detectives issued
15:15
a public appeal, urging anyone
15:17
who may have spotted an individual
15:19
with a blood-stained face, body, or
15:21
clothing to come forward
15:23
quickly. Meanwhile,
15:25
as detectives delved deeper into their
15:28
investigation, they sought out Joanna to
15:30
glean additional insights into Massey's life.
15:33
Their aim was to uncover any potential
15:36
enemies or persons who might
15:38
have harbored ill intentions towards him. There
15:41
was one person who struck out in
15:43
Joanna's mind immediately and it just so
15:46
happened that the first three letters of
15:48
their name had been written in blood
15:50
on the side of the computer. set
16:00
up their own forum, which was
16:02
named War Central and was
16:04
dedicated to the game Advanced Wars. There
16:08
were around 50 devoted fans of the game who
16:11
actively participated in the discussions on the
16:13
forum. But
16:15
over time this virtual community burgeoned
16:17
to a melting pot of friendships,
16:20
drawing enthusiasts from various corners of
16:22
the world. It
16:25
evolved beyond a mere platform for
16:27
game-related discourse, and waved itself
16:29
into the fabric of their daily lives. Let's
16:35
talk hydration. With summer creeping
16:37
up on us, we all have our little
16:39
tricks. Some carry around these
16:42
massive water bottles or giant Stanley
16:44
cups, constantly needing a refill like
16:46
clockwork. Sometimes I'll go through
16:48
the day forgetting to drink anything, then
16:51
suddenly chugging three glasses of water before
16:53
bed. If that sounds like
16:55
you, it's time for you to look
16:57
into 3-10 nutrition. They've got the hydration
16:59
game down to a tea.
17:01
Think water enhancers that turn plain
17:03
old H2O into something delicious and
17:05
nutritious. And their lemonade
17:08
mixes? Pure magic, minus all
17:10
the sugar gilt. Plus
17:12
they've got these all-in-one shakes that make hitting the
17:14
gym a breeze. Personally I can't
17:16
get enough of their strawberry electro-light mix. It's
17:19
like a sip of summer in every gulp. And
17:22
don't even get me started on their peach
17:24
pear lemonade. It's practically heaven in a glass.
17:27
They've got a line-up of flavours and they're
17:29
always rolling out new ones. Plus, as
17:31
someone who battles with bloat now and
17:33
then, their products have been a game-changer.
17:35
Right now our 3-10 is celebrating a
17:37
new year of goals with the code
17:39
morbidology and giving my listeners 50% off
17:42
up to $100 for your first
17:45
order. With so many sample packs.
17:47
New products. It's really fun and easy
17:49
to put together an order or start
17:51
a subscription on products that you know
17:54
you'll use. Go to 310nutrition.com and use
17:56
the code morbidology right now for 50%
17:59
up to $100. $100 for your
18:01
first order. That's 310.com
18:03
and promo code morbidology.
18:10
Participants freely shared snippets of their personal
18:12
narratives, transcending gaming to
18:14
touch upon topics as diverse
18:16
as relationships, family
18:18
dynamics, current events and
18:21
academic pursuits. The
18:23
forum had fostered genuine connections, enduring
18:27
the profound impact of online
18:29
interactions. However,
18:31
amidst this, it remained
18:33
an inherent truth that the
18:35
identities behind digital avatars often
18:37
obscured the true nature of
18:39
individuals. It was
18:42
mostly a male-dominated world, and
18:44
as the only woman in the forum, Joanna
18:47
was a hit with the men. Among
18:50
the online community of advanced wars
18:52
enthusiasts was a man who went by
18:54
the user name Eagle the Lightning.
