Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:16
Welcome everyone to the Pff Fantasy Podcast!
0:19
I'm a House John Macri Fantasy analyst
0:21
year at Pff and Prospects Season rolls
0:23
on. Last week we covered the incoming
0:26
quarterback class and and and a lot
0:28
of fun discussion around those players. You
0:30
can check that out now if you
0:32
haven't already. and now today we get
0:35
to talk about a very fun, very
0:37
interesting wide receiver group with a bunch
0:39
of potential first rounders Were. Maybe.
0:42
Three of which go in the top ten.
0:44
Ah, it's going be a fine discussion here
0:46
to dive into, and naturally I couldn't do
0:48
this on my own. So who better to
0:50
break it all down with me? That. The.
0:53
Great keep my juke as usual I'm
0:55
looking forward caped it to your thoughts
0:57
on this this rookie wide receiver class.
0:59
So how you doing today? Ready to
1:01
talk some more prospects? Are ready to
1:03
attack them are prospects he teased at.
1:05
This is in excellent wide receiver class.
1:08
Were undoubtedly it like going to get
1:10
three wide receivers here in the top
1:12
ten packs and. For. Very good
1:14
reason this is going to be. A
1:17
very fine episode And I am!
1:19
I'm super excited because like. The.
1:22
Running backs it interesting class
1:24
but not a time of.
1:27
You. Know like top and prospects to like
1:30
They're all top and prospects when it
1:32
comes to the side receiver. So really
1:34
this is a in interesting group because
1:36
you really are kind of. Nit.
1:38
Picking a lot between some of
1:41
these, these, you know, tear too.
1:43
wide receivers that. Could. Have a
1:45
very big impact on our fantasy teams for
1:47
the years to come. Yeah.
1:49
No, I am with you
1:52
that second. Third, Fourth,
1:54
Tier like a tinker with a time
1:56
like I feel pretty good obviously of
1:58
about the top guys. But what will
2:00
get into a we'll talk our rankings and
2:02
everything like that? And yeah, it's always one.
2:04
I'm talking rookies, right? Like I have no
2:06
doubt that you know that I'll be the
2:08
case with this year's wide receiver class. We're
2:10
going to cover our eight wide receivers that
2:13
we picked out for for today. So obviously.
2:15
There are a ton more that we can probably
2:17
cover as well because the it is a pretty
2:20
be class but I will look at at another
2:22
way to potentially cover those guys on on a
2:24
later episode as while socks be on the lookout
2:26
for that if you are watching on the you
2:28
tubes I don't forget to like and subscribe. We'd
2:31
greatly appreciate that support if I if you're willing
2:33
and it just helps us the time If you're
2:35
i'm you know in audio only listener he could
2:37
come on stuff on by as well and and
2:39
feel free to hit like unsubscribe while you're here
2:42
at let us know the you're interested in in
2:44
this continent. Enjoy the rookie content. And we will
2:46
keep it rolling all draft season long. Ah,
2:48
speaking of which, before we get into the
2:50
players themselves, I also want to let you
2:52
all know to check out be Pff mock
2:54
drafts simulator at if you haven't already weakened,
2:56
take control and draft for your favorite team
2:59
or draft for the entire league. Whatever he
3:01
wants or know. I like to draw for
3:03
all teams make my own marks, try a
3:05
different strategies for each team along the way.
3:07
Ah, it's not only great way to get
3:09
ready for the actual Nfl draft which is
3:11
less than a month away, it's April officially
3:13
draft months so hop in there aren't make.
3:15
Some pics make some trades, maybe your Bills
3:17
fan and want to figure out some trade
3:20
up possibilities to get that stuff on digs
3:22
replacements. Either way, there's a ton of possibilities
3:24
and if a lot of fun, you can
3:26
also use the promo code thirty Mbs right
3:28
now on pff.com to get thirty percent off
3:30
annual subscriptions which includes all of Nfl draft
3:32
contents and of course, access to the best
3:35
mock draft simulator in the league you're at
3:37
Pff, so check it out now ago have
3:39
yourself some fun again. That is promo code:
3:41
Thirty M D S. Aren't.
3:44
Let's get into it here. Be
3:46
wide receiver position as we mentioned
3:48
is chock full of interesting prospects
3:50
and some very good ones to
3:52
boot. but we have to stop.
3:54
Starts at the top here with
3:56
Ohio State's Marvin Harrison Junior. Take
3:58
you thought that. everyone's top
4:01
ranked wide receiver, but he
4:03
is many people's wide receiver one. And, and
4:05
with that being said, maybe let's
4:07
start with a spoiler for our rankings coming
4:09
later. Um, like we did last episode with
4:11
Caleb Williams is Marvin Harrison Jr.
4:14
Your wide receiver one. Yes, he is. Next.
4:18
Like that, that, this wasn't
4:20
even a question for me. I mean,
4:22
21 years old, three years at Ohio
4:24
state, six, three and a quarter inch,
4:27
209 pounds, like back to
4:29
back seasons with 1200 receiving
4:32
yards, 14 touchdowns, the
4:35
2023 Fred, Belecganoff winner. Like
4:38
what can't Marvin Harrison Jr.
4:40
Do at his size? I
4:42
don't know that there's really
4:44
anything. Yeah,
4:47
no, it like it's everything that he does.
4:49
Right. Like you said, it just can't
4:52
get over just kind of how
4:55
much of a natural he is really in
4:57
like all aspects of his position. And yeah,
4:59
maybe, you know, that shouldn't come as a
5:01
surprise considering he's the son of a hall
5:03
of fame wide receiver in Marvin Harrison senior,
5:05
right? But it's still so
5:07
impressive to watch him, you know, break
5:09
his routes at the exact right moments,
5:11
send corners in the wrong direction, fight
5:13
through contact versus press and use his
5:15
weight and momentum to just make space
5:17
at the right time to come down
5:19
with the ball cleanly, like everything
5:21
that he does. It looks effortless. His adjustments
5:24
on the ball as well. And there's,
5:26
there are definitely times where he has
5:28
to adjust. A lot of times I
5:30
found actually at least relative
5:32
to the top two guys, he's not, or
5:34
the top, the other top two guys, he's
5:36
not getting, you know, kind of the same
5:38
level of quarterback play that a neighbors or,
5:40
or even Oduinze is getting, which,
5:43
you know, when watching him, I know one
5:45
of the knocks on him has been that
5:47
kind of yak ability and it's on the
5:49
lower end, sure. That 32nd percentile among prospects
5:51
since 2019. But I think
5:53
part of it is that he's not always getting
5:56
the ball in stride either or nearly as often
5:58
as some of these other wide. who
6:00
we'll talk about in a bit that
6:02
are getting much better quarterback play. So
6:05
that played into it with me and
6:07
I mean, we can get into some of
6:09
the production numbers from him as
6:12
well. But like just elite,
6:14
absolutely ridiculous production for
6:16
his position. 2.98
6:18
career yards per run, 93rd
6:20
percentile since 2019. 91.3
6:23
career receiving grade was 94th percentile. 2.87
6:27
yards per run lined up in the slot or
6:30
lined up wide, which was 86 percentile. 3.63
6:33
yards per run from the slot, which was 92nd percentile. 45.8%
6:37
explosive play rate, 94th percentile. 94.5 receiving grade versus
6:39
single coverage was 98th percentile. 4.63
6:47
yards per run versus single coverage, 89th percentile. And
6:49
a 17% first down and touchdown rate is
6:51
98th percentile. So every
6:54
ridiculous at an elite level,
6:56
right? Everything he
6:58
does is at an elite level. And
7:00
I really like what you mentioned about
7:02
just everything looking so
7:05
natural and so easy. And
7:07
I will say for a player of his
7:10
size, that's not always the case. Like what
7:13
you love about him, he's a threat at every level
7:15
level of the field. He's got quicker
7:17
feet than you would guess for a
7:19
guy with that long a frame. He's
7:21
a smooth route runner again for a
7:23
man of any size, but especially for
7:25
a guy of his frame, elite
7:28
body control. And really the
7:30
only knock I think you can come up
7:32
with is the yards after
7:34
the catchability. But like, for instance,
7:36
in the 2023 season ranked in
7:39
the 37th percentile and catchable target
7:41
rate, that does
7:44
have a sincere impact
7:47
on your ability to relaying
7:49
yards after the catch. Because that
7:52
elite ball placement can maximize so
7:54
much for what you're able to
7:57
do after the catch point. It's
8:00
something that Marvin Harrison Jr. in comparison
8:02
to a Malik neighbors didn't really have
8:04
the benefit of Yeah,
8:07
absolutely. It makes a huge difference Right
8:09
and like you consider that catchable pass
8:11
rate and he's still putting this level
8:13
of production up like it's just unbelievable
8:16
Yeah, so I mean the
8:18
guy is he's a true like alpha wide
8:20
receiver, right in every sense of the word
8:23
I think he's landing spot proof He's gonna
8:25
step into an offensive and be the clear
8:27
wide receiver one that there's not many that
8:29
are gonna steal targets from him Yeah, I
8:31
think he's gonna elevate whoever his NFL quarterback
8:33
ends up being as well Like
8:36
let's just say Marvin Harrison jr. Is
8:38
him right like he's so
8:41
him He could probably change his
8:43
name to Mar him Harris him
8:45
Wow And
8:48
that's it for today's PFF We Gotta
8:53
end there we gotta end there on a high note I
8:55
don't know Yeah, I like I think what
8:57
like what isn't there to be said for
9:00
Marvin Harrison jr He's as pro ready as
9:02
it comes like you love
9:04
the pedigree You love the fact that he's
9:06
been mentored by a Hall of Fame wide
9:08
receiver literally says birth I mean, yeah, they
9:12
I you know for me. I know
9:14
for a lot of NFL teams right
9:16
now Malik neighbors is Their
9:18
top-end wide receiver, but I honestly
9:20
think it's because Marvin Harrison jr.
