Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
No matter what you're a fan of, Texas has
0:02
the trip for you. There's the...
0:07
...trip to Texas. And the... ...trip.
0:13
or maybe you're the kind of fan who'd prefer
0:15
a... trip
0:18
to Texas. Or a... Or a... up. trip.
0:21
...trip. Either way, go
0:24
to traveltexas.com slash Get Your Own
0:26
for the the only trip to Texas that matters.
0:28
Yours. Travel
0:31
is great, but planning for travel can
0:33
be time-consuming and difficult. That's where OneTravel
0:35
comes in. With OneTravel, you'll find everything
0:37
you need to book the perfect trip.
0:40
Flights, hotels, cars, transportation, it's all right
0:42
there. With OneTravel, you can book online,
0:44
via app, or even pick up the
0:47
phone and talk to a travel advisor
0:49
ready to help you make your selections.
0:51
Visit onetravel.com/music or call 855-437-2154. Plan
0:57
it. Book it. Live it. OneTravel.
1:14
What's the state of high-speed rail in
1:16
the U.S.? The rest of the world
1:18
has found a way to travel faster,
1:20
more convenient, that focuses growth around stations
1:23
and fights climate change. It's
1:25
Wednesday, May 29th. Tickets please,
1:27
tickets please. It's Science Friday. I'm
1:35
Sci-Fi producer Dee Peter Schmidt. Unlike major
1:37
countries, including Japan, China, and France, that
1:39
have invested in trains that go upwards
1:41
of 200 mph, the
1:44
U.S. does not have a high-speed rail system, even
1:46
though the country was once known for its railroads
1:48
in the 1800s. But
1:50
it looks like we're at a turning point.
1:52
California's high-speed rail project, which aims to connect
1:54
Los Angeles to San Francisco, is
1:56
well underway, and there are lots of other exciting
1:58
rail projects gaining steam. across the country. Here's
2:02
Ira with a look at some of those
2:04
undertakings and why there's been renewed investment in
2:06
rail infrastructure in the U.S. There's a
2:08
lot to talk about and here to give us
2:10
an update on high-speed rail in the U.S. and
2:12
what challenges it still faces is
2:14
my guest, Rod Derridaen, co-chair of the
2:17
U.S. High Speed Rail Association. Welcome to
2:19
Science Friday. Nice to be here. Thank
2:21
you for inviting me. You're
2:23
welcome. You know, Rod, it's so frustrating, isn't
2:25
it, to talk about high-speed rail in America?
2:27
It's almost an oxymoron. It's
2:30
not just frustrating. It's embarrassing. We travel
2:32
around the world. We see the other
2:34
countries, 18 other countries with
2:36
high-speed rail systems, and
2:38
the United States is supposed to be a world leader
2:41
dominated by the oil companies to the extent
2:43
that we haven't created
2:45
high-speed rail, which of course is electrically
2:48
powered. And why has it
2:50
taken it so long then to get these kinds
2:52
of projects going in the U.S.? We
2:54
have been wedded to the petroleum-powered
2:56
automobile for the last hundred years
2:59
and has assumed the
3:02
responsibility for our transportation requirements,
3:05
the automobile, the aircraft now,
3:08
and we just have to break that addiction
3:11
and recognize that the rest of the world
3:13
has found a way to travel faster,
3:16
more convenient, that
3:18
focuses growth around stations and fights
3:21
climate change. Yeah, so we have
3:23
chosen to go the highway route while the other
3:25
countries have gone the railroad route. That's
3:27
exactly right. Not only railroads
3:30
for longer distances, but
3:32
also using trolleys and light
3:34
rail and commuter rail and
3:36
other devices for feeder distribution
3:38
systems that really get us
3:40
away from the overcrowded highways and
3:43
the overuse of petroleum fuel. And
3:45
at what speeds do trains need
3:47
to travel to qualify as, quote,
3:50
high-speed rail? The International
3:52
High-Speed Rail Association declares that
3:54
300 kilometers per hour
3:57
is the high-speed rail Measurement
3:59
Point. And. That's a hundred
4:01
eighty six miles an hour. new, you
4:03
know, here in the Northeast where I
4:05
live. I've travelled on Amtrak many times
4:07
between Washington and Boston, and I've actually
4:10
track the speed of sobs. The Amtrak
4:12
train in the never goes more than
4:14
one hundred and twenty five. or maybe
4:16
close to one fifty at a couple
4:18
of points, so that. That doesn't
4:20
