Podchaser Logo
Home
Six Wives: Anne Boleyn

Six Wives: Anne Boleyn

Released Monday, 3rd June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Six Wives: Anne Boleyn

Six Wives: Anne Boleyn

Six Wives: Anne Boleyn

Six Wives: Anne Boleyn

Monday, 3rd June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:02

Welcome to Sincerely Sloan presented by

0:04

Uninterrupted. I'm your

0:06

host, professional tennis player, wife,

0:08

parent, and entrepreneur, Sloan Stephens.

0:11

As an athlete and as a person, my

0:13

journey has had a lot of twists and

0:16

turns, from moments of adversity and doubt to

0:18

unimaginable triumph and satisfaction. Throughout

0:20

the season, I'm joined by some of the biggest

0:22

names in sports, entertainment, culture, and a few members

0:25

of my tribe. Our

0:27

conversations keep it real and push it past

0:29

skin deep. We

0:31

reveal the perspectives, routines, and products that allow

0:33

each of us to show up at our

0:35

best. Join me on

0:38

my journey of self-discovery and many, many

0:40

laughs along the way. Sincerely, Sloan. The

0:45

living room is where you make life's

0:47

most beautiful memories, but your sofa shouldn't

0:50

be the one remembering them. The new

0:52

life-resistant, high-performance furniture collection from Ashley is

0:54

designed to withstand all the spills, slip-ups,

0:57

and muddy paws that come with the

0:59

best parts of life. Ashley

1:01

high-performance sofas and recliners are soft,

1:03

on-trend, and easy to clean. Shop

1:07

the high-performance furniture in-store or online

1:09

at ashley.com. Ashley,

1:11

for the love of home. Six

1:22

wives, six lives, about

1:24

whom we think we know everything. But

1:26

beyond their mostly doomed marriages to

1:29

Henry VIII and, in many cases,

1:31

tragic ends, here were

1:33

six women who shaped history in

1:35

their own unique ways. The

1:38

National Portrait Gallery in London is hosting

1:40

a new exhibition called Six Lives, displaying

1:43

the images that have shaped our perception

1:45

of Henry VIII's queens. It

1:47

was just the excuse I needed to bring

1:49

together the most illuminating interviews about them from

1:52

the Not Just the Tudors archives. Across

1:54

six episodes, I'll also be exploring some of

1:56

the latest research and speaking to the curator

1:58

of the National Portrait Gallery. Portrait Gallery's

2:00

exhibition, Dr. Charlotte Boland, to paint

2:03

an even fuller portrait of each

2:05

of Henry VIII's wives. Our

2:08

second podcast in this series focuses on

2:10

a woman who changed the history of

2:12

England, Anne Boleyn. In order

2:14

to make her his queen, Henry

2:16

altered the very face of the

2:19

country, banished his closest minister, broke

2:21

with Christendom and set aside

2:23

his faithful, once beloved wife

2:25

Catherine. So who was Anne Boleyn?

2:29

In this episode we'll hear

2:31

from Dr. Lauren Mackay, Dr.

2:33

Owen Emerson, Natalie Gruniger, Dr.

2:35

Tracey Borman, Dr. Emma Keilmaron,

2:38

Dr. Estelle Paranc, Dr. Kate

2:41

Hurd, Kate McCaffrey, Professor Joanne

2:43

Deleneva, Dr. Charlotte Boland and

2:46

Matt Lewis features as Henry VIII himself.

2:49

I'm Professor Susanna Lipscomb and

2:51

this is Not Just the Tudors. To

3:04

know who Anne Boleyn was, we first

3:06

have to know her people. Anne

3:09

Boleyn's parents were Sir Thomas Boleyn

3:11

and Elizabeth, me Howard. Elizabeth

3:14

was part of a wealthy and influential

3:16

family. Her father was Thomas Howard, Earl

3:18

of Surrey, later Second Duke of Norfolk.

3:21

But the Boleyn's too had been on the rise

3:24

for decades. Three generations

3:26

of Boleyn men marrying well

3:28

had produced an extraordinary social

3:30

ascent. The last of

3:32

these was Anne's father Thomas. Dr.

3:34

Lauren Mackay explains. The Boleyn story

3:36

is really the story of many

3:39

families at court in that particular

3:41

era. They rise generation by generation.

3:44

And in fact the story

3:46

with the Boleyns really takes shape in a

3:48

little town called Sol in Norfolk which is

3:50

sort of a one pub, one horse

3:52

town minus the pub with

3:55

Jeffrey Boleyn. And Jeffrey Boleyn

3:57

who was Anne Boleyn's great

3:59

grandfather. He actually elevated

4:01

the family from simply a family

4:03

who worked on the land to

4:05

landowners themselves. And he

4:08

formed the blueprint for this idea for

4:10

this mercantile family rising through the echelons

4:12

of society. And what he did brilliantly

4:15

was to marry into a very ancient

4:17

and noble family. So

4:20

he married Anne Hu. This

4:22

particular connection acquired more land and

4:24

gentility and wealth. Now,

4:26

their son, William Berlin, would go on

4:28

to be a very well-respected man of

4:31

Norfolk as well. And he

4:33

did the exact same thing. He married

4:35

into the prestigious ancient noble Butler family,

4:37

which is where we see the earldom

4:40

of Ormond. And their son,

4:42

our Thomas Berlin, would do the same. He

4:44

married into the powerful and noble

4:47

and illustrious Howard family. So

4:49

you have three generations building

4:51

upon these foundations, generation

4:53

to generation. That's really how

4:56

they become a sixter at court. And

4:58

crucially, by the reign of the first

5:00

tutor, Henry VII, they are already part

5:02

of the social fabric of Henry VII's

5:05

court. So we know

5:07

that William Berlin was a very well-respected

5:09

courtier, so Thomas's father. And

5:12

Thomas Berlin himself was actually a squire

5:14

of the body under Henry VII's reign.

5:16

So he had that personal intimate access

5:18

with the king. And of

5:20

course, this is a society upon which patronage

5:22

is absolutely integral to your

5:25

rise. So that connection with the king

5:27

is vital to your

5:29

success. So really, the Berlin story

5:31

typifies this rise from the very

5:33

modest beginnings to something that was

5:36

quite brilliant. And this all

5:38

took place before Anne Berlin was even born. This

5:42

steady climb continued with Anne's

5:44

father, Thomas. Laura MacKay warns

5:47

us that we needn't imagine he needed

5:49

his daughter in the king's bed to

5:51

succeed. Thomas Berlin

5:53

really began to rise at court under the reign

5:55

of Henry VII. He makes his first appearance about

5:58

the age of the king. Twenty

6:00

in the Kings army of all places. He

6:03

is alongside his father and they're pushing

6:05

down a rebellion that the Cornish Rebellion

6:07

string one of the many riot during

6:09

hundred to Seven strain. I don't think

6:11

the military was really he's seen, so

6:13

we actually see him sort of as

6:15

a fixture at courts. Mountain.

6:18

I think from a fling with very

6:20

lucky because he grew up in a

6:22

world of wealth and privilege so far

6:24

from being a steaming Matthew Valley and

6:26

ma'am he didn't need to have any

6:28

of that because he was so well

6:30

place. So until muslims a young man

6:32

at court he has these incredible connections.

