Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
This podcast is part of
0:02
the Acast Creator Network. Tamp
0:07
check. beach-bomb
0:12
summer, or wake me up when the
0:15
sun sets summer. With Instacart,
0:17
choose your own adventure and skip the
0:19
shopping side quests. Where available, you can
0:21
get ice cream delivered to your hotel,
0:23
sunscreen to the pool, or cold brew
0:26
to your bed. In
0:28
as fast as 30 minutes. Wherever you
0:30
find yourself this summer, you can get
0:33
the goods. Download Instacart for free delivery
0:35
on your first three orders. Offer valid
0:37
for a limited time. Minimum $10 per
0:39
order excludes restaurants, additional terms and fees
0:41
apply. Hi, this is Paige
0:43
from Gigli Squad and I want to
0:46
talk to you about splash refresher and
0:48
my water intake. Okay. So you guys
0:50
obviously know that I am a hydrated
0:52
girly, but sometimes when you drink that
0:54
much water, it starts to
0:56
just taste bland and you're just like, I
0:59
need something to spice it up. That's why I
1:01
love splash refresher. It has
1:03
zero sugar, zero calories, and
1:05
it's a splash of sweetness and they
1:08
come in five different flavors. They're so
1:11
good. Wild berry, acai grape, pineapple, mango,
1:13
lemon, and mandarin orange. My favorite is
1:15
the wild berry because I just, I
1:17
just love a berry. So if you're
1:20
like me and you're drinking water all
1:22
day, then try splash refresher. It's going
1:24
to absolutely change your water game and
1:27
it's good for you. Hello
1:31
and welcome to The Stand with Eamonn
1:33
Dunphy. Now
1:43
the recent European elections saw
1:46
a pronounced shift to the
1:48
right across Europe and
1:50
in France, there was a
1:53
dramatic response from president Macron.
1:55
He decided to stop the
1:57
parliament and call parliamentary elections.
2:00
It was as if he was saying to the French
2:02
people, have you lost your mind? And
2:04
this was almost a rebuke. He got
2:06
his answer yesterday, the first round of
2:09
a two round contest to decide the 577
2:11
seats in the parliament. And
2:16
the result was dramatic. And we're
2:18
joined now by Laura Marlowe
2:20
for long. The Paris correspondent of The
2:23
Irish Times, still a contributor to The
2:25
Irish Times on all things
2:27
French. Laura, thank you very much for joining
2:29
us. It's a pleasure, Inan. Yes, and for
2:32
us too. Laura, the
2:34
results yesterday were
2:36
shocking. Marine Le
2:38
Pen's party national rally,
2:41
which is extreme right,
2:43
hard right, were by far the most
2:45
popular party. And there was also a
2:48
strong result for what could
2:50
be called the hard left.
2:52
Jean-Luc Melicon, a long time
2:54
leftist and a formidable
2:57
French politician also. Tell
2:59
us where Macron stands
3:01
now and indeed where France stands,
3:03
because the second round is next
3:05
Sunday and that's when everything
3:07
will be decided. That's
3:09
right, Inan. Basically,
3:12
the Marine Le Pen's national
3:14
rally, which we use the French initials
3:17
RN, got a
3:19
third of the vote. A third of
3:21
French people voted for the extreme right,
3:23
which is pretty amazing. When
3:25
you realize that last night, the
3:28
RN got 10.6 million votes. That
3:32
is more than triple what they got
3:34
seven years ago in the 2017 presidential
3:36
election. So
3:39
they have more than tripled their vote
3:41
in seven years. They even increased the
3:43
vote since the European
3:45
election on June 9th. So
3:47
between June 9th and June 30th, they
3:50
added three million, nearly three million
3:52
more votes. They got 7.7 million
3:54
votes on June 9th and
3:56
10.6 million on the election. night
4:00
on June 30th. So, they are clearly on
4:02
a roll. As
4:04
you said, the left-wing coalition, which
4:06
is going by the name the
4:08
New Popular Front, got 28%, and
4:12
Macron's centrist coalition got 20%. This
4:16
means that Macron will lose about
4:19
two-thirds of the seats that he had
4:21
in the outgoing National Assembly. He'll go
4:23
from 250 seats
4:25
down to something like about 85 seats. So,
4:28
it was really, when
4:30
people say it was a
4:32
Karman-Kazi dissolution, that's a pretty
4:34
accurate description of it. Yes,
4:37
and there was an increased turnout as
4:39
well, a dramatically increased turnout, wasn't there?
