Podchaser Logo
Home
Tracing the origin story of Taylor Swift

Tracing the origin story of Taylor Swift

Released Sunday, 9th June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Tracing the origin story of Taylor Swift

Tracing the origin story of Taylor Swift

Tracing the origin story of Taylor Swift

Tracing the origin story of Taylor Swift

Sunday, 9th June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Ready to start talking to your kids about

0:02

financial literacy? Meet Greenlight, the debit

0:04

card and money app that teaches kids and

0:06

teens how to earn, save, spend

0:09

wisely, and invest with your guardrails

0:11

in place. Parents can send

0:13

instant money transfers, automate allowance, and

0:16

more. Plus, keep an eye on

0:18

spending with real-time notifications. Join

0:20

more than six million parents and

0:22

kids building healthy financial habits together

0:24

on Greenlight. Get your first

0:27

month free at greenlight.com/ACAST. That's greenlight.com/ACAST.

0:29

Many of us have those stubborn

0:31

pounds that seem impossible to lose,

0:33

no matter how good we eat

0:35

or how hard we work out.

0:37

My solution is Plushcare. Plushcare is

0:40

a leading telehealth provider with doctors

0:42

who are there for you day

0:44

and night to partner with you

0:46

in your weight loss journey. They

0:48

can prescribe FDA-approved weight loss medications

0:50

like Wagovi and Zeppound for those

0:52

who qualify. Plus, they accept most

0:55

insurance plans. To get

0:57

started, visit plushcare.com/weight loss.

0:59

That's plushcare.com/weight loss. From

1:06

the Times and the Sunday Times, this

1:08

is the story. I'm Jane Mulkerins.

1:16

I'm just driving up the

1:18

road where

1:20

Taylor Swift spent much

1:23

of her childhood and

1:26

why I'm missing in Pennsylvania.

1:30

For three weeks, the Times and Sunday

1:32

Times' Megan Agnew went on what I

1:34

can only describe as one of the

1:37

most envy-inducing reporting missions I have ever

1:39

heard of, tracing the

1:41

trail of Taylor Swift. From

1:49

Pennsylvania to New Jersey to

1:51

Tennessee, Megan set out

1:53

to speak to everyone and anyone who

1:56

might have known the pop sensation before

1:58

she was a pop sensation. And

10:00

did you get the impression that quite a lot of journalists

10:02

do turn up at their door on the swift trail? Yes,

10:05

I did there, but that was really the

10:07

only place that I did. Everywhere

10:09

else I kind of expected it

10:11

to be this really well trodden

10:14

route. And

10:16

I just, you know, the conversations that I had

10:18

with my editors before was like, just see how

10:20

far you get. See where you get

10:22

to. It's probably been done a million times and people will

10:24

probably be reluctant to speak to

10:26

you. But every door that I

10:28

knocked on and every number I called, someone put

10:30

me in touch with six more people who'd known

10:32

her or school friends or writing

10:35

buddies or, you know, it was

10:37

actually a really extraordinary story to

10:39

work on as a reporter because

10:41

all of these doors just kept

10:44

opening. And it wasn't like these

10:46

people had spoken a million

10:48

times before. Some of them had, but

10:50

really not all of them. So

10:53

tell me about some of the people who did open their

10:55

doors to you and some of the people who spoke to

10:57

you about Taylor growing up. When

10:59

she was in first grade, I just this

11:02

just kills me when she was in first

11:04

grade, I had them

11:06

all do self portraits of

11:09

what they would be

11:11

or look like in the

11:13

year 2024 as president. And

11:17

it's not far from it because she's me

11:19

endorse one of the, you know, people.

11:24

So one of her teachers, Barbara Lenzi,

11:26

whose house I went over to in

11:28

Pennsylvania, who was this like fabulous art

11:30

teacher of hers who had

11:33

her for four or five years, I

11:35

think. And she

11:37

had this old DVD

11:40

that Scott Swift actually

11:42

made for all of the teachers, which

11:45

was a performance of Taylor at

11:47

the school singing some songs

11:49

that she'd written. And

11:52

lovely Barbara Lenzi, the teacher, had

11:54

kept this one old banger of

11:56

a TV in the corner of

11:59

her house. because it was the

12:01

only one that could play this old DVD.