18:58
While Matthew and Joanna didn't have extensive
19:00
knowledge about Eagle the Lightning, they
19:02
knew that he was German and that
19:05
his first name was David. Through
19:08
Joanna's interactions with David, she
19:10
discovered he had a troubled past. His
19:13
parents had abandoned him at the tender age
19:15
of 10, leaving him to
19:17
be raised by his grandmother. Joanna
19:20
empathised with David's story, and
19:23
their conversations soon transitioned from the
19:25
public forum to private messages. Despite
19:29
David's expressed interest in pursuing more than
19:31
a friendship, Joanna remained
19:33
loyal to her relationship with
19:35
Matthew. Undeterred
19:37
by Joanna's commitment to Matthew, David
19:40
persisted in his pursuit. Seeking
19:44
to deepen their connection, he saw Joanna
19:46
on Facebook. Upon
19:48
viewing her profile photo, David
19:51
found himself captivated. Joanna
19:54
embodied everything that he admired, from
19:57
her love for computers and video games, to
19:59
her kindness. Plus,
20:02
Joanna had red hair, and
20:04
David had a thing for redheads. This
20:08
only fueled his desire to learn more about
20:10
her and ultimately pursue
20:12
a romantic relationship. One
20:16
afternoon upon logging on to the Forum, Joanna
20:19
was confronted with a message from David
20:22
telling her that he had a crush on her.
20:25
Joanna replied, I'm
20:28
flattered, but nothing will come of it. I've
20:30
been with Matthew for two and a half years. It
20:34
was evident that Joanna wasn't interested,
20:37
but David's persistence knew no bounds.
20:41
He bombarded Joanna with incessant
20:43
inquiries about Matthew's whereabouts and
20:45
their relationship status, refusing
20:48
to accept her rejection. Driven
20:51
by an insatiable desire to possess
20:53
every detail of Joanna's life, David
20:56
delved into the depths of social
20:58
media. He
21:00
utilized his computer skills to unearth
21:03
information about her past, education,
21:05
and even her social circle.
21:09
He found her online journal and
21:11
read through every single page. Joanna's
21:14
sense of privacy was shattered as
21:17
David's relentless stalking extended beyond the
21:19
confines of the online Forum. Then
21:23
on the 3rd of May, 2008, Joanna
21:25
was met with yet another
21:27
unsettling intrusion into her personal
21:30
space. David
21:32
had posted a handwritten letter on the
21:34
Forum that was addressed to Joanna, professing
21:37
his unwavering devotion. He
21:40
had written, I love you, Jojo,
21:42
more than anything else in my life. I
21:45
shouldn't, but I can't help it. And
21:48
to be honest, it's a great feeling. You're
21:50
my first thought when I wake up and
21:53
my last when I go to sleep. Joanna
21:56
was horrified to say that the letter
21:58
contained references to intimate aspects
22:00
of her life, such as
22:02
her school, friends and hobbies. It
22:06
became apparent that David's knowledge was
22:08
gleaned from his invasive online surveillance.
22:12
This was only the beginning of his
22:14
disturbing obsession. Although
22:22
Matthew found David's interest in his
22:24
girlfriend irritating, he chose to overlook
22:26
it. Both he
22:29
and Joanna believed that David meant no harm,
22:31
assuming he would eventually realize this
22:33
himself. When you drive a vehicle
22:36
so reliable it's backed by a 10-year, 100,000 mile limited
22:39
warranty, you stop thinking about what you
22:41
can't do and start doing
22:43
what you never thought possible. Visit your local
22:45
Kia dealer today to see what you're capable
22:47
of in a vehicle that inspires confidence around
22:50
every corner. Kia, movement
22:52
that inspires. Call 800-333-4 to
22:55
get the details. Always drive safely. Limited
22:57
inventory available. Woyantees include 10-year, 100,000
23:00
mile powertrain and 5-year, 60,000 mile
23:02
basic. Woyantees are limited. He repels the
23:04
details. However, David's
23:06
infatuation with Joanna persisted
23:09
and escalated over time. Eventually,
23:13
he managed to obtain Joanna's mobile
23:15
number and called her on the 13th
23:17
of June, claiming that he only
23:19
wished to discuss forum matters. Then
23:23
the following day, while Matthew and Joanna
23:25
were on vacation in Devon with her
23:27
parents, David sees the opportunity
23:29
to gather more information about them. He
23:32
began messaging other forum
23:34
members privately, attempting to ascertain
23:37
their whereabouts. He
23:39
had gathered that they lived above a pub
23:41
in Nottingham, close to a park, but
23:44
he wasn't sure of the exact location. He
23:48
had searched on Google Maps, but
23:50
there was a handful of places that matched the
23:52
description. So
23:54
David reached out to a man named Gavin
23:57
Sillid on the forum, who claimed
23:59
not to know their whereabouts. whereabouts, at
24:01
least at first. However,
24:04
as their conversation unfolded throughout the
24:06
day, Gavin eventually disclosed Matthew
24:08
and Joanna's address to David.
