Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:01
Welcome to Stuff You Missed in History
0:03
Class from how Stuff Works dot Com.
0:12
Hello and welcome to the podcast.
0:14
I'm Tracy V. Wilson and I'm Holly
0:16
Fry. Still in our favorite month of the year,
0:18
October, Yes,
0:21
Halloween season, and so we
0:23
have an episode that I know a
0:26
lot of people have requested that the only person
0:28
I wrote down was Betty, So thank you Betty
0:30
and everyone that I forgot to write down
0:32
in addition to Betty. It is
0:34
a topic that was written about in the
0:37
twelfth and thirteen centuries as a
0:39
factual thing that really happened,
0:41
but some people today classify at more as folklore.
0:44
And it is the green children of Woolpit
0:47
who made a really eerie appearance
0:49
in Suffolk, England in the twelfth
0:51
century. We accidentally have a little
0:53
theme of like odd happenings in England
0:56
at the beginning of this season.
0:59
We're kicking off with weird English stuff
1:01
apparently, and by
1:03
today's standards. The village of Wolpit
1:05
is quite small, with a population of
1:08
only about two thousand people traveling
1:10
by car. It's a couple of hours northeast of
1:12
London. That's about thirty six miles
1:15
or fifty eight kilometers east of Cambridge,
1:17
and in the twelfth century the area was not
1:19
exactly bustling, but it was more densely
1:21
populated than much of rural England, and
1:24
it was a thriving agricultural center.
1:26
So, according to the story, one day
1:29
in Woolpit, two children, a
1:31
boy and a girl, emerged from a series
1:33
of pits that were used for trapping wolves.
1:36
These these wolf pits,
1:38
and not the fabric of wool
1:41
are where Wolpit gets its name, is
1:43
named after wolf pits. There
1:46
are two chronicles of this event
1:48
and what happened after these two children appeared.
1:51
One is by Ralph Abbot of Cogschal,
1:54
who wrote his explanation of what happened
1:56
as part of the Chronicon Anglicanum,
1:59
and the other is by William of Newburgh
2:01
and the Historia Rerum Anglicarum,
2:04
or the History of English Affairs, and
2:07
both men wrote these accounts in Latin.
2:10
A translation of William's version by Joseph
2:12
Stevenson is part of a truly colossal
2:15
set of volumes called The Church Historians
2:17
of England, which was published in eighteen fifty
2:19
three and is available online archive
2:22
dot org if you want to check it out. Stevenson
2:25
translated Ralph's version two, but we couldn't
2:27
find that part of the Chronicon anglican
2:29
Um in English online. So
2:32
instead of subjecting everyone to Ralph's Latin,
2:34
shoved through Google Translate, which is a
2:36
hilarious activity if you ever want to want
2:39
to get some comedy in your life. We're
2:41
going to read Stevenson's translation of
2:43
William's version. I did, indeed
2:46
of Ralph's Latin version through Google
2:48
Translate, and that was my amusement
2:50
for a good chunk of afternoon. Before
2:54
we get to William's version of this story,
2:56
though, I want to have a brief digression about
2:58
Joseph Stevenson because he is character.
3:01
He was the son of a surgeon, but he also
3:03
helped his uncle out in his job as a
3:05
smuggler. In his youth, he was
3:07
not particularly a good student either.
3:10
While he was enrolled at a grammar school that
3:12
was attached to Durham Cathedral, for
3:14
some reason, he was keeping a loaded pistol
3:17
among his possessions, which went off
3:19
while being handled by a servant,
3:21
and according to the Oxford Dictionary
3:23
of National Biography, that that
3:25
had quote dramatic, although
3:28
not grave, consequences I
3:30
feel like a tea set must have been
3:32
destroyed and
3:35
other things as well. It gave no detail,
3:37
but it makes it sound like Fortunately no one was
3:39
harmed in this accidental discharge
3:41
of a firearm, but there was some dramatic
3:44
incident. And in spite
3:46
of this checkered background, Stevenson
3:48
wound up working at the British Museum.
3:50
He married and he had two children, and
3:52
then he changed courses to join
3:54
the clergy after he was traumatized
3:57
by the death of his brother. He became
3:59
a pre east after the death of his wife.
4:01
So where we come around to these monumental
4:04
volumes of translated works
4:06
of history. He turned out to really have a knack
4:08
for translating and editing historical
4:11
documents. He did a lot of work for
4:13
the Historical Manuscript's Commission. He
4:15
put together a bunch of different gigantic collections
4:17
of historical documents for various different
4:20
clubs and historical societies.
