Podchaser Logo
Home
Will France fall to the far right?

Will France fall to the far right?

Released Thursday, 4th July 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Will France fall to the far right?

Will France fall to the far right?

Will France fall to the far right?

Will France fall to the far right?

Thursday, 4th July 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

This is The Guardian. Today,

0:07

the far right are at the gates

0:10

of power in France. On

0:12

Sunday, will they burst through?

0:20

Hey, I'm Ryan Reynolds. At Mint Mobile, we

0:22

like to do the opposite of what big

0:24

wireless does. They charge you a lot, we

0:26

charge you a little. So naturally, when they

0:28

announced they'd be raising their prices due to

0:30

inflation, we decided to deflate our prices due

0:33

to not hating you. That's right, we're cutting

0:35

the price of Mint Unlimited from $30 a

0:37

month to just $15 a month. Give

0:41

it a try at mintmobile.com/switch.

0:44

$45 up front for three months plus taxes and fees. Promote it for

0:46

new customers for a limited time. Unlimited more than 40 gigabytes per month,

0:48

slows. Full terms at mintmobile.com. A

0:56

few weeks ago, the French

0:58

president Emmanuel Macron took this

1:00

massive gamble. For years,

1:02

support for the far right National

1:05

Rally Party has been growing across

1:07

France, and they are

1:09

pretty extreme. They want

1:11

to restrict the jobs available to

1:13

dual citizens, ban women from wearing

1:15

religious headscarves anywhere in public, and

1:17

make it easier for police to

1:19

get away with using their weapons.

1:22

In European elections on June 9, they

1:25

came out the clear winners, and

1:27

that night, the night of those results, Macron

1:30

did something that from the

1:32

outside seems completely baffling. He

1:35

dissolved the French parliament, called

1:37

for national parliamentary elections, and put

1:40

to the French people a challenge.

1:43

If you really want the far right in

1:46

power, well, here's

1:48

your chance. I

1:50

think we're living in a period which historians

1:53

are going to have to pick over. Everyone

1:55

is still asking themselves why they did it,

1:57

because it seems like an act of complete

1:59

self-destruction. the

8:00

militia of Philippe Pétain's Vichy regime

8:02

during the Second World War. That

8:05

regime during the Nazi occupation collaborated

8:07

with the Nazis and ensured the

8:09

deportation of a quarter of France's

8:11

Jewish population. And in 1972,

8:14

when this party was formed, it

8:16

was formed to present a kind

8:19

of electable front of many disparate

8:21

far-right groups at the time. These

8:24

included neo-fascists, militants known for street

8:26

violence, people who were nostalgic for

8:28

French Algeria. And the idea was

8:30

they wanted to rally around somebody

8:32

who could get them elected. Now

8:34

that person was Jean-Marie Le Pen,

8:36

Marine Le Pen's father, and he

8:38

had been a young MP for

8:40

an anti-taxation movement in Parliament. And

8:43

he'd left Parliament and he'd set up

8:45

a company that sold Nazi speeches and

8:48

German military songs. He

8:50

had volunteered as a paratrooper

8:52

in Algeria. And

8:55

then in the 80s, this party began to have electoral

8:57

success. And as Jean-Marie Le Pen got

9:07

more airtime, that was when he

9:09

started stating his views pretty openly.

9:12

So in 1987, he said that the Holocaust

9:15

was a mere detail of history. He's

9:25

been convicted more than 15 times

9:27

for hate speech and contesting crimes

9:29

against humanity. He

9:31

said the Nazi occupation was not particularly

9:33

inhumane. He said he believed in the

9:36

inequality of races. He's

9:38

been convicted for saying Roma were

9:40

rash-inducing and smelly. He said that

9:42

France should get along with Russia

9:45

to save the white world. Angelique,

9:48

I'm kind of stunned by this potted

9:50

history you've given me. How

9:52

on earth does a party with

9:54

roots like that detoxify

9:56

to the point where it's nationally

9:58

viable? victory.