24:12
That night, David posted on the forum
24:14
his intention to travel to Nottingham on
24:16
the 21st of June, a
24:19
post that Matthew and Joanna missed since they
24:22
were still on holiday. Their
24:24
knowledge of David's plans only surfaced on
24:26
the 28th of June, when
24:29
another member of the forum, James
24:31
Mellor, texted them about it. They
24:35
brushed it off as a joke, thinking
24:37
that David would never actually make
24:39
the trip over. After
24:42
all, he barely knew either of them. Or
24:45
at least so they thought. The
24:48
couple's doubts dissolved when they returned home on
24:50
the 21st to find a
24:53
man sitting outside the pub below
24:55
their flat. He
24:57
approached them and told them that
24:59
he was David, aka Eagle
25:02
the Lightning. Matthew
25:05
warmly welcomed David inside, but
25:07
Joanna couldn't shake her apprehension.
25:11
David had been unsettling her for months, and
25:14
finding him outside their flat only heightened
25:16
her unease. Despite
25:19
Matthew's hospitality, Joanna began reaching
25:21
out to local hotels to
25:24
find alternative accommodations for David.
25:27
But unfortunately, everything was
25:29
already booked up for the night. Matthew
25:32
told David that he could stand their flat for the
25:35
night, and they would help them find
25:37
a hotel first thing in the morning. When
25:41
Matthew left the room, David told
25:43
Joanna that he hoped he hadn't given her the
25:45
wrong impression, and that he wanted
25:47
to keep seeing her. She
25:50
told him that he wasn't weird, but that
25:52
he had freaked her out a little bit since he
25:54
had managed to find out where she lived. That
25:58
night, Joanna found a difficult decision. sleep. Her
26:01
mind was consumed by worries about
26:03
David, who was sleeping on the
26:06
floor at the foot of her bed. In
26:09
the middle of the night she sat up
26:12
in bed and glanced over towards David. He
26:16
was staring directly at her, and
26:18
she wondered if he had been doing that the
26:20
entire night. The
26:22
following morning Joanna informed David that she had
26:24
booked him into a room at the local
26:27
Premier Inn. Matthew
26:29
and Joanna tried to stare clear of David
26:31
while he was in Nottingham, and
26:33
he reached out to several other members of
26:35
the Forum. Some
26:37
of them agreed to meet with him, but
26:40
it soon became clear to them that
26:42
the only thing he wanted to talk
26:44
about was Joanna. Following
26:50
David's trip to Nottingham, his fixation
26:52
on Joanna only intensified,
26:54
a behaviour noted by other Forum members.
26:58
Each interaction with them on the Forum
27:00
seemed to revolve solely around Joanna and
27:03
how much he loved her, causing
27:05
discomfort among the Forum members. Some
27:09
of them chatted amongst themselves, and they
27:11
all said the same thing, that
27:14
David was weird and they needed to get rid
27:16
of him. David
27:19
eventually caught on that he was being spoken
27:21
about by the other Forum members, and it
27:23
made him furious. But
27:25
his anger was solely directed at
27:28
Matthew. One
27:30
day David had messaged another Forum member
27:32
a list of people who he said
27:35
needed to be erased. At
27:38
the top of the list was Matthew, and
27:40
David had said, seriously,
27:43
the whole thing will end in at least one
27:45
of us three dying. He
27:48
then added, I'm developing a
27:50
strong desire to grab his head and smash
27:52
it against a wall. Then
27:55
on the 16th of July, David made
27:57
another reappearance in Nottingham. By
28:00
this point, Matthew was acutely aware
28:02
of how David's presence affected Joanna.