12:04

She couldn't find any other way to play it, so

12:06

that was the reason that she had the TV in

12:08

the house. And on came

12:10

Taylor. Oh, yeah, I'm getting here. Cheers.

12:19

I think it clears that right bar.

12:21

Yes. He

12:26

said 200, please. Is

12:29

this too much wind on you? It's great. Because

12:31

it gets feeling. My

12:38

dad is taking this. And

12:44

these souls that she was singing, she was 13, she

12:47

was coming back to the school to perform for the little

12:49

kids, were so similar

12:51

to the ones that she

12:53

sings now in the way that she sees the world.

12:56

So I've got the lyrics in front of me. I've

12:59

been to a lot of lonely places, being

13:02

here on the outside, looking in, nobody

13:04

ever lets me in. And

13:08

that sort of feeling of

13:11

being separate to everything else,

13:15

I think, is still something that

13:18

she sings about now. So you could

13:20

hear the echoes of who she is and what she was

13:22

writing even then. And

13:26

I've been to a lot of lonely places, living

13:32

here on the outside. Oh,

13:37

I just heard chills. And

13:41

when you were watching these videos, what

13:43

impression did you get of the 13-year-old

13:45

Taylor? Well, she

13:47

did act like she was famous. I

13:49

mean, she is literally 13, performing to

13:51

a bunch of 6-year-olds in an assembly hall. And

13:56

this bottle of water kind of

13:58

appears from this disembodied house. hand

14:00

in between one of the

14:02

songs when she's just taking questions from the audience.

14:05

And without looking, she just sort of takes

14:07

it and opens it and sips it and

14:09

puts it down next to her as if

14:12

she is this super storied

14:14

star already and has been performing

14:16

in pubs and clubs and concert

14:18

halls for decades. It was kind

14:21

of hilarious. Her primary school

14:23

rider, which is the water bottle. Yeah.

14:26

So tell us about how getting started

14:28

in music happens. How does she go

14:30

from playing a school assembly

14:33

for six-year-olds to actually becoming

14:35

a recording star? Well,

14:37

she had lots of guitar lessons, which

14:40

is how she learned to write

14:42

songs. Then she

14:44

enters this karaoke competition in Pennsylvania when

14:46

she's about 11, which she wins, which

14:48

puts her up on stage in front

14:51

of people at these sort of rural

14:53

country fairs, essentially, in the area.

14:57

And I spoke to the guy who performed

14:59

with her and apparently she just sort of

15:01

walked straight up on stage and said, like,

15:03

hi, everybody, my name's Taylor. And, you know,

15:05

it's like speaking as if she's on

15:08

stage in the assembly hall rather than in front of

15:10

tens of thousands of people. And

15:13

then her parents took

15:15

her one spring

15:17

break to Nashville. And

15:19

that is where she drove up

15:21

and down music row, which is where

15:24

everything is. And she knocked on doors

15:26

with this little demo tape that she

15:28

had recorded. And there were some covers

15:30

on there. I think, hopelessly devoted to

15:32

you might have been on there from

15:35

her time in Greece, which

15:37

kind of feels apt for her, right? And

15:40

she handed them out and said, I want a

15:42

record deal. Coming

15:52

up, 13 year

15:54

old Taylor does get that record

15:56

deal and the whole

15:58

Swift family upsticks. to the

16:00

cradle of country music. I'm

16:04

just driving down music row in

16:06

Nashville, which is where

16:08

Taylor came with her mother, driving

16:10

up and down as an 11-year-old, I think.

16:15

Next stop on Megan's Taylor Tour, Nashville.