4:22
These ranged from four to eight
4:24
volumes in length. Some of them
4:27
were these gargantia wine editions of old
4:29
religious and secular histories. And this was
4:31
just his thing. Apparently
4:33
he was also extremely personable
4:35
and generous as well. So
4:37
this is the guy that did the translation of the thing
4:39
that we're about to read. Yeah. Worthy of
4:42
a little mini biography there for sure. Uh
4:44
And back to the story. In Stevenson's
4:47
translation, William begins
4:49
his account by saying that it doesn't seem right
4:51
to skip over the story of the Green Children,
4:54
but at the same time he had some doubts
4:56
about the matter. It seemed
4:58
both ridiculous and serious. But
5:01
at the same time he had heard about it from so
5:03
many people, all of them very
5:05
respectable and competent, that he was
5:07
quote compelled to believe.
5:10
I feel like this is a twelfth century
5:12
version of the X Files poster.
5:16
I know, well, it's also a great that couching
5:18
that happens for spooky stories. And like, I
5:21
know, this is ridiculous, but there
5:23
are enough reasonable people to believe it that
5:25
there must be truth in it. Yes,
5:28
So we are going to read his whole account
5:30
because I love it and I want to share it with all
5:32
of you. And it's a bit long, So we are
5:34
going to take turns, as we recently
5:37
did when we talked about the
5:39
Devil's hoof prints. We took turns on a rather
5:41
lengthy passage. That's so what we're going to do again today. So
5:43
he he got into the story, saying,
5:46
in East Anglia, there's a village
5:48
distant, as it is said, four or
5:50
five miles from the noble monastery
5:53
of the Blessed King and Martyr Edmund.
5:55
Near this place are seen some very
5:57
ancient cavities called wolf
6:00
pits, that in English
6:02
pits for wolves, and which give
6:04
their name to the adjacent village. During
6:07
harvest, while the reapers were employed
6:09
in gathering the produce of the fields, two
6:11
children, a boy and a girl, completely
6:14
green in their persons and clad
6:16
in garments of a strange color and unknown
6:19
materials, emerged from
6:21
these excavations while
6:24
wandering through the fields in astonishment.
6:26
They were seized by the reapers and conducted
6:29
to the village, and many persons coming
6:31
to see so novel a sight. They
6:33
were kept some days without food, But
6:36
when they were nearly exhausted with hunger and
6:38
yet could relish no species of support
6:41
which was offered to them, it happened
6:43
that some beans were brought in from the field,
6:46
which they immediately seized with avidity
6:48
and examined the stock for the pulse, but
6:51
not finding it in the hollow of the stock,
6:53
they wept bitterly. Upon
6:56
this, one of the bystandards, taking
6:58
the beans from the pods, offered them
7:00
to the children, who seized them directly
7:02
and ate them with pleasure. This
7:05
next sentence is my favorite sentence, and the
7:07
entire thing by this food.
7:09
They were supported for many months until
7:12
they learned the use of bread. At
7:17
length by degrees, they changed their
7:19
original color through the natural
7:21
effect of our food, and became like ourselves,
7:24
and also learned our language. It seemed
7:26
fitting to certain discreet persons
7:28
that they should receive the sacrament of baptism,
7:31
which was administered accordingly. The
7:34
boy, who appeared to be the younger, surviving
7:37
his baptism but a little time, died
7:39
prematurely. His sister,
7:41
however, continued in good health and
7:44
differed not in the least from the women of our own
7:46
country. Afterwards,
7:48
as it is reported, she was married at
7:50
Lynne, and was living a few years since,
7:53
at least, so they say.
7:55
Moreover, after they had acquired
7:57
our language, on being asked who
8:00
and whence they were, they are said
8:02
to have replied, we are inhabitants
8:04
of the land of St. Martin, who was regarded
8:06
with peculiar veneration in the country
8:09
which gave us birth. Being further
8:11
asked where that land was and how they
8:13
came thence hither they answered,
8:16
we are ignorant of both these circumstances,
8:19
and we only remember this that on
8:21
a certain day, when we were feeding our father's
8:23
flocks in the fields, we heard a great
8:25
sound, such as we are now accustomed
8:27
to hear at St. Edmund's when the
8:29
bells are charming. And whilst
8:32
listening to the sound and admiration,
8:34
we became, on a sudden, as it were
8:36
entranced, and found ourselves among
8:39
you in the fields where you were reaping.
