Podchaser Logo
Home
Ep 1996: French Parliamentary Election - France rejects Macron and moves sharply to the right

Ep 1996: French Parliamentary Election - France rejects Macron and moves sharply to the right

Released Tuesday, 2nd July 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Ep 1996: French Parliamentary Election - France rejects Macron and moves sharply to the right

Ep 1996: French Parliamentary Election - France rejects Macron and moves sharply to the right

Ep 1996: French Parliamentary Election - France rejects Macron and moves sharply to the right

Ep 1996: French Parliamentary Election - France rejects Macron and moves sharply to the right

Tuesday, 2nd July 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

This podcast is part of

0:02

the Acast Creator Network. Tamp

0:07

check. beach-bomb

0:12

summer, or wake me up when the

0:15

sun sets summer. With Instacart,

0:17

choose your own adventure and skip the

0:19

shopping side quests. Where available, you can

0:21

get ice cream delivered to your hotel,

0:23

sunscreen to the pool, or cold brew

0:26

to your bed. In

0:28

as fast as 30 minutes. Wherever you

0:30

find yourself this summer, you can get

0:33

the goods. Download Instacart for free delivery

0:35

on your first three orders. Offer valid

0:37

for a limited time. Minimum $10 per

0:39

order excludes restaurants, additional terms and fees

0:41

apply. Hi, this is Paige

0:43

from Gigli Squad and I want to

0:46

talk to you about splash refresher and

0:48

my water intake. Okay. So you guys

0:50

obviously know that I am a hydrated

0:52

girly, but sometimes when you drink that

0:54

much water, it starts to

0:56

just taste bland and you're just like, I

0:59

need something to spice it up. That's why I

1:01

love splash refresher. It has

1:03

zero sugar, zero calories, and

1:05

it's a splash of sweetness and they

1:08

come in five different flavors. They're so

1:11

good. Wild berry, acai grape, pineapple, mango,

1:13

lemon, and mandarin orange. My favorite is

1:15

the wild berry because I just, I

1:17

just love a berry. So if you're

1:20

like me and you're drinking water all

1:22

day, then try splash refresher. It's going

1:24

to absolutely change your water game and

1:27

it's good for you. Hello

1:31

and welcome to The Stand with Eamonn

1:33

Dunphy. Now

1:43

the recent European elections saw

1:46

a pronounced shift to the

1:48

right across Europe and

1:50

in France, there was a

1:53

dramatic response from president Macron.

1:55

He decided to stop the

1:57

parliament and call parliamentary elections.

2:00

It was as if he was saying to the French

2:02

people, have you lost your mind? And

2:04

this was almost a rebuke. He got

2:06

his answer yesterday, the first round of

2:09

a two round contest to decide the 577

2:11

seats in the parliament. And

2:16

the result was dramatic. And we're

2:18

joined now by Laura Marlowe

2:20

for long. The Paris correspondent of The

2:23

Irish Times, still a contributor to The

2:25

Irish Times on all things

2:27

French. Laura, thank you very much for joining

2:29

us. It's a pleasure, Inan. Yes, and for

2:32

us too. Laura, the

2:34

results yesterday were

2:36

shocking. Marine Le

2:38

Pen's party national rally,

2:41

which is extreme right,

2:43

hard right, were by far the most

2:45

popular party. And there was also a

2:48

strong result for what could

2:50

be called the hard left.

