Podchaser Logo
Home
Housing Costs Are the Biggest Contributor to Inflation, They Are Starting to Ease

Housing Costs Are the Biggest Contributor to Inflation, They Are Starting to Ease

Released Wednesday, 7th December 2022
Good episode? Give it some love!
Housing Costs Are the Biggest Contributor to Inflation, They Are Starting to Ease

Housing Costs Are the Biggest Contributor to Inflation, They Are Starting to Ease

Housing Costs Are the Biggest Contributor to Inflation, They Are Starting to Ease

Housing Costs Are the Biggest Contributor to Inflation, They Are Starting to Ease

Wednesday, 7th December 2022
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

It's Wednesday, December seven. I'm

0:02

Oscar Ramirez in Los Angeles and this

0:04

is the Daily Dive. One

0:10

of the biggest components of inflation is starting

0:12

to ease. Housing costs are coming

0:15

down, but it could take some time before

0:17

it shows up in official inflation numbers. The

0:19

economys say that increases in rents and home

0:21

prices will remain low as

0:23

the economy has slowed, and mortgage rates

0:25

remain elevated. Shelter inflation

0:28

is one of those things that tend to be sticky,

0:30

which means that once it starts moving in any direction,

0:32

it is slow to change back. Gwen

0:34

Guildford, economics reporter at The Wall

0:36

Street Journal, joins us for what to know next?

0:40

What do you do with an iconic Los Angeles landmark

0:42

that became too old to operating normally and

0:45

too much of a treasure to tear down? Elle

0:47

County would like to turn the old General Hospital

0:49

building into affordable and homeless

0:52

housing, but to do that, there's a ton

0:54

of work to be done. The county has already

0:56

committed two d and fifty million dollars

0:58

to removing hazardous material reals, upgrading

1:00

electrical and water systems, installing

1:03

air conditioning, fire sprinklers, and

1:05

so much more. The eventual goal

1:07

will be to have a healthy village with as

1:09

many as four units with bets for housing

1:12

and medical and mental health care. Doug

1:14

Smith, senior writer at The l A Times,

1:17

joined us for the future of l A's General

1:19

Hospital. It's news without the noise.

1:22

Let's dive in housing

1:25

services. Inflation will probably keep rising

1:28

well into next year, but if inflation

1:30

on new leases continues to fall, we

1:32

will likely see housing services inflation

1:35

begin to fall later next year. Joining us now is Gwynn

1:37

Guilford, economics reporter

1:39

at The Wall Street Journal. Thanks for joining us,

1:41

Quinn, thanks for having me. Let's

1:44

talk inflation. Obviously,

1:46

we're still seeing some high numbers with inflation.

1:48

We're starting to get a lot of indicators that it could be

1:50

easing up a little bit, but still there's

1:53

fears of a recession going on. But one

1:55

of the biggest components of inflation has always

1:58

been housing costs, and we're

2:00

seeing that in particular starting

2:02

to soften right now. We're starting to see new rents

2:04

go down just a little bit. One of the

2:07

problems with this is that a lot of

2:09

the key indicators, a lot of the way that we

2:11

measure this stuff is always kind of delayed,

2:13

so it takes a little bit of time to really see

2:15

if things are dropping. But we're starting

2:18

to feel like the housing costs are

2:20

going down and it could be easing up

2:22

on inflation. So Gwen, tell us a little bit more about

2:24

it. Yeah, and that's right. You

2:27

captured it well after vaccines

2:29

came out and you had that huge economic boom

2:32

that was buoyed by governments stimulus

2:34

and people getting hired like crazy,

2:36

and you know, we just started really taking off. And

2:39

then people moved out of there, you

2:41

know, family homes or situations

2:43

with roommates to get their own place or to

2:46

you know, they upgraded, and so there

2:48

was a lot of rental demand and rents

2:50

just really took off. And um,

2:53

the measure of new rents, which

2:55

is what you know, if you look at Zillo or Apartment

2:58

List, what those are all tracking, Those

3:00

were, you know, rising at a three month annualized

3:03

rate of like in the

3:05

in the summer of which is just

3:08

in the insane pace. And

3:11

and then you know that's snapped back and

3:13

now the Zillo index

3:15

it's barely increasing on a month to

3:18

month level, and it might even start to decline

3:20

soon. But you

3:22

know, right now we're in the sea.