8:42
Being questioned whether in that land
8:44
they believed in Christ or whether the sun
8:46
arose, they replied that the country
8:49
was Christian and possessed churches.
8:51
But said, they quote, the sun does
8:54
not rise upon our countrymen. Our
8:56
land is little cheered by its beams.
8:58
We are contented with that twilight which
9:01
among you precedes the sunrise
9:03
or follows the sunset. Moreover,
9:06
a certain luminous country is seeing not
9:08
far distant from ours, and divided
9:10
from it by a very considerable river.
9:13
These and many other matters too numerous
9:16
to particularize. They are said to have recounted
9:18
to curious inquirers, let
9:21
everyone say as he pleases and
9:23
reason on such matters according to his abilities.
9:26
I feel no regret at having recorded
9:29
an event so prodigious and miraculous.
9:32
So that's the story. I know. Obviously
9:34
they were asked a whole lot of other questions, but it
9:36
tickles me that the ones that he was compelled to
9:38
write down here were do you believe
9:41
in Christ? And also does the sun exist
9:43
there? Uh?
9:46
Yeah, maybe they thought they were from another planet
9:48
the realm that's gonna come up. Yeah,
9:51
they're from Saturn. Clearly. Obviously
9:53
we're gonna take a quick break before
9:55
we get into some of the historical
9:58
elements that really eight
10:00
to this story.
10:07
Overall, Williams and Ralph's versions
10:09
of what happened with these Green children are
10:12
consistent with each other, although Williams is
10:14
a little bit longer and it has a few more details.
10:17
Both agreed that the children were taken to the home
10:19
of Lord Richard de Cown, who lived in
10:21
Whites, which is about six miles to the north
10:23
of a little pit. Williams mentioned
10:26
of this isn't a footnote, which we didn't
10:28
read, which is why it probably does not ring a bell. They
10:31
both talk about the children having green skin
10:33
and only eating beans, and eventually
10:35
assimilating with the rest of the community, with
10:38
the brother dying sometime after being baptized,
10:41
and unlike in the version we read, though, Ralph
10:43
makes it sound as though only the sister lived
10:45
long enough to tell their story. He
10:48
doesn't mention a particular name for where
10:50
they came from, and there's no certain luminous
10:52
country that they could see from their home. There's
10:55
also a slight difference in the two accounts concerning
10:57
how the children claimed that they came to be
11:00
in Wolpit. We read in William's
11:02
version that they had been tending the flocks before hearing
11:04
a loud noise, quotes such as we are now
11:07
accustomed to hear at St. Edmunds when the bells
11:09
are chiming, but they didn't otherwise
11:11
know how they had wound up in Wolpit. Ralph,
11:13
on the other hand, said the children reported
11:16
that they had become disoriented while tending
11:18
cattle, and they got lost, and then they
11:20
followed the sound of chiming bells
11:23
through a long series of underground passages
11:25
before emerge emerging from a cave
11:28
near Wolpit. So bells are involved in both
11:30
of them in a slightly different way.
11:33
One is sort of like they're hoping to get
11:36
home theoretically right, and
11:38
the other is just that they the bells
11:40
put them in some odd mental state, that
11:43
they went into a fugue state and traveled to
11:45
Wolpit. Yes, okay. The
11:47
two accounts do diverge in what happened
11:49
to the surviving sister of the pair as well.
11:52
So we read in William's account that she married a
11:54
man living in Lynn, but Ralph says
11:56
that she became a servant in Lord Richard de Cown's
11:59
house and of there for many years, not
12:02
necessarily happily, though he calls her
12:04
quote very wanton and impudent. Regardless,
12:08
William indicates that she was still living
12:10
when he wrote his chronicle down, and
12:12
there's been some discussion about exactly
12:15
when in the twelfth century this event might
12:17
have happened. William of
12:19
Newburgh lived from roughly eleven thirty
12:21
six to eleven His
12:23
version was probably written down towards
12:26
the end of his life. Ralph's
12:28
version made it into print after William's death
12:30
sometime around twelve twenty, so a
12:32
lot of times we think, okay, the later account
12:35
is probably not quite as accurate,
12:37
but even though Ralph's version was
12:39
written down later, he actually lived
12:41
a lot closer to Woolpit than William
12:44
did, and he said he had learned the story directly
12:46
from Lord Richard to count himself um,
12:49
whereas William was hearing
12:51
it all at least second hand. And
12:54
William notes that it was at harvest
12:56
time during the reign of King Stephen, which
12:59
was from five to eleven fifty
13:01
four. Ralph, on the other hand,
13:03
says that it took place during the reign of his
13:05
successor, Henry the Second, which was from
13:07
eleven fifty four to eleven eighty nine.