28:06
Learning that David had actively sought
28:08
out their address and continued to
28:10
focus on Joanna in his online
28:12
interactions only confirmed his
28:14
obsession. When David
28:16
showed up at their flat again that afternoon,
28:19
Matthew bluntly instructed him to leave
28:21
and to never contact him or
28:23
Joanna again. Two
28:26
days later, David returned to Germany. Soon
28:30
after, Matthew took to the Forum to list
28:33
19 reasons why he hated
28:35
David. He had
28:37
written, I hate you
28:39
because you decided to come into our lives. I
28:42
hate you for ever laying eyes on the girl
28:44
I have dedicated my life to. I
28:47
hate you for your desperation. However,
28:50
David persisted, continuing to
28:52
pastor other Forum members and
28:55
prying for information about Matthew
28:57
and Joanna. Then
28:59
on the 31st of July, he borrowed
29:01
his uncle's car and drove to Nottingham
29:03
through the Channel Tunnel. In
29:07
the early hours of the following morning, at
29:09
around 2.45am, he
29:12
was involved in a car accident on the
29:14
M11 North. Colliding
29:16
with an HGV, David's uncle's car veered
29:19
off the road and into a field.
29:22
Sustaining a wrist injury, David
29:24
was attended to by an ambulance and spent
29:26
the night in the hospital. While
29:30
here, he also spoke with police and
29:32
claimed that he was en route to see
29:35
his girlfriend in Nottingham. Despite
29:37
his car being totaled, David remained
29:40
undeterred. After
29:43
being discharged from the hospital the following
29:45
morning, he promptly boarded a
29:47
train to Nottingham. Upon
29:50
arrival, he headed to an internet cafe
29:53
where he contacted Gavin, another Forum
29:55
member, claiming that he
29:57
was in Nottingham to see Joanna. Despite
30:00
Gavin's attempts to reason with him, labelling
30:03
his behaviour as stalker-like,
30:05
David persisted. Gavin
30:08
immediately reached out to Matthew and warned
30:10
him that David was back in Nottingham.
30:14
When Joanna Dis embarked from the bus near
30:16
her flat that afternoon, she
30:18
was shocked to find David waiting for her. She
30:22
fled in fear, managing to reach the
30:24
safety of her flat, but David
30:26
continued to reach out to both her and
30:28
Matthew. The following
30:31
day, Matthew and Joanna reluctantly agreed to
30:33
make David at a local park, hoping
30:35
to persuade him to leave them alone for good.
30:39
However, when they arrived, they were
30:41
met with David's emotional distress. Despite
30:45
struggling to communicate through tears and
30:48
dry heaves, Joanna firmly
30:50
reiterated her lack of interest in
30:52
him. It
30:55
appeared that David finally understood.
30:58
He left Nottingham the next day and returned
31:00
home to Germany. Matthew
31:03
and Joanna believed that they had seen the last
31:05
of him, but they soon
31:07
realised that shaking him off wouldn't be
31:10
that easy. As
31:19
soon as David landed back in Germany, he
31:21
began to repeatedly call Joanna, prompting
31:23
her to block him. David
31:26
was furious and started to bombard
31:29
her with messages and threats via other
31:31
formats. He told
31:33
her that if she continued to ignore him,
31:35
there would be consequences. Have
31:41
you ever tried kicking a habit and felt like you
31:43
were wandering through a maze with a blindfold on? I've
31:46
been there. But guess what? Enter
31:48
Fume. It's not about giving up,
31:50
it's about switching up. Fume
31:52
isn't just another vapor device. It's
31:55
like a breath of fresh air. Literally.
31:58
Instead of filling your lungs with vapour, it treats
32:00
you to these amazing flavoured airs that
32:03
are as natural as a breeze. No
32:06
electronics, no nasty chemicals, just
32:08
pure delightful flavours. From
32:11
that classic crisp mint, to unique
32:13
ones such as maple pepper and
32:15
white cranberry. The fume device
32:17
is crafted from real wood and has
32:19
these cool moveable parts and magnets. It's
32:22
perfect for people like me who can't keep still.