16:18

That's in just a moment. It's

16:33

that time of the year. Your

16:36

vacation is coming up. You

16:38

can already hear the beach waves, feel

16:41

the warm breeze, relax,

16:44

and think about work. You

16:47

really, really want it all to work out

16:49

while you're away. monday.com gives you and the

16:51

team that peace of mind. When all work

16:53

is on one platform and everyone's in sync,

16:56

things just flow wherever you are. Tap the

16:58

banner to go to monday.com. Everyone

17:04

knows therapy is great for solving

17:06

problems, but getting therapy has its

17:08

own problems too, like finding the

17:10

right therapist, fitting into their schedule,

17:12

and of course, the cost. Well,

17:14

BetterHelp can solve those problems. It's

17:16

totally online and built around your

17:18

schedule. It's surprisingly affordable too. Connect

17:21

with a credential therapist by phone, video,

17:23

or online chat, all from the comfort

17:25

of your home. Visit betterhelp.com to learn

17:27

more and save 10% on

17:30

your first month. That's BetterHelp

17:32

H-E-L-P. Right

17:56

place. With LinkedIn, you can hire professionals

17:58

like a professional. Post your

18:01

free job on linkedin.com/spoken

18:03

today. So

18:16

Megan, you've been taking us through Taylor

18:18

Swift's early life, the road to stardom

18:20

from Pennsylvania when she was primary school

18:23

child. You said the next stop was

18:25

Nashville. Tell us a little bit about

18:27

that. When did the Swift's move to

18:29

Music City? So they moved

18:31

full time there when she was 14 years

18:33

old. Now, from

18:36

what I understand, the family had no

18:38

connection to it whatsoever. They

18:41

moved there to help her become

18:43

a star. I mean,

18:45

how many times can you remember begging

18:47

your parents for something as a kid

18:49

and them saying, no, that's what she

18:51

did? And they said yes. So they

18:54

moved to Hendersonville, which was

18:56

this super wealthy town

18:58

on the northern

19:00

outskirts of Nashville where Johnny

19:02

Cash lived. And

19:05

she went to high school there. And

19:07

she had a development deal. She

19:09

was the youngest singer-songwriter, actually, that

19:12

Sony had ever signed. Wow. So

19:15

she's in a city full

19:17

of incredible musicians and singer-songwriters.

19:20

And has she got a

19:22

record deal at this point? Has she

19:24

been signed? She belongs to a label. She

19:27

belongs to RCA, which is a

19:29

subsidiary of Sony Records. And

19:32

she's on what we think is a

19:34

sort of developmental deal, whereby she makes

19:36

some music sort of experimentally. And then

19:38

the record label will decide whether or

19:40

not they want to keep her on.

19:42

Right, OK. So she's still going to

19:44

school at this point. And what do

19:47

her schoolmates think of her? Did you

19:49

manage to talk to any of them?

19:52

I spoke to some of them. And

19:55

they sort of thought she was a bit

19:57

of a pain. They... obviously

20:00

lived in Nashville and

20:02

she turned up and she basically said, I'm

20:05

going to be a star. I'm here to make

20:07

it. And they all kind

20:09

of rolled their eyes and thought

20:12

she was a bit of a brat. She lived

20:14

in this big house and her parents drove an

20:16

enormous car and they had a boat and jet

20:18

skis and she was gorgeous

20:21

and had been in this

20:23

Abercrombie and Fitch modeling campaign. So they

20:26

found her a bit tiresome. Then

20:28

she starts dating this guy. He's

20:30

kind of like a wealthy, popular

20:32

guy at school. So that

20:34

kind of upset some of the girls

20:37

who'd been desperately trying to win his

20:39

attention for years. Then

20:41

they broke up and

20:43

months later there was a school talent contest.

20:46

And bearing in mind, she'd basically

20:48

just got to Nashville and she was 14 years old, 15

20:50

years old. She

20:53

wrote the song, Teardrops, on my guitar, which

20:55

was about him. And she performed

20:57

it in front of the whole school, her ex.

