Podchaser Logo
Home
Imperfect Pitch

Imperfect Pitch

Released Friday, 28th April 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Imperfect Pitch

Imperfect Pitch

Imperfect Pitch

Imperfect Pitch

Friday, 28th April 2023
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:02

of the past and the curious has a new

0:04

book available. That's me. I

0:06

see Lincoln's underpants as a book about famous people

0:09

and their underwear. 16 chapters

0:11

on 16 people and their undies and

0:13

lots of other stuff too, like the underwear Hall

0:15

of Fame. Lots of laughing, lots of

0:17

learning. It's available wherever

0:19

you get your books. And if you wind up with a copy,

0:22

please leave a review. Be sure to request it at

0:24

your local library too. That will help.

0:26

This is an indie effort. I am indie

0:29

operation.

0:30

Thank you. Well, hello,

0:33

it's episode 78 of the past and

0:37

the

0:41

curious and I am Mick Sullivan and this

0:43

is my show. First off,

0:45

I want to say hello again and thanks to everyone

0:48

who came out to WBUR, the

0:50

podcast festival in Boston at the

0:52

beginning of this month of April. It

0:55

was amazing to meet so

0:57

many listeners and I was thrilled to

0:59

see everyone. I hope you had a good time. I was literally

1:02

moved to tears. So if anyone out there

1:04

has pictures that they want to share, send them on

1:06

my way. I'd love to see them. It was

1:07

also great to spend so much time with so

1:10

many of my kids. Listen, podcast pals.

1:12

And speaking of kids, listen, podcast

1:14

pals. The first story of this episode

1:17

features my good friend, Mellie Victor. Mellie

1:20

is the creator and voice of stoop kids stories

1:22

podcast, but you've heard her work all

1:24

over the place, including on imagination neighborhood,

1:27

the podcast. You may have even seen

1:29

her on stage in New York city.

1:31

She also happens to be the chair of kids. Listen,

1:34

she also happens to totally rule. She's

1:37

going to narrate a

1:37

story about one of my favorite singers, Ella

1:40

Fitzgerald. And then the second half of the episode

1:42

looks at an age old problem,

1:44

tuning musical instruments with each

1:46

other.

1:47

But you might be surprised by some of the problems

1:49

that came about because people

1:51

didn't tune. We'll get to

1:53

that in a minute right now. Let's get started

1:56

with Mellie Victor talking Ella

1:59

Fitzgerald. On

2:04

the evening of November 21, 1934, a very nervous

2:06

young woman named Ella Fitzgerald stood

2:12

off stage waiting to go on at

2:14

the Apollo Theater in Harlem, New

2:16

York.

2:17

Never before had she stood in front of

2:19

a theater audience like the one filling the

2:21

many seats of the Apollo. Honestly,

2:25

she had barely worked up the courage to sign

2:27

her name on a piece of paper that gave

2:29

her the chance to be there in the first place.

2:32

But a few friends

2:34

convinced her to give it a shot. They

2:37

believed in her. They believed in her

2:39

so much that she later realized

2:42

that those friends hadn't actually filled

2:44

out cards of their own for the lottery to

2:46

perform at the Apollo. Years

2:48

later, it dawned on her

2:50

that they also filled out their cards

2:52

with the name Ella Fitzgerald.

2:55

It seems they wanted to

2:57

improve their friend's chance at getting her

2:59

big chance. It worked because

3:02

here she was, nervously

3:04

fidgeting while waiting to take the stage at

3:07

the Apollo's Amateur Night.

3:10

Long before there was American Idol, The Voice,

3:12

or any other culturally important

3:15

talent competition, there

3:17

was Amateur Night at the Apollo

3:19

Theater. But at

3:21

the Apollo, the judges aren't

3:24

official talent scouts or famous

3:26

music producers. Instead,

3:28

there are the 1,500 audience members

3:31

filling the cushioned seats of the historic building.

3:34

It's that way now, and it's been that

3:36

way since it opened. Leaving

3:39

your destiny up to your talent and

3:41

how an unfamiliar audience reacts would

3:43

be nerve-wracking to say the least. And

3:46

Ella was most certainly nervous.