6:34

his grandfather is com a spotless not

6:37

from a butler, was Lord Chamberlain's Elizabeth

6:39

of York and he would also going

6:41

to be Lord Chamberlain to cast and

6:43

vog and in her early years as

6:45

queen as quite a connection there. but

6:47

he's also flanked. By his father in

6:49

law the powerful of sorry Thomas Khalid,

6:51

these connections offered his own trains are

6:53

caught that very few young men actually

6:56

would have enjoyed. So the young from

6:58

Muslim navigates these fears. Of course he

7:00

passed of the inner sphere For Henry

7:02

the Seventh is also part of the

7:04

political sphere is he really gets his

7:07

be great at the beginning of Henry

7:09

the Eighth rain. So and fifty know

7:11

nine he's already been as it's an

7:13

old, the carnations and christenings and weddings

7:15

and funerals and there he is. At

7:18

Top and of our guns. Arrival in

7:20

England and he presents front and center

7:22

at Henry the Eighth Coronation as well

7:24

when you've made a nice as the

7:26

Boss So I have all before Anne

7:28

Boleyn his own the same but crucially

7:30

what happens in the first years of

7:33

Henry the eighth reign as that he

7:35

suddenly appears as a new face in

7:37

the diplomatic line up and is odd

7:39

because it really comes from know where

7:41

he has no history as an ambassador.

7:43

he doesn't apply as we know and

7:45

he's working all of a sudden alongside

7:47

real stalwarts. Of Henry the Eighth

7:49

Diplomatic Stable say men like Thomas

7:52

Finale and Richard Wingfield, and this

7:54

really comes about because of these

7:56

connections, his grandfather and his father

7:58

in law who are. New, the

8:00

architect of Henry the eighth Diplomatic Policy

8:03

and that is the one and only.

8:05

Rich had Fox who would of course

8:07

go on to mental illness Movies

8:09

said that way that interesting connection comes

8:12

in. So now I'm not going to

8:14

their his entire life, but Thomas Boleyn

8:16

obviously begins to ascended court and

8:18

to really cultivate this reputation. He's one

8:21

of those new men because he doesn't

8:23

necessarily have the notable cleaning support from

8:25

those tissue little insertion started generation. but

8:28

he himself is not actually noble. But

8:30

he has skill. He has political,

8:32

asked him and says something about

8:34

him that recommend him to the

8:36

power men have caught. So I

8:39

think that's very very important said.

8:41

by the time and billion does

8:43

bus to on the same in

8:45

the Fifteen Twenty six, Thomas Boleyn

8:47

is already one of the most

8:49

well for us have respected, reliable,

8:51

trustworthy men have caught. He is

8:53

an obsolete Six south and East

8:55

powerful, his influential, and he certainly

8:57

doesn't need. To rise any further on

8:59

the back of his daughter. What?

9:04

This intelligent. Ufo diplomat

9:06

did to further along with his

9:08

was nice to raise his surviving

9:11

children. And Doors and

9:13

Mary to ensure their own

9:15

successful placements. Of the court in

9:17

the fullness of time. I

9:22

had probably been born. Applicant? Who in

9:24

north of can around fifty? No one?

9:27

The to. Spend a large part of her.

9:29

Childhood. At Heave a

9:31

causal in Kent. Doctor. Own Emerson

9:33

takes up the story. We

9:36

know this probably means to evolve

9:38

around fifteen years. Which

9:40

is when Thomas Boleyn or Mission

9:43

of the Castle from his father

9:45

and will they we didn't have

9:47

a huge amounts of information about

9:49

the early access to believe children

9:51

see with you have argued please

9:54

they were late sixties. He's not

9:56

least the great says Thomas and

9:58

Henry Rollins. you us. Very

10:00

good. He's a church and

10:02

app pens past the alleys.

10:04

There's probably quite a lot

10:06

of loss to the building.

10:08

Boys died and I can

10:11

imagine this being an place

10:13

where and was educated, shoot

10:15

the gun for education and

10:17

most likely her parents were

10:19

involved in education sickly. Elizabeth

10:21

her mother to muslim was

10:23

a humanist educated ordered his

10:26

children well and he was

10:28

that three team and able

10:30

diplomat and was able to

10:32

secure really advantageous position. Notice

10:34

at New King Cole say

10:36

I like to think the

10:38

and as education and her

10:40

passions began here season. Insisting

10:43

thirteen when and cannot have been

10:45

more than about twelve years old.

10:48

She was sent to the court as

10:50

Margaret of Austria. Although

10:53

we know how confusing the as Margaret

10:55

of Austria. She had been governor

10:57

of the Low Countries since his dinner

10:59

seven and joined Margaret at her newly

11:01

built palace in Message on. The

11:04

initiative to send an to Margaret to

11:06

land since and to receive training in

11:09

courtly ways may well have come from

11:11

Thomas Boleyn, who had met Margaret to

11:13

his diplomatic career. Another possibility

11:15

that is is it was the idea.

11:17

Of Queen Catherine, His. Dr.

11:20

Emma Cahill Madden. Coffin.

11:22

When she sent and to migrate of

11:25

us sure it was because she values

11:27

education that she would receive in the

11:29

quite. A martyr of us chef and.

11:31

I think because she was trying to

11:34

start this international court with Henry system

11:36

is good idea to send some lady

11:38

for the content to learn things that

11:41

they could learn really in England. Probably

11:43

knowing that she was very bright as

11:45

a young person, she thought she'll do

11:47

really well somewhere else. You'll learn things

11:50

to come back and will find her

11:52

that much and that's how it really

11:54

works with many other ladies cel I

11:57

don't think it would have been defenders

11:59

of time. she was another lady waiting at

12:01

the court. Margaret

12:04

described Anne as bright and pleasant

12:07

for her young age. Anne

12:10

was at Margaret's extraordinary court for a couple

12:12

of years. But in 1515, Anne

12:15

joined the court of the young French Queen

12:17

Claude. Claude was wife

12:19

of the new French King of Hosea,

12:21

or Francis I. Natalie

12:24

Gruniger gives us a flavour of what

12:26

life at Queen Claude of the Francis

12:28

Court was like for Anne. Anne

12:34

was not in service to Francis, she was

12:37

in service to Claude, his wife. Known

12:39

for her piety, for her intelligence, for

12:41

her morality, she was greatly loved actually

12:43

by the people. And in the

12:45

time that Anne was there, Claude was pregnant a

12:47

lot of the time. In fact, she had seven

12:49

pregnancies over a period of nine and a half

12:52

years. And she preferred to

12:54

spend time at her estates in the Loire Valley.

12:56

And Anne, of course, would have

12:58

been expected to conduct herself modestly

13:01

and decoriously and guard

13:03

her chastity like a treasure. This

13:05

is essential. So I think

13:07

when you picture, you know, the dancing

13:09

and all the flirting, most days would

13:12

have been completely different. They would have

13:14

been spent doing activities that were well

13:16

regarded for women at this point. So

13:18

we can imagine Anne and Claude's other

13:21

ladies sewing, embroidering, spending a

13:23

lot of time worshipping.