really qualify as high speed rail, though. We sort
4:22
of considerate that to be. Your. Rights
4:25
as a salah is a is the
4:27
highest speed we have an United States
4:29
or but it would not qualify as
4:31
high speeds around the world. All
4:34
right let's talk about possibly some good
4:36
news. Hairless Talk About California is high
4:39
speed rail project that has been in
4:41
the works for decades. Like I said
4:43
earlier it it aims to connect L
4:46
A to San Francisco. we just under
4:48
three hours you been closely involved in
4:50
that process over the years it's been
4:52
taking a long time. Has a not
4:55
what what is the status of that
4:57
project now. When. It's broken through
4:59
really With the help of Jerry
5:02
Brown and now Gavin Newsom who
5:04
are determined I speed rail advocates
5:06
for is broken through to the
5:09
point where it's been under construction
5:11
now since. Technically. Since
5:13
Ninety Ninety Six, but really aggressively
5:16
since About Two Thousand and Eight,
5:18
and the sister between Bakersfield and
5:20
Or said in the Central Valley.
5:23
Is. Now lot out. oh seventy
5:25
percent complete. Her. The
5:27
abbey infrastructure work is pretty
5:29
well done. A with the
5:31
decree crossings in that major interchange points in
5:34
those kinds of saints and A is expected
5:36
to be in full operation by the end
5:38
of the decade. At. That's aggressive
5:41
objective. But. It looks like is going
5:43
to be accomplished. Will have have any extensions. I mean
5:45
Cedar lines are go in and out of it. Yes
5:48
it will service to central valley which
5:50
has a couple of million people in
5:52
it so as not insignificant but it
5:54
would be. Operating with enough
5:56
so ridership to cover all of
5:58
it's operating costs. The one out
6:01
at the same time that this
6:03
has that does starter line is
6:05
being completed. The line between.
6:08
The. Central Valley and Silicon Valley is
6:10
the one that will allow us
6:12
to be and making money. Cover is
6:14
operating costs and that line. Of
6:17
from a place called Chowchilla. As
6:19
you south of are said. To. Gilroy.
6:22
Are under a dog wider range of
6:24
mountains in fact it takes of. For.
6:27
Tulsa, one of and fifteen miles
6:29
long, Under that great mountain
6:31
range. To. Have known Hamilton
6:33
Rage and it will come out near
6:36
Gilroy and join the tell train system
6:38
at Gilroy. At that point
6:40
we have a connection then between now.
6:43
And the Central Valley. And which
6:45
is the a population that likes to
6:48
commute each day terribly two and half
6:50
hours? Three hours for direction. Between.
6:52
That's an area where housing is more
6:55
affordable. And. And Silicon Valley where
6:57
the jobs are. And. That's the
6:59
market that we're really trying to tap.
7:01
And those are the people that were
7:03
trying to serve. The. Arab experience
7:05
a terrible lifestyle now where they have
7:07
to get up before the kids wake
7:09
up in the morning to and have
7:12
three and a half hours later burning
7:14
for the seven dollar a gallon gasoline
7:16
on dangerous roads. They. Arrive at
7:18
work. And. Then they're supposed to do.
7:20
A day's work and or then in
7:22
the evening they get back on those
7:25
roads and to and have three and
7:27
five hours later they get home. It.
7:29
Would that arduous trip? After the
7:31
kids are going to bed and that's a
7:33
terrible lifestyle, Instead of that, they'll be on
7:36
the high speed train going to hundred and
7:38
twenty miles an hour. From. The
7:40
Central Valley to Silicon Valley
7:42
in fifty to sixty minutes,
7:44
Having breakfast, say catching a
7:46
nap, During. A little early work
7:48
or by computer. and arriving at
7:51
work in silicon valley you with a
7:53
short commute by the ad light rail
7:55
or buses that are already been set
7:57
to stage from the from that station
8:00
The station by the way is named after me,
8:02
the Derrida station, and they'll be
8:04
at work an hour and 15 minutes after
8:06
they leave home. They reverse
8:08
that at night and they're able to get home
8:10
and maybe even watch the Little League game with
8:12
the kid. That
8:15
does sound like an ideal situation. Ira,
8:17
that's 200,000 plus people a day. 200,000
8:20
a day? Wow. They'll
8:22
be taking that trip. At that point, the
8:25
system becomes profitable in operations.