9:22
Is so good at everything. It's
9:25
almost boring and That's
9:27
not that's not any like For
9:30
as much flash as Malik neighbors
9:32
has I think Marvin Harrison jr.
9:35
Has as Much
9:37
flash but because he's so good at
9:39
everything it It
9:42
sometimes like, you know when you're
9:44
you're so good at everything it
9:46
doesn't Feel as meaningful or
9:48
impactful and I feel like that's the only thing we
9:51
can come up with Marvin Harrison jr He's
9:53
so far my wide receiver one. It's
9:55
absolutely ridiculous Yeah, no,
9:58
I'm with you. And yes, it's sure It
10:00
seems, you know too good to be true type
10:02
thing, you know Whatever the case is that they
10:04
they wouldn't have him as wide receiver one, but
10:07
I'm all in he's wide receiver one for
10:09
me as well I'd be taking him first
10:11
overall in rookie drafts any chance
10:13
I get But
10:16
yeah, we touched on Malik neighbors here just
10:18
briefly but let's get into him a little
10:20
bit more out of LSU another
10:23
potential top ten pick here so
10:27
with neighbors one
10:29
of the first things that kind of
10:31
stood out to me watching him is
10:33
that he is like Incredible
10:36
with the ball in his hands, right?
10:38
And and you know for a smaller
10:40
wide receiver sure you'd expect some shift
10:42
e-ness and speed to their game But
10:45
with neighbors one of the things That
10:48
is most impressive about him is just
10:50
how difficult he is to take down
10:52
like just constantly slipping out of tackles
10:55
bouncing off defenders fighting for extra
10:57
yardage He had six point
10:59
six yards after catch per reception for his
11:01
his career That's clearly the best of those
11:03
top three guys and like you mentioned quarterback
11:05
play does play a part in that as
11:07
well But he's great at
11:10
creating after the catch He has
11:12
an ability to take off in space with
11:14
speed and and make guys miss like you
11:16
look at his miss tackles force per reception
11:18
for his career zero point three one
11:21
Which is not just the best for
11:23
this entire wide receiver class But 99th
11:25
percentile among all prospects since 2019 like
11:28
he's he's electric with the ball in
11:30
his hand So he's another
11:32
guy that it's hard not
11:34
to get excited about like I could
11:36
see for sure Why people have him
11:38
as wide receiver one? So how
11:40
about you? What do you what do you like about neighbors? I
11:43
mean so so explosive. He is an elite
11:45
separator. He is Fast
11:47
he's an insane vertical threat so
11:50
much speed. He is Much
11:52
more dynamic after the catch then
11:55
for instance a Marvin Harrison jr.
11:57
Now obviously Jaden Daniels does play
11:59
a part in that into that because you
12:01
know the ball placement has been impeccable.
12:04
Not a ton of concerns
12:07
for him either like you know for
12:09
Marvin Harrison Jr. it was like yards
12:11
after the catch. Really
12:13
not necessarily much to talk about
12:15
with neighbors either like you know
12:18
a little bit smaller than Marvin Harrison Jr. and
12:21
to that point physicality isn't
12:24
always the way
12:27
that he's going to win and you
12:30
know good thing is he doesn't
12:32
really need to because usually he's faster than a
12:34
lot of the guys on the football field. So
12:37
I do think while I think
12:39
you know Marvin Harrison Jr. again
12:42
my wide receiver one I understand
12:45
the appeal with neighbors he's flashier at 1,569
12:47
receiving yards 14 touchdowns this season
12:51
with LSU and I was playing alongside
12:54
brain Thomas who was also very productive.
12:56
I mean this was an
12:58
explosive offense top to bottom and
13:01
like all of these physical traits
13:04
that that you attribute in terms
13:06
of athleticism burst he's
13:09
got them all. He
13:11
does yeah and he's got the production to
13:13
back it up as well right like there's
13:15
just it's just an ideal profile for what
13:17
you're looking for from a first round wide
13:19
receiver a potential top 10 wide receiver everything
13:22
about him too like there's just very little
13:24
red flags for him on tape
13:26
and in his data as well right like
13:28
87 percentile career yards per out run 93rd
13:31
percentile career receiving grade 96
13:33
percentile career receiving grade versus
13:36
single coverage like again everything you'd
13:38
want out of a wide receiver prospect and
13:40
a super smooth route runner whether he's working
13:42
out of the slot or out wide as
13:44
well like there's just so much
13:46
to like and and yeah it I have
13:48
no concerns about neighbors in the NFL whether
13:51
he's you know the first wide receiver off
13:53
the board second third it makes
13:55
no difference to me I'd be
13:57
very excited to get him In
14:00
fantasy drafts, I think again, another guy that
14:02
I think can hit the ground running in
14:04
the NFL and be an immediate fantasy contributor
14:06
as well, wherever he lands.
14:09
So definitely a very exciting
14:11
player there in Malik Neighbors. All
14:15
right, let's go to another potential
14:17
top 10 pick at the wide
14:20
receiver position in this year's draft
14:22
because two wasn't enough. Washington's Rome
14:24
O'Dunze enters the conversation. So how
14:26
are you feeling about O'Dunze out
14:29
of Washington? I'm going to give
14:31
you a little spoiler here for my
14:33
rankings here at the end of the show. Rome
14:36
O'Dunze is actually my wide receiver too
14:38
in this class over Malik Neighbors and
14:41
might be a spicy take,
14:43
but 21 years old coming
14:45
out of Washington has just
14:47
kind of this perfect height,
14:50
size, speed, combination
14:53
for a guy tested well at
14:55
the combine does so many
14:57
of the little things right, kind of
14:59
like a Marvin Harrison Jr. He's just
15:02
super, super well rounded. Led
15:04
the NCAA with 1640 receiving yards in
15:06
2023, 13 receiving touchdowns, averaged 17.8 yards
15:08
per perception, had year over year growth.
15:15
Each of the past three seasons,
15:17
saw jumps in his target share
15:19
yards per reception average, touchdown total,
15:21
just plays with a ton of
15:24
play strength. He's a tough dude, but
15:26
he's a tough dude that has, I think a
15:28
lot of finesse that just
15:30
has me absolutely enamored. I think he shows
15:32
a lot of lower body strength in particular.
15:35
Like there are times where he'll just like,
15:37
you know, players on a
15:39
tackle attempt are just dragged down
15:41
the field. Like
15:44
19.3 breakout age, that's
15:46
in the 84th percentile
15:48
over the past two seasons,
15:51
95th percentile and receiving grade,
15:53
78th percentile in terms of
15:55
separation percentage, 84th in yards per route
15:57
run. Again, not like a yard.