13:25

So private prayer, public

13:27

prayer, reading, devotional texts,

13:29

reading scriptures, discussing

13:31

scriptures, going to

13:33

church, all the chapel, perhaps singing psalms

13:36

or something like that. Charitable

13:38

works that they would have done together, maybe

13:40

taking a walk in the garden and practicing

13:43

or playing an instrument or just chatting

13:45

among the ladies. So possibly some games as

13:47

well, Anne was known for knowing and be

13:49

very good at all the fashionable games. At

13:51

the time, the cards, dice, all that sort

13:53

of thing. But it's very different to what's

13:55

often portrayed in films and books. What

14:01

Anne learnt at Claude's court powerfully

14:03

shaped her outlook. Anne

14:07

Boleyn experienced female power like

14:09

no one before. Dr Estelle

14:11

Paranc. It was very clear

14:13

that being a queen was better than being

14:15

a mistress. Lens, wealth, giving, titles given,

14:17

no problem. By the end of the day,

14:20

the one who was sitting by the

14:22

side of the king, who was important, was

14:24

Queen Claude. And I think Anne Boleyn

14:26

saw that really and must have impacted her

14:28

in many ways. She

14:32

may also have been influenced by

14:35

the king's sister, Marguerite d'Angolem, who

14:37

sought reformation within the Catholic Church.

14:40

There's something very mysterious about

14:42

this relationship. Estelle Paranc again.

14:44

I think that they spent

14:46

significant times together. So you're

14:48

not going to have letters, you're going to have discussions.

14:51

And it's not just about reformed ideas. I think

14:53

they were just both very interested in education, especially

14:56

of women. I'm not saying they're best friends. I'm

14:59

saying that she probably learnt much

15:01

from Marguerite d'Angolem, especially when we

15:03

see how she behaved herself towards

15:05

reaching. It was only

15:07

after seven years of service to Claude,

15:09

and nearly a decade away from England,

15:12

that Anne returned to join the court

15:14

of King Henry VIII and Queen Catherine.

15:18

Lest we think of the court as

15:21

a static place, Owen Emerson explains. The

15:23

court is a very fluid thing,

15:26

actually. It moves from space to

15:28

space. So we have the palaces

15:30

of Richmond, Greenwich and

15:32

Westminster, and the court will

15:34

be continually on the move.

15:37

And Anne enters into what

15:39

is quite a sophisticated court,

15:41

as Catherine's maid of honour.

15:43

On a day-to-day basis, they

15:45

are essentially Catherine's companions. They

15:47

are praying with her, reading

15:49

to her, and also carrying

15:51

messages and being a front-facing

15:54

sort of representation of the Queen's

15:56

household. This

15:58

was an incredibly... colourful and

16:00

sumptuous environment that Anne was going

16:03

into. You can just

16:05

get a flavour of that from the

16:07

clothes that Catherine is wearing here. She's

16:09

in red velvet and cloth of gold

16:12

and she is completely bedoueled. This is

16:14

a really glittering environment and it must

16:17

have been a really dazzling environment for

16:19

the young Anne Boleyn to enter into.

16:23

Who was this Anne? To get

16:25

a handle first on what Anne

16:27

looked like, I talked to Dr

16:29

Charlotte Golland, Curator at the National

16:31

Portrait Gallery, about Anne's portraiture.

16:36

Charlotte, people will feel very

16:39

familiar with portraits of Anne

16:41

Boleyn but caveat

16:43

emptor, we should be wary

16:45

of trusting them. Why is that? We

16:48

don't have a painted portrait produced

16:50

during Anne's lifetime, a large-scale painted

16:52

portrait that's been identified with certainty.

16:55

The most familiar images with Anne

16:57

in a French hood, often against a green

16:59

background with her bee pendant with all the

17:01

pearls, is actually produced in

17:03

the late 16th century. It is an

17:06

Elizabethan image and it's so interesting to

17:08

think about the way that image is

17:10

constructed because it has long been wondered

17:12

whether that image might itself be based

17:14

on a lost painting produced during Anne's

17:16

reign, which is very possible and plausible.

17:19

But it is equally possible that it is a complete

17:22

construction of the Elizabethan

17:24

period when an artist was confronted

17:26

with the question of in the

17:28

celebration of Elizabeth and wanting to celebrate

17:30

her mother, how do you make an image

17:32

of Anne? And so that idea

17:34

of is what's recognisable in that image of

17:36

Anne, something that's familiar to us from portraits

17:38

of Elizabeth, was an image of Elizabeth's starting

17:40

point but then going backwards and so

17:42

there is sort of construction and residency of

17:45

Anne and in that it's intriguing as to

17:47

how she is referred to in the inscriptions

17:49

and this very conscious use of the bee

17:51

emblem. We can know from the amazing inventory

17:54

taken at Henry VIII's death of the

17:56

way in which his initials were combined with his

17:58

queens all over the place. H.A.

18:00

emblems being everywhere, or

18:03

A.R. of Anna Regina everywhere. But

18:05

a B for Berlin isn't actually really

18:07

necessarily part of the way that she

18:09

would present herself, but it's

18:12

intriguing to think about how the Elizabethans

18:14

needed to deal with what happened to

18:16

her, because while Elizabeth could never absolve

18:18

her, as it were, legally, because

18:21

to do so would imply that her father

18:23

had murdered her mother, if Anne were completely

18:25

innocent, nonetheless Anne needs to

18:27

be celebrated because she has had this

18:30

extraordinary daughter. And so it's intriguing that

18:32

as a Berlin that provides a helpful

18:34

bit of distance, as it were, from

18:36

the situation, and also they often explicitly

18:38

identify here as wife rather

18:40

than necessarily as queen. That has to be

18:43

because Elizabeth has to be legitimate, but the

18:45

queen element can be quietened down a bit

18:47

in the iconography. That's so interesting

18:49

because I have often wondered why a

18:52

B for Berlin, because after 1529 she's

18:54

going to be A.R. for Rotford,

18:58

and then she's going to be P

19:00

for Pembroke, and she becomes Mark with

19:02

a Pembroke, and then she's Anna Regina

19:05

in the Latin for queen. There's only

19:07

a very slim window where she would

19:09

have been B for Berlin, except this

19:11

amazing possibility you're presenting, that it is

19:14

posthumously that she's Berlin rather than anything

19:16

else. What do we have

19:18

then that dates from her lifetime?

19:21

The image of Anne that we have that's so

19:24

emblematic almost of the conundrum of

19:26

her reputation, and her semi-arrasure and

19:28

reconstruction is a portrait medal

19:30

made in 1534 that celebrates her as

19:34

A.R. and the most happy written around it.

19:36

But it's in lead, which is very soft,

19:38

and it's been very worn and flattened, and

19:40

there is only one that whether it was

19:43

created in hope of great celebrations

19:45

of the birth of a son in

19:48

1534 that didn't happen and was quietly put

19:50

aside, never got made in great numbers. So

19:52

you have that one sort of image of Anne

19:54

that is very difficult to assess now, and we

19:57

don't also know how much of a likeness it

19:59

ever was. how close it had

20:01

ever been to the Queen in its original condition.