32:25
When they even throw in a magnetic stand so
32:27
you won't be scrambling around the house, searching
32:30
for it. Start the year
32:32
off right with the good habit by
32:35
going to tryfume.com/morbidology
32:38
and getting the journey packed today. Fume
32:41
is giving listeners of the show 10% off
32:44
when they use my code morbidology to
32:47
help make starting a good habit that
32:49
much easier. Are
32:53
you sick of the chaos that comes with spring
32:55
cleaning? Say goodbye to
32:58
the headache of misplaced items and
33:00
hello to streamlined organisation with smart
33:02
labels, the ultimate solution for your
33:05
storage needs. With smart
33:07
labels decluttering has never been
33:09
easier. All you need to
33:11
do is buy the smart labels qr labels
33:13
on amazon and then stick them on your
33:16
storage bins. Then you
33:18
simply download the app scan the
33:20
qr code and effortlessly catalog all
33:22
of your belongings with names descriptions
33:25
and even pictures. No
33:27
more rummaging through boxes to find what you
33:29
need. Everything is neatly organised
33:31
and at your fingertips. This
33:34
spring reclaim your space and
33:36
sanity with smart labels. Whether
33:40
you're tidying up your closet, garage
33:42
or attic, smart labels makes the
33:44
process a breeze. Just
33:47
search on amazon for smart labels which
33:49
is one word and get
33:51
started today. Joanna
33:56
eventually unblocked David Hoping
33:58
that she could reason with him. But he
34:00
wouldn't listen. She advised
34:03
him to see a psychiatrist. David
34:05
responded by telling her that he was
34:07
going to come to Nottingham and kill
34:09
himself in front of her. She.
34:12
Was terrified of what he was capable of.
34:15
And eventually David was blocked embalmed
34:17
from the form. To.
34:20
On and Matthew decided to just give it ever
34:22
turned out that their flaws again. It.
34:24
Would immediately call police. It
34:28
seemed that he had possibly gotten the message.
34:30
But. Then in September David reached i
34:33
to Matthew with one final a
34:35
meal. At. Read.
34:38
Or something I would like to give to you. Not
34:41
going to say what it is so. That.
34:43
You will love it! After
34:51
learning avoid the disturbing behavior of Df
34:53
Id. Attacked us were keen to
34:55
learn more. When.
34:57
The couple slot had been searched it appear
35:00
to so Matthew had tried to write his
35:02
name. The. Ladders
35:04
de a fi or scroll. And blood
35:06
on the side of the computer. That's
35:08
a really written by Matthew before he died.
35:12
It was as if he was trying to niamh his
35:14
killer. The.
35:16
Detectives launched in that tracing operation.
35:19
And. It didn't take them long to figure out
35:21
the David was a twenty one year old
35:23
man named The Of Advice. He lived close
35:25
to. Frankfurt. In Germany. After
35:29
Matthew was found dead. He. Posted on
35:31
do on his face the. I
35:33
will pray for you. Do. You. Must be
35:35
suffering. And. Sorry for causing you
35:37
so much trouble lately. I hope you
35:40
won't lose all your hope. Will. Be there
35:42
for you! David.
35:44
It also reached out to some other people on
35:46
the form. Soon as
35:48
mass he was killed. Everybody on
35:50
the forums suspected that the of it
35:53
was involved. I
35:55
didn't tear him from contacting them. among
35:58
the people he contacted David was David
36:00
Quinn. He told him, People
36:04
are willing to go to the funeral, and seriously,
36:06
if I knew the date, I would go there.
36:09
You think I did it, and so do
36:11
a few people, I believe. David
36:18
Hise was born on the 19th of June 1987 in
36:22
Frankfurt, West Germany, to a
36:24
Bolivian mother and a German father. His
36:27
childhood was marked by upheaval, beginning with his
36:30
parents' divorce when he was just six
36:32
years old. Following
36:34
the divorce, David went to live with his
36:36
grandmother, as his mother remarried
36:38
and his father's presence in his
36:40
life became sporadic. Raised
36:43
primarily by his grandmother, David
36:46
experienced a sense of isolation and
36:48
detachment from his family. Despite
36:52
living relatively close to his mother, she
36:54
struggled to find the time for him, further
36:57
contributing to his solitude. His
37:00
father's absence exacerbated his feelings
37:02
of loneliness, leaving him
37:05
to navigate childhood largely on his
37:07
own. Throughout his
37:09
school years, David grappled with extreme shyness,
37:12
earning him the label of an outsider
37:14
among his peers. Even
37:17
into adulthood at the age of 21, David's
37:20
bedroom retained a distinctly childlike
37:23
atmosphere, adorned with
37:25
cartoon wallpaper, bunk beds, and
37:27
a collection of Mr. Man books. While
37:31
holding a job as an office junior,
37:33
David's true sanctuary lay within the digital
37:35
realm of his computer. He
37:38
devoted countless hours to online interactions,
37:41
especially on the forum established by
37:44
Matthew and Joanna. Immersed
37:47
in virtual worlds and global
37:49
conversations, David von Solus
37:51
in connection within the confines of his
37:53
screen. Despite
37:55
an attempt to find purpose in military
37:57
service, by enrolling in the German Army
38:00
me, David's tenure was short-lived. He
38:03
was expelled after just two weeks, after
38:06
he was deemed mentally unstable. Following
38:09
his online interactions with Matthew and
38:11
Joanna, David began weaving a
38:14
fabricated narrative in his offline
38:16
life. He
38:19
told his colleagues he had a
38:21
girlfriend from Nottingham and spun elaborate
38:23
plans of relocating to be with
38:25
her and pursuing studies in the
38:27
area. But
38:29
detectives were closing in on him, and
38:31
on the 24th of September, David
38:34
was tracked down near Frankfurt and
38:36
arrested on suspicion of murder. After
38:40
David's arrest, detectives delved deeper into
38:42
his movements following his departure from
38:44
Nottingham in July. They
38:47
secured a search warrant for his
38:49
home and came across blood-stained clothing
38:51
and bags. His
38:53
computer revealed even more significant findings
38:56
connecting him to Matthew's murder.