13:10
Author and archaeologist Brian Haughton
13:12
points out that there's no mention of the children
13:15
in the Anglo Saxon Chronicle, which
13:17
documents English history up until Stephen's
13:20
death and includes a number of other
13:22
odd and wondrous stories. It's
13:24
certainly possible that the Green Children aren't
13:26
in the Anglo Saxon Chronicle because its authors
13:28
didn't know about it or just didn't think it
13:30
needed to be included. But if it's
13:32
not included because it hadn't happened yet,
13:35
that would put the time frame into Henry the
13:37
Second's reign rather than Stevens,
13:40
and regarding William's notation of it being
13:42
harvest time, the beans that they were eating
13:44
would have been broad beans, which are more
13:46
commonly known as s fava beans in the United States.
13:49
Those were picked around July in August,
13:51
so that's the approximate time of year,
13:54
and there is a lot to suggest that something
13:57
really did happen. The two
13:59
accounts seemed who have been written completely
14:01
independently of one another, and although
14:03
William does a bit of protesting about how
14:05
he knows that this story sounds unbelievable,
14:08
both men wrote as though they were documenting
14:11
a real event that actually happened.
14:13
At the same time, when both men were writing
14:16
purportedly mystical, supernatural
14:18
and miraculous events were a lot more likely
14:20
to be accepted at face value than they might
14:22
be today. It was pretty much
14:25
normal to write down something as odd as
14:27
two green children crawling out of a wolf pit
14:29
and just accepting the idea that something
14:32
supernatural was at work without
14:34
really having to examine it further. The
14:36
story of the Green Children of Wolpit definitely
14:39
stuck around into the thirteenth century,
14:41
and from there it became a little more obscure
14:44
outside the immediate area until the late
14:46
fifteen hundreds, when the first
14:48
printed edition of Williams Historia
14:51
Rim and Glacaram came out. A
14:53
new edition that came out in sixteen ten
14:55
also included Ralph's version to
14:57
the story as a compliments to Williams. With
15:00
that it started making more appearances
15:03
in written works by other authors, who
15:05
sometimes got understandably confused
15:07
about which version was Ralph's and which
15:09
which version was Williams. I in fact,
15:11
got few confused about that repeatedly
15:14
when working on this podcast. It's
15:16
easy to do retellings
15:19
of the story from the fifteenth century and
15:21
beyond. Also, we're not usually quite
15:23
as credulous as Ralph and William had
15:25
been. William Camden writing
15:27
in his work Britannia in six
15:29
is one example. Here's his description,
15:32
and I wish I could share all of the delightful
15:35
spelling in his description with everyone. It's
15:37
pretty great. It's pretty awesome. Wolp.
15:39
It is a market town which meant
15:42
merchant and soundeth as much
15:44
as the wolves Pit. And
15:46
if we may believe new Brigensis,
15:49
who had told as pretty and formal
15:51
a tale of the place as is that fable
15:54
called the True Narration of Lucian,
15:56
namely how two little boys
15:58
for suits of green color hand
16:00
of satyrs kind after they had made
16:02
a long journey by passages underground,
16:05
from out of another world, from
16:08
the antipoties in St. Martin's land,
16:10
came up here of whom you would
16:12
know more repair to the author himself,
16:15
where you will find such a matter as will
16:17
make you laugh, your phil if
16:19
you have a laughing spleen. I
16:22
feel like I definitely have a laughing spleen. I
16:24
think so yet that we
16:26
have um made that prognosis.
16:29
That's official. I will call my family doctor uh.