2:52

Jean-Luc Melicon, a long time

2:54

leftist and a formidable

2:57

French politician also. Tell

2:59

us where Macron stands

3:01

now and indeed where France stands,

3:03

because the second round is next

3:05

Sunday and that's when everything

3:07

will be decided. That's

3:09

right, Inan. Basically,

3:12

the Marine Le Pen's national

3:14

rally, which we use the French initials

3:17

RN, got a

3:19

third of the vote. A third of

3:21

French people voted for the extreme right,

3:23

which is pretty amazing. When

3:25

you realize that last night, the

3:28

RN got 10.6 million votes. That

3:32

is more than triple what they got

3:34

seven years ago in the 2017 presidential

3:36

election. So

3:39

they have more than tripled their vote

3:41

in seven years. They even increased the

3:43

vote since the European

3:45

election on June 9th. So

3:47

between June 9th and June 30th, they

3:50

added three million, nearly three million

3:52

more votes. They got 7.7 million

3:54

votes on June 9th and

3:56

10.6 million on the election. night

4:00

on June 30th. So, they are clearly on

4:02

a roll. As

4:04

you said, the left-wing coalition, which

4:06

is going by the name the

4:08

New Popular Front, got 28%, and

4:12

Macron's centrist coalition got 20%. This

4:16

means that Macron will lose about

4:19

two-thirds of the seats that he had

4:21

in the outgoing National Assembly. He'll go

4:23

from 250 seats

4:25

down to something like about 85 seats. So,

4:28

it was really, when

4:30

people say it was a

4:32

Karman-Kazi dissolution, that's a pretty

4:34

accurate description of it. Yes,

4:37

and there was an increased turnout as

4:39

well, a dramatically increased turnout, wasn't there?

4:42

Yes, absolutely. It was the biggest turnout

4:44

since 1997, at nearly 67% participation. So,

4:50

that shows how strongly people feel

4:53

about this election and how polarized

4:55

the country is. And

4:57

in the second round, and

4:59

in France there's always a second round,

5:02

we've been here before in a

5:04

way, not quite as emphatically when

5:07

you look at the Le Pen

5:09

situation, but her father, Jean-Marie Le

5:11

Pen, finished second. He had a

5:14

run-off. I'm not sure which Chirac

5:16

I think it was, but you'll

5:18

know it was

5:21

2002 exactly, against Chirac, April 2002.

5:24

And what happens traditionally is

5:26

that the left and

5:28

the centre combine to keep Le

5:30

Pen out. Is that

5:32

an option this time? And particularly,

5:35

I'm thinking, you might explain to

5:37

us about Jordan Bardella, who

5:39

would be the new Prime Minister if

5:41

they get a majority next Sunday, and

5:44

the Assembly becomes, is

5:46

in their hands. Jordan Bardella, who's

5:48

28 years of age, working class

5:50

boy, he will be the

5:52

Prime Minister, or maybe the Prime

5:54

Minister. Let me take

5:57

those one at a time. The first question

5:59

is whether... the rest of

6:01

the French body

6:03

politic will get its act together

6:05

between in the next six, seven

6:08

days and fair

6:10

barrage, bar the way for

6:13

the national rally. As

6:15

you said, Éamon, when Le

6:18

Pen-Perre made it to the

6:20

runoff in 2002, the rest

6:22

of the French parties banded

6:24

together and they agreed that

6:26

in the event of three-way races, the

6:28

French called Triandular, the least well-placed

6:33

of what they called the Republican

6:35

parties, i.e. everything but the far

6:37

right, would stand down. And

6:41

the votes would go then to whether it

6:43

was a socialist or a center right

6:45

or whoever, it would go to the

6:48

other candidate. Now, if they can do

6:50

that, they can limit the power of

6:52

the extreme right. The

6:54

whole question is whether Marine Le

6:57

Pen gets an absolute majority, i.e.

7:00

50% or more of the National

7:02

Assembly or whether she gets a

7:04

relative majority, i.e. something like 35,

7:07

40, even 45% of the Assembly.