16:00
after the catch Maestro, but again, just one
16:02
of these guys that I think is
16:05
probably, you know, outside of Marvin
16:07
Harrison Jr. the safest overall wide
16:09
receiver prospect in this class. Yeah,
16:13
he's he's another one. Like again, like you
16:15
just you see watch him. It's very clear
16:17
why he's going to be a top 10,
16:20
a potential top 10 overall pick
16:22
here and Washington's offense to
16:24
like they had, they have, I
16:27
should say, I guess had a really nice offense there in
16:29
2023, but they
16:31
built a lot of that around getting the
16:33
ball into the hands of O'Doonze and letting
16:35
him to go to work, right? Like there's
16:37
there's a ton of wide receiver screens for
16:39
him on tape where, you know, he's getting
16:41
offensive linemen out in front of him blocking
16:43
for him, creating those yak opportunities, but
16:46
also a go route specialist. 30% of
16:48
his routes in 2023 were
16:50
go routes. And not surprising,
16:52
considering that size speed combo, like you said,
16:54
which is going to be key for him
16:56
in the NFL as well. And just some
16:59
really nice plays on tape where basically, you
17:01
know, when you're watching him on those go
17:03
routes, he's the man that can do both
17:05
right on those deep routes, he can shake
17:07
defenders and get open, but also come down
17:10
with those contested catches and win
17:12
against tight coverage. So very
17:14
exciting player. I mean, you know, the
17:16
other thing with O'Doonze, he was fed
17:18
the ball a ton, like I said,
17:20
in Washington's offense, but there were other
17:22
guys there that were legitimate target competition
17:24
between Jalen Polk and Jalen McMillan. So
17:26
not too much of a surprise to
17:28
see like his yard per outrun figure
17:30
below that of Harrison or neighbors and
17:32
was actually ninth among the power five
17:34
wide receivers in this year's class. So
17:36
it's not like an overly exciting number,
17:38
but I wrote up an article this
17:40
past week looking at like personnel adjusted
17:43
yards per outrun for wide receivers,
17:45
essentially looking at offenses that utilize
17:47
more wide receivers on the field,
17:49
how would that makes it more
17:51
difficult for each individual wide receiver
17:53
to command a higher yards per
17:55
outrun total. And O'Doonze's
17:57
actual yards per outrun deviation,
18:00
was among the best in this year's class
18:03
when taking that into account indicating that his
18:06
yards per run total is actually yards
18:08
per run total that is, was actually
18:10
more impressive when considering those less favorable
18:12
situations. So all that
18:14
to say, Odunze really is an elite
18:16
wide receiver prospect, absolutely deserving
18:18
of that top 10 pick. And he's, like
18:20
you said, between two and three, him
18:23
or neighbors, it feels like
18:25
Devontae Smith or Jalen Waddle for me in
18:27
2021, where I'm just happy with
18:29
either one there. I don't care if it's as
18:32
long as I'm getting one, I'm extremely happy.
18:34
So yeah, I think honestly,
18:36
from a dynasty perspective,
18:39
like you're, you end up
18:41
with any of these three wide receivers, especially,
18:44
you know, long term, I don't
18:46
think you're gonna have any complaints. Depending
18:48
on landing spot, I also think each
18:51
three of these could make an immediate
18:53
impact in redraft league. So like, really
18:56
just kind of depends on, you know, your
18:58
where you're going to split hairs with these
19:00
guys, maybe you kind of what you value.
19:03
I think neighbors definitely a
19:05
flashier overall wide receiver. I
19:08
just think Odunze, generally speaking,
19:10
I like the,
19:12
you know, I think he's just a
19:14
little bit more play strength, which is
19:16
a style that I kind of
19:18
prefer in my wide receivers. But like,
19:20
again, with these top
19:22
prospects, we're splitting hairs. Yeah. Yeah,
19:25
definitely splitting hairs landing spot for sure. Gonna
19:27
play a part, right? Like there's, there's talk
19:30
of Odunze potentially going at nine to Chicago,
19:32
right? So it's a little bit more crowded
19:34
in that offense with Keenan Allen and DJ
19:36
more there. So you could see him becoming
19:39
more of that consensus wide receiver three in
19:42
redraft, at least for these rookies, if that were
19:44
to be the case, but there's also going to
19:46
be opportunity for him in other
19:48
potential landing spots to come in and be the
19:50
wide receiver one or wide receiver two at worst.
19:52
So it's going to be fun. It's going to
19:55
be really fun to see how these, this top
19:57
10 shakes out and where these three wide receivers
19:59
go. And yet will get
20:01
into the rest of them here in just a second.
20:03
But first, I want to let you know about Fabric
20:05
by Gerber Life. If you have a family than you
20:07
need to get term life insurance to protect them. It's
20:09
one of the smartest financial decisions you can make in
20:12
the started. The New Year's the perfect time to get
20:14
a sense you could focus on whatever else the your
20:16
has in store for you. Fabric was designed by Parents
20:18
for parents. help you get a high quality, surprising and
20:20
affordable term life insurance policy and less than ten minutes.
20:22
Africa Flexible policies the fit your family, your budget with
20:24
all the policies like a million dollars and coverage for
20:26
less than a dollar day. Get your precise quote just
20:29
minutes and then apply when it's convenient. For you,
20:31
it's all online and on your schedule. A
20:33
to go from start to covered at least
20:35
a ten minutes with no health exam acquired
20:37
during the thousands of parents you trust fabric
20:39
to protect their family Polluted A Just Minutes
20:41
at Me topic.com/fantasy of Me: fabric.com/fantasy An easy
20:44
fabric.com Fi fantasy pulses issued by Western Southern
20:46
my friends company not available in certain states
20:48
post subject underwriting and health questions. Are,
20:52
let's talk another Alice
20:54
you wide receiver and
20:56
another likely first rounder
20:58
as well. It's Mister
21:00
Bryant Thomas Junior Seau
21:02
Thomas. I found. Really
21:05
one of the more interesting players I
21:07
think like and. I'll. Be curious
21:09
where you're at with them because I
21:11
constantly go back and forth on Thomas
21:13
here and and where I should rank
21:15
him. you know, kind of pre draft
21:17
without a landing spot and will get
21:19
to where I landed later but also
21:21
with the positive for him because you
21:23
know you watch him. On tape.
21:26
I find it hard said. basically not
21:28
envision the upside that he'd have in
21:30
the Nfl considering the size and speed
21:33
that he brings to the table. Right
21:35
for three, three, forty time, ninety fourth
21:37
percentile, he's got good height at nearly
21:39
six Three had a nine, nine, seven
21:42
relative athletic score as well. I'm like
21:44
the upside is absolutely there to work
21:46
out for him in the Nfl. You
21:48
to see him joining a high and
21:51
passing offense as their vertical threat and
21:53
being a weekly like big play weapon.
21:56
and i can also see him joining
21:58
a team whose offense isn't as ideal
22:00
unable to, you know, utilize
22:02
him as effectively, especially early in his
22:04
NFL career, and, and then him not
22:06
be that weekly fantasy option that we
22:09
typically hope for out of a first
22:11
round pick. But yeah,
22:14
I don't know. I mean, almost his entire route
22:16
tree right last year, which was his
22:18
one year as a starter, it was go
22:20
routes and hitches. That's, that's pretty much it.
22:22
Like, he had the occasional crossing route in
22:24
there. But we're talking far from
22:26
like a diverse route tree. And it's why part of
22:28
me is worried that he's going to be kind of
22:30
the one trick pony in the
22:33
NFL and only have boom bust fantasy
22:35
potential. So I, I
22:38
definitely see the upside, I can get excited for
22:40
him at times. And then there's other times where
22:42
I get down on him. So I'm curious, where
22:44
are you at with Thomas before, you know, I
22:46
get into some of his numbers here? I'm
22:50
in a similar boat to you. So
22:52
like, I think there's a lot to
22:54
get enamored with, right? You have the
22:57
height we the height weight speed combination
22:59
there, you mentioned it like just under
23:02
six three. And I mean, to have
23:04
that kind of length, and
23:06
that kind of speed, just, I
23:09
mean, it's done, like put them on
23:11
the outside and let them run, let them
23:13
run a go route, you see why he ran so many of them.
23:15
But like, generally, just a
23:17
natural wide receiver, a big catch
23:20
radius, 89th percentile with his wingspan,
23:23
72nd percentile in arm length. You
23:25
know, I think generally what
23:28
we saw out of him, a lot
23:31
of burst, he's a great athlete.
23:33
But again, like the route tree
23:35
kind of concerning, not a
23:38
refined route runner, you know, I
23:40
think probably got away with more
23:42
because of that supreme athleticism
23:45
that that burst, you know, 1.5
23:47
second 10 yard split tells you
23:49
everything you need to know about
23:52
the kind of burst he has.
