Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
Wine and Crime contains graphic and
0:02
explicit content which may not be
0:04
suitable for some listeners.
0:06
The discussion is advised. You
0:23
are listening to Wine and Crime,
0:25
the podcasts where two friends
0:28
chug wine, chat true crime
0:30
and unleash their worst Minnesota
0:32
accents. You darn tootin' they
0:34
do. Darn tootin'. Mm-hmm.
0:37
And you know what I love about this episode?
0:40
What? That we fuckin' picked
0:42
the topic. We did and you know
0:44
what? It's reminiscent
0:46
of things we've done before. It
0:49
is. But we get to
0:52
explore some really wild
0:55
shit. Mm-hmm. So
0:58
I'm ready. I should say
1:00
before we get too far into this, I'm
1:03
Lucy. Oh, right. I'm Amanda. One
1:05
of these fuckin' days we'll get there. We're gonna get there.
1:08
But yeah, like Amanda mentioned, we've
1:11
covered similar
1:13
things before. But
1:16
this is a little bit different. And
1:19
we are today presenting you
1:21
with Mommy Dearest
1:23
Crimes. Yup. In
1:26
honor of Mother's Day. Correct.
1:28
Happy Mother's Day to all
1:30
you moms out there. All
1:32
you special mams. Ugh. It's
1:36
my first Mother's Day. That's wild. How's
1:38
that feeling? I keep reminding Corey that
1:41
it's my first Mother's Day in
1:43
the hopes of he'll remember.
1:46
Yeah. Yeah. So
1:49
I bet if he door dashed me
1:51
a Egg McMuffin and just present
1:53
it to me in bed and
1:55
then- Your standards are- June downstairs
1:57
for an hour. Yeah. I
2:00
would say quite reasonable. Yeah,
2:03
that's a pretty reasonable request. You
2:05
want breakfast and to be
2:07
left alone. Yes, but isn't
2:09
that what every mother wants? I
2:12
think that's what every person wants. Yeah,
2:15
mmm-hmm. I want that. True. True.
2:18
I don't know. I mean I'm a I'm a mom
2:20
of fur children and
2:23
I want that. You're a fur mom.
2:25
I'm a fur mom. I'm a skin mom.
2:27
Boo. Hate
2:30
that. Really.
2:33
Like skin baby. No, no, no, no.
2:36
Nope. This is not. No.
2:41
Great. As offensive to me as
2:43
the term fur baby. Yeah, no, I hate
2:45
the term fur baby. I only said it as a joke. It
2:48
weirds me out, but I do have an
2:50
unhealthy love for my cat and if
2:53
something happened to her I would need to be put
2:55
into a facility. I mean you're on
2:57
the edge. You're skating on the edge with that one
2:59
anyway. 24-hour surveillance
3:02
would be needed if
3:04
anything happened to
3:06
my baby who is somewhere
3:08
in this room right now probably terrorizing the
3:10
rabbit. A maximum
3:12
security. Yeah. Institution.
3:18
Correct. I love it. Mmm. I
3:20
love it too. Okay, so I'm very excited about
3:22
this episode. Let's kick
3:24
it off with our wine crime
3:26
pairing if you don't mind. Oh,
3:29
I don't mind at all. I wanted to
3:31
take this opportunity to discuss something that might
3:34
be a little controversial. But
3:36
we were open
3:38
to challenging conversations on
3:41
this podcast and we're
3:43
gonna have them and this won't by
3:45
any stretch of the imagination be the
3:47
most challenging conversations that we probably even
3:49
have on this episode. Oh, um,
3:51
but I while
3:53
I was looking for a
3:56
pairing for today, I saw a lot
4:00
of stuff about like
4:03
the wine mom trope.
4:06
Like the culture? Yes.
4:08
And how
4:11
it can be very problematic and
4:14
not only misogynistic, but
4:16
also sort of like waving
4:19
away or undermining
4:24
substance use disorder and kind
4:27
of making like a playful
4:30
joke out of
4:33
overworked, overstressed,
4:36
specifically like woman figures in
4:38
a household having to cope
4:42
by drinking wine, which
4:44
like as much as we love wine,
4:47
if you're, you know, it's
4:49
worth evaluating if alcohol
4:52
is something that's at the top
4:54
of your list of coping mechanisms
4:57
and that can get
4:59
into some unhealthy territory.
5:02
So I just wanted to like look into this
5:04
whole wine mom thing because it felt really new
5:06
as like a culture as
5:08
a trope, but I
5:11
just kind of wanted to get a handle on like where this
5:14
came from and what
5:16
this is all about. So there are
5:18
obviously a lot of articles
5:20
that are very opinionated about this.
5:22
I avoided those. I really, I'm
5:25
starting just like with the
5:27
basics. I'm
5:29
really just going into like the Wikipedia so we
5:31
can figure out like where this came from and
5:34
kind of what it is about.
5:36
And then people can formulate their
5:38
own opinions on the whole wine
5:40
mom thing. But it's been very much
5:42
in the zeitgeist. Like I even
5:44
remember not so long ago, a Saturday
5:47
night live sketch where I think
5:49
it was like Aidy Bryant. They
5:52
were like celebrating her birthday and everybody. It's a
5:54
really funny sketch, but everybody was giving her birthday
5:57
presents and they were all these signs. like
6:00
wooden size that are like,
6:03
not without my wine. And like
6:05
wine, it was just like, whoa,
6:07
this is like a thing. It's
6:09
a total thing. So wine mom
6:11
is a term that is used
6:13
to describe typically an upper
6:15
middle class mother, often with young
6:17
children who turns to alcoholic drinks
6:20
to cope with being overworked or
6:22
fatigued from parenting. Alternatively,
6:24
the term wine mom may also be
6:27
used as a label of self-empowerment. So
6:29
yeah, it is kind of an interesting
6:31
term because like
6:33
some folks find it problematic and offensive and
6:36
I totally understand why that would be. And
6:38
others are like, it's kind
6:40
of like reclaiming it, like making
6:42
it like a funny thing. And
6:44
like whatever helps. Right, I
6:46
also understand that. And like, as long
6:48
as you are okay and you're getting
6:51
support and you're not like harming yourself
6:53
or others. I don't give a shit
6:55
what you call yourself. You
6:58
wanna call yourself a wine mom and you're a mom who likes wine?
7:00
Fucking go off, queen. As
7:02
a label of self-empowerment or as a means of
7:04
finding acceptance by others in a social group, which
7:06
brings up like such, that's such
7:09
an interesting conversation, especially in the West
7:11
and especially in the United States about
7:13
how much of a social crutch alcohol
7:16
is. Oh yes. Alcohol
7:18
in just the baseline social
7:21
structure is
7:24
such a key component across
7:26
so many cultures. It's
7:29
wild. Yeah, it really is when you
7:31
think about it, especially like from a
7:34
global perspective, like
7:36
you go to places in the
7:38
Middle East, they don't drink
7:40
socially. Right. A lot
7:43
of other cultures don't. It's banned in a
7:45
lot of, in some places, but like, yeah,
7:47
particularly in the West, in the US, in
7:49
Europe, it's like,
7:51
ooh, if we're not drinking
7:54
when we go out, what are we doing? What are
7:56
we doing? How do we let our guard down? How do we connect
7:58
with each other? Like what? a common
8:00
threat. While this term is most
8:02
frequently used to describe parents, its usage extends
8:05
to other individuals as well. The term may
8:07
also be used in a self-descriptive manner and
8:09
it is not necessary for a third party
8:11
to label one as a wine mom. The
8:14
term wine mom first came into popular
8:16
use during the COVID-19 pandemic, though the
8:19
term's origins date back to at least
8:21
pre-2016. Factors that
8:23
have been considered relevant by commentators include
8:25
working full-time at home, so I
8:27
could totally see how the pandemic
8:30
would absolutely fuel
8:32
this kind of wine mom movement. And
8:35
your fucking kids are at home. You're homeschooling
8:37
and you're working from
8:40
home. Yeah, child care's closed.
8:42
School is closed. Or remote.
8:44
Work is remote. And
8:46
a lot of the emotional labor and
8:49
the physical and psychological labor of
8:51
running the household does
8:53
disproportionately fall to the
8:55
female figure in the house in
8:57
like nuclear homes. And
8:59
so I kind of get it why
9:02
this would come from
9:04
here. I completely get it. Loneliness
9:06
and lack of social interaction in a
9:08
home or apartment due to COVID-19 restrictions,
9:11
being a single parent, raising one
9:13
or more children, lack of
9:15
personal space or privacy. Oh,
9:17
just lock myself
9:20
in the bathroom, chug a glass
9:22
of wine. Exactly. Social pressures or
9:24
conformity to drink, general feelings of
9:26
overwhelm, the perception that wine is
9:28
a healthy alternative to other alcoholic beverages
9:30
or more socially acceptable, which we have
9:32
talked about that as well. There are
9:34
actually a lot of health benefits to
9:37
like red wine, but obviously
9:39
anything in excess is going
9:41
to have an adverse effect.
9:45
This seems to fall in a
9:47
similar zone as like the
9:49
Karen terminology, the OK Boomer
9:52
terminology. It seems to like
9:54
be a very specific subset
9:57
of like elder millennial into Boomer.
10:01
age group. And obviously that
10:03
just kind of makes sense because we
10:05
are among folks of now like
10:08
pretty common parenting age. But
10:10
yeah, I just think it's really interesting and there are
10:12
a lot of articles out
10:15
there from individuals,
10:17
specifically women who have shared
10:21
their experience. Like there's this one article
10:24
from Amanda Monti that was
10:27
published in 2021 entitled, I became
10:29
a pandemic wine mom, here's what
10:31
I learned. Another from Arena
10:33
Gonzalez, wine mom jokes could be funny, but
10:35
they mask how overwhelmed mothers are right now.