3:24

In the CPI, the consumer Price Index, we're

3:26

seeing inflation being still

3:29

really pretty dangerously hot. And

3:31

a big reason why is housing costs, and

3:33

those are growing at a really fast

3:35

clip. And the reason why is exactly

3:38

what you you mentioned is there's that year

3:40

long delay. There's that lag,

3:43

and so what you know, what you saw

3:45

on the market for new rents,

3:47

the last summer has been feeding

3:50

in to um. You know, the summer

3:53

has been feeding into the inflation that we're

3:55

seeing in the numbers now. But the good news

3:57

is that's going to start

3:59

feeding, that's going to continue to feed through, and

4:01

it's going to help bring down

4:04

measured inflation over the next year.

4:07

Yeah. I mean, to the point of those crazy high

4:09

home prices and rents and all that, I

4:12

was looking for a home throughout the pandemic,

4:14

and man, we were getting shot down with crazy

4:16

bidding wars and all that stuff. It was just you

4:18

really felt like you couldn't compete in a lot of

4:21

areas. UM. So yeah, it was a tough

4:23

time. And so now that things are starting to cool

4:25

that, I mean, we have all sorts of other things going on right,

4:27

we have higher interest rates. The

4:30

supply of homes is kind of still in the same

4:32

boat. But how do we calculate

4:35

this as far as white lags

4:37

so long? What are the measurements that we're looking at

4:39

that makes this lag so long? When

4:41

the BLS the Leeward Department surveys,

4:44

they do a survey of rents from all

4:47

over the country and um,

4:49

kind of alternating different

4:51

groups of cities and

4:54

um, you know, but most people aren't

4:56

getting you know, negotiating a new rent

4:59

every year there. Um,

5:01

you know you do that when you move to a new place. But

5:04

you know most people have, um,

5:06

most renters are you know,

5:09

staying in a place more than one year and you

5:11

know kind of work things out with their landlord

5:13

and aren't seeing like, you know, colossally

5:16

huge rent increases the way you might

5:18

have experienced if you move to a new

5:20

place, if you had to move to a new place during the pandemic.

5:23

And so it takes longer for that

5:26

market pressure to filter through, where you

5:28

know, the landlord starts to realize, oh, hey, I

5:30

could be getting a lot more for this place, and

5:33

you know, really started jacking up the rates.

5:35

You know, well that only happens when you renegotiate

5:37

your lease, which is usually once

5:39

a year, you know, sometimes maybe every six months

5:42

UM. So that's one of the reasons

5:44

it takes a while for it to

5:47

for the market rate to filter through

5:50

UM. It's just that, you know, there's

5:52

the delay that comes

5:54

from when people negotiate. And

5:56

then the other thing is just how the labor

5:59

department average. They do a six month trailing

6:01

average, and so that creates an additional

6:03

methodological lack, so we might

6:05

be seeing they are feeling the effects a little bit

6:08

sooner than the actual numbers are actually going

6:10

to let us know. There and when we're looking at

6:12

overall inflation, how big

6:14

of a portion is that is housing

6:17

in shelter costs, it's like close

6:20

to a third of UM

6:22

the consumer price index. And then when you're talking

6:24

about the core index, which strips out you

6:26

know, kind of volatile food and energy prices

6:29

and is what you know, economists and the FED

6:31

are concerned with UM, it's

6:34

it's close to UM two fifths

6:36

of CORE. So it's a really big deal.

6:39

And so when it's like it doesn't take a very big

6:41

movement to have a big impact. And

6:43

so when we're talking about the FED, and you know they've

6:45

been raising rates. Obviously this is part

6:47

of it, right to raise those interest

6:49

rates enough to cool things down. When

6:52

we're talking about you know, them continuing to

6:54

raise the rates, and what's their goal, like

6:56

what's their target for inflation? Like obviously

6:59

they want to bring it down as much as possible, but what percentage

7:01

are we looking at that they really want to hit where they're feeling

7:03

comfortable. So they

7:06

target two percent was

7:08

a little bit of a band around that UM.

7:10

But and they also are targeting this was getting into

7:13

some pretty arcane inflation

7:15

stuff, but they target a different indicator

7:17

which is from the Commerce Department and it

7:19

comes up two weeks generally after the

7:22

consumer price index comes out UM.