23:54
And I do think that
23:56
helped him in a lot of situations. So do I I
24:00
see all of these physical
24:02
traits that are really exciting for a
24:05
wide receiver. Yes. But
24:07
do I see somebody that's like pro
24:09
ready as, as, you know, these other
24:11
wide receiver prospects that we just reviewed
24:14
know, and that is why there's such
24:16
a massive tier break here leading
24:18
into Brian Thomas as you know, the
24:21
consensus wide receiver for in this class.
24:25
Yeah. I'm with you. Like I could see
24:27
why he'd be ranked as high as four.
24:29
Um, like on our big board specifically as
24:31
well. Right. And then you look at, you
24:34
know, some of the reasons why he'd be
24:36
ranked a lot lower. And his production profile
24:38
is just kind of riddled with red flags,
24:40
right? Like 1.9, five career yards
24:42
per route run is 28th percentile. 71.5
24:47
career receiving grade is 21st percentile
24:49
is yards per route run. When lined up wide is 1.97.
24:53
That's just 36 percentile. Um,
24:55
even explosive play rate, just 32.3% is 34th percentile. Right.
24:59
So I
25:02
know, you know, he had Malik neighbors to
25:04
contend with there. So maybe we could fit,
25:06
you know, forgive some of the
25:08
per route numbers a little bit. And
25:11
like you said, he's nowhere near finished
25:13
product so we can expect him to
25:15
kind of continue developing and hopefully get
25:17
better, but it is at least concerning
25:19
that he performed so poorly. I think
25:21
relative to prospects passed in, in these
25:23
key metrics. And as much
25:25
as I love the speed and I think
25:27
he can absolutely get better in the NFL.
25:29
I'm not convinced that it's worth the first
25:31
round pick, which is where he's
25:33
expected to go in most mocks and you know,
25:35
his mock draft simulator
25:37
ADP right now is I think 23rd
25:40
overall. So he's in
25:42
that range and it is, you know, his
25:44
production profile. Sure. It puts him closer to
25:46
probably like a fourth rounder, but obviously taking
25:49
to into account the athletic ability. He's much
25:51
better than that. But I don't
25:53
think I'd be looking at him until the second round.
25:55
If I'm an NFL team, to be honest, I don't
25:58
know. You're getting
26:00
a number of years if you're one of these
26:02
teams taking him in the first round is the
26:05
potential the upside the athlete
26:08
and almost reminds me of
26:10
like a Christian Watson coming out where you knew he
26:12
had all of the physical
26:14
traits to be a top-end wide
26:16
receiver but doesn't necessarily
26:18
have the refinement as a route runner
26:21
as a um,
26:23
you know in the NFL player
26:25
yet and you know TBD
26:28
I'm not necessarily using Christian Watson as a
26:30
comp for him. I'm not saying that that's
26:33
Christian Watson is the range of outcomes for a
26:35
player like him, but You
26:38
know even maybe similar to like a Quentin
26:40
Johnston where you know had a lot of
26:42
traits that you really like but You
26:46
might not necessarily expect a ton
26:48
out of him immediately coming out
26:50
of the gate, right? Yeah,
26:52
I think I think Christian Watson is a good
26:54
example though Like you said like how the NFL
26:56
does fall in love with traits and values them
26:58
very highly I mean if you want, you know
27:00
to separate the Comp even from
27:02
the position like look just look a couple
27:04
years ago Trayvon Walker going first overall, right?
27:07
Like the NFL Fell in love
27:09
with that upside and that athletic ability and I think
27:11
it's going to be the same here with with Brian
27:13
Thomas obviously not going to go first overall but He's
27:16
going to be drafted highly and it's because a
27:18
team is going to fall in love with those
27:20
traits and That for that reason you can see
27:22
the upside but I think there's still some Work
27:25
in progress there with with him as
27:27
an NFL player. So I do worry
27:29
about potential year one production from from
27:32
Brian Thomas, basically Yeah, probably
27:34
a better, uh, you know long-term
27:36
dynasty asset than he's going to be here,
27:39
but you know potentially he you know
27:41
if he lands in a role with
27:43
a quarterback that can
27:46
deliver the ball downfield and and
27:49
Get him on those go routes and open up
27:51
an offense like maybe maybe there's some room there
27:54
I just can't envision in year one
27:56
having a consistent sort of every down
27:58
role in an offense Yeah,
28:01
I'm with you 100%. All
28:03
right, let's head to Texas for
28:05
a couple of interesting names coming
28:08
out actually. And we'll start with
28:10
another speed freak and an RAS
28:13
stud in Adonae Mitchell.
28:15
Kate, tell us about
28:17
this potential first round wide receiver. You
28:20
mentioned the relative athletic score
28:22
ranked fifth among wide receivers.
28:24
Fifth, like ever. Fifth,
28:27
since what I think 1987
28:30
dating back, like you
28:32
are getting an absolute freak athlete
28:34
in Ady Mitchell. And what's so
28:36
exciting about him is he
28:39
does like it. This feels like just
28:41
a very common thread with this class
28:43
in general is that
28:45
unique combination of height, weight,
28:49
speed. He's got
28:51
it all. And you talk about
28:53
elite size, body control. You know,
28:57
it's, it's something that's very
28:59
special. And what you like about him,
29:01
like, because of that size,
29:03
he can make catches outside of his
29:05
body, he's got an above average wingspan.
29:08
He's a pretty solid route runner for
29:10
his size as well. You know, want
29:12
to kind of shout out his,
29:15
his overall profile, his production profile
29:17
in particular, not necessarily the efficiency
29:19
metrics, but that's
29:21
going to be the biggest hangup in
29:23
his final season at Texas. So posted
29:25
55 receptions, 845 receiving
29:28
yards, 11 touchdowns after
29:30
transferring from Georgia, had
29:33
two seasons there, sophomore season at
29:35
Georgia was one to
29:38
forget, but one that was kind
29:40
of marred by ankle
29:42
injuries and missed, you know,
29:44
had this ankle sprain and in week
29:46
two of the second season, missed
29:49
most of the year, kind of came back
29:51
late and didn't see a
29:53
whole lot before he eventually transferred to
29:55
Texas and then had to
29:57
make his way into this Texas offense where
30:00
Xavier Worthy had already kind of established
30:02
him as this wide receiver
30:04
one for the offense. So, you
30:06
know, never surpass that 845
30:08
receiving yard mark, but not
30:11
necessarily going to ding him there
30:14
for that second season at Georgia
30:16
because of, of, you
30:18
know, his overall health. Now
30:21
for as much as I like
30:23
him, some weaknesses, not necessarily like, despite
30:25
the fact that he's, he's big and,
30:27
you know, six, two and a quarter
30:30
inch, 205 pounds, doesn't have as much
30:34
play strength as you would think. 43.3%
30:38
contested catch percentage over the course of
30:40
his collegiate career. That ranks
30:42
below average. The yards
30:44
after the catch ability, probably the biggest
30:47
red flag when it
30:49
comes to AD Mitchell over the past
30:51
three seasons, averaged three yards after the
30:53
catch perception at ranked 353rd out of
30:55
356 qualifying wide receivers. Yeah,
31:02
it's, that was a, that was a big
31:05
red flag that I had written as well.
31:07
It's just first percentile among prospects since 2019.
31:10
Right. And then look at, you know, in
31:12
a similar vein as Brian Thomas is
31:14
Adonie Mitchell, we have these kind of
31:16
lanky athletic speedsters, right? Who have this
31:19
untapped potential as far as kind of
31:21
what they can be in the NFL
31:23
and how teams can utilize them to
31:25
become like true offensive weapons. And
31:28
I think the upside is absolutely there with
31:30
Mitchell as much as it is with Thomas.