3:49

She was the first act of the amateur portion,

3:52

and had walked through the doors with a plan to

3:55

dance a dance she had choreographed in

3:57

her head.

3:58

Everyone knew her to be a terrific

4:00

dancer so it made sense

4:02

that she would compete on the stage as Ella

4:04

Fitzgerald dancer.

4:07

Doubt soon crept in to compound

4:09

her nerves. Just before

4:12

her moment in the spotlight, a

4:14

pair of professional dancing sisters worked

4:17

their audience into a frenzy.

4:20

The Edwards sisters had come to

4:22

New York from Chicago with a flashy

4:24

and perfectly polished tap dance

4:27

that took Ella's breath away. She

4:29

knew that there was no way she could compete

4:31

with what the audience had just witnessed.

4:34

So she panicked a bit

4:36

and informed the host at the last minute

4:39

that she wouldn't be dancing after all.

4:43

Ella Fitzgerald was born

4:45

in Newport, New Virginia in 1917 or maybe 1916.

4:47

It's been up for debate

4:49

for quite some time now.

4:53

Much

4:55

of Ella's life has remained mysterious because

4:58

though she became internationally famous,

5:01

she was a very private person.

5:03

Her beloved mother Tempe

5:06

was a strong force in her life

5:08

and when Ella was elementary school age

5:10

they moved to Yonkers which is north

5:13

of Manhattan, Harlem, and the Bronx

5:15

in New York City.

5:17

Her mother Tempe and Ella's stepfather

5:19

were in search of work and like many

5:21

others they found it in the factories

5:24

and industries of northern cities in

5:26

the years around World War I.

5:28

It was called the Great Migration and

5:31

the wave of people from the south moving

5:33

to big cities completely changed neighborhoods.

5:37

It was around this time that nearby

5:39

Harlem became the epicenter of

5:41

African-American culture,

5:43

a time known as the Harlem

5:46

Renaissance. Ella

5:48

thrived as a young girl growing up in

5:50

the neighborhood bustling with people from many

5:52

places. She was active in

5:54

sports, a model student, and

5:57

also clearly had a natural ability

6:00

and dancing. From the records

6:02

her mother owned, she memorized popular

6:05

songs of the day. Ella

6:07

loved to sing her name Connie Boswell

6:09

and developed an incredible ability for mimicry.

6:12

By teasing her voice, she could just sing

6:14

like Louis Armstrong and

6:17

then even imitate the sound of his trumpet

6:19

when he played his exciting hot jazz.

6:22

Beyond popular music in school, she

6:24

loved to dance for her friends and sing in

6:26

the church choir. But when she

6:28

was 15,

6:29

her life fell apart.

6:33

It was 1932 when her dear mother,

6:36

trying to protect a friend's child during

6:39

a car accident, died as

6:42

a result of her own injuries. It

6:44

was a monumental shift in Ella's life. Soon

6:48

fleeing the abuse of her stepfather,

6:50

she moved to Harlem to live with an aunt, but

6:53

she couldn't focus in school. With

6:56

little support and the grief from

6:58

the loss of her mother,

7:00

her grades slipped to the point that she stopped

7:02

going to school altogether.

7:04

Like many other young people considered truant

7:07

at this time, she was taken to

7:09

a reform school, this one

7:11

in Hudson, New York.

7:13

By all accounts, it was a terrible

7:15

place for her. 400 or so young women lived

7:18

in 17 cottages.

7:20

Black students were segregated and shared

7:23

the two most crowded of these.

7:25

There is a record of abuse towards many of the girls

7:27

and furthermore, Ella was without

7:30

opportunities the white girls were allowed. After

7:33

class activities like choir, which

7:35

certainly would have been a good way for the future

7:38

lady of song to censor, recover,

7:40

and find herself, were not open

7:43

to her.

7:44

Only white students were allowed. Somehow,

7:48

some way, she escaped.