4:42
Yes, absolutely. It was the biggest turnout
4:44
since 1997, at nearly 67% participation. So,
4:50
that shows how strongly people feel
4:53
about this election and how polarized
4:55
the country is. And
4:57
in the second round, and
4:59
in France there's always a second round,
5:02
we've been here before in a
5:04
way, not quite as emphatically when
5:07
you look at the Le Pen
5:09
situation, but her father, Jean-Marie Le
5:11
Pen, finished second. He had a
5:14
run-off. I'm not sure which Chirac
5:16
I think it was, but you'll
5:18
know it was
5:21
2002 exactly, against Chirac, April 2002.
5:24
And what happens traditionally is
5:26
that the left and
5:28
the centre combine to keep Le
5:30
Pen out. Is that
5:32
an option this time? And particularly,
5:35
I'm thinking, you might explain to
5:37
us about Jordan Bardella, who
5:39
would be the new Prime Minister if
5:41
they get a majority next Sunday, and
5:44
the Assembly becomes, is
5:46
in their hands. Jordan Bardella, who's
5:48
28 years of age, working class
5:50
boy, he will be the
5:52
Prime Minister, or maybe the Prime
5:54
Minister. Let me take
5:57
those one at a time. The first question
5:59
is whether... the rest of
6:01
the French body
6:03
politic will get its act together
6:05
between in the next six, seven
6:08
days and fair
6:10
barrage, bar the way for
6:13
the national rally. As
6:15
you said, Éamon, when Le
6:18
Pen-Perre made it to the
6:20
runoff in 2002, the rest
6:22
of the French parties banded
6:24
together and they agreed that
6:26
in the event of three-way races, the
6:28
French called Triandular, the least well-placed
6:33
of what they called the Republican
6:35
parties, i.e. everything but the far
6:37
right, would stand down. And
6:41
the votes would go then to whether it
6:43
was a socialist or a center right
6:45
or whoever, it would go to the
6:48
other candidate. Now, if they can do
6:50
that, they can limit the power of
6:52
the extreme right. The
6:54
whole question is whether Marine Le
6:57
Pen gets an absolute majority, i.e.
7:00
50% or more of the National
7:02
Assembly or whether she gets a
7:04
relative majority, i.e. something like 35,
7:07
40, even 45% of the Assembly.
7:10
Now, if it's a relative majority,
7:14
basically, it's a hung parliament. Nobody
7:16
can pass legislation. If it's an
7:18
absolute majority, Jordan Bardella,
7:21
as you say, this 28-year-old from
7:23
the immigrant suburbs, he will be
7:25
the Prime Minister of France. And
7:28
he said last night that he
7:30
will govern in cohabitation with Macron,
7:32
which means that basically all Macron
7:35
could do is he'd have some
7:37
authority over defense policy and foreign
7:39
policy. But even that, Bardella
7:42
and Le Pen are saying they are going to
7:44
limit, they want to run the
7:47
country. So, the problem with
7:49
the Republican front, which
7:51
if these other parties had
7:53
their act together could limit
7:55
the damage, is that
7:57
they're divided three ways. Macron Paul
7:59
made a very ambiguous statement last
8:02
night. He said that they would
8:05
step aside for what
8:07
he called democratic or
8:09
republican candidates. Now
8:11
this is ambiguous because he
8:14
doesn't seem to be including
8:16
Jean-Luc Mélanchon's France
8:18
Unbound. He doesn't seem to be
8:20
including the left-wing coalition. Or maybe what
8:22
it means is on a case-by-case basis,
8:25
if it's a socialist, a sort
8:27
of social democrat, then the Macronist
8:29
candidate would stand down and let
8:32
the other guy win. But if
8:34
it's a Mélanchon, France Unbound candidate,
8:36
then in those cases they would
8:38
not step
8:41
out of the contest. So
8:45
if it's a case-by-case basis like
8:47
that, it's probably
8:50
not going to work. The other thing
8:52
that centrist politicians are saying,
8:54
a lot of them are saying, neither the
8:56
extreme left nor the extreme right.