31:33
You know, the, the problem for me was
31:35
as well, like you mentioned, you know, the
31:37
production profile as far as efficiency
31:40
metrics go, it's pretty
31:42
poor, you know, to say the least. And
31:44
definitely some of that has to do with,
31:46
with different offenses and dealing with injuries as
31:49
well. But 1.68 career
31:51
yards per out run being 13th percentile
31:54
among prospects since 2019. Like
31:57
even his best career season in terms of yards
31:59
per out run. run at 1.72 is just third percentile
32:01
since 2019. And
32:08
then like receiving grade yards for outrun
32:10
from different alignments. They're all well below
32:13
average career missed tackles forced per reception,
32:15
just 15th percentile. So even with that,
32:17
that yak ability being really low too,
32:19
like there's reasons why that is. He's
32:22
not making guys miss in the open
32:24
field. So I did,
32:26
I struggled to find like a lot
32:28
of positives in his actual like college
32:30
production with basically the shining light of
32:33
his profile being in his adjusted separation
32:35
rate. So open target rate on throws
32:37
10 plus yards down field. Basically
32:40
he ranked 82nd percentile among prospects there
32:42
and finished with a 76th percentile explosive
32:44
play rate, which you would hope to
32:47
see from these kind of speedsters. And
32:49
he was better than Thomas in that
32:51
regard as well. So his
32:53
route tree was also a bit more
32:55
diverse than a Brian Thomas,
32:58
even though it is still very heavy on the
33:00
go routes and the hitches, like most vertical threats
33:02
are, but there is a bit
33:04
more to his game as far as kind of
33:06
the underneath stuff, like slants, crossing routes, those ins
33:08
and outs as well. Which was nice to see,
33:10
but yeah, I did. I found
33:12
more red flags for him as well, kind
33:15
of when doing the personnel
33:17
adjusted yards per outrun, like he
33:19
was put in more favorable situations
33:22
with fewer wide receivers on the
33:24
field at once, but failed
33:26
to kind of deliver at a rate
33:28
that you'd hope to see from potential
33:30
first round wide receivers. And as highlighted
33:32
in the article, which you could check
33:34
out for free on pff.com now, that
33:37
success rate for those lower
33:39
performers in yards per outrun
33:41
over expected is actually quite
33:43
low. So those things were
33:45
definitely concerning for me. But again,
33:48
like you see the upside, you see
33:50
why this class is considered so deep
33:53
is that they have these guys, like
33:55
these athletics, speedsters, like Donnie
33:57
Mitchell, like Brian Thomas, that...
34:00
can absolutely work out once they get to
34:02
the NFL. And, you know, again, they're not
34:05
finished products coming out of college. So there's
34:07
still work to be done there. And it's
34:10
hard to shut the door on them
34:12
completely because of poor production profiles, basically.
34:15
Yeah, very, very fair. Yeah.
34:20
Okay, let's move on to the
34:22
other Texas wide receiver now and
34:24
another absolute speed freak who ran
34:26
a four to 140 time at the
34:29
combine, it's Xavier Worthy. He
34:32
was not one of the top
34:34
eight wide receivers on the PFF
34:36
big board, but a combine
34:38
riser for a lot of people.
34:40
So definitely worth kind of discussing
34:42
here among so many wide receivers
34:45
that are worth discussing who we weren't able to
34:47
cover, we weren't, aren't able to cover them all
34:49
here today, but he is smaller
34:51
than AD Mitchell, 511, 165, very
34:57
small for a wide receiver. So I think
34:59
right there, you find some of the concerns
35:01
right away when translating to the NFL, but
35:03
that being said, you know, he was used a lot outside
35:06
a lot more at Texas, but I'd imagine,
35:08
you know, he fits better in the slot
35:11
in the NFL and can still serve as
35:13
like a vertical threat. Also
35:15
has a more nuanced route tree relative to
35:18
like a Brian Thomas, for example, just with
35:20
a ton more wide receiver
35:22
screens too, right? Like those screens do
35:25
speak to the team, I think wanting
35:27
to get the ball in his hands
35:29
because with that speed and quickness comes
35:31
a ton of playmaking potential as well.
35:33
And I wouldn't be surprised to
35:35
see him used in a similar way in
35:37
the NFL. He's probably
35:40
not a guy that teams will be spending
35:42
a first round pick on even with that
35:44
elite athletic ability. There's just, you know, some
35:46
of the size concerns and then maybe not
35:49
to the extent of Thomas and AD Mitchell
35:51
production profile concerns, but they are still there
35:53
for him in a way in that he's
35:55
just kind of closer to average and profiles
35:58
probably closer to like a late date. to
36:00
type pick in the draft without factoring in,
36:02
you know, much of his athleticism. He's probably
36:04
going to go earlier than that. So, um,
36:08
yeah, where were you at with, with worthy? Did well, we
36:10
won't give it away. I was going to say, do you
36:12
like him better than Mitchell, but let's, let's save that. I'll
36:14
just see very, where you're at with the word. We can
36:16
save that. Yeah. We can say that. I
36:18
mean, like, look, there's a lot of things
36:20
to like about Xavier worthy, like speed and
36:22
separation, that is the name of the game
36:25
for Xavier worthy. And like,
36:27
no surprise, he ran a four to one
36:29
40 yard dash, like past three seasons
36:31
ranks 93rd percentile with an 83.9% open target rate, um, just fast.
36:38
He can be utilized all over the field. He
36:40
could be kind of a gadget player. Once
36:43
you get the ball in his hands and let him
36:45
make plays after the catch, that's where he is
36:48
going to win. And, you know,
36:50
in terms of production profile, not
36:52
necessarily leave, but there is one
36:54
metric that analytics fans are going
36:56
to really, really like about Xavier
36:58
worthy. And it's this 18.4 breakout
37:00
age, which ranks in the 97th
37:02
percentile for wide receivers as
37:05
a true freshmen in 2021 at Texas ranked 77th
37:07
percentile or better in yards
37:10
per route run yards after the
37:12
catch perception and separation percentage. I
37:15
think, you know, generally speaking, you're going
37:17
to be maybe a little bit more
37:20
disappointed that we didn't see a higher
37:22
ceiling for him, especially in 2023. We
37:25
saw AD Mitchell utilized, um,
37:27
a lot more, you know, then
37:29
maybe we would have liked considering Xavier
37:31
worthy was already established in that offense,
37:34
but. Was still
37:36
the wide receiver one just didn't necessarily
37:38
see a ton of like year over
37:40
year growth, like what we saw as
37:42
a true freshmen was kind of what
37:44
we ended up getting, um, in for
37:47
most of his career. But
37:49
I do want to shout out just the
37:51
fact that I think he's a really good
37:53
solid wide receiver,
37:55
the biggest question for me is just going
37:57
to be the play strength 11th percentile. and
38:00
Kentucky catch rate over his three seasons at Texas.
38:02
He plays like he's 165 pounds in the worst
38:04
way. Yeah,
38:09
that and that becomes a lot harder to
38:11
do at the NFL level as well, right?
38:13
So yeah, you mentioned it. I
38:15
mean, you wish to see higher,
38:18
at least efficiency marks
38:20
for him, but they're not like terrible. They're
38:22
just closer to average, I guess, for the
38:24
prospects coming out over the past few years,
38:26
right? And if you're watching on YouTube, you
38:29
can see the graphic there, 51st
38:31
percentile career yards per run, as well
38:33
as 51st percentile career receiving
38:35
grade, even explosive play rate for
38:38
a guy with that speed, 49th
38:40
percentile. Yeah,
38:43
missed tackles force per reception, 47th
38:45
percentile yards per out run versus
38:47
single coverage, 55th percentile. So you
38:50
mentioned it too, like he did a nice
38:52
job separating, and then you look at adjusted
38:54
separation rate, which is 10 plus yards downfield,
38:56
38% open target rate in that regard, which
39:00
was 78th percentile and really good, you
39:02
know, yards after catch per reception as
39:04
well, which you'd hope to see with
39:07
all those wide receiver screens as well.
39:09
He was 80th percentile there. So I
39:12
think there's definitely a role for
39:14
him in the NFL as a wide receiver that you
39:16
can involve in the offense at
39:18
a high rate, get the ball in his
39:20
hands around the line of scrimmage, let him
39:22
go to work kind of thing, as well
39:24
as the occasional vertical threat. But I
39:27
think that, you know, the
39:29
NFL team that drafts him is going
39:31
to have to be a creative one
39:33
to make him like a consistent fantasy
39:35
asset, basically. So for worthy, I
39:38
felt like I found myself getting
39:40
kind of hung up on potential landing spot for him.