7:10

Now, if it's a relative majority,

7:14

basically, it's a hung parliament. Nobody

7:16

can pass legislation. If it's an

7:18

absolute majority, Jordan Bardella,

7:21

as you say, this 28-year-old from

7:23

the immigrant suburbs, he will be

7:25

the Prime Minister of France. And

7:28

he said last night that he

7:30

will govern in cohabitation with Macron,

7:32

which means that basically all Macron

7:35

could do is he'd have some

7:37

authority over defense policy and foreign

7:39

policy. But even that, Bardella

7:42

and Le Pen are saying they are going to

7:44

limit, they want to run the

7:47

country. So, the problem with

7:49

the Republican front, which

7:51

if these other parties had

7:53

their act together could limit

7:55

the damage, is that

7:57

they're divided three ways. Macron Paul

7:59

made a very ambiguous statement last

8:02

night. He said that they would

8:05

step aside for what

8:07

he called democratic or

8:09

republican candidates. Now

8:11

this is ambiguous because he

8:14

doesn't seem to be including

8:16

Jean-Luc Mélanchon's France

8:18

Unbound. He doesn't seem to be

8:20

including the left-wing coalition. Or maybe what

8:22

it means is on a case-by-case basis,

8:25

if it's a socialist, a sort

8:27

of social democrat, then the Macronist

8:29

candidate would stand down and let

8:32

the other guy win. But if

8:34

it's a Mélanchon, France Unbound candidate,

8:36

then in those cases they would

8:38

not step

8:41

out of the contest. So

8:45

if it's a case-by-case basis like

8:47

that, it's probably

8:50

not going to work. The other thing

8:52

that centrist politicians are saying,

8:54

a lot of them are saying, neither the

8:56

extreme left nor the extreme right.

8:59

So they are unfairly, in

9:01

my view, classifying Mélanchon and

9:03

the far left with

9:06

the French rice. They're saying

9:08

it's plaguing cholera. We want nothing to

9:10

do with either of them. There

9:13

are expected to be more than 300 three-way

9:15

races next week. This

9:18

is in part a result of the high

9:20

participation. So there's

9:22

still a lot to play for. The

9:24

fact is that the national rally

9:26

will have the largest number of seats.

9:28

That is for certain. That is indisputable.

9:31

It's just a question, will they get

9:33

an absolute

9:35

majority and a government or not?

9:38

Jordan Bardella says he will not

9:40

be prime minister unless he has

9:42

an absolute majority. He's basically saying

9:44

it would be a full variant.

9:46

It would be gridlock. Why

9:49

should I discredit the national rally by

9:51

getting involved in something like that? So

9:53

then, in that case, who would

9:55

Macron name prime minister? Who

9:58

could govern this country? It becomes a... Yes,

10:01

and Macron has three years of

10:03

his presidency left. You said to

10:06

me earlier before we started recording,

10:09

Lara, that this was like the

10:11

day after Brexit or indeed the

10:13

day after Trump's election to

10:15

be President of the United States. In

10:18

other words, France is in shock to

10:20

some extent because Le Pen also,

10:22

they have a certain

10:24

attitude to European Union as

10:27

well, which is rather radical.

10:30

Very much so. I mean, they have

10:32

softened it to the extent that they

10:34

no longer say they would withdraw from

10:36

the EU. They no longer say

10:39

they would withdraw from the Euro group. But

10:42

they could be expected to

10:45

ally themselves with Victor Orban's

10:47

new group that Orban announced

10:49

over the weekend. He calls

10:51

them the Patriots, group of

10:53

Patriots. And Victor Orban is

10:55

in his cups. He's

10:57

predicting that by the

11:00

end of this year, what he

11:02

calls patriotic majorities will

11:04

be in power throughout the Western world.

11:06

And he means that Marine Le Pen

11:08

basically will be running France and Donald Trump

11:10

will be running the US. So it's a

11:13

very frightening prospect. It means in terms of

11:15

the European Union, it

11:17

would mean probably an end of EU aid

11:21

for Ukraine. Yes. That's

11:23

what Orban wants. Le Pen has gone

11:26

softly, softly on that lately. So has

11:28

Bardella. But when you

11:30

realize that the national rally

11:32

has a woman who has

11:35

been basically called a Russian

11:37

spy as an advisor in

11:40

the European Parliament, a woman called

11:42

Tamara Volokhova, who

11:44

has basically specialized in

11:47

sending Le

11:50

Penist members of the European

11:52

Parliament to Crimea and to

11:54

Russia and twinned extreme

11:57

right wing towns in France with

11:59

Russia. Russian towns and so

12:02

on and so forth. And, you know, this

12:04

is at a time when the National Rally

12:06

says they would not

12:08

let dual nationals have sensitive

12:11

jobs. And yet they have

12:13

a dual national Franco-Russian running

12:16

their relations with Russia. She's

12:18

on the Foreign Affairs Commission

12:20

for Security and Defense in

12:22

the European Parliament. So it

12:24

would be devastating for help

12:27

for Ukraine. I

12:29

think probably the worst result, I mean,

12:32

it's devastating for Europe and for everybody.