16:32
Newbrigensis was a name for William
16:35
of Newburgh. The quote True Narration
16:37
of Lucian is a second century
16:39
satire by Lucian of sam Asada
16:42
which details a trip to the moon that would
16:44
rival our great Moon Hoax episode. There's
16:47
a whole bit about men with dogs heads
16:49
that fight from winged acorns, and
16:52
flees as big as twelve elephants. Oh, that's
16:54
terrifying, and warriors armed
16:56
with radishes flung from slings. I
16:59
love all of this. This work is
17:01
obviously not meant to be taken as fact,
17:03
and Camden obviously does not take
17:05
the green children seriously at
17:07
all. From there the story
17:10
of the Green Children started to influence other
17:12
more fanciful works. Francis
17:14
Godwin, The Man in the
17:17
Moon, or a Discourse of a Voyage
17:19
thither, which he called a quote
17:21
essay of fancy, talks about
17:24
a novel disciplinary method
17:26
employed by parents on the moon where
17:28
they would send their unruly children down
17:30
to Earth and brings them earthly
17:32
children back in their place. And
17:35
in this whole story he made reference to quote
17:37
certain stories he had heard confirming
17:40
this idea it was true. And those
17:42
certain stories were Williams,
17:44
Historia, Retram and Lucaram. I
17:49
want to know what happened to the earthly kids that lived
17:51
on the moon. Did they
17:53
eventually get fed beans and turned
17:55
green? There's so many questions, he
17:57
might say, I didn't read the whole thing. The
18:00
Green Children have continued to make appearances
18:02
in fiction into the twentieth century and
18:04
beyond. Herbert Reid's novel
18:07
The Green Child came out in nineteen thirty
18:09
four. The Green Children of Bagnios,
18:12
set in Spain in eighteen eighty seven, was
18:14
part of John Macklin's nineteen sixty five
18:16
book Strange Destinies. The
18:19
Spanish setting is echoed in the nineteen seven
18:21
ten thousand Maniacs on Green Children,
18:24
which starts in August Day in the Hills
18:26
of Spain, a pair of children emerged
18:28
from a cave. And of course there are
18:30
lots of other stories and books and TV episodes
18:33
and the like that all draw from this as well.
18:35
And it's not totally clear whether
18:38
the Green Children are the inspiration for
18:40
the basic idea of Martians
18:42
as little green men, but they were
18:45
definitely described as green, and people
18:47
were also speculating that maybe they were aliens.
18:49
Early and as the sixteenth century and
18:52
outside of the world of fiction, the Green Children
18:54
also started being written about as folklore
18:57
in the nineteenth century. In eighteen
18:59
fifty, Thomas Kitelee included bits
19:01
of both Williams and Ralph's accounts
19:03
in his work Fairy Mythology.
19:06
This was the first time the story was available to
19:08
people who did not read Latin, and
19:10
since it was in a book by a folklorist called
19:12
Fairy Mythology, a lot of people
19:15
from this point assumed that story was inherently
19:17
folkloric. Sometimes they're
19:19
specifically fairies, such as in Catherine
19:22
Briggs Dictionary of Fairies, which
19:24
came out in nineteen seventy six. And
19:26
there are also people who interpret them as forest
19:28
spirits or personifications of nature.
19:31
I feel like the whole like fairy
19:34
myth right up through. Tinkerbell was very
19:36
informed by all of this. About
19:39
the same time as Kitele was documenting the story
19:42
as folklore, the Green Children were
19:44
also becoming more widely known to the general
19:47
public. In eighteen seventy five,
19:49
a guide book to East Anglia referenced
19:51
the Green Children, and then other mentions
19:53
and other travel guides followed, as
19:55
you know, interesting points of interests and interesting
19:58
tidbits about the place that you're visit it ng A
20:01
sign at will Pit honoring the story was
20:03
erected in nineteen seventy seven as
20:05
part of Queen Elizabeth Silver Jubilee,
20:07
and today the story is like they're
20:09
on the Village of Wilpit's web page. And
20:12
of course there are also a lot of
20:15
rational or not so rational explanations
20:18
for what was really going on here, and we're going to dive
20:20
into those possibilities after we first
20:22
paused for a little sponsor break.
20:30
So unsurprisingly,
20:33
there are lots of hypotheses about who the
20:35
Green Children were and where they came from.
20:38
One connects them to the Babes in
20:40
the Wood, which was first written down as a
20:42
ballad in and The
20:44
basic story of the Babes in the Wood
20:46
is that a very greedy uncle was guardian
20:49
to two young children and he was hoping
20:51
to steal their fortunes, so he hired some men
20:53
to take them into the woods and murder them.
20:56
As so often happens in these kinds of stories,
20:58
the men he hired didn't have the heart to do
21:00
it and abandoned them instead, so
21:03
in the story, they eventually starved. This
21:06
folk tale is typically set in Whyland
21:08
Wood, which is about thirty miles or forty
21:10
eight kilometers away from Woolpit, so
21:13
people suggesting that the Green Children were
21:15
really the Babes in the Wood just move
21:17
the location closer by. And
21:19
also about four hundred years earlier than
21:21
the ballads first written appearance. That
21:24
definitely doesn't mean the ballad didn't exist
21:26
earlier, but like four years
21:29
of a long time for a ballad to go without
21:31
being written down, or story to go without
21:34
being written down, at least by this point in history.