10:38
I just feel like this
10:40
kind of trope or joke
10:43
is rooted in furious
10:46
discrepancies in the like
10:49
distribution of labor, I mean,
10:51
through a like heteronormative lens
10:54
specifically between men and women
10:56
in those kind of nuclear family relationships.
10:59
And how easy it is to reach
11:02
for something that can kind of
11:05
help numb all of
11:07
that overwhelm and that pressure and stress.
11:09
And it just kind of makes you
11:11
feel normal and adult. Right. It's
11:14
like, I have control over so
11:16
little in my life, I'm just gonna,
11:18
I can control pouring myself this glass
11:21
of wine and taking a fucking moment
11:23
for myself. I'm
11:25
not a parent, but I can
11:27
definitely relate to that. I just
11:30
felt like it was an interesting concept that
11:32
fit well in this episode that I wanted
11:34
to bring up and also connects
11:36
with the pairing that I chose for
11:38
today. And also just a
11:40
reminder to folks that we
11:42
do have a lot of recovery resources on
11:45
our webpage. So if you are wondering
11:48
or considering or questioning your
11:50
relationship with alcohol or other
11:53
substances, that is okay. And
11:55
that is totally normal.
11:58
And there are so many incredible resources
12:00
to help you understand
12:02
and get a plan set
12:04
for what is going to be best
12:06
for you and your loved ones moving
12:09
forward so that you can maintain your
12:11
own health both physically and
12:13
mentally. And that's at the end
12:15
of the day, we don't care
12:17
what substances you choose to imbibe
12:21
in. We certainly imbibe in
12:24
plenty. We only
12:26
care about your health and your
12:28
wellness. And we want to support
12:31
all of the spectrum
12:33
of how that looks for people. Recovery
12:35
looks different to everyone. My husband
12:38
does not drink anymore. He quit drinking in
12:40
2020. And we're
12:42
mostly a marijuana household. And that has been
12:44
a very good decision
12:47
for him, both physically and mentally
12:49
with his health. And so there are lots of...
12:51
I feel like it should just be more normalized
12:54
and accepted that not everybody needs to drink alcohol.
12:57
Not everybody needs to buy
12:59
into the American
13:02
pressures to drink socially.
13:05
Your choices are your own and don't let anybody
13:07
judge you for any of them. As long as
13:09
you're not fucking hurting yourself or other people, we
13:12
don't give a shit what you do. We
13:14
just want you to take care of yourself. Yeah. Oh,
13:16
that's the perfect match for today's episode.
13:19
I also saw a headline recently
13:21
that weed moms are the new wine
13:24
moms. I love that. Mm hmm.
13:26
I'm a weed mom. Yeah, you are.
13:29
I'm more a weed mom now than a wine mom.
13:31
I was definitely a wine mom. But
13:35
I also in my search
13:38
found this really cool
13:41
website because I wanted
13:43
to explore some more NA
13:45
alternatives for myself. And I
13:47
found this super rad, non-alcoholic,
13:50
sparkling wine line that looks
13:52
delicious and fun as hell.
13:54
It's called Badass Mom. Oh,
13:57
and you can order it
13:59
on badassmom.com. and
14:01
they do all non-alcoholic
14:03
sparklings. You can do rose, you can
14:05
do more of like a
14:08
champagne style. They have really cute
14:10
merch and tumblers. A
14:12
lot of their websites really cute. A
14:15
lot of their marketing is for people
14:18
who are pregnant, which is awesome, but
14:20
like you don't have to be pregnant
14:22
to choose an
14:24
NA alternative when that suits you.
14:27
So these just looked really fun and then
14:29
they also have these bundles that you can buy.
14:32
They have wine party
14:35
packs. So like if
14:37
you're putting together a baby shower or just
14:39
a hangout. A baby
14:42
shower, that's such a good idea. Yeah, I mean,
14:44
I helped a friend with a baby shower and
14:46
I did a mimosa bar and it was
14:48
hard for me. Mimosas. Mimosa, it was
14:50
hard for me to find good NA
14:54
sparkling in a liquor store. I did find
14:56
some so that there would be a selection,
14:59
but this stuff looks awesome and
15:01
could be an easy, delicious
15:04
alternative if you still want to like
15:06
celebrate and have your bubbles, but
15:08
you want to avoid some of the alcohol. Badass
15:11
Mom is an incredible brand.
15:13
It looks so delicious. So
15:15
check them out at badassmom.com.
15:18
Fantastic. What a weird
15:20
wine segment, but you know what? I'm just exploring
15:24
things, you know? I'm trying things that are
15:26
new. I think it's perfect. And I think
15:28
the wine mom thing can be
15:30
a damaging trope. Yeah.
15:34
And like you said, it doesn't, it just
15:36
puts like a happy sheen on something that
15:38
could very easily escalate
15:41
into a serious problem.
15:44
Yeah. So yeah, I think it's
15:46
important to talk about not just
15:49
have it be a punchline. But
15:52
if it's your punchline, great. That's,
15:54
you do you boo. Yeah. Well,
15:59
it's like new. So I'm drinking
16:01
sparkling water right now personally.
16:03
blasts. My yeah, Huge Stanley.
16:06
But. I am sick gets bigger as
16:08
it's a little earlier. The fucking
16:10
growing something that will assess, assess,
16:12
scroll something notes that I was
16:14
at all the time. I'll definitely
16:16
be getting. My wine mama tonight
16:18
because board me and I
16:20
are. Definitely. Going to
16:23
see Tom Sandoval should be
16:25
banned. So so that it's worth doing
16:27
one of those like we're going to check.
16:29
It out so you don't have. To set
16:31
an Omen and I have my
16:33
Ariana Maddox one eight Hundred Boys
16:35
Y T shirts or. Ah
16:38
so. Ah yeah I'm I'm
16:40
saving myself for like the to
16:42
cocktails and the joint that I'm
16:45
gonna have to ninety. Really?
16:47
To cope with the sound of has. Ever
16:49
more us he's going to get so sweaty
16:52
it's how it's gonna be vial I
16:54
am not getting So as that says, I
16:56
want to keep us safe distance. I
16:59
and Blast isn't assays looks like a
17:01
trumpet. I don't want to get trumpet
17:03
blast said. I don't want to see
17:06
his nipples to clearly. I oughta experience
17:08
any droplets of any kind. Oh, Yes,
17:11
No, no spray. Know spray know missed.
17:13
So yeah of you're gonna tell me
17:15
about the murder table though because I'll
17:17
send you pics. You know I love
17:19
March or not. Get Up! By.
17:22
Any of it because I'm not giving
17:24
him. More. Mana me a picture
17:26
of. I'll send you a picture if you
17:28
want. To send him money you can venmo
17:30
me and then I'll pay. I'll get you
17:32
the merchants. London that you monster. Okay,
17:34
assess you take him you're going to
17:36
is so so I said. I don't
17:39
want to pay him more money. Oh
17:41
okay. I'm doing this as a sacrifice.
17:44
For our by Cpr.
17:46
Hobbies, It's. Like. Death.
17:49
Like.on safari are taking one for
17:51
the team. I have to
17:53
experience this moment in the cultural like guys.
17:56
And I would regret it if I didn't say
17:58
yes when asked. If I wanted to go. Well,
18:00
you're also balancing it out with seeing Phaedra on
18:02
Sunday. I am seeing Phaedra on Sunday. Oh,
18:04
God bless. It's going to be a good weekend.
18:08
All right, well, let's get to our break
18:10
so we can get to Sandoval sooner. Let's
18:12
do it. Let's hear a quick word from
18:14
our sponsors. May
18:16
is Mental Health Awareness Month and
18:19
TalkSpace, the leading virtual therapy provider,
18:21
is encouraging people to talk it
18:24
out in therapy. Talking
18:26
up to a therapist might
18:29
feel uncomfortable, cathartic, exhausting, or
18:31
exhilarating. People have
18:33
all different experiences, but one thing
18:35
is certain. If you keep talking
18:37
or texting with a licensed therapist,
18:39
you'll gain insights and uncover truths
18:41
that you can only find in
18:43
therapy. Get those personal breakthroughs and
18:45
judgment-free support by signing up
18:47
for TalkSpace. TalkSpace
18:50
has been a game changer in my
18:52
life. I've been using it for what,
18:54
six, seven years? They
18:56
were our very first sponsor. Yeah,
18:59
and I've had the same therapist. She's
19:01
phenomenal. It just works so well
19:03
for me. It's so easy. I
19:08
just encourage everybody to try it. At
19:10
talkspace.com, you can sign up online and
19:12
get a personalized match with a provider that's right
19:14
for you, typically within 48 hours. That
19:17
quick turnaround can be so
19:19
life-changing for people. It's
19:22
incredibly convenient to have virtual sessions with
19:24
your licensed therapist from the comfort of
19:26
your home. I personally love the texting
19:28
because then as things arise for me,
19:30
I can send them to her without
19:32
having to go over an
19:34
inventory of loose anxieties
19:37
in my head once a month. Then
19:40
she just gets to it during her office hours. It's
19:42
literally perfect. A therapy can help you
19:44
shift your perspective. It can help you find tools to
19:46
cope in difficult times and just be a guiding light.
19:49
They have so many skilled therapists
19:52
that are ready to work with you. This
19:54
can help with any specific challenges that you might
19:56
be facing. It's the number one online therapy platform.