12:34

But on the home

12:36

front, domestically, Jordan Bardella said

12:38

a week ago that if

12:40

they come to power, they

12:42

will end the

12:44

birthright, the Jus Soleil, which means

12:46

that anyone born in France has

12:49

a right to French citizenship, although

12:51

you still have to ask for

12:53

it within a year of attaining

12:56

adulthood. But there's

12:59

a poll in February of this year

13:01

that showed that 65% of the French

13:03

want to do away with this right

13:05

to citizenship for people born in France.

13:07

The reason they want to do it,

13:10

of course, is that African and Asian

13:12

and African and Arab immigrants

13:14

have children and those children who are

13:16

born in France have the right to

13:18

French citizenship. So they want to stop

13:20

that. It's discrimination. It's

13:22

discrimination on the basis of

13:24

race, basically. They want

13:27

to discriminate among French citizens

13:29

between those who are white,

13:32

d'souche française, born of French

13:34

origin, and those

13:36

who are non-white. That's what

13:39

it boils down to. Yes, and so

13:41

much of the drift to the right

13:43

across Europe is related to immigration. It

13:45

is really at the top

13:48

of the agenda for so

13:50

many parties. Italy would be

13:52

another example. The

13:54

United Kingdom immigration there is

13:57

also now a contentious issue.

14:00

And even here, there is stuff

14:02

going on, what we would call

14:04

the far right. They're tiny and

14:07

they're contained, but we don't really matter

14:10

in the sense that we're small, but

14:12

France, Italy, Germany, the

14:14

rise of the AFD in Germany

14:16

as well is related to that.

14:19

So the US, the US, the

14:21

US, of course, rises due to

14:24

immigration as an issue. And immigration

14:27

is very often inflated, exaggerated. I mean,

14:29

to hear the I keep wanting to

14:31

say National Front because they were called

14:34

that for decades. But the national rally

14:36

to hear them speak, you

14:38

know, people are being run out of

14:41

their homes and, you know, immigrants are

14:43

taking over the country. A lot of

14:45

them believe in the great replacement theory,

14:48

which is a plot to

14:51

replace the white European

14:53

population with blacks

14:55

and Arabs. So there's

14:57

an obsession over it. And, you

14:59

know, Bardella and Marine Le Pen

15:01

in their speech are

15:04

very careful what they say

15:06

now. But if you listen

15:08

to their voters, it's all

15:10

about it is really hateful

15:12

hatred of immigrants, of foreigners,

15:14

of the other. Yes, the

15:16

great replacement theory is it's

15:18

an American conspiracy theory that's

15:20

widely popular online and read

15:23

internationally. Actually, I hate to

15:25

say the same. It's European.

15:28

It came from a guy called, yeah,

15:30

this is very often forgotten. It came

15:32

from a guy called Honore Camus, who's

15:35

alive and well and living in central

15:37

France. And he is the

15:40

theoretician of Le Grand Place Mont,

15:42

the great replacement. So like many

15:44

things, good and bad, it comes

15:46

from France originally. Just to give

15:48

us our listeners, particularly our younger

15:50

listeners, the sense of Marine Le

15:52

Pen. She has rehabilitated,

15:55

if you like, what

15:57

was the national front. Her

15:59

father. Jean-Marie Le Pen

16:01

was an out-and-out

16:04

racist. He was also

16:06

a Nazi apologist, or

16:08

they were his preference. He

16:11

was a really serious and

16:13

almost untouchable figure

16:16

of the right, very extreme.

