Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
This is The Guardian. Today,
0:07
the far right are at the gates
0:10
of power in France. On
0:12
Sunday, will they burst through?
0:20
Hey, I'm Ryan Reynolds. At Mint Mobile, we
0:22
like to do the opposite of what big
0:24
wireless does. They charge you a lot, we
0:26
charge you a little. So naturally, when they
0:28
announced they'd be raising their prices due to
0:30
inflation, we decided to deflate our prices due
0:33
to not hating you. That's right, we're cutting
0:35
the price of Mint Unlimited from $30 a
0:37
month to just $15 a month. Give
0:41
it a try at mintmobile.com/switch.
0:44
$45 up front for three months plus taxes and fees. Promote it for
0:46
new customers for a limited time. Unlimited more than 40 gigabytes per month,
0:48
slows. Full terms at mintmobile.com. A
0:56
few weeks ago, the French
0:58
president Emmanuel Macron took this
1:00
massive gamble. For years,
1:02
support for the far right National
1:05
Rally Party has been growing across
1:07
France, and they are
1:09
pretty extreme. They want
1:11
to restrict the jobs available to
1:13
dual citizens, ban women from wearing
1:15
religious headscarves anywhere in public, and
1:17
make it easier for police to
1:19
get away with using their weapons.
1:22
In European elections on June 9, they
1:25
came out the clear winners, and
1:27
that night, the night of those results, Macron
1:30
did something that from the
1:32
outside seems completely baffling. He
1:35
dissolved the French parliament, called
1:37
for national parliamentary elections, and put
1:40
to the French people a challenge.
1:43
If you really want the far right in
1:46
power, well, here's
1:48
your chance. I
1:50
think we're living in a period which historians
1:53
are going to have to pick over. Everyone
1:55
is still asking themselves why they did it,
1:57
because it seems like an act of complete
1:59
self-destruction. the
8:00
militia of Philippe Pétain's Vichy regime
8:02
during the Second World War. That
8:05
regime during the Nazi occupation collaborated
8:07
with the Nazis and ensured the
8:09
deportation of a quarter of France's
8:11
Jewish population. And in 1972,
8:14
when this party was formed, it
8:16
was formed to present a kind
8:19
of electable front of many disparate
8:21
far-right groups at the time. These
8:24
included neo-fascists, militants known for street
8:26
violence, people who were nostalgic for
8:28
French Algeria. And the idea was
8:30
they wanted to rally around somebody
8:32
who could get them elected. Now
8:34
that person was Jean-Marie Le Pen,
8:36
Marine Le Pen's father, and he
8:38
had been a young MP for
8:40
an anti-taxation movement in Parliament. And
8:43
he'd left Parliament and he'd set up
8:45
a company that sold Nazi speeches and
8:48
German military songs. He
8:50
had volunteered as a paratrooper
8:52
in Algeria. And
8:55
then in the 80s, this party began to have electoral
8:57
success. And as Jean-Marie Le Pen got
9:07
more airtime, that was when he
9:09
started stating his views pretty openly.
9:12
So in 1987, he said that the Holocaust
9:15
was a mere detail of history. He's
9:25
been convicted more than 15 times
9:27
for hate speech and contesting crimes
9:29
against humanity. He
9:31
said the Nazi occupation was not particularly
9:33
inhumane. He said he believed in the
9:36
inequality of races. He's
9:38
been convicted for saying Roma were
9:40
rash-inducing and smelly. He said that
9:42
France should get along with Russia
9:45
to save the white world. Angelique,
9:48
I'm kind of stunned by this potted
9:50
history you've given me. How
9:52
on earth does a party with
9:54
roots like that detoxify
9:56
to the point where it's nationally
9:58
viable? victory.