8:59
So they are unfairly, in
9:01
my view, classifying Mélanchon and
9:03
the far left with
9:06
the French rice. They're saying
9:08
it's plaguing cholera. We want nothing to
9:10
do with either of them. There
9:13
are expected to be more than 300 three-way
9:15
races next week. This
9:18
is in part a result of the high
9:20
participation. So there's
9:22
still a lot to play for. The
9:24
fact is that the national rally
9:26
will have the largest number of seats.
9:28
That is for certain. That is indisputable.
9:31
It's just a question, will they get
9:33
an absolute
9:35
majority and a government or not?
9:38
Jordan Bardella says he will not
9:40
be prime minister unless he has
9:42
an absolute majority. He's basically saying
9:44
it would be a full variant.
9:46
It would be gridlock. Why
9:49
should I discredit the national rally by
9:51
getting involved in something like that? So
9:53
then, in that case, who would
9:55
Macron name prime minister? Who
9:58
could govern this country? It becomes a... Yes,
10:01
and Macron has three years of
10:03
his presidency left. You said to
10:06
me earlier before we started recording,
10:09
Lara, that this was like the
10:11
day after Brexit or indeed the
10:13
day after Trump's election to
10:15
be President of the United States. In
10:18
other words, France is in shock to
10:20
some extent because Le Pen also,
10:22
they have a certain
10:24
attitude to European Union as
10:27
well, which is rather radical.
10:30
Very much so. I mean, they have
10:32
softened it to the extent that they
10:34
no longer say they would withdraw from
10:36
the EU. They no longer say
10:39
they would withdraw from the Euro group. But
10:42
they could be expected to
10:45
ally themselves with Victor Orban's
10:47
new group that Orban announced
10:49
over the weekend. He calls
10:51
them the Patriots, group of
10:53
Patriots. And Victor Orban is
10:55
in his cups. He's
10:57
predicting that by the
11:00
end of this year, what he
11:02
calls patriotic majorities will
11:04
be in power throughout the Western world.
11:06
And he means that Marine Le Pen
11:08
basically will be running France and Donald Trump
11:10
will be running the US. So it's a
11:13
very frightening prospect. It means in terms of
11:15
the European Union, it
11:17
would mean probably an end of EU aid
11:21
for Ukraine. Yes. That's
11:23
what Orban wants. Le Pen has gone
11:26
softly, softly on that lately. So has
11:28
Bardella. But when you
11:30
realize that the national rally
11:32
has a woman who has
11:35
been basically called a Russian
11:37
spy as an advisor in
11:40
the European Parliament, a woman called
11:42
Tamara Volokhova, who
11:44
has basically specialized in
11:47
sending Le
11:50
Penist members of the European
11:52
Parliament to Crimea and to
11:54
Russia and twinned extreme
11:57
right wing towns in France with
11:59
Russia. Russian towns and so
12:02
on and so forth. And, you know, this
12:04
is at a time when the National Rally
12:06
says they would not
12:08
let dual nationals have sensitive
12:11
jobs. And yet they have
12:13
a dual national Franco-Russian running
12:16
their relations with Russia. She's
12:18
on the Foreign Affairs Commission
12:20
for Security and Defense in
12:22
the European Parliament. So it
12:24
would be devastating for help
12:27
for Ukraine. I
12:29
think probably the worst result, I mean,
12:32
it's devastating for Europe and for everybody.