19:59
They have licensed therapists in over 40 specialties
20:02
including anxiety, check
20:04
depression, check relationships,
20:06
check substance use disorders, so much
20:09
more. Talkspace is
20:11
secure and private. They're using the
20:13
latest end-to-end bank-loading krypton technology to
20:15
store client information and comply with
20:17
the latest HIPAA regulations. And Talkspace
20:20
is very affordable and also
20:22
in network with most major insurers,
20:24
which is huge. To
20:27
celebrate May Mental Health Awareness Month and
20:29
the power of talking it out in
20:31
therapy, Talkspace is offering
20:33
every listener of this podcast $80 off
20:36
your first month with promo
20:38
code SPACE80 when you go
20:41
to talkspace.com/gals. To match the
20:43
licensed therapist today, go to
20:45
talkspace.com/gals to get 80 bucks
20:48
off your first month with
20:50
code SPACE80 and to show
20:52
your support for this show.
20:55
To talkspace.com/gals, code SPACE80
20:58
and treat your client. Treat
21:01
it. Y'all, I
21:04
am obsessed with
21:07
convenience when it comes to my
21:09
cleaning. And most things. And
21:12
most things. And that convenience
21:14
goes beyond just like delivery
21:16
of supplies, refillable items. Like,
21:19
I love the laundry
21:21
tab sensation, but did you know
21:23
that like detergent pods for laundry
21:26
or even dishwashers are
21:28
wrapped in plastic? Like that
21:31
film around the pod that
21:33
dissolves is
21:35
plastic and it's ending
21:37
up in our oceans, rivers, soil, our
21:40
bodies. We're
21:42
eating and drinking about a credit card's
21:44
worth of plastic a week, babe. I
21:46
can't. That's my Roman Empire. I can't
21:48
deal. I never thought thinking about
21:50
it. So what I love about Blue Land
21:52
is they combined that convenience of what's tossing
21:55
a tab in the laundry, tossing a tab
21:57
in the dishwasher, but they set out to
21:59
do something. about the freaking plastic
22:02
and they're trying to eliminate the need
22:04
for single-use plastic in the products that
22:06
we reach for every single day and
22:08
I'm obsessed. Luland is on a mission
22:11
to eliminate single-use plastic by reinventing cleaning
22:13
essentials to be better for you and
22:15
the planet and our bodies with
22:18
the same powerful clean that you are already
22:20
used to. Luland uses no single-use
22:22
plastic in any component. So that's
22:25
the bottles, the tablets, the wrappers,
22:27
like the shipping materials. Their
22:29
tablet packaging is fully compostable.
22:32
Luland products are effective and affordable. Like
22:34
I know a lot of these brands, they
22:37
just don't really cut it. You
22:39
know, they say they're eco-friendly, but you're
22:41
like, hmm, but the chemicals really work.
22:44
I'm like, you know, but these are
22:46
truly, you
22:48
can feel good about like the results
22:51
that you're getting as well as the
22:53
good that you're doing for the planet.
22:55
We've been using Luland products exclusively for
22:57
all the cleaning in our house for like four years
22:59
now. It's our favorite. I don't even
23:01
like the like smell
23:03
or the results from stuff I was buying at
23:05
the grocery store. Yeah, and- It's
23:07
totally changed the game. I
23:10
can't get over their dishwasher tablets
23:12
either. They're the best. They're proven
23:14
to perform on baked on, burnt
23:16
on stains. There's no rinse aid
23:18
needed. Y'all, I put my dishes
23:20
in the dishwasher nasty. Okay.
23:23
Yeah. They work. They
23:26
definitely work. You can get even more savings
23:28
by buying refills in bulk or setting up
23:30
a subscription. Highly recommend the subscription. These
23:33
are customizable and convenient so you never run
23:35
out of your most used products. They just show
23:37
up when you need them. Luland is
23:39
trusted in over a million homes,
23:41
including ours. Luland has a
23:43
special offer for our listeners right now. Get
23:47
15% off your first order
23:49
by going to blueland.com/gals. You
23:51
won't want to miss this.
23:53
blueland.com/gals for 15% off. That's
23:57
blueland.com/gals to get 15%.
24:00
set off and treat your clean.
24:03
So the other day I got a
24:05
very helpful email and most emails are
24:07
not helpful but this one said, hey
24:09
just FYI, the price of one
24:11
of your subscriptions has
24:14
increased. I'm like, oh
24:17
my god, this is like
24:19
actually useful information. Also which
24:23
subscription is it? Right and
24:25
will you get rid of it for me
24:27
because I probably don't use it. So I logged
24:29
into my rocket money account and I could
24:32
see exactly what that was alert was about
24:34
and I decided you know what this specific
24:36
app isn't worth an extra four dollars a
24:38
month so no hey
24:40
rocket money please cancel this for me and
24:43
it did. Bye bye.
24:45
It's a concierge service. It
24:47
truly is. Rocket money is a personal
24:49
finance app that finds and cancels your
24:52
unwanted subscriptions, it monitors your spending and
24:54
helps lower your bills so that you
24:56
can grow your savings babe. With rocket
24:58
money we have full control over our subscriptions
25:01
at a clear view of our expenses. So
25:03
like I love how I can see
25:05
all of my subscriptions in one place, see if
25:07
there's something I don't want, get those alerts like
25:09
you mentioned when something changes in
25:11
price specifically when it goes up.
25:14
Rocket money can then help me cancel it with
25:16
a few taps if I just want to get
25:18
rid of that service. I also love how the
25:21
dashboard shows me my month spending compared to previous
25:23
months like I see clearly like what my habits
25:25
are and you know maybe see
25:28
what I could trim in the future. I
25:30
love that. Yeah they also
25:32
help you create a custom budget to
25:34
help keep your spending on track so
25:37
say you're planning for I don't know a
25:39
wedding which I'm still traumatized about. What
25:42
I really could have
25:44
used more help at
25:47
that time and I was not smart
25:50
if I'd had rocket money I really feel
25:52
like that process honestly could have gone differently.
25:55
But if you're like planning for a trip, a vacation,
25:57
a big event, whatever, this is such
25:59
an awesome to help you reach your
26:01
goals and keep your spending on track. And
26:03
Rocket Money will even try to negotiate to
26:06
lower your bills for you by up to
26:08
20%. All you have to
26:10
do is submit a picture of a recurring
26:12
bill, and Rocket Money takes care of the rest. They
26:14
will deal with customer service for you, and if they can
26:16
get you a lower rate, they'll
26:18
do it. Rocket Money has
26:20
over 5 million users and has saved a total
26:23
of 500 million in
26:27
canceled subscriptions, saving members up
26:30
to $740 a year when using all of
26:32
the apps features. That's a
26:34
trust. That's a more than a weekend away.
26:36
Mm-hmm. Get it. Stop
26:38
wasting money on things you
26:41
don't use. Cancel your unwanted
26:43
subscriptions by going to rocketmoney.com/gals.
26:46
That's rocketmoney.com/gals. One
26:48
more time, rocketmoney.com/gals. And
26:50
treat your spending. Great. Welcome
26:53
back, and I'm
26:55
very excited for what you've cooked
26:57
up for us this week, Lucy. So,
26:59
Lucy, what is the background,
27:02
and I hope to God, psych
27:04
for mom and dearest crimes? I've
27:07
got psych because... Very
27:10
psych. Mm-hmm. So, like
27:12
we said at the top
27:14
of the episode, we have done
27:16
similar topics before. We've done mom
27:19
crimes for episode 195, and
27:21
we also did daddy crimes for 185. Yeah,
27:25
and we've done like case updates on
27:27
some like mommy dearest stuff, but we
27:29
haven't done any of... We
27:32
haven't done the case that I'm covering today. That's
27:34
for God damn sure. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. So,
27:38
I did cover like some psychology
27:40
and some kind of mommy stuff in both
27:42
of those episodes, but
27:44
I am trying to avoid repeating. So, if
27:47
you want more of this content, check out
27:49
195 and 185. Perfect.
27:52
According to medical news today,
27:54
mommy issues often refer to,
27:57
quote, problems forming or
27:59
maintaining. healthy adult relationships due
28:01
to a person's insecure or
28:03
unhealthy relationship with their mother
28:05
or another female figure in
28:07
their childhood. This
28:10
does not necessarily mean that the mom was
28:12
the bad parent. In
28:16
fact, an overprotective or overly
28:18
permissive mother-child dynamic can have
28:20
its own kind of toxicity.
28:23
Abusive or absent or best-friendly
28:26
or super-doting or whatever the
28:28
parenting style might be can
28:31
be on either end of the spectrum
28:33
or anywhere in between. The
28:35
parent's behavior impacts how the child sees
28:37
themselves and their place in the world
28:40
as an adult. Was
28:42
this weird for
28:44
you to research as
28:47
a new parent? Like did this
28:49
thing kind of think about when
28:51
Junie gets older? I
28:54
would have to imagine it would. It's
28:57
fucking stressful. I mean parents are
28:59
incredible. I'm
29:01
not cut out for that shit. I
29:03
think so far I'm
29:06
a good mom. You're doing fucking great. You're
29:09
crushing it. But doing this
29:11
research, especially, I was just
29:14
like, I'll set her down in her
29:16
chair so I can go poop. I
29:18
don't feel like I'm abandoning her. You're
29:20
not. You're crying. It's not the same.
29:23
But like, you know, she naps on me
29:26
all the time. I'm being overly permissive. I
29:29
don't think that I'm falling into any
29:33
kind of cycle where she's going to have fucking
29:36
issues when she gets older. I
29:38
also think right now it's a little too
29:40
early to ascribe these things
29:42
because an infant's needs
29:46
are so different from a toddler and then
29:48
a preteen and then a teenager. Everything
29:51
evolves as the child gets older too. It's
29:54
definitely too early to be spoiling her. Thousand
30:00
Two percent. It's not possible to
30:02
spoil an infant. Know. Seven
30:05
every night for yeah. Like thinking about
30:07
like. The. Next few years
30:10
and ran for the next eighteen
30:12
years like until see season Adult
30:14
Senate will be really interesting to
30:16
see. Because I feel like I
30:18
am. Exactly like my mom.