22:00
He asked himself, and what does that
22:02
mean for these generations that have been
22:04
raised in France? He said to me,
22:07
how will we live our religion normally
22:09
in this country, where we have these
22:11
principles of liberty, equality and fraternity? Will
22:14
we have the liberty to practice our
22:16
religion tomorrow? He asked me, will we
22:18
be equal? One of
22:21
the policies of Schieffer that the RN
22:23
say they will work towards, I mean,
22:25
within the next few years, is a
22:28
ban of the headscarf completely from
22:30
any public spaces in France. Did
22:32
you talk to people about what that
22:34
would mean just for French Muslims going
22:36
about their lives? It's a pretty
22:38
horrific prospect for those who
22:41
are facing it. One
22:43
lady told me, it's like being told
22:45
that I need to remove my trousers
22:47
in public. It's that traumatizing that, to
22:50
me, it's like being naked. And
22:52
so for her, this idea that she
22:54
would be told by the
22:56
government, it was really hard for
22:58
her to maybe swallow. One
23:01
of the things to understand is that France, without
23:04
the RN being in power,
23:07
is in no means a
23:09
place that is free of discrimination. I
23:11
mean, a lot of the interviews that
23:13
I've done, people have already stressed to
23:16
me that they face tremendous discrimination already
23:18
in France. And studies bear that out,
23:20
that it's harder to get a job,
23:22
it's harder to find housing. You're more
23:24
likely to be stopped by police if
23:26
you are Arab or appear to be
23:28
Arab. In reporting on this issue in
23:31
France, I spoke to half
23:33
a dozen people who had left because
23:35
they found that it was just too
23:37
hard to live in France, that they
23:39
felt they could be freer anywhere abroad.
23:42
And so these people were in Australia,
23:44
in Canada, in the UK.
23:46
They were part of a bigger study
23:48
that a professor in Lille had done.
23:50
And it was more than a thousand
23:52
people who responded to a survey. And
23:54
of those, a vast majority of them
23:56
said they had left in order to
23:59
escape discrimination. It's something
24:01
beyond belief. You
24:03
didn't just speak to Muslims though. You
24:05
spoke to other groups who fear the
24:07
rise of the RN. Tell me about
24:09
some of them. This whole
24:11
snap election has coincided with pride.
24:14
And so we've seen kind of
24:16
pride rallies take place across France.
24:19
And what they say is that it
24:21
doesn't feel like we're just rallying together
24:23
to celebrate what we've achieved and push
24:25
to go further. It actually feels as
24:27
though we're under attack. And there was
24:29
one quote that stood out for me
24:31
where someone said, I hope this is
24:33
not the last pride that we
24:35
have. Because our
24:37
N, while they overtly
24:40
don't say anything against the community,
24:42
they have consistently voted against advancing
24:44
rights for the LGBT plus community.
24:47
And so for this community, it
24:49
was fearful. They were wondering what comes next
24:52
and now what happens. And
24:54
is this going to change how our
24:56
lives unfold in this country? France
24:58
is also a racially diverse country. It
25:01
has many of the problems we see
25:03
in places that might be more familiar,
25:05
like the US of police brutality and
25:07
similar issues. Was
25:09
there any sense of what a
25:11
far right victory this Sunday might
25:14
mean for French people of color?
25:16
One of the big promises of the RN
25:18
is that they would change the presumption of
25:20
innocence when an arm
25:22
is used during a police intervention.
25:25
And so we know from studies that
25:27
people who are black and Arab are more
25:30
likely to be stopped by police and they're
25:32
more likely to see force used by police.
25:34
And so for these communities, this
25:37
is terrifying. If you're the mother of
25:39
an Arab child or a black child
25:41
who does get stopped. I mean, you
25:43
hear from people that are 13 years
25:45
old and have been stopped by police,
25:47
you hear that force has been used.
25:49
And to think that there's less recourse
25:51
for them to seek justice is
25:53
quite terrifying. According to
25:56
policies like this, it can be hard to
25:58
understand why somebody would
26:00
cast a vote for a party
26:02
with such an extreme history, with
26:04
a pretty extreme present. But you
26:07
actually encountered several RN voters in
26:09
your travels. Tell me about them
26:11
and what they told you was
26:13
fueling their decision to go with
26:15
the far right this time. I
26:23
was in Marseille recently and I met a
26:25
woman who was in her
26:27
60s and her name was Anne Michelle.