38:59
It was revealed that on the evening of the
39:01
11th of September, he booked a
39:04
flight to Birmingham for the 18th. Subsequently,
39:07
he revisited the love letter he
39:09
had written for Joanna back in
39:11
May, scrutinising its contents. The
39:14
night before his flight, David connected with
39:17
his sister, requesting her
39:19
to log onto the War's central website
39:21
on the 19th. Detectives
39:23
deduced that this was an attempt to
39:25
establish an alibi, suggesting that
39:27
he was online in Germany during the time
39:30
of the murder. Further
39:32
analysis of his computer
39:34
actively uncovered alarming details.
39:38
That same day, David had created two
39:41
documents. One
39:43
bore the title Confession,
39:45
and it masqueraded as a
39:47
suicide note allegedly written by
39:49
Matthew. Within the
39:51
note, Matthew had expressed a loss of
39:54
love for Joanna And said
39:56
goodbye to his family. Peter.
40:01
It's. Intricate knowledge of Marquees family
40:03
suggested a disturbing level of
40:05
insight possessed by D Is
40:07
it. The. Second
40:10
argument was titled I made a
40:12
decision. And it was a
40:14
suicide New written by himself. And.
40:17
The Know: He said that Matthew had driven him
40:19
to take his own. nice. The
40:23
detectives continued in their investigation.
40:25
And learned that on the it into September David
40:28
caught a boss to Frankfurt airport. He told
40:30
his family that he was going to a party.
40:32
That. He flew to Birmingham via Amsterdam.
40:35
And arrive shortly after nine pm that
40:37
night. Cctv footage
40:40
captured him touching a tree and
40:42
to Birmingham. And. Them walking over
40:44
to do that into on a slap. In
40:47
the cctv footage, it was clear that he
40:49
was wearing multiple layers of clothing. Presumably
40:52
to change all of the bloody clothing
40:54
following the murder. Give.
40:57
It slapped overnight on the roof of
40:59
the fluff. To.
41:01
On the left for work the next morning, just
41:03
before seven a m. And. I'd
41:06
avoid seven thirty am. David.
41:08
Climbed on from the roof. Some.
41:10
Minutes later Matthew was attacked and killed as
41:13
he opened up the front door. Initially,
41:16
Day of The denied any involvement in
41:18
Marti's murder. Claiming. That
41:20
he wasn't even in Nottingham at the times.
41:22
The crime. He
41:24
told attacked us to loop it is online
41:26
activity. To. Show that he was in
41:29
Germany on the form at the time. Detectives
41:32
already knew that he had asked his sister
41:34
to log on. And
41:36
confronted with weird if the evidence
41:39
meticulously gathered by detectives. If.
41:41
It eventually also to narrative. According.
41:45
To the of the to point, he admitted
41:47
to traveling to Nottingham and visiting Marchionne Do
41:49
on a slot that morning. He
41:52
claimed that his initial intention was merely
41:54
to be Matthew up. He.