20:04

There are other contenders to be an image

20:06

of Anne produced during her lifetime. Here's

20:09

just one of them. Previous

20:11

schools of historians have not thought it was

20:13

Anne, but that is changing. Charlotte

20:15

Boland again. The other

20:17

image which is growing much more

20:19

securely identified as Anne's scholarship is

20:21

coalescing more about who's Anne Boleyn

20:23

now is drawing in the Royal

20:25

Collection of a woman in a nightcap

20:28

wearing a sort of furred gown identifying

20:31

the sitter as Anne Boleyn. The

20:33

challenge with this portrait is that people have

20:35

looked at it and thought, how is the

20:37

status of this woman, this kind of incredible

20:40

intimacy, this just can't be a queen. Why

20:42

on earth would an artist have the access to

20:44

produce this? Who was it for? How

20:46

can it happen? There is that inversion of the question

20:48

of saying perhaps only a queen could afford to

20:50

have an image of that type made. And

20:54

that the identities have

20:56

been written on a number of the portrait drawings that are all in

20:58

the Royal Collection from the

21:00

great pattern book of physiognomies that Holbein

21:02

created. That while it

21:04

applied at a later date to the drawings, the

21:07

list of the identities of the sitters was

21:09

from people who would have known Anne by

21:11

sight. And that the vast majority of the

21:13

identifications of the sitters in these drawings have

21:15

been accepted. So why

21:17

question this one of Anne? And there's also

21:19

the great record of the fact that we

21:22

have that crumb that Henry Gavann, a

21:24

silk furled gown prior to their marriage.

21:27

And so is this that kind of direct connection.

21:30

The person who would have known

21:32

Anne Boleyn by sight and who

21:34

identified Holbein's drawings was Sir John

21:36

Cheek. Cheek was a tutor to Edward

21:38

VI and he identified the sitters in the

21:40

1540s. I

21:43

met Dr Kate Heard, the curator of

21:45

an exhibition on Holbein by the Royal

21:47

Collection Trust at Buckingham Palace to discuss

21:50

the drawing. We're standing in

21:52

front of a preparatory drawing labelled Anne

21:54

Boleyn and there's been lots of people

21:56

over the years who have said that

21:58

this wasn't Anne. I

22:00

myself am fairly convinced as it is, and

22:02

I want to know all your thoughts and

22:05

to talk about this particular picture and why

22:07

it has been identified as Anne and why

22:09

it hasn't. I think there are all sorts

22:11

of pieces of evidence you can bring to bear

22:13

on whether this shows Anne Boleyn or not and

22:16

to me, again personally I agree,

22:18

it's Anne Boleyn partly because of

22:20

the weight of that evidence all these little

22:22

pieces, the jigsaw that come together and

22:25

the first of those is that inscription, and we've

22:27

talked about these inscriptions a few times that she

22:29

would have known who Anne Boleyn was. So

22:31

the fact that in the 18th century, based on

22:33

the 16th century inscription, this was identified

22:35

as Anne Boleyn, that's a good start. There's

22:37

been some work on her dress, some really

22:40

interesting dress history done that's been tied

22:42

to items of clothing that Anne

22:44

Boleyn is known to have had. There

22:46

are for me two very other

22:48

interesting facts about the drawing. One

22:51

of the reasons for debating whether it is Anne Boleyn

22:53

is the colour of the hair and

22:55

the sitter in this drawing has brown eyes

22:57

but her hair is very light. We

23:00

looked at it under a microscope as part of

23:02

the preparation for the exhibition and the drawing is

23:05

a chalk drawing like most of those in the

23:07

exhibition, there will have been some rubbing of the

23:09

surface. And what seems

23:12

likely is that because

23:14

we know that Holbein built up his

23:16

hair colours in layers of different colours

23:19

to create the tone he wanted and he

23:21

started with light chalks and then built up

23:23

the darker chalks on top to darken the

23:25

hair. Possibly quite a bit of

23:27

that darker shading from the top has disappeared

23:29

so what you're seeing is probably a lighter

23:31

hair colour than she would originally have had.

23:34

But I also find the back of the drawing very interesting

23:36

because this is the only drawing in the exhibition that

23:38

has something on the back. Which

23:40

in itself is unusual for a Renaissance drawing,

23:42

it's usually paper's expensive and artists will use

23:45

it as much as they can. But

23:48

this has the Wyatt arms on the back. I

23:50

think it's really interesting that Henry Wyatt, who's

23:52

one of Holbein's patrons dies in November 1536

23:54

shortly after Anne's executed and you start to

23:56

wonder if this became a scrap piece of paper.

23:58

It would have been known. that no longer

24:01

would any portraits of Anne Melin be commissioned.

24:03

Unlike Jane Seymour, we've got the drawing of

24:05

Jane Seymour next to it. That

24:07

was constantly used for portraits, but you can

24:09

imagine Holbein turning it over and using

24:11

it for a different project at that

24:13

point. It's

24:18

always up for debate. That's the excitement about Holbein.

24:20

There's lots of discussions to be had, but to

24:22

me this is a good candidate for Anne Melin.

24:26

For centuries, we have built up this

24:28

image of Anne as a beautiful femme

24:30

fatale. Maybe we need to imagine

24:32

a radically different iconography of Anne. Perhaps

24:35

it's time to reckon with the idea

24:37

that maybe Anne was not beautiful. She

24:40

was just brilliant. Natalie Gruniger

24:42

agrees. We get this idea

24:44

of, I suppose, what she looks like, which is

24:47

a long oval face, quite

24:49

a strong nose, and

24:51

a pretty decided chin as well. Eric

24:54

Ives concluded that it's a face of

24:56

character, not beauty. She

24:58

probably had dark, Albany hair

25:00

colour. You know, a

25:03

lot of people think black, that we

25:05

actually have one contemporary account of her

25:07

having black hair, and that comes later

25:09

in the Deilisbeetham period. So her allure

25:11

was much more to do with her

25:13

sophistication, her intelligence, her charisma, her wit,

25:16

rather than, I think, her

25:18

actual physical appearance. What

25:20

then can we make of Anne's character?

25:23

Owen Emerson suggests that above all,

25:26

we see evidence of her intelligence.

25:29

You can see that evidence in a list

25:31

of her surviving, written

25:34

words. In her books of

25:37

hours, she writes the most poignant and beautiful

25:40

couplets. Everyone

25:42

that knew her said

25:45

how engaging she was, how sort of

25:47

vivacious she was. She had a wonderful

25:50

character. And I

25:52

would say a very keen intellect as well.

25:55

I would almost argue that she was

25:57

on a par with Henry, in terms of

25:59

being able to... debate and

26:01

I think that engagement underpinned the

26:04

loss of a turmoil

26:06

that their relationship went through. It wasn't

26:08

all sunshine with Anne and

26:10

Henry. There were some storms,

26:13

shall we say, where they were up

26:15

heads and their makeup and

26:17

I think underpinning that

26:19

was her amazing intellect. In

26:24

coming to the English court, what did

26:26

Anne hope for? What were her ambitions?