39:42
I think that's going to be particularly important here for
39:44
him. But yeah,
39:47
I, again, like, I
39:49
like all these wide receivers, which is it, I
39:52
feel like I have to point out some of
39:54
the negatives just to kind of separate these guys
39:56
a little bit. But really, like, again, you look
39:58
in, you're looking at upside and stuff with these
40:00
guys and it is a very exciting class
40:02
and as far as potential goes. And
40:05
I do want to say Xavier worthy like he
40:07
he has time right he has time to put
40:09
on a little bit
40:11
of monthly five eleven it like that's not
40:14
that's not great for a wide receiver but it's not
40:16
the end of the world he's the 165 pounds it's a
40:19
lot to get over but also again
40:23
twenty years old he's going to turn
40:25
21 just ahead of the
40:28
NFL draft here and I do
40:30
think like that that gives him some
40:32
some time to put on muscle conceivably
40:35
over the next couple of seasons once
40:37
he's actually conditioned
40:39
for the NFL and and you know
40:41
maybe makes an effort to put on
40:43
some of that muscle I
40:46
can foresee that happening and I do
40:48
think landing spot is going to be key
40:50
like I don't
40:52
want him seeing I don't want to see
40:54
him going to like the AFC North where
40:57
they're going to play a physical brand of
40:59
defensive football I don't want to see that
41:01
I it's like I think that you know I
41:04
don't want to see him going to a place
41:06
with you know that where he's going to be
41:08
able to you know get bullied by his common
41:10
opponents like I I want a situation
41:12
where maybe he doesn't necessarily have to
41:14
be the number one and he can
41:16
just play his brand of speed
41:19
and separation and and we don't
41:21
have to worry about these contested
41:23
catch situations that he's not necessarily
41:25
going to excel in yeah
41:28
yeah I'm with you I think yeah
41:30
landing spot again I think it's going
41:32
to be particularly important for somebody like
41:34
Xavier Worthy um all right a couple
41:37
wide receivers left for today we got
41:39
Ladd McConkie up next uh the productive
41:41
little guy out of Georgia Kate McConkie
41:44
is fun to say but was he
41:46
fun to watch in your opinion so
41:48
fun to watch Ladd McConkie probably one
41:51
of my favorite prospects and watching
41:53
him I got like these little tinglies the
41:55
same way that I got like about tank
41:57
del where you look at the
42:00
situation, you look at the type of player he is
42:02
and you wonder like, can he
42:04
really be productive for fantasy? And
42:06
you know, you don't know,
42:08
but like from a
42:11
pure football standpoint, you see why
42:13
lad mcconkey has first round potential
42:16
in the NFL draft, because there are going to be
42:18
a lot of teams that are kind of enamored with
42:21
the traits that he has. He's a
42:23
good athlete ran in the four threes.
42:26
Small, yes. You
42:29
know, just under six foot, 186 pounds, but like
42:31
a, he's got, you know, still some
42:35
muscle for him. He's not all
42:38
all lanky. You know, small hands,
42:41
short arms, like just not from
42:43
a size, he's just he's a
42:45
compact human, but offers a ton
42:48
of burst. Now, I
42:50
do think, you know, from a production
42:53
standpoint, people are going to see his college
42:55
stats. They're probably going to
42:57
be a little bit nervous. Now, final
42:59
season at Georgia, you know, played in,
43:01
you know, had a redshirt freshman year
43:03
came in 2021, posted a solid 447
43:06
yards, five touchdowns, 2022 built on that
43:08
762 yards, seven
43:16
touchdowns, and then all things went
43:19
south in 2023, which I
43:21
think we could have had a really solid year, missed
43:23
the first four games of the 2023 season
43:26
with a back injury, then an
43:28
ankle injury forced him out of the game
43:30
mid season against Tennessee, missed the following week,
43:33
just wasn't fully healthy in
43:35
2023. But what there
43:38
is to like about him, he is one
43:40
of the best route runners in this class,
43:42
he can put a defensive back on their
43:44
butt, because of
43:47
just the manipulation mid route.
43:49
And I
43:51
think that just generally speaking
43:53
showed up a lot on
43:55
tape. And in terms
43:57
of the analytics that misforce tackles
43:59
per perception. Everything
44:02
about Lad McConkie, I think you
44:04
saw translate pretty well
44:06
both between the tape and the
44:08
statistical profile in terms of advanced
44:11
metrics. It's really just those,
44:13
those face value stats, like
44:16
the actual box score that's going to
44:18
have you hesitating,
44:21
but generally speaking, I think it's kind
44:23
of meaningless when you consider the
44:26
circumstances. I'm with you and also contending
44:28
with the player that's actually pictured on
44:30
the YouTube screen in Brock Bowers. That's
44:33
not Lad McConkie. I just realized that's
44:35
my fault for not picking up on
44:37
that earlier. But yeah, he's,
44:40
he is absolutely a fun player, right? Like you said,
44:42
he's on the smaller side, 511, 186,
44:45
so a bit thicker than Xavier Worthy,
44:48
though probably another slot type wide receiver here,
44:50
which we know can be
44:52
fine in the NFL. It was definitely
44:54
more productive working out of the slot
44:56
for his college career as well. 2.84 yards per
44:59
out run from the slot, which was
45:02
76 percentile versus the 2.37 out wide,
45:04
which was 65th percentile. And
45:09
you mentioned it, he's an excellent route
45:11
runner as well. And that shows in
45:13
how Georgia, Georgia utilized him
45:15
in a variety of different ways, whether
45:18
it was deep routes, a bunch of
45:20
his acrosser and underneath and those ins
45:22
and outs slants on top of a
45:24
bunch of wide receiver screens as well,
45:26
because they want to get the ball in his hands. So
45:29
again, just a fun player that you
45:31
can utilize in any kind of offense.
45:33
He's a good separator downfield as well.
45:35
38% open
45:37
target rate on those 10 plus a dot
45:39
throws, which was 78 percentile, just
45:42
has a really great feel for finding
45:44
the holes and zone coverages as well
45:47
as how to win one on one
45:49
with leverage and with quick breaks on
45:51
his routes. So I'm with
45:53
you. I loved lad McConkie.
45:55
You know, you Mentioned the miss tackles
45:57
forest, the yards after catch, things like that, that he
45:59
can do. Once the balls in his hands
46:01
and you could just I think use
46:03
him in so many different ways and
46:05
I think that helps them fit the
46:07
so many Nfl off answers that I
46:09
feel fairly confident in him as as
46:11
a potential fantasy starters starter regardless of
46:14
kind of where he lands that you
46:16
know I'm for the most part and
46:18
obviously you know the injury suffered. It
46:20
is a bit of a concern as
46:22
well, but. There's. Yeah,
46:24
I I just came way feeling excited
46:26
about him about his potential in in
46:28
the Nfl, especially as a potential first
46:30
round pick and he added there's gonna
46:32
be some lower per wrote numbers for
46:34
him I think as well because you
46:36
know again he has to contend with.
46:38
but the generational Brock Powers for targets
46:40
and and yardage in Georgia softens. But
46:42
I think factoring that in and knowing
46:44
that is not likely to be a
46:46
number one wide receiver in the Nfl
46:48
anyways and just seeing that he can
46:51
still be productive with and a at
46:53
now for Target. Earner in an office
46:55
is is still a very encouraging
46:57
sign. So yeah, I came away
46:59
feeling pretty excited about Lad Mccarthy.
47:02
I'm in L. I'm I'm probably
47:04
a problem that just a few
47:06
are question marks. In terms of
47:09
the translation to fantasy, that's like
47:11
let me save face value. Fantasy
47:13
aside, and of this is the
47:15
Fantasy podcast. Best. Like. From a
47:18
a Nfl readiness standpoint, from a
47:20
skills the employee from the ability
47:22
to play the wide receiver, I'd
47:24
make the argument that Lad Mcconkey
47:26
is probably the fourth best wide
47:28
receiver in this class. I
47:30
know there's like the size concerns he can
47:32
put on some more muscle at the next
47:35
level. It again like a little bit older
47:37
than some of the other wide receivers that
47:39
we talked about harrys twenty two or turned
47:41
twenty three November but still, time to put
47:43
on a little bit of both. But. From.
