Podchaser Logo
Home
Election Surprises and a Surprise Election in Europe

Election Surprises and a Surprise Election in Europe

Released Monday, 10th June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Election Surprises and a Surprise Election in Europe

Election Surprises and a Surprise Election in Europe

Election Surprises and a Surprise Election in Europe

Election Surprises and a Surprise Election in Europe

Monday, 10th June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

This message comes from NPR sponsor

0:02

Spectrum Business, who understands that small

0:05

business owners do it all. That's

0:07

why Spectrum Business provides internet, phone,

0:09

TV, and mobile packages just for

0:11

small businesses. Find one that works

0:13

for you at spectrum.com-business. Today

0:18

on State of the World, election surprises

0:20

and a surprise election in

0:23

Europe. You're

0:27

listening to State of the World from NPR, the

0:29

day's most vital international stories up close

0:31

where they're happening. It's Monday, June 10th.

0:34

I'm Greg Dixon. In Europe,

0:36

the far rate made big gains in

0:38

the European parliament. 27

0:41

countries went to the polls over the weekend,

0:43

and while the center party still has a

0:45

majority, it is much smaller now. Here's

0:48

European Commission President Ursula von der

0:50

Leyen. The center is

0:52

holding, but it is also

0:54

true that the extremes on

0:56

the left and on the right have

0:58

gained support. And this

1:01

is why the result comes

1:03

with great responsibility for

1:05

the parties in the center. To

1:08

understand the implications of this shift,

1:10

NPR's Mary Louise Kelly talked to

1:12

Constanza Stelzenmuller. She's a senior fellow

1:14

at the Brookings Institution and a

1:16

European security expert. These are elections

1:18

for the European parliament, which is

1:21

the legislative organ of the European Union,

1:23

but they're managed by the member states

1:25

and they're contested by national political parties,

1:27

which always means that all

1:30

these elections are also referendums on

1:32

incumbent governments, right? And those

1:34

referendums were particularly severe in

1:36

France and in Germany. In

1:39

France, in fact, the hard right, Rasson-Lebon

1:42

National Party of Marine Le Pen,

1:45

the leader of the opposition

1:47

to President Macron, swept

1:49

the country, literally. And

1:52

Macron immediately dissolved

1:54

the national parliament and

1:56

called new elections on July 7th.

2:00

And there is a distinct possibility

2:02

that that will end up with

2:04

a hard-right prime minister, still

2:07

under President Macron, in the form of Marine

2:10

de Pen, making

2:12

for very fraught French politics. Making

2:14

him something of a lame duck

2:16

president. Possibly. Because of the

2:18

presidential system, he still has considerable powers.

