Podchaser Logo
Home
S8: Best of Once Upon a Crime: Betty Broderick

S8: Best of Once Upon a Crime: Betty Broderick

Released Friday, 10th May 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
S8: Best of Once Upon a Crime: Betty Broderick

S8: Best of Once Upon a Crime: Betty Broderick

S8: Best of Once Upon a Crime: Betty Broderick

S8: Best of Once Upon a Crime: Betty Broderick

Friday, 10th May 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

This. Podcast details true crime cases.

0:02

It contains adult themes and may

0:04

contain descriptions of violence. This episode

0:06

contains explicit language it is not

0:09

intended for children. Listener. Discretion

0:11

is advised. Thinking

0:21

of again even today's episode and with

0:23

the money crime wrapping up theme and

0:25

eight with a. Retrospective. Up

0:27

The Mess Dead owe you a the

0:30

episode I'm sharing from like Stories from

0:32

our Our Caleb Woman. Three hundred episodes

0:34

which you may have missed a few

0:36

began this season Five, three or even

0:39

season one. I'll share to best of

0:41

episodes weekly one on Monday and one

0:43

on Friday. I'll briefly introduce why we've

0:45

chosen each episode as one of our

0:48

best and then share a preview clip

0:50

of what you'll hear links to the

0:52

full episodes will be in the show

0:55

knows. I released a series. Called a

0:57

Woman Scorned in season One, it

0:59

detailed the crimes of women who

1:01

felt wronged by the romantic partners

1:03

and took matters into their own

1:05

hands with deadly results. In this

1:08

best of episode, I'll tell you

1:10

the story of Betty Broderick. Betty

1:12

was married to a handsome and

1:14

successful attorney and lived a life

1:16

she'd always dreamed of, but she

1:18

never felt secure in the love

1:20

of her husband, Dan Broderick. Arguments

1:23

and bickering escalating to accusations of

1:25

infidelity, threats of divorce, And

1:27

even physical fights. Betty's behavior became

1:29

more erratic when she learned her

1:31

husband was in a relationship with

1:33

his much younger secretary. As their

1:36

divorce preceded, Betty spun out of

1:38

control and her rage towards Dan

1:40

Broderick finally came to a tragic

1:42

end in Nineteen Eighty Nine. This

1:46

clip is from Season One

1:48

episode Forty two: A woman

1:50

scorned Betty Broderick. Are.

2:02

You a superfan of once upon a crime.

2:05

Show your love, support the show and get

2:07

tons of perks by joining our patriotic. Hatred.

2:10

Members get ad free episodes and can

2:12

hear them before anyone else. You.

2:14

Also get bonus episodes and a special gifts

2:16

sense in the mail when you become a

2:18

member. Membership. Start I just two

2:20

dollars per month. You. Can save you

2:22

the more when you choose the option to pay annually.

2:25

Go. To patriotic.com/once upon a crime

2:27

to get more info and become

2:29

a member. You. Can also find

2:32

the link on her website true and podcast.

2:34

Dot Com. Thanks. So much for

2:36

listening and supporting the show. His

2:39

eyes. This is esther host of once upon

2:41

a crime. I got an exciting

2:43

opportunity time. so psyched to share with

2:45

you. How would you like to

2:47

travel the world with me? My

2:50

second love after True Crime is seeing the

2:52

world. Now. I've been given

2:54

the opportunity to host trip to destinations

2:56

around the world and bring you my

2:59

listeners and sense of the show along

3:01

with me. But I need your help.

3:04

I need your input to plan these threads. Where

3:06

would you like to go? What? Kind of

3:08

activities would you like to enjoy? Would.

3:11

You like to visit a city like New

3:13

York, London, or Mexico City? And

3:15

set out the local entertainment, culture and

3:17

nightlife. Or. Would you prefer

3:19

a type of get away like Bali

3:21

or the Caribbean for laid back, sightseeing

3:23

and beat stays. Or. Anything in

3:26

between. How. About crossing Us

3:28

accepted Turkey or Indonesia or Italy.

3:30

Off your bucket list. Put.

3:33

On the link in the show notes to complete a. Short

3:35

to minute survey and tell. Me: what

3:37

kind of trouble you're most interested in. And

3:39

I'll keep you informed about upcoming trip as

3:41

soon as they're confirmed. Will.

3:43

Plan trips around your interest and budget and

3:46

will tell the together as a small group.