41:57
described knocking on the front door and
42:00
said that when Matthew opened, he tried to
42:02
punch him. According
42:04
to David, Matthew turned around and ran back
42:06
into the flat, and a fistfight
42:08
ensued, but David said the
42:10
punches weren't landing. He
42:13
said that Matthew was being abusive to him, so
42:16
he told him to shut up and listen. At
42:18
this moment, David said the knife he had brought
42:20
along with him slipped out of his waistband, and
42:23
Matthew tried to grab it. David
42:26
asserted that he only sought to defend himself
42:28
by attempting to push Matthew's arms away, fearing
42:31
potential harm. He
42:34
recounted a chaotic struggle, alleging
42:36
that he stumbled backwards and collided with the
42:38
table, causing the knife to fall from Matthew's
42:40
grasp. In David's
42:42
version of events, he described thwarting
42:45
Matthew's attempts to retrieve the knife
42:47
by restraining him physically. He
42:50
claimed that Matthew's desperate actions, including kicking
42:52
him in the back, fueled
42:54
his own determination to secure the weapon
42:56
first, fearing for his own
42:58
safety. He said that
43:01
he was so afraid that when he finally
43:03
got his hands on the knife, he stabbed
43:05
Matthew repeatedly. He
43:07
said that he only stopped when Matthew stopped struggling.
43:11
After David's extradition back to the United
43:13
Kingdom, he was charged with the
43:15
murder of Matthew on the 26th of November.
43:18
He was ordered to stand trial, which commenced
43:21
on the 28th of April 2009 at Nottingham Crown Court.
43:27
Accompanied by his defence team, David entered the
43:29
courtroom to take his place alongside them. The
43:33
public gallery swelled with Matthew's grieving
43:35
loved ones as the trial proceedings
43:37
unfolded. During the
43:39
opening statements, prosecutors presented their case to
43:41
the jury. Prosecutor
43:44
Sean Smith outlined David's disturbing
43:46
obsession with Joanna and detailed
43:48
his alleged plan to kill Matthew, while staging
43:51
it to appear as a suicide. Prosecutor
43:55
Smith informed the jury that the printed suicide
43:57
note was discovered in David's suitcase as well as the
43:59
jury. It on his computer. I
44:02
have to because of the frenzied nature of the
44:05
murder. it was apparent that Matthew hadn't taken to
44:07
some nice. Prosecutor said
44:09
the day the Dan resorted to ransacking
44:11
the home to give the appearance the
44:13
murder was a robbery gone wrong. According
44:16
to the prosecution's narrative is David waited
44:19
on the roof top as the slot
44:21
overnight. Observing to on and
44:23
leaving for work the next morning before
44:25
launching his attack. He. Stay at
44:27
it. It's. The prosecution's case
44:29
that Matthew had absolutely no chance
44:32
that.the. war. Where. The applaud his.
44:35
He. Was stabbed right away by this
44:37
defendant. After Marty
44:39
was dead, diva change died of his bloody
44:41
clothing and stole a pair of Marty series
44:43
and a baseball cap. Then.
44:46
Embarked on his. Return. Trip to Germany,
44:48
And discarded the murder weapon along the way.
44:52
David's. Japan's wasn't that he had and
44:54
carried out the murder, but instead that
44:56
he had acted in self defense. Joanna.
44:59
Was the first witness to testify on
45:01
behalf the prosecution. And. She detail
45:04
the of that obsession with her. She.
45:07
Said when he first showed up at
45:09
their flawed and slapped overnight, she was
45:11
petrified. She described
45:13
going into the bathroom and crying. After
45:17
he last the only thing stealing never left
45:19
her. She said to the
45:22
jury. I was afraid that he
45:24
is going to turn up again. And. I didn't
45:26
know what he was capable of. Drama
45:29
testified that she began to blunt David.
45:32
Hoping that he would get the hint. She.
45:35
Was asked why she didn't just block him. But
45:38
she replied. I was
45:40
trying to come thing storing. The
45:42
by blocked him it would have made it worse
45:44
and made him com to Nottingham. So.
45:46
It's a other users of the form testified
45:48
against the as it. Did. Chilling
45:51
to the jury his disturbing obsession
45:53
and comments about wanting to various
45:55
matthew. He.