16:19

And she has cleaned up that

16:21

party. We're told she's got

16:24

rid of some of the more extreme

16:26

people in it. They present

16:28

now as something different. But

16:31

her father would be, you know,

16:34

you would have thought unelectable when he was running

16:36

20, 25, 30 years ago. Yes,

16:41

Jean-Marie Le Pen co-founded the National

16:43

Front in 1972. He'd

16:47

been a paratrooper in Algeria.

16:49

He tortured Algerians when

16:51

he was in the French army. There

16:56

were two former members of the

16:58

Waffen-SS, of the French division of

17:00

the Waffen-SS. There

17:05

were two former French

17:07

members of the Nazi Waffen-SS

17:09

among the founding members of

17:11

the National Front. There were

17:13

also several people who had

17:16

served in Marichal Pétain's collaboration

17:18

as government during the Second

17:20

World War. And as you say,

17:22

Le Pen was a Holocaust

17:24

denier. One of Le Pen's

17:26

most famous quotes was, who has ever seen a

17:29

gas chamber? And he said

17:31

that the Holocaust was a

17:33

detail of history. Now

17:35

Marie Le Pen started rising in the

17:37

ranks of the National Front during the

17:40

2000s. And

17:43

by 2011, she became the leader of

17:45

the party and she decided she eventually

17:48

expelled her own father. It was a

17:50

Shakespearean drama of her throwing her

17:52

father out of the party. And

17:54

she decided she would detoxify it.

17:56

That was the verb that was

17:58

used. She distanced herself

18:01

from the anti-Semitism, which

18:03

the extreme right was known for,

18:05

to such an extent that it's

18:07

quite stunning in this election, Serge

18:10

Klatfeld, who's a Nazi hunter, has

18:12

said that in the second round, if it's a

18:15

question of voting for the far left or the

18:17

far right, he'll vote for the far right. Alan

18:20

Finkelkraut, who's a Jewish

18:22

philosopher, has said

18:24

the same thing, that it's all right to vote

18:26

for the extreme right. Now, I

18:29

must say that there are French Jews who are divided

18:31

on this. I have a Jewish

18:34

friend who's a journalist who sent

18:36

me a text message after the

18:38

European election saying they're going to

18:40

reestablish direct trains to Auschwitz. And

18:42

it was a sick joke, but

18:45

a lot of Jews feel very insecure and unhappy

18:47

about this as well. So,

18:49

Marine Le Pen got rid of the

18:51

anti-Semitism. She did not get rid of

18:53

the Islamophobia. That is a very, very

18:55

strong element of the party's ideology. She

19:00

changed the name in 2018 from

19:03

Fond-Nacional to Ha-Sam-de-Mond-Nacional,

19:06

all to make the party acceptable.

19:08

And she had, I must give

19:12

her credit for having political

19:14

talent. She spotted Jordan Bardella

19:17

and coached him, had him coached,

19:19

and sort of brought him up

19:21

from a 16-year-old teenage

19:24

militant in the party to

19:27

the point where she says he will

19:29

be our prime minister if we win

19:31

an absolute majority. So,

19:33

it's quite an amazing comeback.

19:36

She has made it to the

19:38

runoff in the presidential election twice

19:41

already. Macron does not

19:43

want to be succeeded by Marine Le

19:45

Pen. Some people think

19:47

that's why he conceived

19:49

this harebrained scheme to

19:52

dissolve the National Assembly and

19:54

hold a snap election because he's hoping

19:57

that the National Rally will discredit them.

19:59

themselves that they'll make a huge mess

20:01

of everything. And that in three years

20:03

from now, when we're due for another

20:05

presidential election, then France

20:08

will choose someone else. A lot of

20:10

people think that Mélanchon

20:13

is making the same calculation. He

20:15

knows he cannot be prime minister.

20:17

The new popular front

20:19

cannot possibly win an absolute majority

20:21

next week. So

20:23

what he's really hoping is that the

20:26

national rally will make a mess or

20:28

that we'll have gridlock and chaos and

20:32

have a nose, perhaps street fighting, whatever.