30:21
So. As soon as you enter the
30:23
late relationship. With your mother to I
30:25
really do You really do? I
30:28
think I'm up. I think I'm a pretty
30:30
pretty well functioning adult. Yeah, you're doing great.
30:32
I mean, I would trust you as my emergency. Contact
30:34
I'll be emergency contact sir I my sister's
30:36
my emerged to god that and my husband
30:38
said the best and only my think I
30:41
have like your mom cell phone number of.
30:44
Us Ff, Ff, Ff. That's
30:46
fine. By. A I can name. Ten
30:50
way worse. Mom's the My
30:52
Mom oh forces or ss
30:54
admit that my Mom. But
30:57
like as a child, you look
30:59
at your mom. Your. Parents
31:01
And you're lying. Oh that. That's
31:04
how adults behave. Like,
31:06
that's how that's how I'm going to
31:08
behave. That's how I will be as
31:10
an adult. So even if it's subconscious,
31:12
even if they're very young, they're not
31:14
like actively seeking these things. That that
31:17
is what they are. They're learning by
31:19
example. Exactly. So
31:21
I'm certain that that
31:24
parenting behavior. If.
31:26
It's not great. It can
31:28
lead to that child as
31:30
an adult having a negative
31:32
self image. Low levels
31:34
of trust and other like
31:36
psychologically based issues. It's also
31:38
worth noting that mommy issues
31:41
can be affected by either
31:43
parent. So. Many times
31:45
daddy issues are seen as like a
31:47
different set of problems. And. Often
31:49
it's a girl children described as
31:51
having daddy issues and boy children
31:54
as having mommy issues. I think
31:56
daddy issues also kind of comes
31:58
across frequently as like. sexual
32:02
manifestations, whereas
32:05
mommy issues are more like dependents
32:07
and attachment
32:09
styles. Yeah. First
32:12
of all, people tend to use these terms
32:14
very casually and apply them very broadly because
32:17
they themselves are not clinical terms.
32:19
Right. Also, I know we've
32:21
talked before, it's often the opposite sex parent
32:23
that has the biggest social impact on children
32:26
and yes, we will get to Sigmund Freud,
32:28
don't worry. Oh, God. I think
32:30
that the two concepts like mommy issues
32:32
and daddy issues are sort of kept
32:35
separate because your mother arguably is the
32:37
more important parent early in a child's
32:39
life. Sure. And
32:41
so the way that
32:44
their behaviors manifest
32:46
and are reflected in the children's
32:49
psychology can be
32:52
different. Like
32:54
you were saying, attachment styles
32:56
versus how women are
32:58
taught to be respected by
33:01
men, by their dad. And
33:03
I think it's also obviously worth
33:05
noting that this conversation that
33:07
we're having is based
33:10
in research that
33:12
is more widely available and we
33:14
understand that that research really does
33:17
focus on heteronormative families. Oh, yeah. And
33:20
this is by no means a
33:22
reflection on same-sex couples
33:24
or gender-fluid couples, queer couples
33:27
and their ability to
33:29
parent or like what role they
33:31
step into for their child. Just
33:34
for the sake of this episode, things
33:37
will likely be more on the binary for
33:39
this segment because of the research that's available,
33:41
which is like problematic in and of itself,
33:45
obviously. But we only have what
33:47
we can find to work with. And
33:49
a lot of this research took place in like
33:51
the first half of the 20th century. Right. So
33:54
same-sex couples having kids was
33:57
like unheard of. Yeah. And
33:59
besides that, they were not studying
34:01
those types of relationships. Because they
34:03
were illegal. Yeah. Too
34:06
many out and proud in the open. Good
34:08
God. In 1944, psychologist
34:11
and psychotherapist John Bowlby
34:13
wrote about how the
34:15
different forms of attachments
34:18
developed with a mother in infancy
34:21
directly correlate with how adults behave.
34:23
He worked closely with developmental psychologist
34:26
Mary Ainsworth and found that specific
34:28
aspects of how a mother interacts
34:30
with their child can lead to
34:32
different attachment styles in children later
34:34
on. They found that
34:36
there are four attachment styles that can
34:39
occur in a mother-child relationship. So tag
34:41
yourself. Oh God, here we
34:43
go. We have... Take this
34:45
fun quiz. Mostly bees. We
34:48
have a secure relationship. So people
34:50
with this attachment style are able
34:52
to form secure and loving relationships
34:55
with other people. They were
34:57
shown love as a child and felt safe
34:59
and secure with their caregiver. Then
35:02
we have anxious insecure. There's mine.
35:05
People with this attachment style have
35:07
a deeply rooted fear of abandonment. They
35:12
are often insecure in their relationships and
35:14
worried that their partner will leave them.
35:17
I'm not worried that your partner is going to leave you.
35:20
I'm not necessarily either, but I definitely
35:22
have... This is
35:24
definitely my attachment style. I've
35:26
been in therapy for a long time. It's
35:29
not an abandonment issue that comes
35:31
from my parents. My parents were
35:34
wonderful, loving parents that provided for me and made
35:36
me feel loved and safe in my home. Most
35:39
of it honestly comes from medical trauma
35:41
that my dad went through when I
35:43
was a young teenager. Losing
35:46
his leg. Yeah,
35:48
losing his leg and potentially losing his life and
35:50
then eventually he did lose his life. That's
35:53
more where it came from. My
35:56
role in the household at that
35:58
time... of became
36:00
by default as sort of like an
36:02
emotional regulator because things were really intense
36:04
at our house. And like, you know,
36:06
there was depression and anxiety. Like we
36:08
had a lot going on. And
36:11
so I know that as a result of
36:13
that, something that I've worked through is like,
36:16
I am very anxious about
36:18
other people's emotions in a room.
36:20
And that definitely comes up in my marriage where I
36:22
like ask my husband all the time, like, are you mad at
36:24
me? Or like, did I do
36:27
something wrong? Like, because I'm, that's just like,
36:29
that's childhood shit that I just developed.
36:31
So it's, you know, it's worth noting
36:33
that like these attachment styles can come
36:36
from all kinds of different life
36:38
experiences and trauma that you
36:40
may experience that aren't just from, you
36:43
know, a parent. Your mother holding you when you
36:45
were in an instance. Exactly, putting you down to
36:47
shit for too long. So,
36:50
you know, it's just, these are interesting concepts,
36:52
but like, oh my God, the amount
36:54
of deep diving I've done into my attachment style of
36:57
where it comes from is bottomless.
37:00
Very self-aware. Very good that you
37:02
know this already. I'm not not
37:04
a mess. Oh, no.
37:06
But you also need a lot of validation
37:09
and tend to be clingy as is the
37:11
end of this anxious, insecure description. There it
37:13
is. I don't know that I'd call you
37:16
clingy. I'm less on the clingy end,
37:18
but I definitely need validation. And I need
37:20
like verbal communication.
37:23
And, you know, my husband has been really great
37:25
about like meeting me where I'm at and vice
37:27
versa for him. But yeah, the validation
37:29
thing, absolutely I fucking need it.
37:32
Same side. Well, you give it
37:34
too, so. I do give it. You do. You
37:38
do give validation. And
37:41
I love you for it. I
37:44
love you too. I feel so secure with you. I
37:47
know. We might have
37:49
a lot of trauma, but didn't come from
37:51
each other. No, we're good. Okay,
37:53
so the next one is avoidant
37:55
insecure. So people with this
37:58
attachment style have a fear of intimacy. usually
38:00
because they were ignored or had their
38:02
feelings invalidated by their parents. Like,
38:06
I'll give you something to cry about. Yeah,
38:08
yeah, I mean, this can come up a
38:10
lot if some parent or
38:12
both parents have kind of a short fuse or a
38:14
temper. You want to
38:16
avoid conflict, you're scared of, you know,
38:19
creating drama or getting up an adverse
38:21
reaction in your house. That's a very
38:24
real thing. And leads
38:26
to that fear of intimacy.
38:28
They tend to have difficulty
38:30
developing trusting relationships and prefer
38:32
to rely on themselves for
38:34
emotional support. Then
38:37
last but not least, we
38:39
have the disorganized insecure people.
38:43
So people sounds like me on
38:45
the surface. You were definitely that second one. I
38:48
love you. So
38:54
people with a disorganized insecure attachment style
38:56
have a combination of both anxious and
38:58
avoidant attachment styles. They can be clingy
39:00
for affection and for their partner's time,
39:02
but they also tend to push their
39:05
partners away and feel like they can't
39:07
trust them. Yeah, that's not me. They
39:09
crave love, but they're afraid to give
39:11
it and also to receive it. Do
39:14
you feel like you
39:16
know where you fall on that scale? Or do
39:18
you identify with any of those? I mean, I
39:20
feel like I'm a pretty I think I'm a
39:23
secure. I would 100% agree having been
39:25
friends with you for a very fucking long time.
39:27
Yeah, I feel like I don't have
39:29
issues trusting people.
39:32
If anything, I trust people a little
39:34
too much. As
39:36
far as like the relying on
39:39
people who prefer to rely on themselves for
39:42
emotional support, I would more
39:44
closely identify with that which would
39:46
be the avoidant insecure just because
39:50
I don't know. I just I mean,
39:52
it's also sort of like an introvert quality
39:55
characteristic, I think too. 1000%.