26:29
And I met her at a rally
26:31
for Macron's centrists and she was there
26:33
because a friend of hers had brought
26:35
her along very shortly after we started
26:37
talking about why they were here. Her
26:39
friend said, we're here really because
26:42
she's going to vote for the RN. And
26:48
I asked her why and she said, I'm fed up
26:50
of seeing these migrants who are ordered to go back
26:52
to where they're from but they're still here. She was
26:55
just fed up with seeing the kind of paralysis
26:57
in terms of sending migrants back once they
27:00
had been rejected by the system. She
27:10
mentioned a few high profile
27:12
crimes that migrants were allegedly
27:14
involved in and really picked
27:16
at these and kept pointing at these and
27:18
just said, I'm sick of putting out candles
27:21
over and over to mourn. What
27:23
was fascinating about this is that we
27:25
were at an event at the Armenian
27:27
church and the candidate that the event
27:30
was for was Algerian. And so you
27:32
had all these examples around you of
27:34
people who had built incredible lives in
27:36
France because France had not
27:38
had a party like the National Rally in power.
27:41
When I pointed that out to her that here
27:43
you are kind of standing amongst 300 people
27:46
who most of whom have an
27:48
immigrant background and are not criminals.
27:51
It was like talking to a wall to be honest
27:53
and I think there's something to mention as well about
27:56
the fact that the largest share
27:58
of our invoke came from Hey,
29:09
I'm Ryan Reynolds. At Mint Mobile, we like
29:11
to do the opposite of what big wireless
29:13
does. They charge you a lot, we charge
29:15
you a little. So naturally, when they announced
29:17
they'd be raising their prices due to inflation,
29:19
we decided to deflate our prices due to
29:21
not hating you. That's right, we're cutting the
29:24
price of Mint Unlimited from $30 a month
29:26
to just $15 a month. Give
29:30
it a try at mintmobile.com/switch.
29:33
$45 up front for three months plus taxes and fees. Promote it for
29:35
new customers for a limited time. Unlimited more than 40 gigabytes per month,
29:37
slows. Full terms at mintmobile.com. say
34:00
in fact what she has done
34:02
is not succeeded in fully stamping
34:05
out anti-Semitic views amongst every member
34:07
of her party and
34:09
that also a hatred towards one group,
34:11
they say, a hatred towards Jews, has
34:13
now led to a hatred of another
34:16
group, Muslims, and that is the argument
34:18
of the left. I
34:23
remember we spoke to you a couple of
34:25
years ago, just as Emmanuel Macron was running
34:27
for office, and he presented
34:29
himself as somebody who meant French
34:31
voters wouldn't have to choose between
34:34
the extremes anymore. That was his
34:36
pitch, that I'm going to transcend
34:38
the left-right divide and be something
34:40
new, something different. Is
34:42
it fair to say that after
34:44
last Sunday's results, no matter what
34:47
happens next Sunday, that project,
34:49
that vision he offered of a
34:51
kind of centrism that makes the
34:53
old categories of left and right
34:55
redundant? That has failed. Yes,
34:57
I think you can say
34:59
ultimately that Emmanuel Macron has
35:02
brought his own centrist project
35:04
tumbling down, that
35:06
Macronism, as we call it, which
35:08
is a centrist project built around
35:10
one man who promised to revolutionize
35:13
politics by cherry-picking ideas from the
35:15
left and right, but
35:17
who then veered right himself after his
35:19
2022 re-election.
35:22
Macronism built around one man is
35:24
finished. Macron himself, he
35:26
says, will stay president for another
35:29
three years, he can't run again,
35:31
but his centrist project with
35:34
his centrist MPs is
35:36
over, and those centrists will now
35:38
have to regroup, because whatever happens
35:40
on Sunday, it appears quite clear
35:42
that the centrists have shrunk back
35:44
into third position, they could lose
35:46
half their seats, the
35:48
left have held their position, but they're
35:50
still in second place, and
35:53
the far right, however well it does,
35:55
will be the biggest party in parliament.
35:57
They will either take government.
38:00
at some point, you can get tickets
38:02
to the event or watch it online
38:04
by searching Guardian Live and following the
38:07
links to the election newsroom special. There
38:09
are just a few tickets still available.
38:11
And if you've enjoyed our election coverage
38:13
on Today in Focus, election extra, leave
38:16
us a review, we would love to hear from you. And
38:21
that is it for today. This
38:23
episode was produced by Courtney Yousuf and
38:25
Natalie Ktonup. Sound design was
38:28
by Joel Cox. The executive
38:30
producer was Homer Khalili. And we're back
38:32
with you and maybe a new government
38:34
tomorrow. This
38:40
is The Guardian.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More