8:29
Being of profitable, I know there's a
8:31
relatively new player on the scene and
8:33
it's a private best under rail service
8:35
called Brightline. I know some listeners of
8:38
ours in Florida might have heard of
8:40
them because there is service in Florida.
8:43
Many of our listeners have not. Tell
8:45
us what Brightline is and what service
8:47
they're doing in Florida. Tell us about
8:49
the Miami to Orlando service there. Brightline
8:52
is a breath of fresh air. They may not
8:54
make all of the deadlines that they hope, but
8:56
they're doing a great job. That service
8:59
is a Brightline project. It was
9:01
a dedicated right of way
9:04
and they were able to move ahead rather
9:06
expeditiously. They're
9:08
doing well financially. I don't know whether
9:10
they're turning a profit yet on operations,
9:12
but they're coming close and
9:15
it's a way to examine for
9:18
the way forward. They're
9:20
building a route between Las Vegas and
9:22
Los Angeles? Actually, it doesn't quite
9:24
go to Los Angeles. It goes to a
9:26
place called Cucamonga. It's
9:29
the butt of many jokes because- I remember
9:31
an old Jack Benny routine that
9:34
ended in Cucamonga. There
9:38
is a town called Cucamonga. It's a nice little
9:40
town. It's a place
9:42
where the commuter line,
9:45
LA Metro, ends and
9:47
they'll be able to tap then right
9:49
into the LA metropolitan transportation system. They're
9:52
a little bit of a different kind
9:54
of transportation system than the California system.
9:57
They're going to be in the middle of a freeway. The
10:00
right of way all dedicated to them by given
10:02
to them by the state. And. At
10:04
they're going to have some interchanges to
10:06
a circle That but other than that
10:09
it said they don't have to worry
10:11
about the land use and utility issues.
10:14
And at the Greenfield construction of California
10:16
I see real is already. Yes it.
10:18
but they're moving ahead quickly. They.
10:20
Have some private funding. It's nice
10:22
to have those folks in Las
10:24
Vegas and supporting you and day.
10:27
There's. Expected be an operation
10:29
by Ron Twenty Thirty. The
10:31
California project is what's called a
10:33
greenfield project. And. The words:
10:36
It has to go through areas where
10:38
there are not current transportation systems and
10:40
that makes it much more complicated. Have
10:42
to negotiate was over two thousand different
10:45
little farmers and landowners and and it's
10:47
just takes an awful long time. Many
10:50
of them and don't want to settle
10:52
quickly because we go through eminent domain
10:54
and and fight it does. You.
10:56
Reduce your tax burdens and so
10:58
there's every encouragement to delay. And.
11:01
Of course behind the scenes he we
11:03
have the oil companies who are attempting
11:05
to delay the project Also. Because.
11:08
As soon as high speed rail goes
11:10
into effect to sort out, their lines
11:12
between those served cities are no longer
11:15
profitable. And as in Europe
11:17
and France is just outlawed. short
11:19
hop airlines between cities that are
11:22
served by high speed rail. Interesting
11:24
So of Us companies are certainly
11:26
not very happy with size speed
11:28
rail system. Speaking. Of
11:31
the trip from Vegas to L
11:33
A, let's talk about be total
11:35
commute time. Bright Line says on
11:37
it's website that the trip between
11:39
Vegas to Rancho Cucamonga will be
11:41
just two hours and ten minutes.
11:43
How does that compare to a
11:45
car or a plane. Had
11:47
two hours and ten minutes but then
11:49
have to either agile Glenda, that Ted
11:51
that is. It's certainly all lot better
11:54
than driving by car at all. He
11:56
is a lot better on the people
11:58
littered are taking a trip. My.