3:48

Their. Safety in numbers to so single

3:51

men and women are encouraged. Or

3:53

bring your significant other or best friends alone.

3:55

Either way, it will be a blessed. click

3:58

on the survey linked right away The

4:00

sooner we get your responses, the sooner we'll

4:02

be on the road together to new adventures.

4:05

Thank you so much and I can't wait to travel

4:07

with you. Betty

4:13

was raised to be a wife and mother, and she

4:15

had a specific man in mind for a mate. He

4:18

should be handsome, of course. He

4:20

should also be a college man who aspired

4:22

to become a professional, like a doctor, lawyer,

4:24

or businessman. Someone like

4:26

Betty was raised to value home and family above

4:29

all, but he also aspired towards

4:31

the finer things in life, and was

4:33

willing to work hard to have a successful career

4:35

to provide his family with all the things money

4:37

could buy. Now having

4:39

met Betty, he could see the future in front of

4:41

him, to be a successful doctor,

4:44

to be married to a beautiful wife, and

4:46

eventually have children and a beautiful home as well.

4:50

She could envision their life as well, living

4:52

in a beautiful home, being a doctor's wife,

4:55

and hobnobbing in upper-class society circles.

4:58

These were all the things her parents had dreamed of for her.

5:01

She had charm and grace and a sense of style.

5:05

Dan was smart, funny, and charismatic.

5:08

Everyone saw them as a golden couple, perfectly

5:10

matched. Their first child,

5:12

Kimberly, was born in 1970. One

5:15

year later, their second daughter, Lee, was born. When

5:19

Dan decided after he'd finished his medical degree

5:21

that he wanted to attend law school instead of

5:23

becoming a doctor, Betty agreed. While

5:26

she knew it would take more sacrifice and they would

5:29

continue to live on a tight budget, she

5:31

believed Dan when he said, with both a medical

5:33

and a law degree, he could

5:35

specialize in medical malpractice law and be

5:37

in high demand at top law firms.

5:40

Dan entered Harvard Law School while Betty continued

5:42

to work to support the family, sometimes

5:45

even selling Tupperware door to door. Dan

5:48

finally graduated with his law degree in 1974. Dan

5:52

took a job at the prestigious law firm

5:54

Gray, Carey, Ames & Fry. While

5:57

Dan worked on building a successful legal career, he

5:59

would offer a often put in 15-hour days.

6:02

There was a definite strain in the marriage with

6:04

Betty left alone long hours with the children while

6:07

Dan worked at the office. Even

6:09

when he was home, he was preoccupied with

6:11

work that needed to be completed before court.

6:14

She was lonely in the marriage and wanted more of

6:16

his time. She missed the way

6:18

he used to dote on her when they were dating and

6:21

engaged. Dan was becoming

6:23

more successful and popular in his field and

6:25

was away from the home more and more. Only

6:29

she felt her husband was leaving her behind and

6:32

didn't view her as important or special anymore.

6:35

Betty was once again and for the last

6:37

time pregnant. She gave birth

6:39

to their fourth child and second son, Rhett, in

6:41

1979. By

6:44

now, Betty had been complaining and nagging her husband

6:46

about his lack of time spent with her and

6:48

the family for years. Their

6:50

fights began to escalate and the children

6:52

would later vividly recall these tense times.

6:55

By the time he would arrive, she would be

6:57

furious. Dan remembers many, many instances

7:00

of her mother and father screaming at each

7:02

other and that her mother would often throw

7:04

things at him. She would

7:06

pick up and hurl whatever was in reach,

7:08

including plates, cups, and once an almost full

7:10

bottle of ketchup that shattered just

7:12

over Dan's head. Betty's

7:15

behavior became increasingly immature as her

7:17

frustration grew. The children were

7:19

subjected to her angry tirades. She

7:22

was increasingly insecure about her looks and her

7:24

weight and worried that Dan would no longer

7:26

find her attractive. Betty

7:29

began criticizing and taunting Dan at every

7:31

opportunity that he was going through a

7:33

midlife crisis. Betty continued to

7:36

yell, complain, and berate her husband. She

7:38

often threatened divorce, sometimes putting Dan's clothes in

7:40

a suitcase and dropping it on the porch

7:42

for him to find. Dan's

7:45

response became to ignore his wife's histrionics.