26:29

And did she have designs on Henry?

26:32

From a young age, 12 at least, we've got

26:34

evidence from a letter that Anne wrote. She

26:36

is dreaming of serving class rats.

26:38

She wants to serve her loyally,

26:40

diligently. She wants to be a really

26:42

great, perhaps waiting to her one day. She

26:45

wants to please her parents and she wants

26:47

to please the Queen. Natalie Gruniger, she admires

26:49

her, perhaps she even loved her. There's all

26:51

these years that we kind of just skip

26:53

over and we go to the juicy bits

26:55

later but Anne's a court from probably end

26:57

of 1521, start of 1522. We know that she

27:00

was in service to Catherine. Perhaps it was on

27:02

and off but she was definitely in service to Catherine

27:05

at some point. They would have spent

27:07

time together. They would have eaten together. They would

27:09

have worshipped together. They would have played games together.

27:11

There was obviously a relationship there. We

27:13

hear nothing until Henry's interest in

27:16

Anne which means that things are probably

27:18

going really well. Anne was doing everything

27:20

she was supposed to be doing and

27:22

this goes on for let's say four

27:24

to five years. Do

27:35

you remember what it's like being in your 20s?

27:38

I sometimes look back at that period of my

27:40

life and laugh just as much as I cringe.

27:42

If you do the same then you've got to

27:44

watch Queenie, the new original series on Hulu. Who

27:47

is Queenie? Queenie is a 20-something

27:49

year old living in London. She's facing

27:51

all the first. First major

27:53

heartbreak, first shitty apartment and soul sucking

27:55

job, first therapy session to work through

27:57

those mommy issues. Can she turn her

28:00

quarter-life crisis into a revolution? Maybe.

28:02

Will she make some questionable decisions

28:04

along the way? Definitely. All episodes

28:06

of Cleanie premiere June 7th, streaming

28:09

on Hulu. If

28:30

people send you the same generic conversation

28:32

starters, they message everyone else. Conversations

28:34

that actually help you get to know

28:36

each other. Imagine that. Get who

28:39

gets you on eHarmony. Sign up today. Welcome

28:44

to Sincerely Sloan, presented by Uninterrupted.

28:47

I'm your host, professional tennis

28:49

player, wife, parent, and entrepreneur,

28:51

Sloan Seedons. As

28:53

an athlete and as a person, my journey

28:55

has had a lot of twists and turns.

28:57

For moments of adversity and doubt to unimaginable

29:00

triumph and satisfaction. Throughout

29:02

the season, I'm joined by some of the biggest names

29:04

in sports, entertainment, culture, and a few members

29:06

of my tribe. Our

29:09

conversations keep it real and push it

29:11

past Cindy. We

29:13

reveal the perspectives, routines, and products that allow

29:15

each of us to show up at our bets. Join

29:18

me on my journey of self-discovery and many,

29:21

many lasts along the way. Sincerely,

29:23

Sloan. So

29:38

I think when Henry does declare his

29:40

intentions, a difficult

29:42

decision for Anne, I think it must of

29:44

course, her a great deal of distress. She's

29:47

a pious woman. She spent time serving the

29:49

Queen. I don't think it's

29:51

something that she just overnight decided, I'm going to

29:53

go off with Henry. I'm going to steal him.

29:55

That I think is ridiculous. I don't think it's

29:57

true. And I think we can see there are. 17

30:01

love letters that Henry wrote and some

30:03

in English, some in French, they're in the Vatican. And

30:06

one of them that's thought to be one of

30:08

the sort of first letters, Henry

30:10

says that he's basically wanting an answer from

30:13

her, he's wanting to clarify what their

30:15

relationship is, what it's about and

30:17

he says having been for more than a year

30:19

now struck by the dart of

30:21

love. To me it sounds

30:23

like he has been pursuing her for

30:26

at least a year and perhaps

30:28

Anne hasn't known how to react. Perhaps

30:31

she felt guilty, she was serving

30:33

Catherine, Catherine was a beloved queen. At

30:36

some point there's a shift I think and she felt

30:38

like this is her past but I

30:40

don't for a second think that she was the aggressor, that

30:42

she was the one chasing him, that she was trying

30:44

to steal him, that it was a sort of plan

30:46

of her family or a plot to

30:48

rise him further in status, I don't think so. Although

30:53

Anne is first recorded at the English

30:55

court in March 1522, Henry's interest in

30:57

her does not

30:59

seem to have been kindled until 1526. At some point

31:01

during the years 1527 and 1528, Henry

31:07

wrote Anne a series of love letters.

31:10

His first letters were written in

31:12

French, a language that Henry and

31:14

Anne shared, a language that was

31:16

deliberately courtly, formal and elevated. As

31:19

we've heard in one he declares that he

31:21

has loved her for more than a year and

31:24

he asks her to be his sole

31:26

mistress. He promises that he will be

31:28

loyal only and to her. I'm

31:34

turning over in my mind the contents

31:37

of your last letter. I've put myself

31:39

into great agony, not knowing how to

31:41

interpret them, whether to my disadvantage

31:43

as you show in some places or

31:46

to my advantage as I understand them in some

31:48

others, beseeching you earnestly to

31:50

let me know expressly your whole

31:52

mind as to the love between

31:54

us two. It is

31:56

absolutely necessary for me to obtain this

31:59

answer having been for above a whole

32:01

year stricken with the dart of love, and

32:04

not yet sure whether I shall fail

32:06

of finding a place in your heart

32:08

and affection which last point has prevented

32:10

me for some time past from calling

32:12

you my mistress, because if

32:14

you only love me with an ordinary

32:17

love, that name is not

32:19

suitable for you, because it denotes

32:21

a singular love which is far

32:23

from common. But if you please to do

32:25

the office of a true loyal mistress and friend,

32:28

and to give up yourself body and

32:30

heart to me who will be and

32:32

have been your most loyal servant, if

32:35

your rigour does not forbid me, I promise

32:38

you that not only the name shall be

32:40

given you, but also that I will take

32:42

you for my only mistress, casting

32:44

off all others besides you out of

32:46

my thoughts and affections, and serve

32:48

you only. At

32:54

some point Anne consented to accept the

32:56

title. Henry wrote to tell

32:58

her of how he suffered in her absence.

33:01

He begins, My

33:04

mistress and friend, my heart and

33:07

I surrender ourselves into your hands, beseeching

33:09

you to hold us commended of your

33:11

favour, and that by absence your

33:13

affection to us may not be lessened, for

33:16

it were a great pity to increase our pain,

33:19

of which absence produces enough and more than

33:21

I could ever have thought could be felt,

33:24

reminding us of a point in astronomy which is

33:26

this, the longer the days

33:28

are, the more distant is the sun, and

33:31

nevertheless the hotter. So it

33:33

is with our love, for by absence

33:35

we are kept a distance from one another,

33:37

and yet it retains its fervour, at least

33:39

on my side. Seeing

33:43

as they cannot be together he sends her the

33:46

nearest thing to that possible, a

33:48

miniature painting of himself, probably

33:50

one of those that had been painted by the horror-boots

33:52

in around 1525-26. can

34:00

to that, namely my picture

34:02

set in a bracelet, with the

34:04

whole of the device which you already know, wishing

34:07

myself in their place if it should please

34:09

you. This is from the

34:11

hand of your loyal servant and friend, H.R.