7:51

We don't know details because she never talked about

7:54

it. It's clear she hated

7:56

that place. Since she couldn't

7:58

go back to her aunt's home,

7:59

where they'd be able to find her again,

8:02

Ella Fitzgerald was homeless in

8:04

New York at the age of 17. Technically,

8:08

a ward of the state, since she

8:10

was not yet an adult,

8:12

she made money working for a gambling

8:14

operation and singing and dancing

8:17

on bustling street corners for spare change.

8:21

It was an uneasy and unfortunate

8:23

life for anyone, but luckily

8:26

for Ella, someone helped her.

8:29

That year, a group of older women

8:31

took her in and offered her a bed.

8:34

After hearing her sing,

8:36

they also convinced her to try her luck

8:38

at the new amateur night competition

8:40

at the Apollo Theater.

8:44

When the building

8:44

Housing the Apollo first opened

8:46

on 125th Street in 1913, it

8:50

was called Herdick and Seaman's Theater.

8:53

And like many other theaters in the area, it

8:55

was only open to white New Yorkers.

8:58

By 1933, a man named Sidney Cohen bought it, renovated

9:04

the inside, and with the help of actor

9:06

and local radio personality, Ralph

9:08

Cooper, the Apollo began to

9:10

reflect the Harlem neighborhood around

9:13

it. Harlem was bursting

9:15

with creativity and achievement, and

9:17

the Apollo soon became a jewel

9:19

of the neighborhood. Black artists

9:22

performed for largely black audiences,

9:25

and as the years went by, it

9:27

played host to some of the most important

9:29

names in music, from Duke Ellington

9:32

to James Brown, to the Jackson Five,

9:34

to Mary J. Blige. But

9:37

the Apollo's most famous gift to the world

9:39

was amateur night, when anyone

9:41

could wind up on stage where they

9:44

either find

9:44

the rowdy applause of 1,500

9:47

new found fans, or

9:49

the demoralizing boos

9:51

of 1,500 people who think the

9:54

artist on stage should get off

9:56

stage and go home to practice.

9:59

a similar segment of Ralph Cooper's radio

10:02

show. But the live

10:04

audience of the Apollo really said it all.

10:07

As a result, the onstage

10:09

adaptation has never ceased to draw

10:12

a crowd ready to make or break any

10:14

performers brave enough to stand

10:16

on the Apollo stage.

10:19

It was less than a year after

10:21

the very first amateur night that

10:24

17-year-old Ella found herself on

10:26

that stage.

10:28

A million things led her to

10:30

that moment. Some small,

10:33

some big,

10:34

some happy, and

10:36

some tragic.

10:38

Would she have been there if her mother hadn't

10:40

bought those records?

10:42

Would she have been there if her mother had still

10:44

been alive? Would she

10:46

have been there if she hadn't run away

10:48

from reform school? Would

10:51

she have been there if someone who cared

10:53

enough had never encouraged a homeless

10:55

teenager to give it a

10:57

try?

10:58

And while we're

11:00

asking questions,

11:01

what if she failed? Would she drift

11:04

off into obscurity in a hard life alone

11:06

in New York?

11:07

We'll never know. But it's

11:10

important to consider all of the

11:13

things that get someone to any point

11:15

in their lives. And

11:17

it's also important to consider what they're

11:20

capable of, if only given

11:22

the right chance. Ella

11:24

had her chance, but she

11:27

knew she couldn't dance. There was

11:29

no topping the Edwards sisters

11:31

who just left the stage and left the crowd

11:34

feeling great.

11:36

After Ella unfroze from a short panic

11:39

and informed Ralph Cooper that she wouldn't

11:41

be dancing after all, the host

11:43

probably worried for the young woman a bit. This

11:46

was a lot of pressure. It'd

11:49

be easy to crack. Who could blame her?

11:52

But then she told him that she instead

11:54

be taking the stage as Ella Fitzgerald's

11:57

singer.

11:58

It was a momentous decision to-

11:59

say the least.

12:01

Conveniently, the Apollo had

12:03

its own house band to back up performers

12:06

live and in person. Ella

12:08

asked if they knew a few songs that she had memorized.

12:12

At the time, she didn't know anything about keys,

12:15

tempos, or anything else about the technical

12:17

aspects of music. She just

12:19

had to follow their lead and hope

12:22

they started in a key she could sing.