7:48

After years of constant criticism and nagging by

7:50

Betty, he just stopped fighting with her. He

7:53

would ignore her, stay silent, and pretend

7:55

like nothing had happened. That

7:57

she was now getting no response from her husband. made

8:00

many even more angry. Have

8:11

you noticed that your grocery prices have

8:13

increased significantly lately? If you're

8:15

shopping for your family and want quality products,

8:17

it can really make a dent in your

8:19

food budget. That's why I

8:21

shop Thrive Market. Thrive Market

8:23

is an online destination that makes healthy

8:26

living easy and affordable for everyone. You

8:28

can shop for thousands of best-selling organic

8:30

foods and natural products at

8:32

number-only pulses. And believe

8:34

me, as a long-time member of Thrive Market,

8:37

I can vouch for the quality and their

8:39

prices just can't be beat. Shopping

8:41

online with Thrive Market is a breeze.

8:43

You can filter the products you're shopping

8:46

for by dietary or lifestyle preferences. For

8:49

my diet and lifestyle, I put in

8:51

search terms like keto, sugar-free, low-carb, and

8:53

organic. But there are

8:55

over 90 values to choose from,

8:57

including Fair Trade Certified, Gluten Free,

8:59

and Non-GMO. Thrive Market

9:02

isn't just for grocery items, although

9:04

they do have everything you need.

9:06

From healthy kid-friendly snacks, to cooking

9:08

and baking staples, pantry items, meats,

9:10

and seafood. But that's not all.

9:13

You can also find a wide

9:15

range of high-quality personal care items,

9:18

baby products, pet products, home cleaning

9:20

products, and cosmetics. It's like

9:22

a one-stop shop for all your healthy and organic

9:24

needs. I have found

9:26

the best prices on some of my

9:29

favorite quality food brands, such as Kind,

9:31

Simple Mills, Siete, Organe, and The Honest

9:33

Kitchen. And I have a

9:35

special offer for my listeners. New

9:37

members who join using

9:39

our affiliate link, thrivemarket.com-slash-once,

9:42

get 30% off their first order, plus

9:44

a free gift up to $60. As

9:47

a member, you get special promotions all

9:49

the time, including free gifts with orders.

9:52

From May 13-17, Thrive Market members

9:55

get 25% off bars and snacks

9:57

for all new and existing members.

10:00

At Thrive Market, you can get healthy snacks

10:03

your kids will actually love, at much lower

10:05

prices than other retailers. I'm sure

10:07

you've seen some of these products at your local Whole

10:09

Paycheck and then put them right back on the shelf

10:11

when you saw the sticker price. But

10:13

at Thrive Market, you can enjoy the

10:16

same quality at a fraction of the

10:18

cost, making healthy living more affordable and

10:20

accessible. Some of

10:22

my little favorites are Lesser Evil Little

10:24

Puffs, Scout Organic Kid Snack

10:26

Bars, Logo Squeeze Yogurt,

10:29

Annie's Organic Snack Bars, and Bobo's

10:31

Oat Bars. And you can

10:33

easily filter products to exclude food allergens

10:35

and taste preferences too. Go

10:38

to thrivemarket.com/once to get 30% off

10:40

your first order when you become

10:42

a member, plus a free

10:44

gift of up to $60 and start saving

10:47

on your food bill every month. That's

10:50

thrivemarket.com/once. And thanks

10:52

so much for supporting the show. In

10:58

1982, the family went on a week-long

11:00

vacation to a dude ranch in Montana.