2:20

But it will make for fraught national

2:22

politics, and it will make for a

2:25

president who has been very forward-leaning, for

2:27

example, on Ukraine, against

2:31

a prime minister whose parties has

2:33

been notably pro-Russian in its

2:35

pronouncements. That could make for some very

2:37

fraught tension going forward. And then

2:39

in Germany, where you are, where it's your

2:41

read on the situation there? And in Germany,

2:43

it's slightly more complicated, because it's always more

2:46

complicated. You are German,

2:48

so you're allowed to say that, yes. It's a form

2:50

of national narcissism, I guess. So

2:52

we have a fraught center-left

2:54

traffic light three-way coalition under

2:56

Chancellor Olaf Schatz, which has

2:58

been struggling for a variety

3:00

of reasons. And the

3:03

European Parliament elections put the

3:07

center-right opposition leader of the

3:09

CDU firmly in first place,

3:12

and the extreme-right AFD in

3:14

second place, ahead of

3:16

every one of the three

3:18

parties of the traffic

3:21

light coalition, including the Social

3:23

Democrats of Chancellor Schatz. That

3:25

is terrible. And

3:29

the Greens especially got

3:31

a trouncing. They lost 8.6%. That

3:35

is a very bad report card for a

3:37

government that was really helping to get a

3:39

bit of a fillip ahead of very difficult

3:41

state elections in the fall, in

3:43

September, and then national elections a year

3:46

later. So understanding

3:49

that it is difficult, indeed

3:51

impossible, to generalize across a

3:53

continent, what are the issues

3:55

driving this? Is this about immigration? Is

3:58

it about war, the economy? What? all

4:00

of the above. Also about

4:02

climate change. And I

4:04

think there's a generalized anxiety about

4:06

Europe's strategic exposure at a

4:09

time when the

4:11

Russians are waging war on the

4:13

continent, when the Chinese are interfering

4:15

in European politics, and when it

4:19

seems unclear what

4:21

the outcome of the US election will be. The

4:25

cooperation between Europeans and the

4:27

Biden administration has

4:30

been unusually harmonious, especially

4:32

on supporting Ukraine. But

4:35

I think most of Europe still has

4:37

PTSD with regard

4:40

to the four years of the Trump administration,

4:42

and is dreading more of the

4:44

same or worse. Stay with that for

4:46

a minute. What might this portend for

4:49

the US? Americans listening might recall the

4:51

vote back in 2016 for Brexit in

4:53

the UK, the shift to the right

4:55

in the UK, and then six months

4:57

later, Donald Trump won the

4:59

presidency here in the US. I

5:01

think it would be stretching Europe's

5:03

influence a tad too far to

5:06

suggest that what happens in Europe

5:08

has consequences for American political elections,

5:10

presidential elections especially. Although those same

5:12

issues are driving voters here, immigration,

5:14

the economy, wars. That's certainly correct.

5:16

Hard right groupings in America and

5:18

in Europe are watching each other very

5:20

closely. See each other

5:22

as mutual enablers are encouraged by

5:25

each other's successes. And

5:27

of course, what many of them

5:29

have in common is a distinct

5:32

sympathy for autocrats and authoritarian

5:34

governments, such as those in

5:36

Russia and in China. You

5:38

know, as you watch the main

5:40

headline here, voters in Europe

5:42

shifting to the right, do

5:44

you hear champagne corks popping in

5:47

the Kremlin? I think we can

5:49

assume that given the amount of

5:51

disinformation and disruption that was clearly

5:54

coming from Russia during

5:56

the election campaign period.

5:58

And that was

6:00

clearly trying to

6:02

confuse voters, trying to

6:05

put them off incumbent

6:07

governments and push them

6:09

towards more extremist parties. But I

6:12

also want to say this. The

6:15

external authoritarian

6:17

interference only

6:20

exploits vulnerabilities that are already there.

6:23

Right? And those vulnerabilities on us,

6:25

they are on democratic governments in

6:27

Europe that are struggling

6:29

to solve crucial problems of

6:31

government, such as climate

6:33

change, such as migration, such

6:36

as economic stability. That's

6:38

on us and it's only being

6:40

exploited by the others. Constanze

6:42

Stelzenmuller, director of the Center on

6:44

the US and Europe at the

6:47

Brookings Institution, we reached her in

6:49

Munich. Thank you. My pleasure as always,

6:51

Mary Louise. Thank you. As we

6:53

just heard in France, President Emmanuel Macron

6:55

reacted to his party's massive loss by

6:58

dissolving the French parliament, calling new elections

7:00

in a bid to get stronger backing

7:02

for his remaining three years as president.

7:05

The move stunned the country. And

7:08

Paris' Eleanor Beardsley brings us reactions

7:10

from Paris. About an

7:12

hour after European Parliament results showed President

7:14

Emmanuel Macron's party with 15

7:16

percent of the vote and far-right leader

7:19

Marine Le Pen's with 32 percent, he

7:21

dropped the bomb on national television. The

7:23

party of French candidates, the

7:26

representatives of the current president

7:28

of the French Supreme Court.