12:34
But on the home
12:36
front, domestically, Jordan Bardella said
12:38
a week ago that if
12:40
they come to power, they
12:42
will end the
12:44
birthright, the Jus Soleil, which means
12:46
that anyone born in France has
12:49
a right to French citizenship, although
12:51
you still have to ask for
12:53
it within a year of attaining
12:56
adulthood. But there's
12:59
a poll in February of this year
13:01
that showed that 65% of the French
13:03
want to do away with this right
13:05
to citizenship for people born in France.
13:07
The reason they want to do it,
13:10
of course, is that African and Asian
13:12
and African and Arab immigrants
13:14
have children and those children who are
13:16
born in France have the right to
13:18
French citizenship. So they want to stop
13:20
that. It's discrimination. It's
13:22
discrimination on the basis of
13:24
race, basically. They want
13:27
to discriminate among French citizens
13:29
between those who are white,
13:32
d'souche française, born of French
13:34
origin, and those
13:36
who are non-white. That's what
13:39
it boils down to. Yes, and so
13:41
much of the drift to the right
13:43
across Europe is related to immigration. It
13:45
is really at the top
13:48
of the agenda for so
13:50
many parties. Italy would be
13:52
another example. The
13:54
United Kingdom immigration there is
13:57
also now a contentious issue.
14:00
And even here, there is stuff
14:02
going on, what we would call
14:04
the far right. They're tiny and
14:07
they're contained, but we don't really matter
14:10
in the sense that we're small, but
14:12
France, Italy, Germany, the
14:14
rise of the AFD in Germany
14:16
as well is related to that.
14:19
So the US, the US, the
14:21
US, of course, rises due to
14:24
immigration as an issue. And immigration
14:27
is very often inflated, exaggerated. I mean,
14:29
to hear the I keep wanting to
14:31
say National Front because they were called
14:34
that for decades. But the national rally
14:36
to hear them speak, you
14:38
know, people are being run out of
14:41
their homes and, you know, immigrants are
14:43
taking over the country. A lot of
14:45
them believe in the great replacement theory,
14:48
which is a plot to
14:51
replace the white European
14:53
population with blacks
14:55
and Arabs. So there's
14:57
an obsession over it. And, you
14:59
know, Bardella and Marine Le Pen
15:01
in their speech are
15:04
very careful what they say
15:06
now. But if you listen
15:08
to their voters, it's all
15:10
about it is really hateful
15:12
hatred of immigrants, of foreigners,
15:14
of the other. Yes, the
15:16
great replacement theory is it's
15:18
an American conspiracy theory that's
15:20
widely popular online and read
15:23
internationally. Actually, I hate to
15:25
say the same. It's European.
15:28
It came from a guy called, yeah,
15:30
this is very often forgotten. It came
15:32
from a guy called Honore Camus, who's
15:35
alive and well and living in central
15:37
France. And he is the
15:40
theoretician of Le Grand Place Mont,
15:42
the great replacement. So like many
15:44
things, good and bad, it comes
15:46
from France originally. Just to give
15:48
us our listeners, particularly our younger
15:50
listeners, the sense of Marine Le
15:52
Pen. She has rehabilitated,
15:55
if you like, what
15:57
was the national front. Her
15:59
father. Jean-Marie Le Pen
16:01
was an out-and-out
16:04
racist. He was also
16:06
a Nazi apologist, or
16:08
they were his preference. He
16:11
was a really serious and
16:13
almost untouchable figure
16:16
of the right, very extreme.