45:57
Is it himself Testified on his own. behalf,
46:01
telling the jury the same thing that he
46:03
had told detectives. He
46:06
said that he had brought the knife along with him that
46:09
day because he wanted to be prepared. He
46:12
testified. He might attack
46:14
me and get the upper hand. He
46:17
said that it was his intention to beat Matty up
46:19
so badly that he needed to go to hospital. When
46:23
he was shown a photograph of Matty's
46:25
computer with the letters D-A-V smeared in
46:27
blood, he seemed surprised.
46:31
He denied that he had written it and
46:33
said that Matty couldn't have written it either
46:35
because he was dead when he left. Ultimately,
46:39
the jury sided with the prosecution
46:41
and found David Hice guilty of
46:43
the murder of Matty Pike. The
46:47
sentencing phase followed and
46:49
the judge sentenced him to life in prison with a
46:51
minimum of 18 years. In
46:55
handing down the sentence, the judge told David,
46:58
the fact that your motive for murder was so
47:00
bizarre doesn't make your killing
47:02
of Matty any less serious. He
47:06
said it was evident that David was unable to
47:08
cope with rejection, telling him, I
47:11
have no doubt that at some stage you
47:14
decided that Matty had to die and
47:16
that your killing of him involved a
47:18
substantial degree of both planning and
47:21
premeditation, which is
47:23
a significant aggravating factor. Following
47:38
David's sentencing to life in
47:40
prison, the disturbing revelation surfaced
47:42
regarding his persistent fixation on
47:44
Joanna. Despite
47:46
his incarceration, he continued to harbor delusions
47:49
of a future with her, evidence
47:52
by a letter he penned from behind bars.
47:55
In the letter, he said he hoped
47:57
they could be reunited. Meanwhile,
48:00
Joanna Stead Fosley maintained the War
48:03
Central's forms in the years following
48:05
Matthew's tragic murder. She
48:08
dedicated herself to preserving his memory,
48:11
creating a heartfelt tribute page where
48:13
visitors could share their cherished recollections
48:15
of him. The
48:18
outpouring of affection within the form testified
48:20
to the enduring impact Matthew had on
48:23
the community, united by
48:25
their shared passion for the video game. Each
48:29
year, Joanna wished Matthew
48:31
happy anniversary and happy birthday.
48:34
Matthew's mother even joined the forum so that
48:36
she could post on his wall. However,
48:39
in a bittersweet turn of events
48:42
in 2018, Joanna announced the
48:44
closure of the forum, marking
48:46
the end of an era. With
48:49
a poignant message, she wrote, On
48:52
the 1st of March 2018, War Central
48:56
will close and become another corner
48:58
of the internet remembered only
49:00
by the membership and archiving
49:02
websites. I'd like to
49:04
thank you for all the good times and good friendships
49:06
that were formed over the 10
49:08
years War Central existed. There
49:11
were some fun times and they'll be fondly
49:13
remembered. Have a
49:15
great life, Jo. The
49:24
intricate web of the internet has not
49:27
only interconnected the world, but also
49:29
laid bare the depths of human
49:31
obsession. David Heiss
49:33
found himself obsessed with the woman he
49:35
met online, but despite
49:37
her relentless rejection, his fixation
49:40
only intensified. In
49:43
the end, David's obsession took over
49:45
his life, leading him to
49:47
Nottingham, where David's obsession
49:50
ended Matthew Pike's life. Well
50:16
besties that is it for this episode
50:18
of Morbidology. As always thank you
50:21
so much for listening and I'd like to
50:23
say a massive thank you to my newest
50:25
supporter up on Patreon, Pat. You
50:27
can join us up on Patreon for as little as $1
50:30
a month and there are absolutely no obligations.
50:33
You can cancel your subscription at any time. The
50:36
link to Patreon is in the show notes,
50:38
or alternatively, you can download the app and
50:40
search for Morbidology, or search on
50:42
your internet browser. As
50:45
mentioned last week, Morbidology is now up
50:47
on YouTube. The episodes
50:49
are presented in a documentary style,
50:51
along with photographs and videos relevant
50:53
to each case, along with some
50:55
videos. So please
50:57
head on over to YouTube, type
50:59
in Morbidology and subscribe to the
51:01
channel. It'll really help out. Remember
51:04
to check us out at morbidology.com for more
51:07
information about this episode and to read
51:09
some true crime articles. Until
51:11
next time, take care of yourselves, stay safe
51:13
and have an amazing week.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More