12:24

What happened next is unclear.

12:26

It's been told many ways and

12:29

in fact Ella herself has

12:31

gone on record saying that she sang different

12:33

songs. There was no recording

12:36

so we don't know for certain. Regardless,

12:39

it's become the stuff of legend. It

12:42

seems the most accurate scenario goes

12:44

like this. Ella chose

12:46

to sing a hoagie Carmichael song called

12:48

Judy and though she had memorized

12:51

the lyrics, she fumbled a bit at first,

12:53

likely thanks

12:54

to her nerves. The audience

12:56

rumbled and perhaps Ralph Cooper

12:59

came out to calm her and urged

13:01

her to start again.

13:03

If that was the case, it worked

13:06

because most recollections say she

13:08

knocked them dead. Ella

13:10

sang with the powerful swing

13:12

that seemed to dance around time while

13:15

she also improvised melodically around

13:17

the tune every one of the audience members

13:19

knew. By the end, the audience

13:22

was squarely on her side, filling

13:24

the Apollo with cheers and claps

13:27

and hoots of joy.

13:29

That night Ella was the winner of Amateur

13:32

Night at the Apollo, but

13:34

it didn't stop there.

13:36

Her voice was so unique. She

13:39

was so confident in her delivery

13:41

and she could swing so hard that she was soon

13:44

asked to join as the lead singer

13:46

of the Chick Webb Band, a band

13:48

who split time as the Apollo house band.

13:52

From that point on, Ella Fitzgerald

13:54

spent almost every day of her life surrounded

13:57

by and performing music.

14:00

Known as the First Lady of Song,

14:03

Ella set the precedent of conquering

14:05

the Apollo and then making

14:07

a bigger splash and breaking into

14:10

the music world at large. In

14:12

the years that followed her debut, the

14:15

Apollo remained a springboard for

14:17

many. Just a few years

14:19

after her fateful switch from dance

14:21

to song, she celebrated a

14:24

big commercial breakthrough when she

14:26

recorded her song, A-tisket,

14:28

A-tasket, which she adapted

14:30

from a nursery rhyme. In

14:32

her early years,

14:33

Ella sang with Duke Ellington, Louis

14:36

Armstrong, and Count Basie, all

14:38

of whom were huge figures in swing

14:40

and jazz. Ella's

14:42

voice was perfectly suited to their styles.

14:45

But as the music changed and jazz

14:48

moved towards the complicated and

14:50

technically challenging styles like beat-bop,

14:53

many of the singers did not make the transition.

14:56

Ella, however, was as strong of

14:58

an improviser as anyone who picked

15:00

up an instrument.

15:02

And thanks to her pioneering in the art of scat

15:04

singing, she would share stages with

15:06

Dizzy Gillespie, Joe Pass, and

15:09

even Brazilian bossa nova composer

15:12

Antonio Carlos Jobim. She

15:15

made incredible music for over 50 years,

15:18

toured the world, was adored by

15:20

audiences, and was a beloved collaborator

15:23

to some of the greatest musicians

15:25

of her era. Under any

15:27

other set of circumstances, this

15:29

remarkable life probably wouldn't have looked the

15:31

same for

15:32

Ella Fitzgerald. And what a shame

15:34

it would have been if the world had

15:36

never heard Ella's voice.

15:42

For this month's You Have 30 Seconds, we

15:44

have a perfect fit. And

15:47

I love it when that happens. Inna from Ohio

15:49

is going to tell you about another incredible singer. But

15:53

this lady was more than just a singer. I'll

15:56

let Inna fill you in. Take it away! God

16:00

be and I'll be talking about Josephine Baker. She

16:03

was born June 3rd, 1906 and died April 12th, 1975. And

16:08

was a famous black performer

16:10

and was an official spy of World War II. She

16:13

also played in the Broadway show Shuffle along

16:15

the first with an all African American cast.

16:18

She also adapted 12 children all over the

16:20

world and called them

16:23

the Rainbow Tribe. That is why everyone

16:25

should know about Josephine

16:26

Baker. She's very inspiring.