22:00

He asked himself, and what does that

22:02

mean for these generations that have been

22:04

raised in France? He said to me,

22:07

how will we live our religion normally

22:09

in this country, where we have these

22:11

principles of liberty, equality and fraternity? Will

22:14

we have the liberty to practice our

22:16

religion tomorrow? He asked me, will we

22:18

be equal? One of

22:21

the policies of Schieffer that the RN

22:23

say they will work towards, I mean,

22:25

within the next few years, is a

22:28

ban of the headscarf completely from

22:30

any public spaces in France. Did

22:32

you talk to people about what that

22:34

would mean just for French Muslims going

22:36

about their lives? It's a pretty

22:38

horrific prospect for those who

22:41

are facing it. One

22:43

lady told me, it's like being told

22:45

that I need to remove my trousers

22:47

in public. It's that traumatizing that, to

22:50

me, it's like being naked. And

22:52

so for her, this idea that she

22:54

would be told by the

22:56

government, it was really hard for

22:58

her to maybe swallow. One

23:01

of the things to understand is that France, without

23:04

the RN being in power,

23:07

is in no means a

23:09

place that is free of discrimination. I

23:11

mean, a lot of the interviews that

23:13

I've done, people have already stressed to

23:16

me that they face tremendous discrimination already

23:18

in France. And studies bear that out,

23:20

that it's harder to get a job,

23:22

it's harder to find housing. You're more

23:24

likely to be stopped by police if

23:26

you are Arab or appear to be

23:28

Arab. In reporting on this issue in

23:31

France, I spoke to half

23:33

a dozen people who had left because

23:35

they found that it was just too

23:37

hard to live in France, that they

23:39

felt they could be freer anywhere abroad.

23:42

And so these people were in Australia,

23:44

in Canada, in the UK.

23:46

They were part of a bigger study

23:48

that a professor in Lille had done.

23:50

And it was more than a thousand

23:52

people who responded to a survey. And

23:54

of those, a vast majority of them

23:56

said they had left in order to

23:59

escape discrimination. It's something

24:01

beyond belief. You

24:03

didn't just speak to Muslims though. You

24:05

spoke to other groups who fear the

24:07

rise of the RN. Tell me about

24:09

some of them. This whole

24:11

snap election has coincided with pride.

24:14

And so we've seen kind of

24:16

pride rallies take place across France.

24:19

And what they say is that it

24:21

doesn't feel like we're just rallying together

24:23

to celebrate what we've achieved and push

24:25

to go further. It actually feels as

24:27

though we're under attack. And there was

24:29

one quote that stood out for me

24:31

where someone said, I hope this is

24:33

not the last pride that we

24:35

have. Because our

24:37

N, while they overtly

24:40

don't say anything against the community,

24:42

they have consistently voted against advancing

24:44

rights for the LGBT plus community.

24:47

And so for this community, it

24:49

was fearful. They were wondering what comes next

24:52

and now what happens. And

24:54

is this going to change how our

24:56

lives unfold in this country? France

24:58

is also a racially diverse country. It

25:01

has many of the problems we see

25:03

in places that might be more familiar,

25:05

like the US of police brutality and

25:07

similar issues. Was

25:09

there any sense of what a

25:11

far right victory this Sunday might

25:14

mean for French people of color?

25:16

One of the big promises of the RN

25:18

is that they would change the presumption of

25:20

innocence when an arm

25:22

is used during a police intervention.

25:25

And so we know from studies that

25:27

people who are black and Arab are more

25:30

likely to be stopped by police and they're

25:32

more likely to see force used by police.

25:34

And so for these communities, this

25:37

is terrifying. If you're the mother of

25:39

an Arab child or a black child

25:41

who does get stopped. I mean, you

25:43

hear from people that are 13 years

25:45

old and have been stopped by police,

25:47

you hear that force has been used.

25:49

And to think that there's less recourse

25:51

for them to seek justice is

25:53

quite terrifying. According to

25:56

policies like this, it can be hard to

25:58

understand why somebody would

26:00

cast a vote for a party

26:02

with such an extreme history, with

26:04

a pretty extreme present. But you

26:07

actually encountered several RN voters in

26:09

your travels. Tell me about them

26:11

and what they told you was

26:13

fueling their decision to go with

26:15

the far right this time. I

26:23

was in Marseille recently and I met a

26:25

woman who was in her

26:27

60s and her name was Anne Michelle.

26:29

And I met her at a rally

26:31

for Macron's centrists and she was there

26:33

because a friend of hers had brought

26:35

her along very shortly after we started

26:37

talking about why they were here. Her

26:39

friend said, we're here really because

26:42

she's going to vote for the RN. And

26:48

I asked her why and she said, I'm fed up

26:50

of seeing these migrants who are ordered to go back

26:52

to where they're from but they're still here. She was

26:55

just fed up with seeing the kind of paralysis

26:57

in terms of sending migrants back once they

27:00

had been rejected by the system. She

27:10

mentioned a few high profile

27:12

crimes that migrants were allegedly

27:14

involved in and really picked

27:16

at these and kept pointing at these and

27:18

just said, I'm sick of putting out candles

27:21

over and over to mourn. What

27:23

was fascinating about this is that we

27:25

were at an event at the Armenian

27:27

church and the candidate that the event

27:30

was for was Algerian. And so you

27:32

had all these examples around you of

27:34

people who had built incredible lives in

27:36

France because France had not

27:38

had a party like the National Rally in power.

27:41

When I pointed that out to her that here

27:43

you are kind of standing amongst 300 people

27:46

who most of whom have an

27:48

immigrant background and are not criminals.