21:37
So compounding the kind of
21:39
far fetchedness of this explanation is
21:41
they go to rationale for why they were green,
21:45
which is chlorosis, otherwise known
21:47
as green sickness. Now, while
21:49
there are rare forms of
21:51
anemia that can cause a person
21:53
to have a kind of greenish pallor, along
21:56
with the idea that people who are really nauseated
21:58
are described as looking sometimes green
22:02
sickness is not that. Green
22:05
sickness was described in medical literature
22:07
from the sixteenth to late nineteenth century.
22:10
It was diagnosed almost exclusively in young
22:13
women, and it was also called the virgin's
22:15
disease. The symptoms
22:17
included things like restlessness, irritability,
22:20
fatigue, too little appetite, too
22:22
much appetite, indigestion,
22:24
headache, and an absence of menstrual
22:26
periods. Treatments included
22:29
blood letting, marriage always
22:32
on a prescription pad, and
22:35
medicines to bring on menstrual flow. To
22:38
be clear, marriage really meant
22:40
sex in this case, And there are some extremely
22:43
suggestive ballads dating back to the sixteenth
22:45
and seventeen centuries about
22:47
treatments, and we're using the air quotes there
22:49
for green sickness. There's actually a
22:51
Sawbones episode about green sickness if
22:53
you want to hear a whole lot more about this. It
22:56
also does not really take a lot of
22:58
Google effort to find these
23:01
extremely suggestive ballads, ballads about
23:03
how to treat green sickness.
23:06
So obviously they probably
23:08
didn't have green sickness, because that's
23:10
not a real thing. Right. And
23:13
also those in in this
23:15
sort of combination story of the green
23:17
children in the babes in the wood, the folks who
23:19
don't suggest that maybe they had clurosis
23:22
often suggest that maybe the hired men did
23:24
actually try to kill them using arsenic,
23:27
that they had survived with the arsenic had turned
23:29
their skin green. This is a
23:31
weird conflation of sort of two different
23:34
historical things. While arsenic has
23:36
definitely been used to make green
23:38
dies, it was typically exposure
23:41
to those diyes that made a
23:43
person's skin turned green, not
23:46
surviving an attempt to be poisoned with
23:48
it. Right, Arsenic in itself
23:50
does not carry that pigment right to a
23:52
person's person. I guess if you tried
23:54
to murder someone with green dye, which
23:57
you could have done, you could have done, then
23:59
you have green skin. You'll
24:02
be so fashionable and deceased.
24:04
Yeah, that would be a weird way to murder
24:07
people. I'll make a great story for any
24:09
of our writers out there. You just take that one, ather. Uh.
24:12
The idea that the Green children might have
24:15
been aliens, which I love, goes
24:17
all the way back to William Camden, who
24:19
suggested that they were either Satyrs
24:21
meaning wild men, or Antipodeans
24:24
meaning aliens. Robert
24:26
Burton also made a passing reference to the idea
24:28
that they may have come from another planet in
24:31
Anatomy of Melancholy, which was published
24:33
in sixteen twenty one. So the
24:35
aliens hypothesis has been around for
24:37
a really long time and it has persisted
24:40
to the present. In article
24:43
in Analog, which is a science fiction magazine,
24:46
Duncan Lunin asserted that they were from
24:48
a human colony on an alien planet,
24:51
sent here through a malfunctioning transporter,
24:54
and this explanation also involves the Knights
24:56
Templar in some way. This
24:58
is one of the few things I didn't actually you get to read for
25:00
myself all the way through, some relying on someone else's
25:03
synopsis of it. But uh.
25:05
Interestingly, in a much more
25:07
down to earth portion of this article,
25:10
he also pieced together
25:12
a family treat for Richard to count and
25:14
claims that the surviving sister
25:16
was baptized as Agnes and that the
25:18
man she married was a royal official named
25:20
Richard Barr. So that's
25:22
a fascinating, possibly
25:25
totally legit historical fact in
25:27
the context of this overall aliens
25:30
article with the Knights Templar involved,
25:33
I wonder if that means that someone could trace
25:35
their alien heritage all the way back
25:37
to Agnes and you could know that you are part
25:40
from another planet, which you really
25:42
all are, because we're all made to start us to some
25:44
degree. True story, we're all aliens.