47:46
A skill perspective from a like
47:48
a tools perspective of just playing
47:51
the wide receiver position. I'd argue
47:53
he's wide receiver for in this
47:55
class like it doesn't have. maybe
47:58
the flash and the by. and
48:00
the you know top-end speed that like
48:03
a Brian Thomas has but you
48:05
know a much more diverse skill set
48:07
I think that's gonna translate to a
48:09
lot of different NFL teams that you
48:12
know it again you can kind of plug
48:14
and play him in any type of offense because he
48:17
can play he can
48:19
play out wide he can play in the slot
48:21
I want to see him get to a place
48:23
where you know he's gonna
48:25
have some PPR upside though I think
48:28
he's capable of being
48:30
a a volume guy at
48:32
the next level I just want I want him to
48:34
land in a spot where he doesn't get you know
48:39
put into a situation where he's like
48:41
the third option on on a roster
48:43
and because I think this dude deserves
48:46
volume and I think he's got the
48:48
skill set to handle it yeah
48:50
absolutely good way to
48:52
put it all right last
48:54
but certainly not least at least
48:56
as far as I'm concerned he's
48:58
the number seven ranked wide receiver
49:00
on the PFF big board out
49:02
of Oregon it is Troy freaking
49:04
Franklin so one
49:07
of the lightest wide receivers in this class
49:09
as well like he's lanky as hell but
49:11
man he is exciting like
49:13
I keep going back to
49:15
his tape and I keep
49:18
finding more things to love
49:20
so to me he stands
49:22
out as another one
49:24
of those wide receivers who just has
49:26
such like a strong feel for the
49:29
game and the field and in how
49:31
he's able to get open and optimize
49:34
himself as a target he
49:36
can separate as a deep threat as well as in
49:39
those intermediate areas of the field where
49:41
he's you know just constantly making himself
49:44
like a QB friendly target by working
49:46
back to the ball or feeling where
49:48
a defender is and just creating that
49:50
little adjustment for a little bit more
49:52
space he's also not afraid to catch
49:54
those passes in the middle of the field where
49:56
contact is coming in just despite the thinner frame
49:58
he's able to hang in there make contested
50:00
catches or make adjustments on the ball deep
50:03
downfield, which I noticed he had to do
50:05
quite a bit. You know, we touched on
50:07
Bonyx's deep ball accuracy last week and that
50:09
it wasn't necessarily the best, but Franklin
50:12
helps his case there by working back
50:14
to the ball and fighting through contact
50:17
not necessarily as a nuance of a route
50:19
tree as someone like a lad McConkey, for
50:21
example, but it's not terrible in
50:24
that he, you know, he isn't just a
50:26
deep threat. He's able to earn targets kind
50:28
of regardless of where or regardless
50:31
of what he's running on the field. And
50:33
that's particularly encouraging. I found for him as
50:36
a potential number one wide
50:38
receiver in the NFL at some point as
50:40
he kind of continues to develop and like
50:43
his production profile also super
50:45
positive 89th percentile
50:48
profile just behind Romo Dunes a career
50:50
yards per route run is 2.63, which
50:53
is slightly better than O'Dunes in the
50:55
80th percentile, a 2.64 yards
50:57
per out run when lined up wide 79th percentile, 40.6% explosive play
50:59
rate, 75th percentile, 5.1 career yards per
51:07
out run versus single coverage is 94th percentile.
51:11
And then a 45% adjusted separation rate
51:13
is 92nd percentile. I,
51:16
yeah, I, I love Troy Franklin
51:18
spoilers. He's ranked fairly high for
51:20
me. I think, you know, there's
51:23
even some untapped potential there with him that
51:25
would just make him all the more dangerous
51:27
at the NFL level as well. Like if
51:29
he can pack on some weight, obviously get
51:31
a little stronger. I think, you know, his
51:33
game and production can definitely still translate since
51:36
he has such a strong feel for the
51:38
game and he has some speed to spare
51:40
as well. So I love Troy Franklin. I'll
51:42
be curious to see where you at. You're
51:44
at with him because I know he's not
51:46
everybody's cup of tea. I'm
51:49
not, I'm not nearly as high, but you made an
51:52
excellent case. I mean, definitely
51:54
want to see him put on a little
51:56
bit of weight, 176 pounds on a 6.2 Free.
52:00
Him He's light on rate of
52:02
for for one forty yard-which you
52:04
love use explosive. Thirty nine inch
52:07
vertical jump like a I think
52:09
they're the biggest concerns for me.
52:11
Definitely lie in the the overall
52:14
frame. Of Troy franco
52:16
much again can. Can. Build
52:18
on but. It. Is
52:20
a stark contrast. Even like lot
52:22
of lad, Mcconkey has a i
52:24
think a lot more bulk, less
52:26
lanky, just overall more compact Live
52:28
Mcconkey is. For. Franklin's just.
52:31
A lanky and in it's hard.
52:33
I mean it's a good for
52:36
good thing is like it's not
52:38
necessarily a length problems the lake
52:40
is the length is is excellent.
52:42
Ah. Il
52:44
things generally speaking. You.
52:47
Like to see the the way that
52:49
he moves for the size which again
52:51
just a very common theme in this
52:53
draft class but probably the biggest concern
52:55
from. We is the route tree.
52:58
And and have limited that
53:00
is it makes me just
53:02
curious. Like for how excellent
53:04
the production profile is. As
53:07
how's that going to translate in the Nfl
53:09
when he asked to do. A.
53:12
Lot more on a in. Is he
53:14
ready it like it is he ready
53:16
to be asked more of of. It's.
53:19
Hard for me to say
53:21
and that's probably my biggest
53:23
pence point for for his
53:25
production. In the next level
53:27
is how refined is he
53:29
really. I'm not sure I. I.
53:32
Feel confident enough. Answering
53:35
Not at this point? i
53:38
think that's fair and and look get lucky
53:40
like we said you know if it is
53:42
a lotta go roads for him on on
53:44
t with not merely the refined wrote tree
53:46
that i think you know you're kind of
53:48
hoping for from a potential first round pick
53:50
either so i definitely get it i think
53:52
just for me you know kind of watching
53:54
him and just seeing again that that kind
53:57
of feel for the game and and a
53:59
bill to still run those routes, even though
54:01
he doesn't do it often, you definitely see
54:03
the, I think, the potential for him to
54:05
be able to develop there if he was
54:07
asked to do it a little bit more.
54:09
So I feel more
54:11
confident than you, I
54:13
guess, for Franklin. And that's okay. Like, there's
54:15
a reason that he's, you
54:17
know, considered like a later first round pick at
54:20
best here as opposed to, you know, early on
54:22
in the draft. And because
54:24
he's not a perfect prospect, but
54:26
I came away feeling
54:28
very excited about about Troy
54:30
Franklin here. And yeah, 28th overall, the Buffalo
54:33
Bills are picking, I would love to see
54:35
Troy Franklin there. Obviously, I think they're going
54:37
to trade up to potentially grab somebody a
54:40
little bit earlier, not probably not
54:42
too high, but I
54:44
would be excited about that fit, for example. All
54:48
right, rankings time. I know
54:51
that we were pretty perfectly aligned
54:53
with our quarterback rankings last episode,
54:56
but I imagine we'll have some
54:58
differences among our top eight wide
55:00
receivers here in where they land
55:02
just because, you know, it's
55:04
a mixed bag of options. And even at
55:07
the very top, we have an argument for
55:09
any of those three guys to be number
55:11
one. So Kate, we'll start at the top.
55:13
We actually, you already mentioned it, Marvin Harrison
55:15
Jr. is wide receiver one for you. He
55:19
is as well for me. Yep.
55:21
I think where things get interesting,
55:24
I mentioned Romadonze, my wide receiver
55:26
two. Again, it's kind of
55:28
like 1A1B with Malik neighbors, but I'm just
55:30
going to give my slight preference to Romadonze.
55:32
How egregious do you think this is? Because
55:35
I'm going to guess you have neighbors as
55:37
your wide receiver crew. Yeah,
55:39
I have neighbors wide receiver two. But
55:42
I don't think it's egregious. Like I said, I would
55:44
be very happy with either one of these guys. Like
55:47
these are the top end of consolation
55:49
prizes. You know, if you're not getting
55:51
Marvin Harrison or if you're not getting,
55:53
you know, number two on your
55:55
board versus number three. So these guys
55:58
are very, very good. I think there's absolutely. day
56:01
one potential for them is as fantasy
56:03
assets as well. So I'm with you.
56:05
I got them as basically like a
56:07
two way to be type situation but
56:09
I do give the edge to neighbors
56:11
for me with Marvin Harrison, number one.
56:13
So that first tier
56:16
is still locked in. Like there's,
56:18
I don't think anybody else entering
56:20
that conversation. So where
56:22
it does get more interesting is outside of that
56:24
tier. So who do you have at
56:27
number four? I've got Brian
56:29
Thomas Jr. who I think is pretty
56:31
much like consensus wide receiver four at
56:33
this point. I did mention
56:35
that like fantasy aside, Ladma Conkey
56:37
is like my true NFL wide
56:40
receiver four at this point. But
56:43
I do it just because of like
56:45
maybe fantasy upside and
56:48
looking at some of those athletic
56:50
traits and kind of
56:52
projecting that forward the size, all
56:55
of that put together paired
56:58
with maybe some higher draft capital for
57:00
Brian Thomas, I think probably
57:02
gives him the edge for me. Is he your
57:04
wide receiver four as well? He's
57:07
not. That is where I
57:09
put in Troy Franklin. Yeah,
57:12
I moved Troy Franklin to my wide
57:15
receiver four after
57:17
all things considered, right? Like between
57:19
the tape and the production profile,
57:22
I love Troy Franklin. So it was hard for
57:24
me to put anybody else outside of the big
57:27
three there ahead of him.