39:58
I think you and I both have that. Similar
40:00
quality. Of when that like worse really
40:02
stress or overwhelmed we kind of wanted
40:04
like revert in word. And
40:07
like isolate and just like take
40:09
a be. But I don't think
40:11
that's coming from a place of
40:13
insecurity and necessarily. It's is how we
40:15
process and maybe sometimes it's not healthy because
40:17
we should be asking for help. but it's
40:19
just you need a fucking. Break.
40:22
Yeah yeah. Yeah. This
40:25
is. A fucking
40:27
break. Up stuff such as
40:29
my. Mother's
40:34
day of fatigue bright. Make
40:38
Muffins! Thank you for joining us
40:40
as we process through a lot
40:43
and this episode of us were
40:45
laid it all out. Oh.
40:48
My. God. It. As should have gotten wind.
40:51
Up! Ah. Not
40:54
a regular mom and the line mom? I'm a lie.
40:56
Bob. I think for the most part you
40:58
and I are both fairly secure because the. Definitely.
41:01
Had trusting, loving, caring, safe relationships with
41:03
their parents. Yep, Growing that we're we're
41:06
very lucky. We are very lucky in
41:08
that way. Okay, so
41:10
there are five main signs of
41:12
having what we might call mommy
41:14
issues. And again,
41:16
while each case is dependent on
41:18
multiple factors specific to ones childhood
41:20
experience. Mommy. Issues can
41:23
be characterized by the
41:25
inability to experience deep
41:27
connections clinging s. The.
41:29
Inability to be affectionate, Being.
41:32
Overly critical and
41:34
also dependencies. Because
41:37
mommy issues also manifest differently
41:39
in. Men: Versus Women again
41:41
talking on the binary here. In
41:44
men, seven signs can include always
41:46
needing to say in contact with
41:48
their mother or never wanting anything
41:50
to do with their mother. Could
41:54
see I have a
41:56
good disrespectful attitude towards
41:58
women insecurity, cheating, and
42:01
or a sense of entitlement. In
42:04
women some signs can include low
42:07
self-esteem, difficulty trusting
42:09
others, having very
42:11
few female friends, and
42:15
having difficulty setting boundaries.
42:18
Interesting. So
42:21
yeah it can
42:23
manifest differently again. There's a lot of
42:25
overlap between so-called mommy issues
42:27
and daddy issues. Right. But
42:30
at the end it's just about it's
42:32
about attachment styles. Mm-hmm. So usually when
42:34
we think about mommy issues we often
42:37
think about Sigmund Freud and the infamous
42:39
Oedipus complex. Damn it.
42:41
I'm such a Freud hater. I know.
42:44
I can't. It's so
42:46
gross. Everything is just about
42:48
dicks and sex and yeah.
42:51
God. I know. So. It's
42:53
too much. According to my love
42:56
our encyclopedia of Atonica, the
42:58
Oedipus complex was proposed by Sigmund Freud as
43:00
part of his theory that
43:03
childhood can be divided
43:05
into psychosexual stages. Everyone
43:08
wants to fuck their mom. Or
43:10
their dad. So these
43:13
stages are differentiated by the child's
43:16
supposed sexual fixation on different parts
43:18
of the body. Mm-hmm. The psychoanalytic
43:20
theory refers to a desire for
43:23
sexual involvement with the parent of
43:25
the opposite sex and
43:27
a sense of rivalry with the parent of
43:29
the same sex. Okay. I
43:31
find that so disturbing. I
43:33
know. And unrealistic.
43:36
And like what fascinating, I
43:38
mean a child comes out
43:40
of your cooch, feeds
43:42
off your titty, you got to hold them a
43:44
bunch. Mm-hmm. I mean a body's
43:47
just a body. Sex is only one
43:50
part of your whole body. I mean Freud's
43:53
theories were more about him
43:55
than they were about other people. Oh yeah. I
43:57
think he got super close.
44:00
on a lot of shit and
44:02
to the point where it's like
44:04
everyone wants to have sex with their
44:06
mom and their dad like okay no
44:08
but your parental figures are often like
44:11
we talked about earlier the
44:13
example of how
44:15
adults treat each other how adults
44:17
in a romantic relationship interact with
44:19
each other like how it's you
44:21
know what the expectation is that
44:25
is completely true and makes sense yeah
44:27
I just feel like Freud takes it to
44:29
a such a gross place kids aren't
44:32
thinking about sex little
44:34
children are not thinking about sex no
44:36
and they shouldn't be they
44:38
shouldn't have anything to do with it nothing's
44:40
probably gone wrong and because like
44:43
everyone wants to explore
44:45
their body and like see what
44:47
can fit in their nature's pocket or like see
44:49
how hard they can tug their ding dong
44:52
doesn't mean they're sexual yeah
44:54
we all experience exploration figuring out
44:57
what we've got how many
44:59
how many Barbie legs you can fit
45:01
up your butt exactly four
45:05
just get it yeah
45:07
minimum minimum gross okay
45:12
so he attributed the
45:14
complex to children aged
45:16
three to five mm-hmm
45:19
the Oedipus complex and said that the stage
45:21
ended when the child started to identify with
45:23
the parent of the same sex and
45:25
repressed their sexual desires for the parent
45:28
of the opposite sex so apparently between
45:30
the ages of three and five you
45:32
start to change your if it's
45:34
a girl child you're gonna hate your mom and want
45:36
to fuck your dad oh
45:39
but when you turn five that goes away because
45:41
you identify more with your mom great
45:44
thanks Freud yeah if
45:46
the child has a decently loving and non-traumatic
45:48
relationship with their parents they will pass the
45:50
stage quickly but if they
45:52
have a traumatic relationship with their parents then
45:55
they will experience what he called
45:57
infantile neurosis which
45:59
is characterized by internalized conflict that leads
46:01
to anxiety and
46:04
adult neurosis. Okay.
46:06
Sure. This term was originally used
46:09
to apply the concept to boys,
46:11
hence Oedipus. The
46:14
equivalent in girls is called the Electra
46:16
Complex. So the Oedipus
46:18
Complex, if you weren't in
46:20
the same English class as me in
46:22
high school. And me. It's
46:25
originally named after the Greek myth of
46:27
Oedipus, the Theban king who unknowingly kills
46:30
his father and marries his mother. They
46:32
had children together. After he's been blinded.
46:34
No, he blinds himself at the end.
46:36
Oh, that's right. That's right. That's right.
46:39
He had, they had children together, but Oedipus eventually finds out the
46:41
truth about his marriage. Once he and
46:43
his mother realize they are, they are
46:46
married and their relationship to each other,
46:48
she hangs herself and he takes
46:50
off her, her broaches from her
46:53
regal dress and gouges out his
46:55
eyes. So
46:58
yeah. High school English was a
47:00
trip. A trip. So there
47:02
are some famous examples of mommy issues
47:04
in media. We
47:07
have Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho, which is a movie
47:09
that came out in 1960. In
47:12
this movie, Norman Bates of the
47:14
Bates Motel develops a split personality
47:16
after killing his controlling mother and
47:18
her lover out of jealousy. Out
47:23
of guilt and grief, he stashes his
47:25
mother's corpse and assumes her personality. When
47:28
he commits crimes against women, he becomes
47:30
attracted to. Oh, it's
47:32
such a great movie. Ari
47:35
Aster's Bow is Afraid that came out
47:37
last year. My God.
47:40
Have you seen that? Yeah, I,
47:42
I don't think I was really
47:44
following it very well. It's a
47:47
very challenging movie with a lot
47:49
of like cultural references from the
47:52
Jewish community that we may not
47:54
understand, but it's really
47:57
fucking good and it's fascinating.
48:00
I think I'm a Nookin Phoenix is badass,
48:02
but like, isn't Patti LuPone
48:05
who plays his mom? Yeah, I think so. She,
48:08
her performance. I've
48:11
never seen fucking anything like it. I'm
48:13
gonna have to watch it again. I'm gonna have
48:15
to read a review that just like thoroughly
48:17
explains it and then watch it again. Read
48:20
more about this movie and then watch it
48:22
again, but it's a challenging movie. It's a
48:24
commitment. Yeah, it's like three
48:26
hours long. It's three hours long. It's like
48:29
pretty wildly surrealist
48:31
slash realist. It's
48:36
confusing. It's very confusing. But it's
48:38
beautiful and the performances are incredible.
48:40
And if you can like take
48:43
in, yeah, the
48:46
some of the message that he's
48:48
trying to convey. It's
48:50
a fascinating movie. I loved
48:52
it. I also really like, I mean,
48:54
R.E.S. like
48:56
Midsummer and Hereditary. There
48:59
was so much
49:02
deeper into it. That's
49:04
why I can watch those movies over and
49:07
over. Correct. There's
49:09
just so much. Think Bo is Afraid
49:12
didn't do quite as well because people
49:14
were expecting something like that. Something
49:16
linear with a story that made
49:19
a lot of sense. That was easy to follow.
49:22
And this definitely falls like in
49:24
the realm of psychological horror, but
49:26
it is definitely more of
49:28
like you're getting his view
49:31
of childhood trauma and
49:33
how that affected his life. And like, you
49:35
don't know what's real that he's experiencing and
49:37
what isn't. And then she, Patti
49:40
LuPone is like actually a mastermind behind like
49:42
manipulating him and doing all this wild shit.
49:44
It's so unhinged. I love it.
49:47
It's really fucking cool. That's what I'm saying. If
49:49
I have like read something about it and can
49:51
like kind of know what to look for, what
49:53
it's just packed with
49:56
like hidden threads and thousand.