16:30

I love it. Thank you so much. I was

16:32

so excited to see one about Josephine Baker. It's one

16:34

of my favorite stories. In

16:36

fact, if you remember our episode about

16:39

Eugene Bullard, the World War I pilot

16:41

and civil rights figure. When they both lived in

16:43

Paris, Josephine would sing at his jazz

16:45

club. But it was also believed

16:48

that she filled in as a babysitter for his

16:50

kids from time to time too, which is awesome.

16:53

So thanks and I love what

16:55

you did with it. Great job. If

16:57

anyone else out there has a you have 30 seconds,

17:00

all you got to do is record it usually with a phone

17:02

or a tablet. Tell me a story from the past in 30

17:04

seconds and send it to me. Hello

17:07

at thepastinthecurious.com.

17:10

It's quiz time. It's

17:12

quiz time. It's quiz

17:14

time. Time time.

17:20

Yep, it's that time again. Quiz

17:23

time. And your first question, which has

17:25

to do with musical instruments, is this.

17:28

A pair of instruments were found

17:30

in King Tutankhamen's tomb in 1922

17:34

and later played live on

17:36

BBC radio in 1939.

17:39

What kind of instruments

17:41

were they?

17:47

A pair of ornate and ancient

17:49

trumpets were found among

17:51

King Tut's afterlife riches at

17:54

over 3000 years old. They are believed

17:56

to be the oldest trumpets in the world.

17:59

One is made of stone.

17:59

Silver and the other of bronze. When

18:02

played in 1939, 150 million international listeners tuned in to

18:04

hear the trumpets. The

18:10

audio is available through BBC's

18:12

program Ghost Music, if you'd like to

18:14

find it. In 2011,

18:17

the bronze trumpet was stolen from the Egyptian

18:19

Museum in Cairo, but it

18:21

was mysteriously returned a few

18:24

weeks later. Okay

18:27

question number two. Many people are familiar

18:29

with Louis Armstrong's hit What a Wonderful

18:31

World, which was easily his biggest

18:34

hit. So it's easy to think of him

18:36

as a singer, but he was an incredible

18:38

instrumentalist as well, actually for

18:40

most of his career. What instrument

18:43

did Louis Armstrong play?

18:49

Louis Armstrong played the trumpet. He

18:51

didn't play King Tut's trumpet, but

18:53

some of his trumpets are in museums too. Louis

18:56

Armstrong began his career in New Orleans

18:59

in the 1920s, and by the time of his

19:01

death in 1971, he had five

19:03

decades of success, stardom, and influence

19:06

on American music that no one could

19:09

rival. One of his

19:11

trumpets is in a place of honor in the Smithsonian's

19:14

National Museum of African American

19:16

Culture.

19:19

Question number three. So

19:21

Ella played with Louis Armstrong, and she

19:24

also played with Duke Ellington, one of music's

19:26

most important figures. What

19:28

instrument did Duke Ellington play?

19:34

Duke was the leader of a big band filled with

19:36

horns and drums, which he called his orchestra.

19:39

And Duke wrote much of the music and arranged

19:41

all of the parts that people would play. And

19:44

in the band, he played the piano. Duke

19:47

combined classical music ideas, swing, jazz,

19:49

and Afro-Cuban aspects into

19:52

a totally unique sound. Duke was

19:54

the king. But when you have all of

19:56

those instruments, everyone has to

19:58

agree on how to play.

19:59

get in tune. Lucky for

20:02

Duke, before he really hit his stride,

20:04

people had worked to settle the age-old

20:07

dilemma of tuning a group of musicians,

20:10

as you're about to hear.

20:18

On June 28, 1919, the

20:21

Treaty of Versailles was signed, clearly

20:23

marking an end to World War

20:26

I. The International Accord

20:28

took place in France's fancy-pants

20:31

Palace of Versailles, exactly

20:33

five years to the day that Archduke

20:36

of Austria, Franz Ferdinand, was

20:39

assassinated. This is notable

20:41

and symbolic, because

20:43

that historic moment is typically considered

20:45

the opening act of World War I.