7:24

It's called the PC the personal

7:27

consumption expenditure price index

7:29

UM. And that's interesting since you

7:31

know, we're getting into the wonkery UM

7:34

because the rent component,

7:36

the shelter component is much smaller UM

7:39

and in the PC price index,

7:41

but medical care is much bigger

7:44

UM. So that like that

7:47

that creates it means that there there

7:49

was less it increased less UM

7:52

because the rent impact was

7:54

was less and but it's also going to

7:56

come down less UM than

7:59

a lot of economists expect CPI to come

8:01

down in the next year year and a half. All

8:03

right, well, we'll keep an eye out on what's going on

8:05

with this. Hopefully, as these housing costs

8:08

you go down, we get to see that reflection

8:10

in the overall inflation numbers, and then obviously

8:13

people start feeling the rest of that go

8:15

down. I know, all of this that we talked about sticky

8:17

prices a lot of times to these housing

8:19

costs, that shelter costs tend to be sticky,

8:22

right once they start moving a little bit, it gets

8:24

really slow to change back. Yeah,

8:26

and that's a couple of a couple of reasons for that. One is

8:28

just that methodological stuff that we're talking

8:30

about, but the other is also just the

8:33

nature of It's sort of like wages, like you don't

8:35

um, you know, food prices that can go You're gonna

8:38

buy milk for you know, four

8:40

dollars a gallon one month,

8:43

and then a couple of months later it's five dollars, and then it

8:45

goes down the leg two fifty, you know, like

8:47

they go up and they go down. But that

8:50

does not really happen with rent, Like,

8:52

you know, no landlord's gonna be like, oh,

8:55

well, I'm just gonna reduce my rent a whole

8:57

bunch Like they there's generally

8:59

a floor of past experience, so

9:02

you know, it's really hard for once

9:04

prices go up, they don't tend to come down.

9:06

There doesn't increase might slow, but

9:08

yeah, they're sticky. All right, Well, we'll keep

9:11

an eye out for all of these inflation news

9:13

as it comes up. Gwen Guildford,

9:15

economics reporter at the Wall Street Journal,

9:17

Thank you very much for joining us. Yeah,

9:20

great to join you. Old

9:29

l A County hospital has been vacant

9:31

now for well over a decade.

9:35

You have one point one million. You can't make

9:37

this at one point one bigan. They

9:39

can square feet. The opportunity

9:41

to get over eight hund units

9:44

thousands of people in the housing

9:46

off the streets presents itself. Joining

9:49

us now is Doug Smith, senior writer at

9:51

The l A Times. Thanks for joining us, Dad,

9:53

You're welcome, glad to be here. Well, let's

9:55

talk about what's going on with a

9:58

Los Angeles landmark, the General

10:00

Hospital. It closed down fourteen

10:02

years ago and really nothing has been done

10:04

with it over all that time. The idea

10:07

now is as homelessness is such a huge

10:09

issue in l A and all parts

10:11

of the country really, but it's very pronounced. In Los Angeles.

10:13

They're planning on changing the General

10:16

hospital there into a

10:19

homeless and affordable housing, a

10:21

healthy village. They want to college. It's gonna

10:23

have bets for housing, it's gonna have spaces where

10:25

social services, community activities, all

10:27

sorts of stuff. It seems like a huge

10:30

undertaking, So Doug tell us a little bit about

10:32

what's going on here. Sure, it is

10:34

a huge undertaking. And since a

10:37

general hospital closed in

10:39

two thousand and eight for various reasons. It

10:41

was almost it was by then eighty

10:43

something years old, ninety almost

10:45

ninety years old, and it didn't have the

10:48

systems at modern hospitals made. It didn't

10:50

have air conditioning, it didn't have the

10:52

electrical system, couldn't support

10:54

the modern medical technology.

10:56

And then after the north Ridge earthquake,

10:59

the side mixed standards for hospitals

11:01

were upgraded and it didn't meet those standards.

11:04

So a new hospital was built right next

11:06

to it, and general hospital just kind of

11:08

closed. Some of the ground floors

11:10

were still used for wellness, community

11:13

and research training, but

11:16

most of its nineteen floors were just left

11:18

empty. And they've deteriorated. The ceiling

11:20

pot tiles are falling, and there's dust everywhere.