50:00
It's a cool movie. Well, in this movie,
50:02
the main character, Bo, Joaquin Phoenix, deals
50:05
with a lot of anxiety, guilt,
50:07
and sexual repression that stems from
50:09
a particularly over-involved mother-son relationship. Another
50:13
one, we have Greta Gerwig's Lady Bird. I
50:15
like that movie. Came out in 2017. Such
50:17
a sweet movie. But
50:20
in this movie, the main character, Christine, goes
50:22
through a coming-of-age situation in
50:24
which we learn more about the emotional
50:26
abuse she's experienced from her mother and
50:28
how it's impacted her. And
50:31
at the end of the movie, when she's getting
50:33
on her plane to move to, I forget, where
50:35
she moves to New York, maybe. And
50:38
the mom just keeps, she just
50:40
gets, kicks her out of the car
50:42
and the mom kind of just drives around and,
50:44
oh, it's sad. It is sad. It's
50:47
really sad. And it shows a good perspective
50:49
of not only how that affects her
50:52
daughter, but then what the mom
50:54
is losing by behaving
50:57
that way. It's
50:59
a good movie. Yeah. Yeah.
51:01
And it's also a movie that's not only about
51:03
that. No. I mean, it's
51:06
about so much. Yeah. But yeah, that's
51:08
an important part of it. And it really makes
51:10
the ending a lot more heartbreaking than it
51:14
would be without it. And
51:16
of course, I had to put in a bit
51:19
about the 1981 biographical psychological drama
51:21
American cinematic masterpiece that this episode
51:23
is named after, Mommy
51:26
Dearest. Oh my
51:28
God. I was waiting for this. This
51:31
movie is wild. And
51:34
the fact that it is
51:36
biographical. Yeah. Well, I'm
51:38
going to get to all that.
51:42
So directed by Frank Perry,
51:44
this film stars Faye Dunaway
51:46
as actress
51:48
Joan Crawford. It is
51:50
one of Faye Dunaway's most unhinged
51:53
and incredible performances of
51:56
all fucking time. It's
51:58
iconic. So I just. doing
52:00
this with my eyebrows like
52:02
subconsciously. Yes. Her brows. I
52:05
know. They're so at attention. They're
52:07
so sharp. So amazing. So
52:10
Faye Dunaway plays Joan Crawford
52:12
whose abuse was described by
52:15
her adult daughter, Christina Crawford,
52:17
in Christina's 1978 autobiography of
52:19
the same name, Mommy Dearest.
52:22
Yep. So Christina, her actual daughter wrote
52:24
a book about
52:26
how fucked up her household
52:28
was and how it was made into this
52:31
movie. Yeah. Also,
52:33
I had no idea
52:35
that this movie is often considered to
52:37
be one of the worst films of
52:40
all time. That's not true. It is
52:42
true. I don't care who said
52:44
no. I don't believe that. At the
52:46
second- I mean, I believe you that people say that.
52:48
This movie is fucking incredible and everyone who
52:50
says that can eat a pile of
52:52
shit. At the second annual Golden
52:54
Raspberry Awards, it was
52:57
nominated for nine categories. And
53:00
it won two, including worst
53:02
picture and worst actress. That's
53:05
bullshit. I have to
53:08
wonder if the subject
53:10
matter because Joan Crawford was
53:12
someone who was so revered
53:14
and protected in Hollywood. And
53:17
there's, I'm certain
53:19
controversy over these
53:21
allegations from Christine- We'll get
53:23
to it. That the
53:25
movie got panned more than it
53:27
deserved because of that. One
53:30
thing that I read
53:32
was that audiences thought
53:35
it was supposed to be a comedy. What?
53:39
Audiences were laughing because her
53:41
performance was so
53:44
outrageous and some of those
53:46
scenes were pretty ridiculous. Strap yourself in. I love
53:48
it. I mean, to me,
53:52
I've seen that movie a lot of fucking
53:54
times. I have never taken
53:56
it in as comedy. I
53:58
take it in as horror. Yeah,
54:01
it is a horror movie to me.
54:04
It's this creepy Yeah
54:08
Okay. So here's a little bit of the
54:10
background if you've not seen mommy dearest What
54:13
the fuck we'll just frame for frame
54:15
recreate it for you right now. Here we go
54:20
Okay, so Joan Crawford was a
54:22
very successful dancer and actress in the early
54:24
20th century She was
54:27
under contract at MGM and then
54:29
later She
54:31
broke that contract and went to one of the other big
54:33
production movie houses. I forgot which one.
54:35
Mm-hmm She was married to the
54:38
president of Pepsi for a while and served
54:41
on its board of directors until 1973
54:44
when she was forcibly retired after her
54:46
husband died because she was a Real
54:50
for a woman and a woman. Yeah.
54:52
Yeah She had been married
54:54
and divorced three times before the
54:56
Pepsi guy. Mm-hmm and she had
54:58
five adopted children
55:02
The oldest of these children was a girl
55:04
who was adopted in June of 1940 This
55:07
is a this is taken from
55:10
Wikipedia quote the child was temporarily
55:12
called Joan I think
55:14
while she was being adopted, but then she was
55:16
adopted by Joan Crawford So we can't have that.
55:19
Yeah, so there can only be one. So
55:21
Joan Crawford changed the girl's name
55:23
to Christina Christina's
55:26
mother was a 19 year
55:28
old unmarried girl who had
55:30
moved who had moved to LA with
55:32
her family Christina's birth
55:34
mother Contracted
55:37
with a baby broker For
55:40
Joan Crawford to adopt her
55:42
after her birth.
55:44
There was something about She
55:47
had to go through some like weird
55:49
loopholes because you can't adopt a child
55:51
from LA if you live in LA
55:53
at the time For some reason or
55:55
something like that. So they had to
55:58
like go through some weird maybe not
56:00
super legal, a baby broker. While
56:03
married to Philip Terry, who was not the Pepsi
56:05
guy, it was a different guy, the couple
56:08
adopted a son whom they named Christopher,
56:10
but his birth mother learned that the child
56:13
had been adopted by a celebrity and attempted
56:16
to blackmail Joan Crawford for money,
56:18
which resulted in Crawford
56:20
giving the child back to
56:22
his birth mother, who in
56:24
turn placed him back for
56:26
adoption. Oh, these poor kids.
56:29
The couple adopted another boy who
56:31
they named Philip Terry Jr. and
56:35
then after their marriage ended in 1946, Crawford
56:37
changed that child's name to
56:39
Christopher. Stop. So
56:42
she didn't want this, technically
56:44
the third adopted child because the second
56:46
one, she returned.
56:50
Wow. She didn't
56:52
want that boy to have her
56:54
ex-husband's name, so she changed that
56:56
child's name like into his
56:59
life. These kids. So that's Christopher.
57:01
Poor fucking kids. Who's the other
57:04
boy in the movie. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
57:07
So Joan dies on May 10, 1977 from a heart attack and
57:09
in 1978, the next year, Tina publishes a
57:16
memoir depicting her mother as a, quote,
57:18
cruel, unbalanced alcoholic mother
57:21
with Crawford's other twin daughters, all
57:25
of their household staff and
57:27
their family friends denouncing Christina's
57:29
book as sensationalized fiction. So
57:33
nobody else is backing her on her
57:35
claims that she makes in this book.
57:38
Not even Christopher? Mm-hmm. Christopher
57:41
maybe. Mm-hmm. Actually,
57:44
yes, Christopher did side with
57:48
Christina and I'll get to that. But
57:50
the other two children
57:52
who were twins, because remember,
57:54
she adopted five kids, she returned one of
57:57
them. Jesus Christ, yeah. The oldest two are
57:59
Christina and Christopher and then there's
58:01
two girls who are younger. So again
58:03
more from Wikipedia.
58:06
In the book, Christina alleges that
58:08
Joan Crawford placed far more importance
58:10
on her cinematic career than her
58:12
family life and that Joan later
58:14
was an alcoholic in the 1960s.
58:17
She also claims that Joan had sexual
58:19
affairs with various men
58:22
whom Christina was required to call
58:24
uncle. Isn't that gross? I
58:27
hate that. Christina claimed that Joan's
58:29
controlling behavior continued throughout Christina's adulthood
58:32
asserting that Joan was jealous of
58:34
Christina's acting career in the 1960s
58:36
because Christina was on a soap
58:39
opera. Yeah like a pretty
58:41
prominent one I think. It's called the
58:43
Secret Storm. Mm-hmm. And so
58:46
Joan was jealous to the point
58:48
of taking over Christina's role in
58:50
the Secret Storm while Christina was
58:52
in the hospital recovering from an
58:54
operation to remove an ovarian cyst.
58:57
That part of the movie is wild.
58:59
I know. It's wild. I
59:02
mean holy shit. I'm
59:05
definitely, I tried to be
59:07
a reasonable person and I
59:10
believe Christina
59:15
and, not but, and the truth
59:18
always lies somewhere in the middle.
59:20
This was an expression of Christina's
59:23
experience which comes
59:25
with how her memory
59:27
or her processing has been affected
59:30
by the trauma of her childhood.
59:33
And so it may not have
59:35
looked to other people in the household
59:37
the exact same way that it looked
59:39
and felt to Christina but that doesn't
59:41
invalidate her experience. That's how I feel
59:43
about it. There are also some
59:46
parts of the movie that were not in the
59:48
book and were never claimed to have happened by
59:52
Christina. They sensationalized some stuff for the movie for
59:54
sure. So like the chopping down of the
59:57
rose bush at the tree. I
59:59
did. In my house, we
1:00:02
had these hideous shrubs and I could not
1:00:04
fucking look at them anymore and I got
1:00:06
like an ADHD manic episode at like 11.30pm
1:00:09
and put on a headlamp and just went
1:00:12
outside and started digging these hideous shrubs out
1:00:14
of my front yard. Yup.