20:34

And that in three years from now,

20:36

people will elect President Jean-Luc Mélanchon.

20:39

Yes, and there was trouble, which

20:41

would say in some French cities

20:44

last night, particularly in Paris, but

20:46

it wasn't on a scale that

20:48

would worry you compared to the

20:50

past and even the goalless times.

20:55

Hi, Brooke here from Naked Beauty. When I

20:58

tell you that Sunglass Hut is really my

21:00

go-to to really kick off summer because they

21:02

have such a good curated summer collection, perfectly

21:04

aligned for finding every shade of you. Sunglass

21:06

Hut really has shades at every price point

21:09

and they are so incredibly helpful there. They

21:11

will take their time with you. They even

21:13

tightened my glasses to make sure they didn't

21:15

fall off my head. They gladly adjusted them

21:17

for me. And if you need a prescription

21:20

lens, they can add that into your sunglasses

21:22

as well. Sunglass Hut really has it all

21:24

and again, a frame for every shade of

21:26

you. Millions of people

21:28

have lost weight with personalized plans from

21:30

Noom. Like Evan, who can't stand salads

21:32

and still lost 50 pounds. Salads

21:35

generally for most people are the easy button,

21:37

right? For me, that wasn't an option. I

21:40

never really was a salad guy. That's just

21:42

not who I am. But Noom worked for

21:44

me. Get your

21:46

personalized plan today at noom.com. Real

21:49

Noom user compensated to provide their story. In four

21:51

weeks, the typical Noom user can expect to lose

21:53

one to two pounds per week. Individual results may

21:55

vary. to

22:00

you about splash refresher and my

22:02

water intake. Okay, so you guys

22:04

obviously know that I am

22:06

a hydrated girly, but sometimes when you

22:08

drink that much water, it

22:10

starts to just taste bland and you're just

22:12

like, I need something to spice it up.

22:15

That's why I love splash refresher. It

22:17

has zero sugar, zero calories, and

22:19

it's a splash of sweetness. And

22:22

they come in five different flavors.

22:24

They're so good.

22:26

Wild berry, acai grape, pineapple

22:28

mango, lemon and mandarin orange.

22:30

My favorite is the wild berry because

22:33

I just love a berry. So if

22:35

you're like me and you're drinking water

22:37

all day, then try splash refresher. It's

22:39

going to absolutely change your water game

22:41

and it's good for you. We

22:44

all belong outside. We're drawn to nature,

22:46

whether it's the recorded sounds of the

22:48

ocean we doze off to or the

22:50

succulents that adorn our homes. Nature

22:52

makes all of our lives, well, better.

22:55

Despite all this, we often go about

22:57

our busy lives removed from it, but

23:00

the outdoors is closer than we realize. With

23:03

AllTrails, you can discover trails nearby

23:05

and explore confidently. With offline maps

23:07

and on-trail navigation, download the free

23:09

app today and make the most

23:11

of your summer with AllTrails. Just

23:17

to ask about Macron,

23:19

he came out of nowhere. Is

23:22

he going back to nowhere? Because

23:24

he does seem... I know

23:26

that many people had great hopes for him.

23:29

Is he a rather vacuous figure

23:31

now? He said his big thing

23:33

was, I'm neither left nor right.

23:36

But the question is, and

23:39

he has tried to play on the world

23:41

stage, but his judgment,

23:43

you'd have to question in

23:45

terms of his response to the disappointments

23:47

of the European election, which was felt

23:50

by many leaders. Certainly. I

23:53

would certainly question his judgment. In

23:55

fact, I'd say he's deluded.

32:08

Ready to start talking to your kids about

32:10

financial literacy? Meet Greenlight, the

32:13

debit card and money app that teaches

32:15

kids and teens how to earn, save,

32:17

spend wisely, and invest with your guardrails

32:19

in place. Parents can send

32:21

instant money transfers.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features