27:51

It was like talking to a wall to be honest

27:53

and I think there's something to mention as well about

27:56

the fact that the largest share

27:58

of our invoke came from Hey,

29:09

I'm Ryan Reynolds. At Mint Mobile, we like

29:11

to do the opposite of what big wireless

29:13

does. They charge you a lot, we charge

29:15

you a little. So naturally, when they announced

29:17

they'd be raising their prices due to inflation,

29:19

we decided to deflate our prices due to

29:21

not hating you. That's right, we're cutting the

29:24

price of Mint Unlimited from $30 a month

29:26

to just $15 a month. Give

29:30

it a try at mintmobile.com/switch.

29:33

$45 up front for three months plus taxes and fees. Promote it for

29:35

new customers for a limited time. Unlimited more than 40 gigabytes per month,

29:37

slows. Full terms at mintmobile.com. say

34:00

in fact what she has done

34:02

is not succeeded in fully stamping

34:05

out anti-Semitic views amongst every member

34:07

of her party and

34:09

that also a hatred towards one group,

34:11

they say, a hatred towards Jews, has

34:13

now led to a hatred of another

34:16

group, Muslims, and that is the argument

34:18

of the left. I

34:23

remember we spoke to you a couple of

34:25

years ago, just as Emmanuel Macron was running

34:27

for office, and he presented

34:29

himself as somebody who meant French

34:31

voters wouldn't have to choose between

34:34

the extremes anymore. That was his

34:36

pitch, that I'm going to transcend

34:38

the left-right divide and be something

34:40

new, something different. Is

34:42

it fair to say that after

34:44

last Sunday's results, no matter what

34:47

happens next Sunday, that project,

34:49

that vision he offered of a

34:51

kind of centrism that makes the

34:53

old categories of left and right

34:55

redundant? That has failed. Yes,

34:57

I think you can say

34:59

ultimately that Emmanuel Macron has

35:02

brought his own centrist project

35:04

tumbling down, that

35:06

Macronism, as we call it, which

35:08

is a centrist project built around

35:10

one man who promised to revolutionize

35:13

politics by cherry-picking ideas from the

35:15

left and right, but

35:17

who then veered right himself after his

35:19

2022 re-election.

35:22

Macronism built around one man is

35:24

finished. Macron himself, he

35:26

says, will stay president for another

35:29

three years, he can't run again,

35:31

but his centrist project with

35:34

his centrist MPs is

35:36

over, and those centrists will now

35:38

have to regroup, because whatever happens

35:40

on Sunday, it appears quite clear

35:42

that the centrists have shrunk back

35:44

into third position, they could lose

35:46

half their seats, the

35:48

left have held their position, but they're

35:50

still in second place, and

35:53

the far right, however well it does,

35:55

will be the biggest party in parliament.

35:57

They will either take government.

38:00

at some point, you can get tickets

38:02

to the event or watch it online

38:04

by searching Guardian Live and following the

38:07

links to the election newsroom special. There

38:09

are just a few tickets still available.

38:11

And if you've enjoyed our election coverage

38:13

on Today in Focus, election extra, leave

38:16

us a review, we would love to hear from you. And

38:21

that is it for today. This

38:23

episode was produced by Courtney Yousuf and

38:25

Natalie Ktonup. Sound design was

38:28

by Joel Cox. The executive

38:30

producer was Homer Khalili. And we're back

38:32

with you and maybe a new government

38:34

tomorrow. This

38:40

is The Guardian.

Rate

From The Podcast

Today in Focus

Hosted by Michael Safi and Helen Pidd, Today in Focus brings you closer to Guardian journalism. Combining personal storytelling with insightful analysis, this podcast takes you behind the headlines for a deeper understanding of the news, every weekday. Today in Focus features journalists such as: Aditya Chakrabortty, Alex Hern, Alexis Petridis, Andrew Roth, Emma Graham-Harrison, George Monbiot, Jim Waterson, John Crace, John Harris, Jonathan Freedland, Kiran Stacey, Larry Elliott, Luke Harding, Marina Hyde, Nesrine Malik, Owen Jones, Peter Walker, Pippa Crerar, Polly Toynbee, Shaun Walker, Simon Hattenstone and Zoe Williams. The podcast is a topical, deep dive, explainer on a topic or story in the news, covering: current affairs, politics, investigations, leaks, scandals and interviews. It might cover topics such as: GB, Scotland, England and Ireland news, the environment, green issues, climate change, the climate emergency and global warming; American politics including: US presidential election 2024, Biden, Trump, the White House, the GOP, the Republicans and the Republican Party, the Democrats and the Democratic Party; UK politics including: UK election 24, Parliament, Labour, the Conservative Party, the Liberal Democrats, Reform UK, Rishi Sunak, Keir Starmer; culture; the royals and the royal family, including King Charles III and Prince Harry; HS2; the police and current affairs including: Ukraine, Russia, Bangladesh, Israel, Palestine, Gaza and AI.

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features