12:00
To in terms of climate change
12:02
show putting people in an electrically
12:05
powered I speed train where there
12:07
is no pollution virtually no pollution
12:09
is a great step forward than
12:11
having people I sort out their
12:13
line or car will be of
12:15
which are the most polluting devices
12:17
on a seat mile basis. We
12:20
been talking about California in Florida,
12:22
but I understand there are some
12:24
other region in the Us. That
12:27
are planning for high speed rail
12:29
that you're excited about The city
12:31
pairs that are too long to
12:33
drive between, but too short to
12:35
justify a plane trip? Tell us
12:37
about those. Why they it's specifically
12:39
especially in the Pacific Northwest and
12:41
then in Texas town. Talk about
12:43
those. The largest area
12:45
that said looking at it now
12:48
Chicago and are several are outside
12:50
of Chicago to St Louis said
12:52
that are under consideration and and
12:54
big studied and upgraded. From
12:57
current day systems. Are,
12:59
but the new high speed rail projects
13:01
that are being under the under consideration
13:03
are really moving I had now are
13:05
the north west corner. And. That's
13:07
from most Seattle down to. Portland.
13:10
And maybe on down to Eugene. And
13:13
and the Texas Triangle though is
13:15
that movie gad they were ahead
13:17
of of of everybody else. And
13:19
then the. The governor
13:21
of at last gov stop the project
13:24
and now it's moving ahead again. Gradually
13:26
the Florida project had been way ahead
13:28
of everybody else and and they were
13:31
stopped by their governor and they they
13:33
had received quite a nice grant from.
13:36
The. Obama administration and and they gave
13:38
that money back. By. German,
13:40
the seller quarter as great potential
13:42
to upgrade some of their track
13:44
to high speed rail. They're going
13:46
to have to change their rolling
13:49
stock to be electrically powered. A
13:51
high speed rail trains that they have
13:53
the market. And have the opportunity to
13:56
and will they had very very quickly. when
13:58
it comes to family the decent There are
14:00
a million different trips you can take. You
14:02
can get your own trip to Texas. Or
14:10
if you prefer a vacation from your family,
14:12
you can always get your own leave
14:14
the kids with grandma trip
14:17
to Texas. So
14:19
go to traveltexas.com/get your own for the
14:22
only trip to Texas that matters, yours.
14:29
Travel is great, but planning for travel
14:31
can be time consuming and difficult. That's
14:33
where OneTravel comes in. With OneTravel, you'll
14:35
find everything you need to book the
14:38
perfect trip. Flights, hotels, cars, transportation. It's
14:40
all right there. With OneTravel, you can
14:42
book online, via app, or even pick
14:44
up the phone and talk to a
14:47
travel advisor ready to help you make
14:49
your selections. Visit one travel.com/music or call
14:51
855-437-2154. Plan
14:55
it, book it, live it. OneTravel.
15:00
If you think Taco Bell is only for late
15:02
night, you are mistaken. Taco Bell is also for
15:04
daytime, which is why it's introducing the
15:06
new Cantina Chicken menu, with new
15:09
Cantina Chicken tacos, burrito, and quesadilla.
15:11
And new ingredients like seasoned slow roasted
15:13
chicken, freshly prepared pico de gallo, shredded
15:15
purple cabbage, and even a new avocado
15:17
verde salsa package. Get to Taco Bell
15:20
for when it's not late night. Whoa,
15:22
that is late. Try the new Cantina Chicken
15:24
menu now. A participating
15:26
Taco Bell location was provided by Panic Store for
15:29
participation only. Carnegie
15:33
Hall is one of the most famous concert venues
15:35
in the world. The first time I walked on
15:38
the stage, I felt like my feet were moving,
15:40
but they were not touching the floor. Join
15:42
us for If This Hall Could Talk, a
15:45
new podcast that explores the history of this
15:47
iconic landmark through the unique items in its
15:49
archives. I'm your host, Jessica Vosk,
15:51
and together we'll explore how the past shaped the
15:53
culture we live in today. Listen
15:55
to If This Hall Could Talk wherever you get
15:57
podcasts. Do
16:02
you feel there has been a
16:06
shift in the thinking about expanding rail
16:08
system in the U.S.? I
16:11
think the shift has been dramatic over the
16:13
last several years. People
16:15
have begun to travel around the world and
16:18
there are 18 countries, all of the advanced
16:20
countries and many of the emerging countries now
16:22
have high speed rail. And
16:24
they're replacing those short hop airlines that cause
16:26
all the pollution and use all that petroleum
16:29
and make the noise and so on with
16:31
the high speed rail trains. And
16:35
as we travel around the world, the Americans
16:37
travel a lot, we see
16:39
these other countries serve so wonderfully.