1:00:18
Your current house? Yeah. Oh my
1:00:20
god. They needed to fucking go. And
1:00:22
you know, when I get the desire
1:00:24
to do something, if I don't capitalize on
1:00:26
it then I may never get that motivation
1:00:28
again. So of course not. I fucking rolled
1:00:30
with it. But it was unhinged and
1:00:33
we were the new neighbors with the
1:00:35
headlamp holding the plants out in the
1:00:38
shroud of darkness of night. You're so
1:00:40
creepy. I love that. Yeah, I know.
1:00:43
Also the infamous wire hanger scene. Not
1:00:46
in the book. It wasn't in the book and
1:00:48
it never, it didn't happen. So
1:00:52
the book culminates with
1:00:54
Christina learning that she
1:00:56
and her brother Christopher
1:00:58
were intentionally disinherited upon
1:01:01
the death of their mother for quote
1:01:03
reasons known to them. So
1:01:06
basically she cut them out of her will right
1:01:08
before she died. Possibly
1:01:10
because she knew that Christina was writing this book. Also
1:01:14
possibly just because a lot of
1:01:16
those allegations might have been true. It could have
1:01:18
been true. Yeah, exactly. She's a
1:01:20
horrible person. Yeah. So
1:01:24
yeah, we may never know. But
1:01:27
again, if you've never seen mommy
1:01:29
dearest, please do yourself a favor.
1:01:32
Yeah. And you know,
1:01:34
Joan Crawford and whatever abuse
1:01:36
she is alleged to have
1:01:39
inflicted on her adopted children was like
1:01:41
not created in a vacuum. She's also
1:01:43
a product of a lot of trauma and
1:01:46
a lot of fucked up shit both in
1:01:48
and outside of Hollywood. And
1:01:52
so being an adopted child by
1:01:54
itself can have a lot of challenges.
1:01:57
And trauma. Yeah. So and I
1:01:59
think that the this was just not
1:02:01
just but that there's
1:02:03
obvious generational
1:02:05
cycles perpetuated here
1:02:08
on unwilling and
1:02:10
unsuspecting children that were adopted into
1:02:12
her home. I didn't know about
1:02:15
the second adoption and that
1:02:17
boy essentially being used as
1:02:19
blackmail by his birth mother
1:02:21
and then adopted
1:02:23
out again. Yeah. I
1:02:26
mean, that's fucking horrifying, horrifying.
1:02:29
And then that second boy getting his
1:02:31
name changed because she hated
1:02:33
her ex husband. I don't know. The whole thing
1:02:35
is very messy, very
1:02:37
fucking messy. So messy, good,
1:02:40
classic examples of mommy issues
1:02:42
there and extreme
1:02:45
examples. Yeah. I'm glad that you
1:02:47
and I got to dig into
1:02:50
our own, our own upbringing
1:02:53
a little bit. Oh, I
1:02:55
have absolutely loved this. So
1:02:57
thank you so much. Thank
1:03:00
you. That was pretty fun.
1:03:02
And my case is
1:03:06
horrifying. So well
1:03:11
let's get to it. I would
1:03:13
recommend bracing yourselves during
1:03:16
our quick break and
1:03:18
coming back ready for
1:03:21
more traumatic. Let's
1:03:25
do it. I'm totally ready
1:03:27
and prepared. You're not y'all.
1:03:30
It's 2024. We are done
1:03:33
with uncomfortable undergarments and uncomfortable
1:03:35
shapewear. We're not doing anymore.
1:03:37
So support suit we did
1:03:39
there for today's episode comes
1:03:41
from honey love. And
1:03:43
like no matter what you're going for
1:03:45
honey love is to go
1:03:48
to for all things shapewear and
1:03:50
undergarments honey love has revolutionized compression
1:03:52
technology so you no longer have
1:03:54
to feel like you're suffocating while
1:03:56
wearing shapewear plus they won't
1:03:58
ever roll down. These are
1:04:00
my summer go-to for under skirts and dresses,
1:04:02
especially when I'm on my scooter. It
1:04:05
protects me from chafing. It keeps me
1:04:07
feeling covered, you know? And no matter
1:04:10
how much you groove on the dance
1:04:12
floor or scoot on your vessa, that's
1:04:14
not gonna roll down. Honeylove Shapewear features
1:04:16
lingerie-inspired design details that you'll want to
1:04:18
show off and is made with breathable
1:04:21
fabric. Hello, summer protection in breathable fabric.
1:04:23
Get out of here. That keeps you
1:04:25
nice and cool. For a limited time
1:04:27
only, you can get Honeylove on sale.
1:04:29
Get 20% off your entire
1:04:32
order with our exclusive link,
1:04:34
honeylove.com forward slash wine. So support our
1:04:37
show and check them out at honeylove.com/wine.
1:04:39
Tell us more, Lucy. Yeah.
1:04:41
Oh, so Honeylove is mostly
1:04:43
known for like shapewear, but
1:04:46
all of their things I
1:04:48
am hooked on because of just how smoothing
1:04:51
everything is. Oh, their bras are
1:04:53
so comfortable too. Their bras are insanely
1:04:55
comfortable and like, I don't know, I
1:04:57
got, I got a very unique to
1:05:01
these. So, you do. They're very
1:05:03
unique. They're gorgeous. And the smooth,
1:05:05
the cup, one of my cups
1:05:08
may, may overflow with sometimes or
1:05:10
maybe the other one, there's like
1:05:12
a gap. And with Honeylove,
1:05:14
this is one of the only bras
1:05:16
that I have that you can't tell.
1:05:19
Like it's just, it's so smoothing. Like
1:05:21
Amanda said, this lingerie inspired fabric. It's
1:05:24
just gorgeous. And I do have to
1:05:27
talk about their best selling shapewear,
1:05:29
which is their super power short.
1:05:32
Love those. Yeah. So it has
1:05:34
targeted compression technology that distinguishes between
1:05:36
areas where you want a little
1:05:38
more support will suit up and
1:05:41
areas you need, like less compression,
1:05:43
like just let your beautiful curves shine,
1:05:45
you know, their signature X targets and
1:05:47
sculpts your midsection without squeezing those natural
1:05:49
curves is designed to work with your
1:05:51
body, not against it. So it's not
1:05:54
like, you know, take a deep
1:05:56
breath, but you need two friends to like, right, put
1:05:58
it on and then shove you in. heal it
1:06:00
off at the end of the night. No,
1:06:03
it fits so well, especially considering the
1:06:05
fact that it doesn't roll down, which
1:06:07
is absolutely unheard of in shapewear. So
1:06:10
it's got flexible boning that's hidden in
1:06:12
the side seam. It
1:06:15
just feels like it's like molded
1:06:18
to your body in the best way. And
1:06:21
this piece also has like a
1:06:23
booty lifting technology. I love the
1:06:25
booty lifter. You know I have a lot of
1:06:27
booty. This stuff makes my booty look BBL
1:06:30
baby. It looks fantastic. So they got
1:06:33
these boost bands on the back of
1:06:35
the thigh, which gives your bum incredible
1:06:38
shape. It's like a
1:06:41
bra for your butt. It kind of is.
1:06:43
And the last thing I'm gonna praise about
1:06:45
how to love cause there's so much, but
1:06:47
like in the middle of a party and
1:06:49
you gotta go to the bathroom. Yeah. Don't
1:06:52
worry about it because their
1:06:54
power short has a 100% cotton gusset. So
1:06:57
you can just, you know,
1:06:59
do your thing without taking the whole thing off.
1:07:02
But it's convenient opening in that area
1:07:04
for a very easy quick bathroom trip.
1:07:06
It's not gonna take you 15 minutes
1:07:09
to get in and out of this stuff. Yep. So
1:07:12
with a line full of angry people tapping their feet
1:07:14
at you. So no matter what your event
1:07:17
is or even if you're just scooting around
1:07:19
town or wanna look real cute, Honey
1:07:21
Love is the perfect plus one. Treat
1:07:24
yourself to the best bra and shapewear
1:07:26
on the market and save 20% off
1:07:28
at honeylove.com/wine. Use our exclusive links to
1:07:30
get 20% off honeylove.com/wine. And after you
1:07:33
purchase, they'll ask you where you heard
1:07:35
about them. So please support our show
1:07:37
and tell them we sent you shape
1:07:39
your life with Honey Love and treat
1:07:41
your undergarments. Try it out. So
1:07:44
last summer I went to the arts festival which
1:07:46
is like my favorite weekend of
1:07:48
the year here in Des Moines. And
1:07:51
I got this, the coolest
1:07:54
print. It was made by
1:07:56
this like old Japanese technique where
1:07:58
they like paint and. actual fish
1:08:00
and then put like a fabric down on
1:08:02
it so it's like a fish stamp. Oh
1:08:05
cool! It's so gorgeous and like
1:08:07
the fabric that it's on is just so
1:08:10
detailed and I fell in love
1:08:12
with it but I was like man I
1:08:14
want to get this framed in like the
1:08:16
best way that I can still see all of
1:08:19
those details immediately
1:08:21
without hesitation. I thought of
1:08:23
Framebridge. I sent it in with their secure packaging
1:08:26
that I like trust with my child. Yeah.
1:08:29
Just pack Junie right up in there. Yeah.
1:08:32
I went through all of their beautiful frame options.
1:08:34
I chose like a really good one that looked
1:08:37
kind of like retro Japanese-y sort of. So like
1:08:39
bits of style. Got it
1:08:41
back so fast and it is one of my favorite
1:08:43
things I have hanging in my house. Framebridge
1:08:47
is literally the best.