34:15

If it should please you, Henry says,

34:18

and letters to Henry, which we

34:20

know once existed, no longer

34:23

do. His survive through time by

34:25

sheer accident, or perhaps by

34:27

sheer design, they were almost certainly seized

34:29

and taken back to Rome, where they

34:31

remain in the Vatican Library. But

34:35

Anne's letters to him were not. We

34:37

should not imagine that she was silent. The

34:39

words she was writing to him evidently

34:42

moved and convinced him. The

34:45

demonstrations of your affection are such

34:47

the beautiful mottos of the letter

34:50

so cordially expressed that they oblige

34:52

me forever to honour, love and

34:54

serve you sincerely, beseeching you to

34:57

continue in the same firm and

34:59

constant purpose, assuring you

35:01

that on my part I will surpass

35:03

it rather than make it reciprocal, if

35:06

loyalty of heart and a desire to

35:08

please you can accomplish this, assuring

35:11

you that henceforward my heart

35:13

shall be dedicated to you

35:15

alone. I wish

35:17

my person was so too. God can

35:19

do it if he pleases, to

35:22

whom I pray every day for that end, hoping

35:24

that at length my prayers will be heard.

35:28

Henry was praying that God would endorse adultery,

35:30

but he didn't see it like that. In

35:34

September 1527, Henry's

35:37

agents had been sent to Rome to ask

35:39

for an annulment of his marriage to

35:41

Catherine. The business of getting that annulment,

35:43

what became known as the King's Great

35:45

Matter, would take another six years, and

35:48

could only be accomplished by the casting

35:50

aside of Queen Catherine, the

35:52

destruction of Cardinal Thomas Warsie and

35:54

the severing of England from the

35:56

Roman Catholic Church. Eventually

35:58

in 1535, Henry's

36:01

new Archbishop of Canterbury, Thomas Crammer,

36:03

proclaimed the marriage to Catherine, Knoll

36:05

and Void. He had already married

36:08

Henry to Anne, and

36:10

big with child, Anne was crowned

36:12

Queen of England on the 1st

36:14

of June 1533. The child

36:17

she was carrying was born on the

36:19

7th of September. It

36:22

was a girl. They named her after both

36:24

their mothers, Elizabeth. It

36:27

was a disappointment, and it

36:29

was a setback, and it was a bit embarrassing,

36:31

particularly for Henry, after everything he'd done

36:34

to marry Anne. Dr. Tracey

36:36

Borman. But she had proved

36:38

that she could come through a

36:40

birth, she could survive unscathed, and so could

36:42

her child, who was thriving.

36:44

So it wasn't a

36:46

disaster at all. And what I

36:48

really love, actually, is

36:50

that Anne herself showed

36:53

no regret, no disappointment. That

36:55

was all Henry. Anne doted

36:57

on her child from the very beginning,

36:59

asking this Elizabeth to be placed next

37:01

to her on velvet cushions so she

37:03

didn't have to be parted from her,

37:06

and even causing a bit of

37:08

a scandal by expressing her intention

37:10

to breastfeed her daughter, which definitely

37:12

wasn't done in a royal wife, and she

37:14

had to step down from that

37:16

intention. But she was

37:19

proud of Elizabeth, and made sure

37:21

that everybody honored her as the

37:23

heir to the throne

37:25

that she was. Anne

37:27

used her position as queen to advance the

37:30

causes that were dear to her heart, chief

37:33

among them, reform. Tracey

37:35

Borman again. Henry might have gone

37:37

through the break with Rome really sparked by

37:40

the desire for an annulment, but for

37:42

Anne, it was genuine. She wanted to

37:44

reform the Catholic Church, and she certainly

37:47

instilled her daughter Elizabeth with the same

37:49

kind of reforming zeal that would

37:52

ultimately become known as Protestantism. She

37:55

was enormously influential. She

37:57

took risks for her faith importing banned

38:00

heretical texts and actually showing

38:02

some of them to Henry.

38:05

So she was always a great

38:07

advocate for religious reform and she

38:10

was listed by one member of Henry's

38:12

court at the head of a group

38:14

of four or five really influential religious

38:17

reformers including Thomas Cromwell, her erstwhile ally.

38:19

Of course they would clash over religion

38:21

and the dissolution in particular with fatal

38:24

results for Anne but we

38:26

should I think focus more and celebrate

38:28

more the influence that Anne was able

38:30

to have during her brief tenure

38:33

as Queen. Her

38:41

tenure was brief because only

38:43

three years into her reign Anne

38:45

was accused of adultery, incest

38:47

and conspiring the King's death.

38:50

The last of those charges was

38:53

treason. Within three

38:55

short weeks in May 1536 she

38:58

and the men charged

39:00

with her had been

39:02

tried and executed. The

39:04

reason for these charges has long been a

39:06

mystery. Did Henry want to

39:09

get rid of Anne so suddenly? Was

39:11

it a conspiracy against her? Was

39:14

she guilty? Professor

39:16

Joanne Deleneva has studied a poem from

39:18

June 1536 which

39:20

was sent as a dispatch

39:22

from the French embassy in

39:25

London to Paris within two

39:27

weeks of this unprecedented and

39:29

unsathomable execution of an anointed

39:31

Queen. The dispatch was

39:33

written by Lance Rotte-Cull, secretary

39:36

to the French ambassador to England and

39:38

it shed some light on how these

39:41

accusations arose. Well

39:45

I think if you talk about it

39:47

in journalistic terms he delivers the speech

39:50

which is how exactly

39:52

did the story of Anne

39:54

Boleyn's adultery break and

39:56

that's his main claim to

39:58

hang here because he He frames

40:00

this as a conversation or

40:03

an argument that takes place

40:05

between a close counselor as a king

40:07

and that counselor's sister,

40:09

who he would

40:11

like to admonish for her bad behavior. And

40:14

so the sister responds with, well,

40:17

if you think I'm behaving badly, basically you

40:19

should see what's going on with the queen.

40:22

And she makes the accusation that

40:25

Anne has been sleeping with her

40:27

brother, George, and that Mark

40:29

Sneeden would know all about it. So go talk

40:31

to Mark and he'll tell you even more than

40:33

I can claim. Now of course there are other

40:35

sources that talk about the

40:37

fact that these accusations may

40:40

have arisen from her inner

40:42

circle, but the thing

40:44

that's distinctive about Carl is that he

40:46

dramatizes this moment. He gives

40:48

a dialogue of this conversation

40:50

between the brother and sister,

40:53

which has fatal consequences, of course.

41:00

So was Anne incestuous with

41:02

her brother? Anne and

41:04

George had a very special relationship.

41:06

Natalie Gruniga. They

41:11

were incredibly close. I think they

41:13

loved each other dearly. They were two peas

41:15

in a pod. I think having the two

41:17

of them in the same room must have

41:19

been overwhelming. You know, they

41:21

were just incredibly intelligent, captivating, witty.