20:49

This treaty, like pretty much all treaties,

20:52

was an agreement between nations.

20:55

In it, there are a lot of words which

20:57

national representatives quibbled over and crafted

21:00

ever so diligently. So I'm

21:02

sure they would be very grateful,

21:05

even from their graves, if you read it today. But

21:08

I'm here to tell you, it's pretty

21:10

dry, unless you're someone who specializes

21:12

in the legal nitty gritty of the

21:14

war to end all wars. Not

21:16

your thing? Me neither. Mostly, the

21:18

many words had to do with ending

21:21

the fights over borders and Germany surrendering

21:24

and so on and so forth. But there were

21:26

a few other fights that had been going on

21:28

beyond the battlefield. The

21:31

Treaty of Versailles was an agreement

21:33

to end those fights too. And

21:36

my favorite?

21:37

It tried to end the war on how

21:40

to tune your musical instrument.

21:45

Yep, tuning instruments. It's

21:47

in there, all right. Article 282, Section 22. Like I told

21:49

you, there's a lot of words. Would

21:55

you believe that tuning an instrument wasn't

21:58

something everyone agreed on? Up

22:01

through the 1800s, many things were being standardized,

22:04

meaning everyone agreed on the details

22:06

of things. I'm talking measurements, time,

22:09

weights, cataloging numbers, you name

22:11

it.

22:12

And it was for good reason. I mean, it's pretty hard to

22:14

trade for something if you don't agree on a way

22:16

to measure it. Likewise, musical

22:18

tuning is something that is standardized today.

22:22

But it wasn't always. In a way,

22:24

it makes sense that the tuning clause… You mean Article 282,

22:26

Section 22? Yes, thank

22:29

you.

22:30

It makes sense that this clause was included

22:32

in a treaty signed in France. Because

22:35

France took musical pitch seriously and

22:38

actually passed a national law way

22:40

back in 1852 about how to tune.

22:45

Western music is a term used to describe

22:47

music that developed in Europe, and

22:50

the largest batch of early western music

22:52

was written to be performed in churches.

22:55

You

23:01

ever heard that joke?

23:02

What's the difference between a piano and a tuna

23:04

fish? You can tune a piano,

23:06

but you can't tune a fish. Yeah,

23:09

that's the one. Well, that joke

23:11

doesn't work with pipe organs. Ah,

23:14

bummer. You see, pipe organs

23:16

and tuna fish actually have something

23:18

in common.

23:19

You can't tune either. Pipe

23:22

organs are gigantic. So

23:25

gigantic that they'd be built right into

23:27

the church. The way they sounded was

23:29

the way that they were built. There

23:31

was no standardization. Michael

23:34

McOregon Builder, somewhere in Ireland,

23:36

would have built a different organ than Hermann

23:38

von Organmeister in Germany. And

23:41

all of those probably would have differed from Monsieur

23:44

Pierre Le Organ in France.

23:47

And if these guys were as good of organ builders

23:49

as their names would imply, the

23:52

organs would be in tune with themselves,

23:55

but probably not with one another. Not

23:57

that it mattered, their instruments would never

23:59

be

23:59

in the same room. They'd never be around

24:02

one another. These organs built

24:04

into the churches were pretty permanent

24:07

and they couldn't be moved, but

24:09

they also couldn't be tuned without

24:11

major, major work, unlike

24:13

a violin where you can just tighten

24:16

or loosen a string with a little peg at the

24:18

headstock.

24:20

So when it came time to play, the

24:23

other musicians would just tune

24:25

to the organ and singers

24:27

would, you know, follow their ears to match

24:29

those musicians. That meant

24:32

musicians in France might sound

24:34

a little different than the ones gathered around

24:37

Ol Herman von Organmeister's masterful

24:39

organ in Germany. Today

24:43

musicians tune to a note called A-440. It's

24:46

an A note, and

24:49

if it's played on a string, that string

24:51

will vibrate 440 times per second. In fact,

24:56

no matter what instrument is playing

24:58

the A note, the sound waves coming

25:01

from that instrument are vibrating at 440

25:03

times per second. But if it's a little lower, say 430 times

25:05

per second,

25:07

or a little

25:13

higher,

25:15

say 450 times per second,

25:17

we might not be able to tell easily.