7:31

I always considered a strong, independent and

7:33

united Europe a good thing for France,

7:35

said Macron, so I cannot accept this.

7:37

Macron said he was acting to clarify

7:39

France's ambitions and give the French people

7:42

the choice of their parliamentary future through

7:44

the vote. The two-round poll will take

7:46

place June 30 and July 7. This

7:51

morning in Montmartre, 21-year-old geography student Louis

7:53

Grusé was talking with a friend

7:55

as they stood under his umbrella.

7:57

He says Macron's move was massive.

8:00

Yes, it's quite massive, but... So are you

8:03

worried about what will happen? Yeah, I'm quite worried, yeah. But

8:07

I think that we must

8:10

to fight them. The younger

8:14

must vote, and I think

8:16

that it's really, really important. Grusé

8:18

says the French are in shock

8:20

with the far-right Rassomblement Nationale or

8:22

National Rally Party now at the

8:24

doors to power. Many

8:27

wonder if Macron will be able to stop

8:29

the unthinkable. Douglas Weber, who

8:31

teaches political science at French business school

8:33

in Sied, isn't sure he will. I

8:36

regard this being a very,

8:38

very risky maneuver, and

8:41

I think it's one that's more than

8:43

likely to backfire. It's really quite likely

8:45

that the Rassomblement Nationale will get either

8:47

a relative or an absolute majority at

8:49

the end of the day in the

8:51

parliamentary elections. If that

8:53

were to happen, France would have divided

8:55

government, what's known as cohabitation, and Macron's

8:58

prime minister would be from the hostile

9:00

opposition. Traditionally, French voters

9:02

of all stripes have always come together

9:04

to block the far-right from power, like

9:06

in 2002 when Marine Le Pen's father

9:09

Jean-Marie Le Pen made it to the

9:11

second round of the presidential election. But

9:13

Montmartre shopkeeper Antony Bovet doesn't think

9:16

that will happen this time. Macron

9:20

is playing his last hand in poker, but

9:22

this time I think he's going to lose.

9:24

We already voted for him twice

9:26

in the last two presidential elections, many just

9:28

to block her. I believe we're

9:30

going to see the far-right in power for the first time.

9:35

A busker plays an accordion in the Paris Metro. Forty-year-old

9:38

lawyer David Bergamo is coming home from

9:40

work. He says

9:42

many people who vote for the far-right are afraid to

9:44

say so, but he's not. We

9:47

ride the Metro in tall. We

9:51

can't keep opening our borders and

9:54

welcoming people. We have no

9:56

more work. Factories are closing. French

9:58

humanism is over. We can't

10:01

afford it. France's political landscape

10:03

is extremely fragmented after its

10:05

mainstream right and left parties

10:07

imploded several years ago. Macron's

10:10

party is fracturing. France is

10:12

entering a period of uncertainty

10:14

rarely seen before. Eleanor Beersley,

10:17

NPR News, Paris. That's

10:23

the state of the world from NPR. Thanks

10:25

for listening. Last year, over 20,000

10:27

people joined the

10:30

Body Electric Study to change

10:32

their sedentary, screen-filled lives. And

10:34

guess what? We saw amazing effects.

10:37

Now you can try NPR's Body

10:40

Electric Challenge yourself. Listen

10:42

to updated and new episodes wherever

10:44

you get your podcasts. This

10:59

message comes from NPR sponsor, Viore. This

11:07

message comes from NPR sponsor, Viore.

11:09

Jump into a new perspective on

11:12

performance apparel. Viore makes products

11:14

that stand the test of time

11:16

and hope to inspire others to

11:18

live vibrant, healthy lives, empowering your

11:21

best life in clothing that can

11:23

be worn for just about any

11:25

activity from running to yoga. Visit

11:27

viore.com/NPR to receive 20% off

11:30

your first purchase and enjoy free shipping

11:32

on any US orders over. Discover

11:35

the versatility of Viore clothing.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features