16:19
And she has cleaned up that
16:21
party. We're told she's got
16:24
rid of some of the more extreme
16:26
people in it. They present
16:28
now as something different. But
16:31
her father would be, you know,
16:34
you would have thought unelectable when he was running
16:36
20, 25, 30 years ago. Yes,
16:41
Jean-Marie Le Pen co-founded the National
16:43
Front in 1972. He'd
16:47
been a paratrooper in Algeria.
16:49
He tortured Algerians when
16:51
he was in the French army. There
16:56
were two former members of the
16:58
Waffen-SS, of the French division of
17:00
the Waffen-SS. There
17:05
were two former French
17:07
members of the Nazi Waffen-SS
17:09
among the founding members of
17:11
the National Front. There were
17:13
also several people who had
17:16
served in Marichal Pétain's collaboration
17:18
as government during the Second
17:20
World War. And as you say,
17:22
Le Pen was a Holocaust
17:24
denier. One of Le Pen's
17:26
most famous quotes was, who has ever seen a
17:29
gas chamber? And he said
17:31
that the Holocaust was a
17:33
detail of history. Now
17:35
Marie Le Pen started rising in the
17:37
ranks of the National Front during the
17:40
2000s. And
17:43
by 2011, she became the leader of
17:45
the party and she decided she eventually
17:48
expelled her own father. It was a
17:50
Shakespearean drama of her throwing her
17:52
father out of the party. And
17:54
she decided she would detoxify it.
17:56
That was the verb that was
17:58
used. She distanced herself
18:01
from the anti-Semitism, which
18:03
the extreme right was known for,
18:05
to such an extent that it's
18:07
quite stunning in this election, Serge
18:10
Klatfeld, who's a Nazi hunter, has
18:12
said that in the second round, if it's a
18:15
question of voting for the far left or the
18:17
far right, he'll vote for the far right. Alan
18:20
Finkelkraut, who's a Jewish
18:22
philosopher, has said
18:24
the same thing, that it's all right to vote
18:26
for the extreme right. Now, I
18:29
must say that there are French Jews who are divided
18:31
on this. I have a Jewish
18:34
friend who's a journalist who sent
18:36
me a text message after the
18:38
European election saying they're going to
18:40
reestablish direct trains to Auschwitz. And
18:42
it was a sick joke, but
18:45
a lot of Jews feel very insecure and unhappy
18:47
about this as well. So,
18:49
Marine Le Pen got rid of the
18:51
anti-Semitism. She did not get rid of
18:53
the Islamophobia. That is a very, very
18:55
strong element of the party's ideology. She
19:00
changed the name in 2018 from
19:03
Fond-Nacional to Ha-Sam-de-Mond-Nacional,
19:06
all to make the party acceptable.
19:08
And she had, I must give
19:12
her credit for having political
19:14
talent. She spotted Jordan Bardella
19:17
and coached him, had him coached,
19:19
and sort of brought him up
19:21
from a 16-year-old teenage
19:24
militant in the party to
19:27
the point where she says he will
19:29
be our prime minister if we win
19:31
an absolute majority. So,
19:33
it's quite an amazing comeback.
19:36
She has made it to the
19:38
runoff in the presidential election twice
19:41
already. Macron does not
19:43
want to be succeeded by Marine Le
19:45
Pen. Some people think
19:47
that's why he conceived
19:49
this harebrained scheme to
19:52
dissolve the National Assembly and
19:54
hold a snap election because he's hoping
19:57
that the National Rally will discredit them.
19:59
themselves that they'll make a huge mess
20:01
of everything. And that in three years
20:03
from now, when we're due for another
20:05
presidential election, then France
20:08
will choose someone else. A lot of
20:10
people think that Mélanchon
20:13
is making the same calculation. He
20:15
knows he cannot be prime minister.
20:17
The new popular front
20:19
cannot possibly win an absolute majority
20:21
next week. So
20:23
what he's really hoping is that the
20:26
national rally will make a mess or
20:28
that we'll have gridlock and chaos and
20:32
have a nose, perhaps street fighting, whatever.