21:00

Her ex's new girlfriend and

21:03

sort of named him in it. And

21:05

everyone was like, Crikey,

21:08

who is this girl? How ballsy of her

21:11

to do that? And

21:13

it made me think back again to all of

21:15

the albums and the songs that she's sung about

21:17

her exes in front of the whole world since

21:19

then. Yeah, I mean, I've

21:21

definitely been at the Victoria's

21:23

Secret show when at least one of her

21:25

exes was in the audience while she performed.

21:29

Oh my gosh. It's classic

21:31

Taylor, isn't it? Obviously the die was set very

21:33

young. This is her M.O. Totally,

21:35

totally. So they kind of thought she

21:37

was a brat,

21:40

a lot of them. And

21:42

she was popular. I think she had some

21:44

struggles in middle school at Pennsylvania, but she

21:47

was popular and preppy. And she

21:49

did okay by the sounds of things. Okay,

21:52

so in school, she's popular. She's dating the guy

21:54

that everyone wants to date. She's breaking up

21:56

with him. She's singing a song about him in

21:59

front of him. What is your girlfriend? What's

22:01

she doing out of school? How's her music

22:03

career progressing? So after

22:05

school, her mum is dropping

22:07

her at these various songwriter

22:10

and producers' houses. I mean,

22:12

these are like epic Nashville

22:15

names. One of them, Angelo

22:18

Petraglia, who basically

22:20

put together Kings of Leon. He said, Kings

22:22

of Leon became Kings of Leon on my

22:24

front porch. He's like an old

22:26

New Yorker who's got this real rock background.

22:29

He started writing with her and this guy

22:31

called Robert Ellis Orell. Angelo

22:34

called me up one day and said, I've

22:37

got this 13-year-old girl coming over, and

22:41

you got to come over and help me write because

22:43

I don't know where to start with

22:45

a 13-year-old. And I

22:47

had a 13-year-old daughter. And

22:50

I said, I said,

22:52

I'll come over and help you. And

22:54

they kind of became this writing trio, this

22:56

funny writing trio. These two

22:58

older guys and Taylor, and

23:01

both of them just said that

23:03

she really had no fear.

23:06

They said that she drove

23:08

the sessions forward and she had a very clear

23:10

idea about what she wanted. And

23:13

that was this one story that Robert was telling

23:15

me when

23:17

Angelo suggested some line in

23:19

a song. Angelo

23:21

threw out a lyric line, and

23:24

she said, I don't know,

23:26

that sounds kind of trite. Stop.

23:31

And I

23:33

made both of my hands like little guns

23:35

and went, boom, look at that shot down

23:37

by the 13-year-old. It's

23:41

like, Angelo is 17 now and

23:44

has this roster of Grammys,

23:46

basically. But they all kind

23:48

of liked her. They were stunned by her. But

23:51

yeah, she knew what she wanted. Her

23:54

parents had built her this $10,000 recording studio in

23:58

their home. They'd bought her this share. as

24:00

former tour bus, that's what she

24:02

toured in when she was about 15, 16. You

24:06

know, she had it all, but she

24:08

also had this real extraordinary talent. They

24:10

said one in 10 songs that she'd

24:12

write would be absolute perfection. This was

24:14

her at 14. And then in the

24:16

years since they said, you know, that

24:19

ratio has only got higher. And

24:21

so she is plugging

24:23

away. She eventually gets

24:26

dropped by RCA. They say

24:28

they want 60 days to figure out

24:30

whether they want to

24:33

keep her. The Swiss kind of do

24:35

this huddle and then they decide to walk

24:37

away, which is really extraordinary. And

24:39

what someone said, you know, Sony made the

24:41

biggest mistake of their corporate career. And

24:44

then Robert Ellis Orell

24:47

has a showcase at the

24:49

Bluebird Cafe, which he invites

24:51

her to do with him.