41:24

And I think in the end, this really

41:26

graded on Henry. I think he felt somehow

41:28

diminished in their presence, to be honest with

41:31

you. It's pretty ludicrous,

41:33

but the only evidence that is

41:35

given at court, and this is

41:37

Shpui, used to Shpui the imperial ambassador

41:39

that's commenting on this. So this is a

41:41

man that of course is devoted to Catherine

41:43

and to the Lady Mary, every second he's

41:45

trying to improve their situation. That's what he's

41:48

there for. He's just totally devoted to that.

41:51

He says that the only evidence of

41:54

this incestuous relationship was that

41:56

George had spent a long time with his

41:58

Sister. This is one occasion that I've never seen. He had

42:00

a long time. I see if no

42:03

witnesses, there's no other testimony that we

42:05

know Wallace. That's the only. Thing it

42:07

is just farcical. really? That's all

42:09

they could get. Whoever it was

42:11

crumbling. Who have thinking would weaken it

42:13

is he? Oh yes. George spent a long

42:16

time with and that day because he did,

42:18

he would come back from diplomatic missions and

42:20

rather than going to the King he would

42:22

go to. And that's how close they were.

42:25

That's how much he valued his sister and

42:27

how much he believed in. Her right to

42:29

rule by Henry. It's really toxic and it's

42:31

really amazing that makes this whole story all

42:33

the more tragic to be honest, Another

42:40

enduring this is it. Ambulance

42:42

was accused of witchcraft. The

42:45

only contemporary reference that corresponds asshole

42:48

to this comes from a piece

42:50

of course third, third, or fourth

42:52

hand, suggesting that Henry's thought and

42:55

had attracted him by the use.

42:57

The city ledge. This.

43:00

Is picked up later in the sixteenth

43:02

century by a Catholic enemy of a

43:04

list of the first Nicholas under. Twenty.

43:06

Ninth of January. Fifteen. Thirty Six. Quite

43:09

a crucial that actually. Natalie grew

43:11

nigga is the cieply reports on

43:13

that very day that morning that

43:15

his heard Henry. Has confessed something

43:17

Henry stressed. something happens deplete, doesn't know

43:20

what it is at this point. But

43:23

apparently Henry and great secrecy has

43:25

confessed that he had been seduced

43:28

and forced. Into the second marriage

43:30

by means of sorts leads Psalms and

43:32

that owing to that he held it

43:34

is no said. this would still feel

43:36

it splits. There was confusion around exactly

43:38

what Henry was talking about. If Henry

43:40

ever said it, because let's remember,

43:42

this is translated swell and comes

43:44

from three different people to different

43:47

languages. So what's. The king implying that

43:49

is why for the which. Is.

43:51

He was. Then it would have

43:53

to lend credence to another myth. Which

43:55

is that. and as birth to

43:57

a baby that had malformations, Conversely,

44:01

Effects were associated with witchcraft and

44:04

sorcery, as well as moral and

44:06

theological and maybe sexual sins as

44:08

well. But. Let's go back to

44:10

the which think so. And. Was not

44:12

accused of witchcraft, With any at

44:14

the trial this is not only indictment

44:16

and Eric I'm actually says in his.

44:19

Biography that the prime me english meaning

44:21

the would at the time so to

44:23

lead with divination so he suggests that

44:25

is Henry did in fact he's this

44:28

term remembering all the people. It's concerts.

44:30

Cities? perhaps? Referring to those

44:32

promises that and fade into promises that

44:34

she would give him some is that

44:36

there's a union would solidify the cheater

44:38

main and fifteen employees have something like

44:40

that. It's possible that's what he was

44:42

referring to and that he still had.

44:44

Can't say I'm burning himself to one

44:46

of his court. He is. And when

44:48

said the concept that simply. Nicholas

44:51

Sanders Low that picks up on this is

44:53

painting the picture the which because people are

44:56

using and memories. For their own political

44:58

agenda So people that want to

45:00

curry favor with Elizabeth articles honoring

45:02

and memory and see becomes the

45:04

Sodas Protestant March. Three

45:08

Elizabeth and bring her down, His and.

45:10

His memory in order to do that

45:12

says a black and Elizabeth reputation by

45:14

saying what these three things about her

45:16

mother. So they will that going on

45:18

as well that I think if she'd

45:20

been accused of witchcraft we would have

45:22

had abandoned in the trial People like

45:24

simply he's talking about which is accused

45:27

of but if an incentive. It.

45:29

Was also Sundance who perpetuated

45:31

the idea that and gave

45:33

birth. To. A deformed fetus,

45:36

Berries. Absolutely no contemporary evidenced.

45:39

Eerie, Natalie grew together again. And

45:42

let's just remind everyone that Sanders at

45:44

the time is around six years old.

45:46

Just think space you will embrace. So

45:49

you know this is not something he's

45:51

an eyewitness to or anything like that.

45:53

He's obviously relying on things that he

45:55

third, but at no point during an

45:57

slice or Henry's lifetime. Or during and

45:59

with. for that matter where there

46:01

probably was reason to bring these

46:03

stories out. Did anyone comment or

46:05

remark on the appearance of that

46:07

baby and claim that it was

46:09

in any way unusual? Mr Sheppui

46:12

comments on the fact that Anne herself thought she

46:14

was about 15 weeks gone at the time. There

46:17

is no comment that there's anything wrong with

46:19

this baby apart from obviously the reason why

46:21

she's miscarried. In one copy

46:23

of Lancelot de Karl's poem at

46:26

the Bibliothèque Nationale de France, there

46:28

are some additional verses that carry

46:31

an important message about Anne's

46:33

guilt or innocence. I

46:37

think that some of the verses are comparable

46:40

to other verses that are found in different

46:42

manuscripts and why they're there and not

46:44

in others I'm not quite sure.

46:47

Joanne de la Niva. But

46:49

there are four verses

46:51

in particular that read in the

46:53

English translation. He's describing a moment

46:56

of Anne's execution and how

46:59

the witnesses to her execution are reacting

47:01

to that and he says that everyone

47:03

on the basis of her mightily

47:05

steady end judges her life to have

47:08

been prudent and believes that

47:10

they have committed a great offense in having thought

47:12

so ill of her. And

47:14

those lines are quite distinctive from anything

47:16

else that he's written because they are

47:19

the most explicit with regard

47:21

to Karl's depiction

47:23

of her guilt or innocence. And

47:25

clearly by saying that she has

47:28

been prudent, which he had said

47:30

specifically earlier on that he doubted that

47:32

she was prudent because she wasn't following

47:35

the path of the prudent mistress Claude

47:37

de France. Here he's saying her life

47:39

had been prudent. And prudence

47:41

is an important virtue, according to

47:43

Thomas Aquinas, it's the virtue that

47:45

you need for holding the passions

47:48

and the appetites in check. So

47:51

if you know that, if you know your Aquinas

47:53

and clearly he as a clerk would have and

47:55

many people at the time would have, that's

47:58

a freely loaded expression. right there

48:00

and it would mean that

48:03

he is suggesting that not

48:06

only had she repented of anything but

48:08

it's more than that she probably was

48:10

not guilty and no one should ever

48:12

have sought her to be guilty that's

48:15

pretty astounding. It's

48:17

so exciting because it means that DeKalb is

48:19

tying his colors to the mast we can

48:21

see what he thinks and it's

48:23

crucial that we can understand the meaning of

48:25

the language that he's using in order to

48:27

do that and also because

48:29

actually DeKalb as you well know

48:32

has often been used or particularly

48:34

been used recently by my dear

48:36

friend George Bernard to suggest that

48:38

actually this is an indication of

48:40

Anne's guilt and that the DeKalb

48:42

poem really testifies to that but

48:45

actually what you're saying is something quite different.