20:34
And that in three years from now,
20:36
people will elect President Jean-Luc Mélanchon.
20:39
Yes, and there was trouble, which
20:41
would say in some French cities
20:44
last night, particularly in Paris, but
20:46
it wasn't on a scale that
20:48
would worry you compared to the
20:50
past and even the goalless times.
20:55
Hi, Brooke here from Naked Beauty. When I
20:58
tell you that Sunglass Hut is really my
21:00
go-to to really kick off summer because they
21:02
have such a good curated summer collection, perfectly
21:04
aligned for finding every shade of you. Sunglass
21:06
Hut really has shades at every price point
21:09
and they are so incredibly helpful there. They
21:11
will take their time with you. They even
21:13
tightened my glasses to make sure they didn't
21:15
fall off my head. They gladly adjusted them
21:17
for me. And if you need a prescription
21:20
lens, they can add that into your sunglasses
21:22
as well. Sunglass Hut really has it all
21:24
and again, a frame for every shade of
21:26
you. Millions of people
21:28
have lost weight with personalized plans from
21:30
Noom. Like Evan, who can't stand salads
21:32
and still lost 50 pounds. Salads
21:35
generally for most people are the easy button,
21:37
right? For me, that wasn't an option. I
21:40
never really was a salad guy. That's just
21:42
not who I am. But Noom worked for
21:44
me. Get your
21:46
personalized plan today at noom.com. Real
21:49
Noom user compensated to provide their story. In four
21:51
weeks, the typical Noom user can expect to lose
21:53
one to two pounds per week. Individual results may
21:55
vary. to
22:00
you about splash refresher and my
22:02
water intake. Okay, so you guys
22:04
obviously know that I am
22:06
a hydrated girly, but sometimes when you
22:08
drink that much water, it
22:10
starts to just taste bland and you're just
22:12
like, I need something to spice it up.
22:15
That's why I love splash refresher. It
22:17
has zero sugar, zero calories, and
22:19
it's a splash of sweetness. And
22:22
they come in five different flavors.
22:24
They're so good.
22:26
Wild berry, acai grape, pineapple
22:28
mango, lemon and mandarin orange.
22:30
My favorite is the wild berry because
22:33
I just love a berry. So if
22:35
you're like me and you're drinking water
22:37
all day, then try splash refresher. It's
22:39
going to absolutely change your water game
22:41
and it's good for you. We
22:44
all belong outside. We're drawn to nature,
22:46
whether it's the recorded sounds of the
22:48
ocean we doze off to or the
22:50
succulents that adorn our homes. Nature
22:52
makes all of our lives, well, better.
22:55
Despite all this, we often go about
22:57
our busy lives removed from it, but
23:00
the outdoors is closer than we realize. With
23:03
AllTrails, you can discover trails nearby
23:05
and explore confidently. With offline maps
23:07
and on-trail navigation, download the free
23:09
app today and make the most
23:11
of your summer with AllTrails. Just
23:17
to ask about Macron,
23:19
he came out of nowhere. Is
23:22
he going back to nowhere? Because
23:24
he does seem... I know
23:26
that many people had great hopes for him.
23:29
Is he a rather vacuous figure
23:31
now? He said his big thing
23:33
was, I'm neither left nor right.
23:36
But the question is, and
23:39
he has tried to play on the world
23:41
stage, but his judgment,
23:43
you'd have to question in
23:45
terms of his response to the disappointments
23:47
of the European election, which was felt
23:50
by many leaders. Certainly. I
23:53
would certainly question his judgment. In
23:55
fact, I'd say he's deluded.
32:08
Ready to start talking to your kids about
32:10
financial literacy? Meet Greenlight, the
32:13
debit card and money app that teaches
32:15
kids and teens how to earn, save,
32:17
spend wisely, and invest with your guardrails
32:19
in place. Parents can send
32:21
instant money transfers.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More