57:29
And I know like the
57:32
skinny lankiness of him
57:34
is going to be a concern for sure.
57:36
But I just I don't know. I
57:38
have faith that he can still translate to the NFL.
57:40
I think there's still a lot to like about his
57:42
game. And yeah, the
57:44
production profile as well, like added on
57:46
to what I'd liked from him on
57:48
tape was just everything I needed
57:50
to kind of put him at the
57:53
top of this second tier for me. I
57:55
think that's fair. Now is Brian Thomas
57:57
your wider theater five? So
58:00
Brian Thomas roll down the list. Let's go
58:02
from your wide receiver for Troy Franklin
58:05
Let's roll down the rest of your list and
58:07
then we'll close out with the rest of my
58:09
list It seems like we're gonna have some shake-ups
58:11
and some differences here. We got some
58:13
differences. Yeah, so I do not have Brian Thomas's
58:15
number five I have lad
58:17
mcconkey out of Georgia as number five
58:21
Yeah, so I again another guy
58:23
that I really liked again,
58:26
you know tape wise I know he's on the
58:28
smaller side but his Potential
58:31
as like a full-time slot wide receiver
58:33
in the NFL with his route running
58:35
ability with his past production with his
58:37
ability to still earn targets in that
58:40
Georgia offense, you know competing with Brock
58:42
Bowers and a lot of offensive weapons
58:44
there like I'm
58:46
feeling pretty confident about lad mcconkey. I think
58:48
you know first round As
58:50
far as first round wide receivers go he's kind
58:52
of the I have I have five guys that
58:54
I would take in the first round and he's
58:57
the he's the last of the bunch there, so
58:59
that's where kind of the tier break happens for
59:01
me is after mcconkey and Yeah,
59:03
and at number six is where I had Brian Thomas jr. So
59:07
This third tier for me was
59:09
super close. It had Brian Thomas At
59:12
six a Donnie Mitchell at seven and
59:14
Xavier worthy at eight These
59:17
guys again, I moved around a ton.
59:20
There was a time where I had Brian
59:22
Thomas in the second Tier
59:24
as well, but I just fell less in
59:26
love with him I guess as far as
59:28
you know what he's shown so
59:31
far and and understanding that I think he's
59:33
gonna take some time but Yeah,
59:35
Brian Thomas. I still like the upside. I like
59:38
the production profile a little bit better than a
59:40
Donnie Mitchell But that was
59:42
kind of the tiebreaker for me was that production
59:44
profile the one for Mitchell does scare me a
59:46
little bit So I've cooled on him. He's at
59:48
seven and then Xavier worthy at eight. I Think
59:51
that's all very fair lad mcconkey is
59:54
one that like I
59:56
keep wanting to move
59:58
further further up my draft board. And
1:00:01
I'm going to be honest, this next year,
1:00:03
I have shuffled around, left
1:00:06
and right. And it depends
1:00:08
on which way the wind is blowing.
1:00:10
So based on the trajectory of where
1:00:13
the wind is blowing right now here
1:00:15
in Houston, Texas, as
1:00:17
we're recording this, I'm gonna go
1:00:20
with Lad McConkie, I think you're right. At
1:00:22
wide receiver five, I'll be bold here. I'm
1:00:25
actually gonna go with Xavier Worthy as
1:00:27
wide receiver six, who I think is
1:00:29
just a better overall
1:00:31
wide receiver, obviously frame concerns,
1:00:34
like size concerns. But in
1:00:36
terms of like, you know, just his
1:00:39
natural ability as a wide receiver, I'll
1:00:41
take him over a guy
1:00:43
like Troy Franklin or AD Mitchell.
1:00:47
Then I'll take Troy Franklin, then I'll take
1:00:49
AD Mitchell. So for me, it's
1:00:51
Marvin Harrison Jr. Roma Dunsey, Malik
1:00:53
neighbors in that first year. Then
1:00:56
I've got Brian Thomas, Lad
1:00:59
McConkie, Xavier Worthy, Troy
1:01:01
Franklin, and finally AD Mitchell
1:01:04
at wide receiver eight. Nice. Yeah,
1:01:06
so that I definitely understand
1:01:08
that for sure. I've had that kind of
1:01:10
similar order already with these guys before this
1:01:12
is where I am. All right, tomorrow, it'll
1:01:14
be totally different. Yeah, exactly. I'm gonna write
1:01:17
up rankings at some point. And I'm sure
1:01:19
there's going to be some changes. But yeah,
1:01:21
I got Marvin Harrison one Malik neighbors to
1:01:23
Roma Dunsey three, then a tier break for
1:01:25
Troy Franklin for Lad McConkie five another tier
1:01:27
break Brian Thomas, Adani Mitchell, Xavier Worthy for
1:01:30
me. So there's plenty
1:01:32
of wide receivers in this
1:01:34
class that are going to be worthy of
1:01:37
that top eight top 10. However you want to look
1:01:39
at it. I mean, we might have to get into
1:01:41
the wide receiver position again at some point here. But
1:01:44
yeah, that is going to do it for
1:01:46
today's episode at least. Thank you all very
1:01:48
much for tuning in and
1:01:51
following along here. And next week, I'm
1:01:53
sure we're going to go into another
1:01:55
position probably running backs, I'm gonna guess
1:01:57
we'll see how it goes. But Kate.
1:02:00
As always, thank you very much for
1:02:02
coming on here and lending your thoughts
1:02:04
and expertise on these prospects. I really
1:02:06
do look forward to doing this every
1:02:08
week and look forward to doing it
1:02:10
again with you as well. Thanks
1:02:12
for having me. Give me a follow on Twitter
1:02:15
at Kate Majuk and follow along
1:02:17
with my wide receiver
1:02:19
ranking shuffle all offseason long. I
1:02:21
have a feeling I'm
1:02:23
just going to be tinkering. And that's where we're
1:02:26
at with this class because there's
1:02:28
a lot to love about so many
1:02:30
of these different prospects. And they
1:02:32
all have like very different things that I
1:02:34
think they offer. So we're going to have
1:02:36
a lot of things to talk about. I
1:02:38
think especially after the draft, once we have
1:02:40
some landing spots here, because again,
1:02:43
you know, size, speed,
1:02:45
athleticism, that's like the name of
1:02:48
the game for this class. And
1:02:50
I'm going to say NFL teams and our
1:02:53
fantasy football team is probably going to be
1:02:55
pretty spoiled here in the season to come. Yeah,
1:02:58
no, absolutely. It's going to be exciting. We're
1:03:00
definitely going to have to, you know, sort
1:03:02
it out again after the draft, once all
1:03:05
these landing spots kind of come to fruition
1:03:07
and we see where guys end up and
1:03:09
which offenses because there's a ton of potential
1:03:11
here for fantasy purposes. But
1:03:13
we'll get into all that at some point as well down
1:03:16
the road. And yeah, as far
1:03:18
as this podcast goes, if you're looking for
1:03:20
more draft talk or prospect talk on the
1:03:22
defensive side of the ball, whether
1:03:25
it's IDP or just want to know more
1:03:27
about these defensive prospects, we will have another
1:03:29
episode here later in the week talking rookie
1:03:31
edge defenders, which is going to be
1:03:33
a lot of fun. We got my guy Joseph Hagan, aka
1:03:35
Joey, the tooth from football guys joining
1:03:37
me. So be sure to check that
1:03:39
out as well. Don't forget to use
1:03:41
the promo code 30 MDS and check
1:03:43
out the PFF draft guide, get 30%
1:03:46
off an annual subscription, all of that fun stuff
1:03:48
in the mock draft simulator as well. But
1:03:51
yeah, other than that, we got a ton of
1:03:53
draft content up on the site on pff.com. I've
1:03:56
written up the analytical strengths and weaknesses at
1:03:58
the top of the. quarterback wide receiver
1:04:00
tight end at running back classes as well as
1:04:03
some Analytics sleepers for wide
1:04:05
receiver and running back rode up that
1:04:07
personnel adjusted yards per row run piece
1:04:09
as well for the wide receivers Well,
1:04:12
yeah, check it all out. It's draft season
1:04:14
again stay locked in We will continue to
1:04:16
keep you covered here on PFF and
1:04:18
at the PFF fantasy podcast and until next
1:04:20
time you
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More