24:53

I suggested that we just do a Bluebird

24:56

show. We would go to the

24:58

Bluebird Cafe, where, you know, take the songwriting

25:00

lecture of the world. And

25:02

we would have, I said, you know, it

25:04

would be three grizzled old songwriters. And

25:07

then it would come around to this teenager and

25:11

she's going to blow their minds. I mean,

25:13

she's just so confident. So, and it

25:15

was just something about it. And

25:17

I tried to go to the Bluebird Cafe.

25:20

It's still this like songwriting institution, but it

25:22

was closed for refurbishments.

25:25

And then, I was like, I was like,

25:27

I'm going to go get in there. Because you've

25:29

been, haven't you? Tell me, I'm desperate to know

25:32

how it was. I wish I could have been.

25:34

You must go back because it's one of

25:37

the most magical places I've ever been. It's

25:39

a tiny, tiny venue. And

25:41

it's not fancy. It's a tiny little

25:43

place where, you know, they serve wine

25:45

in, you know, sort of the cheapest

25:47

glasses imaginable. And it's very intimate. But

25:49

it's where these singer songwriters, whose names

25:51

you may never have heard of, but

25:53

who've written every hit you've ever heard

25:56

of, just play the round. Last time

25:58

I was there, I saw... or

26:00

the man who wrote The Gambler, Kenny Rogers,

26:02

The Gambler, which is one of my favourite

26:04

songs in the world. And he wrote it

26:06

and he sang it. And my dad has

26:08

never been so starstruck in his life. But

26:10

I can imagine what it was like for

26:12

Taylor playing in that venue, surrounded by all

26:14

of the music executives who go there three

26:16

times a week to find the next big

26:18

thing. Yeah, exactly. And they

26:21

did. Scott Borchetta, who had just

26:23

started this new label

26:25

called Big Machine, saw

26:28

her and he'd apparently been looking for

26:30

the person to build the label around

26:32

and she was it. They

26:35

just knew. And apparently he was one of

26:37

many who wanted to sign her. But he

26:39

got there and made the

26:41

best deal and said that is what

26:43

happened. And the rest is Swift

26:46

law, as you said at the beginning. Yeah,

26:48

until this sort of huge car

26:50

crash, right, in 2018 or so, when

26:54

Swift wanted to own her own music,

26:57

which Big Machine didn't allow her

26:59

to do. So yet again, as

27:01

they did with RCA, the Swifts,

27:03

I'm guessing, had a huddle. The

27:05

family, they still seem to work

27:07

closely together around Taylor's

27:09

career. And they walked away

27:11

from that as well, so

27:14

that she could own her own

27:16

music going forward. And hence all

27:18

of the re-records of all of

27:20

the albums that she'd previously recorded.

27:22

And then re-entering the charts and

27:24

re-entering everything. I mean, it was

27:26

like the savviest commercial decision ever.

27:29

And you can again see

27:32

the echoes of Scott Swift's

27:34

investment history and

27:36

experience through those decisions as

27:38

well. Yeah, I think we can add

27:40

to everything we said before about talent and focus

27:43

and the right family. Also

27:45

a tremendous business acumen these

27:47

days. Totally. I mean,

27:49

one of her school friends, actually, from

27:52

when she was 11 years old, there

27:55

was a sort of Pop Idols Juniors or

27:57

something that had just started in America. And

28:00

she asked her, she asked Taylor, are

28:02

you going to enter? And Taylor said

28:04

something like, no, I

28:06

don't think so because you're not allowed

28:08

to record an album in the first

28:10

two years after the deal. And

28:13

this like 11 year old was like, oh

28:15

my gosh, how do you know? So

28:18

Taylor was also incredibly, seemingly involved and

28:20

clued up on all of this. It

28:23

wasn't just her parents drawing up the

28:25

contracts and getting her to sign on

28:27

the dotted line. She knew

28:29

from an early age what she wanted. So Megan,

28:31

you spent an awful lot of time on

28:33

the trail of Taylor and talked to all

28:35

of these people from various parts of her

28:37

life. Did it change the

28:39

way that you came to understand her

28:42

stardom now and how she's got to

28:44

become probably the biggest superstar

28:46

that we've seen certainly in the last

28:48

couple of decades? Yes,

28:51

I think it made me realize that

28:53

she was a child star, but

28:56

she managed to time it

28:59

so brilliantly well, whereby

29:01

she kind of entered the public

29:04

consciousness when she was about 16.