25:47
The most complete practical explanation
25:49
for what might have happened came from Paul
25:52
Harris in and that
25:54
was published in forty in Studies, which is
25:56
an offshoot of forty Times. I
25:58
actually used a lot of writing
26:00
from one of the editors there for our
26:02
Devil's Footprints episode. Uh.
26:04
And that's a magazine that's devoted to strange
26:07
phenomena. And he suggests that
26:09
all of this really happened in eleven seventy
26:11
three in the Reign of Henry the Second.
26:14
In brief, Harris suggests
26:16
that these were the children of Flemish immigrants
26:19
and that their parents were killed at the Battle
26:21
of Fornhum in eleven seventy three.
26:23
The St. Martin's Land that the
26:26
sister referred to was Fornhum St
26:28
Martin, roughly ten miles or sixteen
26:30
kilometers from Woolpits. They're not that far away
26:33
and also not far from the River Lark,
26:35
so there would have been a river nearby. According
26:38
to this theory, they escaped
26:40
the battle, and then the two children fled
26:42
into Thetford forest and took refuge
26:45
in flint mines there before
26:47
following the bells from Barry St Edmund's
26:50
to find their way out and make their way to Woolpit.
26:52
So their unknown tongue and clothing
26:54
were just Flemish and their skin was
26:56
greenish due to malnutrition due
26:58
to this extended time of being abandoned
27:01
and wandering in flint mines. That
27:04
all holds up. Uh. It all
27:06
sounds like it fits so very well, But of
27:08
course there are a few problems. One,
27:11
the Flemish people killed at for Hum were
27:13
mercenaries hired to fight with English
27:16
rebels against Henry the Seconds Forces.
27:18
Mercenaries generally, as a rule, did
27:20
not bring their children with them into battle.
27:23
Uh. Two, it seems unlikely that no
27:25
one around Wolpit spoke Flemish
27:28
or some other version of Dutch, at least
27:30
enough to spot it as a known language
27:32
rather than some unrecognizable tongue.
27:35
Three, the river Lark isn't really
27:37
that big and even to a child's eye,
27:40
it's probably not quote a very
27:42
considerable river. So that descriptor does
27:44
not really hold up. And for
27:46
this Fornhum to Thetford to Bury St
27:49
Edmund's to Woolpit trek really
27:51
goes way out of the way. It's actually a total
27:53
of about thirty miles or fifty two kilometers,
27:56
the first leg of it going in nearly
27:58
the direct opposite direction from Wolpit.
28:01
Thattford is also way too far away from
28:03
Barry st Edmund's to hear the bells
28:05
from there. Also, want a
28:08
lot more just immediate non
28:11
synchronization in the descriptions. That
28:13
battle happened in October. So
28:16
unless those two kids wandered
28:19
for months and months and months before
28:21
arriving in Wolpit, like, there would not have been
28:23
any fresh beans harvest
28:26
and that because you'll remember that was what June
28:28
July, I think July August was
28:30
when they are generally harvested. That's
28:33
nine months including
28:35
winter, right with two tiny
28:38
children. Yeah, so malnourished,
28:40
tiny children. So it's
28:42
a mystery. Maybe
28:44
they made the Devil's footprints. Maybe so
28:48
sick little side trip play a little frank time
28:51
traveled seven
28:53
years maybe or some other number
28:55
of years, depending which account you ready. So
28:59
pretty much all of a historical um
29:02
accounts, and then also a lot
29:04
of the his like farther
29:06
back in the past. Works of fiction that we talked
29:08
about today are all on the internet for
29:10
free, and they will all be linked from our show
29:13
notes to this episode. If you just
29:15
really want to go read either a
29:17
colossally long history
29:19
of the Church in England
29:21
as translated UH in
29:23
the nineteenth century, or if you just want to read
29:26
some weird science
29:28
fictionesque stories about the moon written
29:30
in the distant past, Like that's all there. Who
29:33
doesn't want to read those? I kind of do the whole
29:35
thing about the flying acorns and the dog faced
29:37
people and the the specifically
29:40
multiple number of elephants that the fleas
29:42
were as big as it's all, But people
29:44
are pretty much on their own if they want to go looking for
29:46
the dirty ballads? Is that where we decided the
29:49
Dirty Ballads are not linked into one
29:54
of them is definitely not safe for work.
29:57
Um. But so, as I was trying
30:00
to put together some thoughts about green sickness.