11:23

The electrical outlets are open and

11:26

nobody can go there. So it's been very

11:28

hard to find out what to do with it because it's a

11:30

gigantic building. You know, when you walk

11:33

inside, you feel like you're entering an Egyptian

11:35

pyramid, it's that big, and

11:38

so it couldn't be reused as a

11:40

hospital. There was had been replaced,

11:42

and what to do with it, well, the idea

11:45

of housing became more tenable

11:47

as a homeless crisis and what's really

11:49

an affordable housing crisis in Los Angeles

11:52

became more severe, and so

11:54

first Supervisor Gloria Molina

11:57

and then Supervisor Heeless Release started

11:59

to pursue the idea of using it for housing

12:01

in a health and community related context.

12:04

So the plans are finally now

12:07

taking shape. There will be a RFP, a

12:09

request for Proposals, will be developed

12:12

and offered in January for a developer

12:14

to come and figure out how to

12:16

convert basically operating

12:19

rooms, wards and laboratories

12:21

into housing and

12:23

um we don't know exactly how

12:26

that will play out, but it could be anywhere

12:28

from three fifty to seven hundred units

12:30

of housing, depending on whether how many

12:32

of them are single units or how many

12:34

of them are multi bedroom units for families.

12:37

Yeah, and that's part of it, the huge

12:39

undertaking of how to convert what was once

12:41

a hospital into a space for

12:44

housing, a space for all these other services

12:46

and whatnot. And so you

12:48

mentioned the article to the prep work, just

12:50

just the prep work is expected to start next

12:52

year, after the county committed

12:54

two fifty million dollars to take the first step.

12:56

But it was to some of that stuff you had mentioned, removing

12:59

us as those other hasnudous materials,

13:02

installing air conditioning. I mean, you can't

13:04

have anything built now without air conditioning

13:06

and fire sprinklers. So all of that stuff

13:08

is barely going to get started. And then, as you mentioned,

13:11

then there's the proposals and all that to really figure

13:13

out exactly what's going to be going on there. Yeah, the

13:15

county's approach on this is that it is kind

13:17

of unusual. They decided to

13:19

first prepare the building just sort

13:21

of quite empty it out and create

13:23

an empty structure that

13:26

a developer, an imaginative

13:28

developer could look at and say, we

13:30

could do this with it, We could use the operating rooms

13:32

for this purpose and come up with

13:34

the individual plans. But

13:37

even just that prep work and which also

13:39

includes a significant seismic upgrade,

13:41

it's going to cost two hundred million.

13:44

You mentioned it as well too. Some of the

13:46

you know, when you walk in it seems

13:49

like an Egyptian pyramid or something that it is one

13:51

of the best city's best examples of Art deco

13:53

architecture. Tell me a little bit about the

13:55

art there, because that's also some one

13:57

of the reasons why they haven't torn it all down to before

14:00

hand is they want to preserve some of that stuff. As

14:02

you mentioned, it's such been such a landmark for Los

14:05

Angeles. There's statutory

14:07

on the outside. It's all of medical theme.

14:09

The Hypocritus and the Galen

14:11

and the sort of the big figures in

14:14

the history of medicine are represented

14:16

in statues. And then there's a in

14:19

the entry. There is a

14:21

mural on the ceiling that you

14:24

know, it makes you feel like you're looking at the Sistine

14:26

Chapel. It's obviously not by

14:28

Michelangelo, but it but it just has that feeling

14:30

of awe that you're looking up at this vast

14:33

ceiling eural as you walk into

14:35

the hospital what used to be the main floor

14:37

of the hospital. It's it's so huge

14:39

that there's a color stripe

14:42

in the middle of band. It's about five feet

14:44

wide. It has different colored stripes as

14:47

you walk through. Some of them go right, some of them

14:49

go left, and you're told at the beginning,

14:51

when they know where you need to go, you're told to follow

14:54

a certain color to get you there. It's

14:56

sort of how big and complex the building

14:58

is. Tell me a little bit more. Were

15:00

about the history of General Hospital.

15:03

You made mention in the article about you know, some

15:05

of the pretty nasty stuff there that

15:07

was done under an old eugenics law.

15:09

A lot of things for that happened to the Latino

15:12

community as well. You know, even when the

15:14

new hospital was built, you know a lot of people

15:16

were displaced because construction had to

15:18

be done. Tell me a little bit about some of that. Sure,

15:21

the hospital has been a huge

15:23

presence in Boil Heights since it

15:25

was built in nineteen in the late

15:27

nineteen twenties and open in nineteen three,

15:30

and it's it's always been a

15:32

place where people in that community could go

15:35

and if they had they couldn't afford that, they would

15:37

get free medical care, but it also had

15:39

this other element of its history.