29:07

So she wasn't seen as a child star

29:09

actually, she was seen as like a teen

29:11

pop idol. So I think

29:14

that timing worked brilliantly. And

29:16

secondly, I've just thought over and over

29:18

again, we can really

29:20

hammer home this like idea

29:23

of privilege, but the

29:25

fact is she had it and that's how it

29:27

was. But it

29:29

has made me think, gosh, I wonder how

29:32

many other people who had 60% of what

29:34

she did and

29:37

not all of it might have slipped

29:39

through the cracks along the way. It's

29:41

easy to see her parents as being

29:43

pushy or over involved, but

29:46

I think they could just see

29:48

that their kid was kind of

29:50

this freak, this like

29:53

sparkling freak and

29:55

they had to do something with her and they

29:58

did. She had this dr-

30:00

to drive forward and this

30:02

conscientiousness, which she later said was

30:04

instilled by her parents. Then,

30:07

to be born into a family with

30:09

money to allow her to do all

30:11

of these things, to a father who

30:13

was a stockbroker, who literally makes investments

30:15

on behalf of other people for a

30:17

living, and to a mother who had

30:19

lots of time to invest in her

30:21

daughter, as well as a background in

30:24

marketing. It is genuinely

30:26

a once-in-a-generation combination of all

30:28

of those things. Talent, money,

30:32

time, and

30:34

environment. And focus

30:36

and drive. Yeah, it's a bit of a superstar

30:39

storm, isn't it? Yes, exactly.

30:41

So to say one thing

30:43

overpowers the other, in my opinion, is

30:45

not right. You know, it really is

30:47

a collection of all of those things

30:49

at once. Thanks

31:09

so much to the Swift-agnostic,

31:11

hopefully now converted Swifty, Megan Agnew.

31:14

There was so much stuff from Megan's Taylor

31:16

tour that we just couldn't fit in this

31:18

podcast. So do read the full story at

31:20

thetimes.com with a subscription. This

31:23

episode was produced by Taryn Siegel.

31:25

The executive producer is Kate Ford.

31:27

And sound design and theme tune

31:29

by Mao Losetto. If

31:32

you've enjoyed what you heard today, please do leave us

31:34

a review. And make it a nice

31:37

one, wherever you're listening to this. Thanks

31:39

for listening. See you tomorrow. Welcome

32:05

to Sincerely Sloan presented by Uninterrupted.

32:08

I'm your host, professional tennis

32:10

player, wife, parent, and entrepreneur,

32:12

Sloan Stevens. As

32:14

an athlete and as a person, my journey

32:17

has had a lot of twists and turns,

32:19

from moments of adversity and doubt to unimaginable

32:21

triumph and satisfaction. Throughout

32:23

the season, I'm joined by some of the biggest

32:25

names in sports, entertainment, culture, and a few members

32:28

of my tribe. Our

32:30

conversations keep it real and push it past

32:32

skin deep. We

32:34

reveal the perspectives, routines, and products that allow

32:36

each of us to show up at our

32:38

best. Join me on

32:41

my journey of self-discovery and many, many

32:43

laughs along the way. Sincerely, Sloan.

32:48

It's okay if you aren't ready for kids right

32:51

now. It's okay if you don't

32:53

want to be a mom now or even ever.

32:56

It's nobody's decision but yours. But do you

32:58

know it's not okay? Not

33:00

knowing how effective your birth control is. Talk

33:03

to your doctor about effective birth control options

33:05

so you can make an informed decision. Tap

33:07

to learn more.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features