16:42
For example, China, they have 27,000 miles of
16:44
235 mile an hour high speed trains and
16:51
they've shifted much of their
16:54
passenger and some of their freight
16:56
work to over to the high
16:58
speed rail systems which are non
17:00
polluting. They don't
17:02
require the diesel fuel that
17:04
the old trains do and
17:07
get you there much faster and more conveniently.
17:10
Yeah. And I imagine that the
17:12
cities would benefit from all the
17:14
jobs that they would create building
17:16
the rail system and not just
17:18
making it easier for commuters. Well,
17:21
it will be a new boom in probably
17:24
organized labor work. Remember
17:27
when the original railroads were built
17:29
in America, it was the
17:31
birth of the middle class because that's
17:34
when organized labor really began
17:36
to be involved with the
17:39
railroad unions and building everything from the
17:41
tracks to operating the trains and running
17:43
the depots and providing the
17:45
insurance and all of the rest. At
17:48
one point, 40% of the jobs in the
17:50
United States were associated with the railroads.
17:53
Now we're going back into that boom period
17:55
for railroads again. And
17:57
it'll be helpful to everybody from the...
18:00
that cleans out the cars to
18:03
the person riding. Wow. As
18:06
you say, you have a
18:08
transit station named after you in
18:10
San Jose. Are you hoping that
18:12
your grandchildren are going to be
18:14
riding the high speed rail? Well,
18:17
I'd love to be able to do it myself, but
18:19
at 85, that's nip and tuck. But
18:22
I have four grandchildren who I
18:24
know will ride that train and
18:26
remember grandpa. And more
18:29
importantly, I have four grandchildren that
18:31
will have a better chance at having a
18:33
good life because we shifted
18:36
people away from automobiles and buses
18:38
and airplanes
18:41
onto electrically powered
18:43
trains and maybe save
18:45
the environment a bit. Well, Rod,
18:47
we wish you, your family and everybody else in
18:49
the train business good luck and we'll be rooting
18:52
and watching along with you. Thank you for taking time
18:54
to be with us today. Ira,
18:56
thank you so much for looking into this issue.
18:59
The future of the world depends on us moving
19:01
over to electric power. Thank you.
19:04
Rod Dyridon is co-chair of the
19:06
US High Speed Rail Association. That's
19:09
all the time we have for today. Lots of folks help make
19:11
the show happen, including Jordan Smudgik,
19:13
Rasha Uridi, Charles Bergquist,
19:15
Shoshana Buckshdown. Next time, we'll take a
19:17
look at the growing field of medicine
19:20
trying to better understand how we age
19:22
using our metabolism. I'm Sci-fi
19:24
producer Dee Peterschmidt. See you then. Travel
19:29
is great, but planning for travel can
19:32
be time-consuming and difficult. That's where OneTravel
19:34
comes in. With OneTravel, you'll find everything
19:36
you need to book the perfect trip.
19:38
Flights, hotels, cars, transportation, it's all right
19:41
there. With OneTravel, you can book online,
19:43
via app, or even pick up the
19:45
phone and talk to a travel advisor
19:47
ready to help you make your selections.
19:50
Visit onetravel.com/music or call 855-437-2154. Plan
19:55
it. Book it. Live it. OneTravel.
20:00
Save big money on your next
20:02
project right now at Menards. Champion
20:04
Power Equipment is a leader in
20:06
power generation equipment with durable and
20:09
dependable generators and inverters. They're ultra
20:11
quiet and ideal for camping, tailgating,
20:13
and keeping your family safe during
20:15
power outages. Save big money on
20:17
Champion generators and inverters. Visit us
20:19
in-store and menards.com and see all
20:22
the great deals going on now
20:24
in our weekly flyer. you
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More