15:42

Racial attitudes were sort

15:44

of became a part of its

15:46

service. And so sometimes Latino women

15:48

came to deliver babies,

15:50

and there was a doctor there who thought

15:52

that they were bringing too many babies

15:55

into the world, weren't educated, didn't have a

15:57

chance, and so they steralyzed a

15:59

couple of women there with their

16:01

consent, but it wasn't clear if they

16:03

actually gave their consent knowingly. They signed

16:05

forms and there, you know, they were given a forms

16:08

had signed this, and it was a consent to

16:10

sterilize them, and this became a

16:12

practice in the hospital in the seventies and

16:14

sixties and seventies under California

16:16

had a eugenics law under which thousands

16:19

of women across the state were sterilized.

16:22

The state finally provided a fund

16:24

to compensate them, but it didn't apply to the women

16:26

who were sterilized at County General because

16:29

the hospital was locally funded. And

16:31

all of this you spoke to a number of people,

16:33

though you know, this is some of the worst

16:36

parts of that history, but you spoke to a lot of

16:38

people too who where General Hospital

16:40

was, where they were born, where

16:43

they went and then they had a broken arm where their

16:45

family members were saved from having you

16:47

know, after recovering and after

16:49

having heart attacks and whatnot. And it was just a

16:51

central place there where people got

16:54

their healthcare done. It was

16:56

and we spoke to Monica Alcoroz,

16:58

who has been the president of the

17:00

Highland Park Neighborhood Council, and

17:03

she was born there and her siblings were born there.

17:05

Her mother went there when she had a heart attack, and so

17:07

the hospital is it's hard to

17:09

believe. It's this gigantic structure that

17:12

you can see from many parts

17:14

of Los Angeles. It's sort of present everywhere,

17:16

but it's also an intimate part of people's

17:18

lives, including my own. My own

17:21

father went there when he had a heart attack

17:23

in and they saved his

17:25

life there. And in all of this, what

17:27

has been the community

17:29

reaction to, at least some of this plan,

17:32

you know, changing it into a homeless

17:34

and affordable housing because that's a touchy

17:37

subject a lot of times when you're bringing

17:39

certain elements into the community

17:41

and all that. So what I know, there's a lot of

17:43

homeless encampments that have been seen around the

17:45

area as well. So how is the community

17:48

reacted to a lot of this, So Hilda Solely

17:50

did a smart thing. Boil Heights

17:53

and and Lincoln Heights on the north are

17:55

communities that are really guarded their

17:58

heritage carefully, and you could

18:00

take a misstep and get the community against

18:02

you, as the owner of the former Series

18:05

building did by proposing to

18:07

make it a home for ten thousand homeless people.

18:09

But Homeless Solely built a community

18:11

organization that has been looking

18:14

at this for years and has

18:16

been involved in the planning of it. And

18:19

my colleague Andrew spoke to all

18:21

the major people in the community and and there's

18:23

generally support for this project. Also

18:25

because the project will not be just

18:28

the hospital, but it will be twelve acres to

18:30

the west that will be used for

18:32

housing for community spaces,

18:34

and there's a childcare center that's being

18:36

built that will open there in

18:38

December, and the restorative

18:41

Care Village, which is a part of the larger

18:43

property. They've already completed

18:46

sixty four units of mental

18:48

health residential care and

18:50

d twenty unit units of recuperative

18:53

care for people leaving the hospital who

18:55

aren't ready to go home, and and that there's

18:57

twice as much space in their recuperative care list.

19:00

It's going to be developed for more services

19:02

like that, including workforce development.

19:05

So the community at this point

19:07

is very much behind the project. Of course, it's

19:09

one more big step when the developer

19:11

makes a proposal, and that could be a

19:14

moment when there could be tension. Doug

19:16

Smith, Senior writer at The l A Times,

19:19

thank you very much for joining us. Thank you

19:21

appreciate it. That's

19:29

it for today. Join us on social media

19:31

at Daily Dive Pod on both Twitter and

19:34

Instagram. Leave us a comment, give

19:36

us a rating, and tell us the stories that you're interested

19:38

in. Allow us and I heard radio or

19:40

subscribe or ever you get your podcast. This

19:43

episode of The Daily Dive is produced by Vicker Wright

19:46

and engineered by Tony Sarrantino. I'm

19:48

Oscar Ramirez and this was your

19:51

Daily Dive.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features