30:03
I found a larger
30:05
than I would expect number of just very
30:07
incredulous papers published
30:09
in journals that were like, do you think green
30:12
sickness could have been caused by malnutrition?
30:14
No? I think green sickness probably was
30:16
caused by misogyny.
30:18
But
30:21
but one of them like this,
30:24
it started out seeming like
30:27
they were genuinely asking whether there was some
30:29
kind of organic mechanism
30:31
at work, and then the conclusion was like
30:33
no, really, like people just got really into
30:36
Hippocrates and started making
30:39
these Hippocratic diagnoses, and
30:41
that's why it suddenly enters this historical
30:43
record at this time and leaves and this time.
30:45
But it was through that one article that I found
30:48
this particularly risk a
30:51
ballad which you know, if you're
30:53
an adult person with kind of a skewed sense
30:55
of humor, it is always
30:58
funny to me and a little a
31:00
little bit of a silly and almost borderline
31:02
charming way to read sort of dirty
31:05
writing. And I'm again I'm using the air quotes
31:07
from really olden times
31:10
because their choice of words is just very funny
31:12
to today's year, and that's what makes
31:14
it hilarious. Yeah, So I
31:16
don't know. If you try to search for this yourself and
31:19
you come up with with
31:21
no responses, just send us an email history
31:23
podcast at how stuff works dot com. I will tell
31:25
you where to find it. Tracy is going to
31:27
peddle the dirty paddles. You
31:31
have listener mail that is not a dirty valid
31:33
I sure do, and it's not dirty
31:35
yet. All Kyle
31:37
sent us a note, and Kyle says,
31:40
Ladies, I would like to start off by saying, this
31:42
is my first time writing in, but I love your podcast
31:45
and listen to it all the time at work. I'm a huge
31:47
history buff and I'm always fascinated
31:49
how the actions and events surrounding a single
31:51
person can affect the entire world of billions.
31:54
Three perfect examples of this were in
31:56
your episode three Nuclear Close Calls.
31:59
They were very intra stories about how people
32:01
in the Cold War prevented armageddon through
32:03
quick thinking and faith and their fellow
32:05
humans. I'm sure I won't be the only person
32:07
to write in about this, but news just came in a few
32:09
hours ago confirming the death of Stanislav
32:12
Petrov, one of the three people featured in the podcast.
32:15
He passed away in May, according to multiple
32:17
sources, but most people are just learning
32:19
of it now. He was the perfect
32:21
example of how the level headed thinking of one
32:23
individual can and did save the
32:25
world as we know it today. I was
32:27
born after the incident which happened in three
32:30
but I can say with confidence that I and
32:32
so many more would not be alive if not for
32:34
his actions. And then Uh
32:37
notes that his parents lived in a city that, as I
32:39
probably would have been a target. The
32:42
world owes Mr Petrov and so many others
32:44
like him a tremendous debt, and I am glad
32:46
that now, if delayed, many mainstream media
32:48
outlets are publishing stories about his deeds.
32:51
Keep up the great work your podcast keep
32:53
me saye during some of my most tedious hours
32:55
at work. So thanks for that. And then
32:57
he included some links to stories about
32:59
the death of Stanislav Petrov.
33:02
Thank you so much, Kyle. That music
33:04
came UH to the four.
33:06
It's true. It was like back in May that he that
33:09
he died. Um, but this
33:11
news started to circulate while I was on vacation
33:14
and Holly was at Salt Lake Comic Con, so it
33:16
was like we were not really at our desks to
33:18
just spread the word on our social media
33:20
or whatever. So I want to take the opportunity to note
33:23
it in the show today. Yeah,
33:25
thanks Kyle, Yeah, thank you very much.
33:28
Thanks to everyone else who's written us awesome
33:30
notes about things
33:33
or queries about where we have found
33:35
things on our on our show. So
33:37
if you would like to write to us or at history podcasts
33:40
at how stuff works dot com. We're also on
33:42
Facebook and Pinterest and Tumbler
33:45
and Instagram, all of those
33:47
at missed in History
33:49
And if you come to our website, which is missed
33:51
in History dot com, there's a searchable
33:53
archive of all the episodes that have ever been on the show.
33:56
There are show notes for all the episodes that
33:58
Holly and I have ever done. There are
34:00
lots of tags that we have and you can click on
34:02
on our website and that will take you to lots
34:05
of other episodes that are about that same subject.
34:08
So there's a whole lot you can do if you come to miss
34:10
in History dot com.
34:16
For more on this and thousands of other topics,
34:18
visit how stuff Works dot com.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More