48:47

Right and it's understandable that other people might

48:49

not have come to that conclusion so usually

48:52

if they don't have access to these

48:54

extra verses so I do

48:56

think that these verses are important for

48:58

historians to consider in the overall picture.

49:01

Certainly early in the poem Carl

49:04

is not depicting Anne

49:06

in a favorable light. He says all

49:08

kinds of nasty things about her. He

49:11

says that she was full of malice

49:13

and evil and that's pretty damning but

49:15

then at a certain point it shifts

49:18

and he becomes much more sympathetic and generally

49:20

people have thought well this is the moment

49:23

towards the middle of the poem where

49:25

she's already in prison and she turns

49:28

her thoughts to God. That's what he

49:30

says and so it's because she

49:33

realizes that her past has been

49:35

bad, that she has not been

49:37

living up to a good Christian

49:39

standard, and she's repenting. That's

49:41

why Carl is now sympathetic to her

49:43

because she's repentant and worthy of our

49:45

mercy as well but

49:48

I think this changes that because

49:50

it's more than she's simply saying

49:53

she has repented. It's saying

49:55

she was never guilty. Her life

49:57

has been prudent And we

49:59

have thought it was her in we have

50:01

don't her a great since. And.

50:04

The nineteenth of May. Fifteen Thirty

50:06

Six. And Berlin. That.

50:08

intelligent, learned, reforming woman.

50:11

From. A family in the ascendant

50:13

shaped by training on the Continent

50:15

who had become like her erstwhile

50:17

Mr. Claude, a false and anointed

50:19

queen. Was. Beheaded. At

50:22

the Tower of London. Henry

50:25

had destroyed her body. But.

50:27

He could not quench her memory. In

50:30

her printed book of ours now kept it

50:32

he the causal an had written. Remember.

50:35

Me When you do pray that hope

50:37

this lead from day to day. Case.

50:42

Mccaffrey discovered some other arrays inscriptions

50:44

in the same book to the

50:47

homeless. Sir.

50:53

John Gauge previously seems to see who

50:55

sits inside this Birch Bayh prominent political

50:58

unrest, court and play citrus. The course

51:00

made fast and it's him and his

51:02

wife his base. recent side it's Mary

51:04

West was part of the West family

51:06

with a barn still a war and

51:08

Elizabeth shadow and epic age for base

51:10

tortoises. Sir Richard Gale said head with

51:13

a close friend of had a seventh

51:15

said is a kind of people who

51:17

unlike well at Harrys Court but there

51:19

since has been mainly in the province's

51:21

intense especially the women he wrestles. But

51:23

since have been mainly from this area

51:26

of a phenomenal piece of historical detective

51:28

work is done. What do you think

51:30

it tells us about the memory of

51:33

on his It's that it's something provincial

51:35

that it becomes just a memory you

51:37

keep in the county from which she

51:40

came or do you think it has

51:42

something more to tell us about her

51:44

status in people's minds it will tell

51:47

us a loss in terms of how

51:49

spite these widespread. Attempt to discredit on

51:51

in the his or her downfall. She

51:53

was. Still terrorist and held close

51:56

by. Keep pushing you have had

51:58

a close to her. And I

52:00

was able to discover a connection

52:02

between these other owners and Anne,

52:04

which comes to another woman, Elizabeth

52:06

Hill, who was the wife of

52:08

the sergeant of the King's cellar, Richard Hill. And

52:11

we have some anecdotal evidence to suggest that

52:13

they were close to Anne. And

52:15

I suppose we could imagine that this is

52:17

a Protestant story in some ways. If

52:20

they're very willing to cross out the

52:22

Pope's name, and if they're cherishing Anne's

52:25

memory, those two things might be connected

52:27

by their faith at the time. Do

52:30

you think that's part of it? I think certainly that is

52:32

part of it, because I think that we see

52:34

in the completion of the time that the

52:36

Pope said this, that at least the Confirm

52:38

was here a compliance to the kind of

52:40

evangelism at the time. But

52:42

whether that's purely religion, also I think

52:44

definitely is a personal connection to Anne.

52:47

But with this personal connection comes a

52:49

suggestion that maybe they were connected also

52:51

in that religious way as well, and

52:53

in these kind of Kent networks that

52:55

were close to the Berlin family. And

52:57

it feels like perhaps that remained in

52:59

similar religious circles as well. Anne

53:02

was remembered. And

53:05

she still is. Thanks

53:26

to you for listening to Not Just the

53:28

Tudors from History Hit. And

53:30

also to my researcher Alice Smith, my

53:33

producer Rob Weinberg and Ella

53:35

Baxorn who edited this episode.

53:38

We're always eager to hear from

53:40

you, so do drop us a

53:43

line at notjustthetudors at historyhit.com or

53:46

on X, formerly known as

53:49

Twitter, at notjusttudors. And

53:51

do remember to follow Not Just the Tudors

53:53

wherever you get your podcasts, so you get

53:56

each new episode as soon as it's released.

54:05

At the Goddard School, we turn your

54:07

child's curiosity into everyday moments of wonder

54:10

that inspire their lifelong love of learning.

54:12

With small class sizes and lessons tailored

54:14

to your child's unique interests, the Goddard

54:16

School is where extraordinary awaits. Visit

54:19

gotterdschool.com to enroll today. Whether

54:22

you're a morning person or a bedtime

54:24

procrastinator, everyone deserves a mattress that works

54:26

for their style, and you'll find the

54:28

best mattress for you at Ashley. The

54:30

new Tempr Adapt Collection at Ashley brings

54:32

you one-of-a-kind body-conforming technology,

54:35

making every sleep tailored to be your

54:37

best. The collection also features cool-to-the-touch covers

54:39

and motion absorption to help minimize

54:42

sleep disruptions from partners, pets, or

54:44

kids. Shop the all-new Tempr Adapt

54:46

Collection at Ashley in-store or online

54:48

at ashley.com. Ashley, for the love

54:50

of home. History

54:55

is full of extraordinary people, the

54:57

Tudors being just a handful. In

55:00

my latest film on History Hit, we

55:02

meet Bess of Hardwick and go inside

55:04

the incredible house that she built, a

55:07

house that defines the elegance and grandeur

55:09

of the Elizabethan age, a house fit

55:11

for a woman who climbed to the

55:13

top of the Tudor social ladder. To

55:16

find out more about the life of Bess,

55:18

and many more fascinating figures from the past,

55:21

sign up via the link in the description with

55:23

the code TUDORS for an

55:25

exclusive discount.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features