25:20

Doesn't really matter as long as everyone has their

25:22

instrument tuned to the same note

25:24

and that is their agreed upon A.

25:27

But scientifically they are not the same,

25:30

and

25:32

they are clearly not in tune with one another. Now

25:36

it wasn't really a problem at first.

25:38

Some places played their music tuned low, usually

25:41

because that's what their organ player demanded.

25:44

But some tuned theirs high, like

25:46

Goldilocks, some tuned theirs just right. But

25:49

a few problems developed, and they got

25:51

worse over time. First

25:53

off, if you've ever been to a concert, you

25:56

may recall having an easier time hearing,

25:59

maybe even feeling,

25:59

the lower sounds like the bass and

26:02

the kick drum. That's because those

26:04

low sound waves are bigger and

26:06

slower, so they actually go farther

26:08

distances. You can imagine

26:11

the low notes of an organ blasting their way

26:13

through a church and drowning everyone else out. But

26:16

once the organ was phased out, orchestras

26:18

could tune however they liked, and soon

26:21

groups started to raise the pitch, so

26:23

the lower instruments in the ensembles didn't

26:26

overshadow them, since now everything

26:28

could be tuned together.

26:29

Many liked the way this higher

26:32

tuning sounded, it was bright and

26:34

brilliant. And what orchestra

26:36

wouldn't want to sound more brilliant?

26:39

Of course, with the rising pitch, it

26:41

meant

26:42

tighter strings, so a few

26:44

instruments got damaged and a lot of

26:46

snapped strings bothered musicians. But

26:49

in the name of brilliance, they tuned higher

26:52

and higher. In places like

26:54

Austria, things got really dramatic,

26:56

though. You see, singers

26:58

produce their music with their mouth, lungs,

27:01

and vocal cords. Ahh! You

27:03

know this. All of these are part of

27:05

the physical body, and like every

27:08

other body part,

27:09

they can be overstressed.

27:11

As orchestras raised their pitch

27:13

to stand out and be more brilliant than

27:15

their neighbors or their cross-continental

27:18

competitors,

27:20

the pitch got out of hand. And

27:23

high notes got higher. Ahh! And

27:25

higher. And higher. And

27:28

higher! Until the singers couldn't

27:30

keep up.

27:33

Enough was enough. Something had to be

27:35

done. This was around the time that France

27:37

passed a law saying that an A note

27:40

was 435 Hz,

27:42

which is the scientific way to say 435 vibrations per second. This

27:47

created a reference point for all of the other

27:49

notes to tune to. An A vibrated

27:51

at 435, a C above that

27:53

would vibrate faster, and an E above

27:55

that faster still.

27:56

But if the A's matched,

27:59

everything else would be fine.

28:00

wood too, and

28:01

if standard pitch had not been set,

28:03

people might just have kept raising their pitch

28:05

until everyone's vocal cords

28:07

were shot and all of the violins were broken

28:10

from overly tight strings.

28:15

Science to the Rescue One

28:17

guy working in Paris created the most complete

28:20

set of tuning forks the world had ever

28:22

seen,

28:23

or heard, more appropriately.

28:26

Rudolph Koenig was born in Prussia

28:28

but came to France to learn to make violins.

28:31

But instead of becoming one of the most famous violin

28:33

makers, he became one of the finest makers

28:36

of tuning forks in the world. Tuning

28:39

forks, if you're unaware, are the little

28:41

metal tools that you can strike and then place

28:43

on something like a table or an instrument

28:46

or your teeth, and hear a very precise

28:49

pitch which they are specifically

28:51

crafted to create. As

28:54

a maker, Koenig was so precise

28:57

and such a perfectionist that when adjusting

28:59

a fork's tuning,

29:01

he would file it no more than three

29:03

times,

29:04

and then let it sit for a full day to cool

29:06

down from that friction. So

29:09

when the tuning fork king showed up in America

29:11

for the 1876 World's Fair, everyone took

29:14

notice. Say, who's

29:16

the guy with the tuning forks?