11:03

Betty and the kids arrived first and had a

11:06

great time horseback riding and swimming. Dan

11:08

arrived a bit later, and at first, they

11:11

enjoyed their vacation as a family. Soon,

11:14

however, Dan and Betty had a big fight,

11:16

and Dan decided to go back to San Diego on

11:18

his own. Betty tried to

11:20

call him repeatedly, but he did not

11:22

answer her calls. Betty drove the

11:24

kids home alone soon after, and

11:26

she became angrier the closer they approached their

11:29

home. When they

11:31

arrived, she lit into Dan about being

11:33

an irresponsible parent, a terrible husband, and

11:35

a selfish human being, a

11:37

laundry list of his faults that he'd been hearing for

11:39

years. But this time, something

11:42

snapped. Without a word,

11:44

Dan packed a bag and left. Betty

11:46

was stunned, as were the children. Remembering

11:49

this time, Kim would write, from

11:51

my viewpoint, Dad Without Mom equaled

11:54

peace and normalcy, while

11:56

Mom Without Dad had disaster written all

11:58

over it. A

12:06

new stress came into play in the life of the Brodericks in

12:08

1983. After

12:10

all the years of Betty accusing Dan of going

12:12

through a midlife crisis, she was

12:14

now convinced he was also having an affair. Perhaps

12:17

because of what ultimately happened, for years,

12:19

no one would comment lunch on Dan's

12:22

behavior during this time. Later,

12:24

a few details would emerge. While

12:27

some at the time would say that Dan didn't

12:29

begin a relationship until after he and Betty separated

12:31

for good, others would admit

12:33

they knew an affair had begun sometime before.

12:37

Not much would be said about Linda's part in the

12:39

breakup of Dan Broderick's marriage. While

12:42

it's certainly true that the marriage had been

12:44

on the rocks long before Linda Colcana made

12:46

her appearance in Dan Broderick's life, she

12:48

would certainly turn out to be a factor in his exit

12:51

from the marriage. Betty

12:53

discussed Dan's infidelity with her children, filling them

12:55

in on all the gossip and calling

12:57

his assistant ever more colorful names. All

13:00

of this, of course, was inappropriate to share with

13:02

her children. Betty

13:04

never stopped her tirades against their father and

13:07

began to grow angrier at each passing day. Dan

13:11

filed for legal separation and then finally

13:13

admitted to having a relationship with Linda

13:15

Colcana. Betty's anger turned

13:17

to hate. Dan

13:19

finally filed for divorce on September 23, 1985. When

13:25

Betty found out that Dan had filed for divorce

13:27

and changed the locks after 16 years of marriage,

13:30

she lost all control. She

13:32

arrived at his house and threw a patio umbrella through

13:34

a glass in the back door, unlocking

13:36

it and letting herself in. She

13:38

went on a rampage and tore apart every room in

13:41

the house, throwing furniture, ripping

13:43

up pictures, shredding curtains, and even

13:45

spray painting the walls. She

13:48

tried to drag out the divorce proceedings in many ways.

13:51

The day of the final court hearing, Betty

13:53

had no lawyer representing her and

13:55

she decided if she didn't show up, they would

13:58

have to postpone the final divorce judgment. She

14:01

was wrong. The judge finalize

14:03

the Broderick's divorce on July sixteenth,

14:05

Nineteen Eighty Six. Without that, he

14:07

presents. Betty

14:10

even three years after the separation and

14:12

almost as long since there was. Still,

14:15

Held hatred for Dan and now Linda.

14:17

Suit. Off until the children that she was going

14:19

to kill him. They heard it

14:21

so often they didn't react to it anymore.

14:24

She. Sometimes with elaborate saying that she was

14:26

going to shoot him in the head.

14:29

In early Nineteen Eighty Nine, Betty bought

14:31

a gun. With

14:45

them and. Incidentally

14:48

to the entire episode, if you wanna hear

14:50

it, I cut or do other pieces in.

14:53

A woman scorned feel the areas and

14:55

Clara Harris Harris's cases also known as

14:57

Murder by Mercedes that included linked to

15:00

those episodes in the show Notes as

15:02

was also in the show Notes are

15:04

linked to become a thrive market member

15:06

and save money and healthier spots for

15:09

your family's groceries, home and pet care

15:11

products of here and there is also

15:13

linked to us as a tricycle survey

15:16

and of he to outpace. I appreciate

15:18

your support of the show whether you

15:20

visit are sponsored links showing our patriotic.

15:23

Or just listen think so much

15:25

as a part a crime is written

15:27

and produced. I mean as recent as

15:29

Ludlow By executive producer is Laura Mercier.

15:32

Until next time seated to one

15:34

another. Some

16:24

people just know there's a better way to do things.

16:26

Like bundling your home and auto insurance with

16:29

Allstate. Or going to the

16:31

grocery store for milk instead of buying your own cow.

16:35

You know there's an easier and better way.

16:38

Save up to 25% when you bundle

16:40

home and auto with Allstate. Bundled

16:43

savings vary by state and are not available in every state.

16:46

Saving up to 25% is the country-wide average of the maximum available

16:48

savings off the home policy. You can

16:50

also purchase your own property insurance company in affiliates Northbrook, Illinois.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features