29:19

Oh, I want to hear his pitch. It was a big

29:21

deal because Koenig had brought his

29:23

grand tonometer, which

29:25

was the most complete and most precise

29:28

set of tuning forks in the world.

29:31

With incredible precision and diligence, he

29:34

painstakingly created a whopping 670

29:36

forks in

29:39

all, ranging from the super low 16 Hz,

29:42

or vibrations per second, all the way

29:44

up to 4096 Hz. It

29:48

was incredibly accurate, complete,

29:50

and as close to a perfect collection

29:53

of reference pitch tools that the world

29:55

had ever seen.

29:58

they could

30:00

do to keep the tuning forks of the Grand

30:02

Tenometer on American

30:04

shores. Ultimately, the US Military

30:07

Academy paid him handsomely for it, though

30:09

now today the Grand Tenometer Collection is

30:12

in the Smithsonian's National

30:14

Tuning Fork Collection.

30:16

But, Rudolf König didn't

30:18

solve any international conflicts,

30:20

nor did he save the vocal cords of stressed

30:23

opera singers. France's laws

30:25

didn't even do that. Heck, the

30:27

Treaty of Versailles didn't even give us today's

30:29

standard of the 440 Hz A note.

30:32

The Treaty of Versailles set the standard at 435. The

30:36

International Standards Organization,

30:39

who regulates such things, recommended

30:41

the pitch be set to 440 vibrations

30:43

per second in 1955, but they didn't make

30:46

it the official international

30:48

standard until the 1970s.

30:51

It's kind of funny to think that nearly all

30:53

of the music written by people like

30:55

Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, or

30:58

anyone else really sounded very, very

31:00

different because of the relative tunings of

31:02

their time and place.

31:04

Unless you have the opportunity to hear Bach's

31:06

music played on what are called

31:09

period instruments today, tuned to the

31:11

tuning standards of his time,

31:13

you will never hear Bach the way Bach heard

31:16

Bach. Is there chicken in

31:18

here? And if you ever need

31:20

an A note at exactly 440 Hz for any reason,

31:22

you can hear them all over

31:25

the place.

31:27

In fact, there's often a short tone played at the top

31:29

of the hour on many radio stations.

31:31

That's a 440. Guess

31:34

what else is? The dial tone

31:36

on your phone. Or you can just hear it

31:39

here, right now. So if you ever need an A,

31:41

just, you know, come find this episode again.

31:44

Easy peasy.

31:47

Well, yeah, there's an A note for you. Hey,

31:50

thanks everybody for listening to episode 78. Huge

31:53

thanks to Melly Victor. I

31:55

love working with her and it was

31:57

really, really fun. Actually, really moving to put that

31:59

down. story together so I'm very proud of

32:01

that one. Also again I

32:03

want to thank everyone who came to Boston and thank

32:06

WBR BUR also because that was just

32:08

a wonderful opportunity. Had so

32:10

much fun. I'd love to hear from you

32:12

if you went you enjoyed it. Okay

32:15

I have some Patreon people to thank absolutely.

32:18

First off Ethan Turner of Hubley

32:20

Nova Scotia who turned 10 just

32:23

this April 13th. So happy

32:26

late birthday Ethan. I understand

32:28

that you are a car schooler so you listen

32:31

to podcasts such as mine and others I'm

32:33

sure as you're driving to school

32:35

to continue the learning process and I think that's

32:38

awesome and shout out to you and

32:40

shout out to everyone else all the car schoolers

32:42

out there who do that who learn while they commute.

32:45

I love it. Happy birthday Ethan.

32:47

I also need to thank Chi Sing

32:49

Com. Thank you so much for your

32:51

support. I am so glad that you are out there

32:54

and what we're producing matters

32:56

to you. It's so great to know. Glad

32:58

you're out there listening. And then

32:59

also Atticus, Mohammed

33:02

Zadeh and the rest of the family

33:04

including Molly Bloom who is not

33:06

the kids podcast star Molly Bloom but certainly

33:08

just as cool. I hear

33:10

that Atticus is a superfan and that

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features