1:08:50
I love it so much and it's
1:08:52
so easy. So you can just order
1:08:55
online at framebridge.com or you can visit
1:08:57
a Framebridge retail store. They make it
1:09:00
so easy especially the online process. You upload
1:09:02
a digital photo for them to print and
1:09:04
then you can also mail
1:09:06
an item like Lucy did using
1:09:08
their free secure prepaid packaging or you
1:09:10
could take that item or I think even
1:09:13
do the digital stuff in one of their 20
1:09:15
plus retail stores. It's on my bucket list. Go
1:09:17
to a Framebridge store and then Framebridge
1:09:19
custom frames your piece in their studio using
1:09:21
the highest quality materials and ships it to
1:09:23
your door in days for free like ready
1:09:26
to hang all you need is a hammer and a
1:09:28
wall baby. It's so easy
1:09:30
and affordable to custom frame just about
1:09:33
anything. The pricing is so
1:09:35
fair and transparent and upfront.
1:09:39
Simply on the size of your items by the
1:09:41
time you're approaching checkout like you know what it's
1:09:43
going to cost you which I really appreciate.
1:09:46
There is a beautifully curated selection
1:09:48
of frame styles with design experts
1:09:50
on hand who make it fun to
1:09:52
choose the perfect frame. I have so
1:09:55
much option overwhelm as an ADHD
1:09:57
girlie in a good way. In a
1:09:59
great way. love working with the designers to
1:10:01
be like, this is kind of the vibe I'm
1:10:03
going for. And then they make recommendations on what
1:10:05
frames would fit that aesthetic. And I just think
1:10:08
it's so nice and helpful. The service is so
1:10:10
fast, the shipping is free. And this is phenomenal
1:10:13
for gifts, but also like get
1:10:15
it for yourself because create yourself.
1:10:18
And they have a happiness guarantee. If you're not 100%
1:10:20
happy with your piece, they will make it right. Their
1:10:23
customer service is truly
1:10:25
phenomenal. We love Framebridge.
1:10:27
See why Framebridge has been
1:10:29
trusted to fame over two
1:10:31
million pieces. Visit framebridge.com or
1:10:33
a local Framebridge store to
1:10:36
get started and custom frame
1:10:38
just about anything. That's framebridge.com
1:10:40
and treat your walls. Shout
1:10:43
out to Claritin for supporting this episode and
1:10:45
providing us with samples. Y'all, I don't know
1:10:47
how many of you listeners are in the
1:10:49
Midwest, but like at least in the United
1:10:51
States, it's spring
1:10:53
allergy season. Yeah. And
1:10:57
while I have gotten like pretty accustomed
1:10:59
to the allergies that are normal
1:11:01
for me here in Minnesota, I
1:11:04
always get new spring allergies, especially
1:11:06
when I travel. Yeah, it
1:11:09
is so annoying.
1:11:12
It's like suddenly it's
1:11:15
just put a your allergies have just put
1:11:17
a damper on your whole experience. And then
1:11:19
you're like, wait, am I sick? Are these
1:11:22
my allergies? Why is my nose so soft? Why
1:11:24
are my eyes so red? Why can't I enjoy
1:11:26
my dinner because I can't taste the food
1:11:28
that I have saved up to go try
1:11:31
at this amazing restaurant? It's not fire. It's
1:11:34
not. It's really not fun.
1:11:36
So honestly, I use Claritin
1:11:38
D and you should too if you
1:11:40
are an allergy sufferer because luckily for those
1:11:42
of us who live with the
1:11:44
symptoms of allergies, we can
1:11:46
literally live Claritin clear with
1:11:48
Claritin D. I love having
1:11:50
this in my medicine bag.
1:11:52
Yeah. So this double action
1:11:54
combination of prescription strength allergy
1:11:57
medicine and the best decongestant
1:11:59
available relief sneezing, a runny
1:12:01
nose, itchy watery eyes, an
1:12:03
itchy nose and throat, and sinus
1:12:05
congestion and pressure with ease.
1:12:08
Truly. Some things I love about Claritin
1:12:10
D as well is their fast symptom
1:12:12
relief starts working on allergies with nasal
1:12:14
congestion in as little as 30 minutes. So if
1:12:17
I've like landed somewhere new and I start to
1:12:19
notice like, uh oh, I'm allergic
1:12:21
to something on your plants here people. I could
1:12:23
pop that and I'm going to start getting relief
1:12:25
in about half an hour. And
1:12:28
you can get non-drowsy relief
1:12:30
of allergy symptoms, especially good when you're traveling
1:12:32
and you want to experience a new place
1:12:34
with Claritin D, you can still make the
1:12:36
most of your day without compromise. So if
1:12:38
you are ready to live life as
1:12:41
if you don't have allergies, it's
1:12:43
time to live Claritin Clear. Fast
1:12:45
and powerful relief is just a quick trip away.
1:12:47
Find Claritin D at the pharmacy counter.
1:12:50
Ask for Claritin D at your local
1:12:52
pharmacy counter. You don't even need a
1:12:54
prescription. Go to claritin.com right now for
1:12:56
a discount so you can live Claritin Clear
1:12:59
and use as directed. Okay,
1:13:01
so this is
1:13:04
a brutal and heartbreaking story.
1:13:06
Okay. I know that
1:13:08
many folks have heard this. It's
1:13:10
quite famous specifically because of
1:13:13
a viral photo that we will get to. But
1:13:17
you know, in the event you're listening and you
1:13:19
have not heard this story and possibly
1:13:21
have seen the photo but don't know the
1:13:23
truth behind it, we'll break
1:13:25
it down. I don't know what you're getting
1:13:27
at. When you see
1:13:30
the photo, you'll know exactly what I'm talking
1:13:32
about. So I'm just going to dive in here. Married
1:13:35
couple Jennifer Jean Hart and
1:13:37
Sarah Margaret Hart. Sarah's maiden
1:13:39
name is Gangler, but they
1:13:41
end up married. So Gangler. Gangler
1:13:44
began their relationship at Northern
1:13:46
State University while both majoring
1:13:48
in elementary education. This
1:13:51
is in North Dakota. When they
1:13:53
read this. Well, they
1:13:55
were together but not married yet.
1:13:57
They met at college in the early.
1:14:00
Sarah graduated in 2002. Jen left school without
1:14:02
graduating. Okay. Jen
1:14:05
was the bigger personality of the two
1:14:07
women. She was confident, funny, a bit
1:14:09
in your face. Jen
1:14:12
is the Amanda if we were
1:14:14
tagging ourselves, but we shouldn't because...
1:14:16
She's the anxious, insecure attachment,
1:14:18
whatever it was. These women
1:14:21
did unspeakable things, so we shouldn't be tagging
1:14:23
ourselves. But if I were tagging myself, I'd
1:14:25
be the Jen. Okay. And the other one?
1:14:28
Yup. Sarah was more sensitive. She'd
1:14:30
be nearly in tears during high-pressure
1:14:33
days when they'd count inventory at
1:14:35
work. And I literally wrote
1:14:37
the Lucy, but we still
1:14:39
definitely are not tagging ourselves.
1:14:41
Yeah. Oh, yeah. I've cried
1:14:43
doing inventory before. Who hasn't?
1:14:45
Inventory is a nightmare. It really
1:14:47
is. It's awful. It's awful.
1:14:49
Go in this dark room and count shit, and
1:14:52
if you get it off or get it wrong,
1:14:54
you have to start over again. Watch
1:14:57
me into the sun.
1:14:59
Anyway, okay. In
1:15:01
2004, the couple moved to Alexandria,
1:15:04
Minnesota, and both took jobs at
1:15:06
the now-defunct Herberger's department store. I
1:15:08
remember Herberger's. I do too. Good
1:15:11
shit. Their move to
1:15:13
Minnesota brought freedom to their relationship. They
1:15:15
had been closeted in South Dakota, calling
1:15:17
each other friends or roommates, but
1:15:19
they felt safe to come out and be open about the
1:15:22
nature of their relationship in Minnesota. But we're not allowed
1:15:24
to like them. No.
1:15:27
Okay. And these are like gays
1:15:29
on the surface that you would really
1:15:31
want to like based on their presence
1:15:33
online, and they posture—we'll get
1:15:35
to it—but they posture themselves as like
1:15:38
woke white women who like
1:15:40
to love Bernie Sanders and cared
1:15:42
about the environment. And it
1:15:44
was— I just wanted to
1:15:47
cheer for them getting to live their
1:15:49
lives openly now in Minnesota. Sure, that's
1:15:51
great. And they also are
1:15:54
not good people. Okay. Because
1:15:56
monsters come in every Gender.
1:16:00
The gender of the
1:16:02
Fowler: Political Affiliation: Religious
1:16:04
affiliation. There's always. Both.
1:16:06
Sides of the burning of I had. A. Thousand
1:16:08
percent of thousand percent it's There's
1:16:10
lots of like one set of
1:16:12
criteria. That can make people do
1:16:15
heinous shit. Same sex marriage
1:16:17
was still not legal in the state. Of Minnesota
1:16:19
in two thousand and four. Ah. At
1:16:22
that time, but they committed to each other
1:16:24
and started making plans to expand their family
1:16:26
in the summer of Two Thousand Four, they
1:16:28
temporarily fostered. A fifteen year old girl will
1:16:30
panic. Get back to her a little later.
1:16:33
Oh My. God. I know A Cases. Yeah.
1:16:37
This was a on the surface,
1:16:39
a joyful and exciting experience for
1:16:41
them. And solidified that they
1:16:44
wanted. To adopt children. So
1:16:47
Thera continued working had Harbors while
1:16:49
Jan works miscellaneous odd jobs before
1:16:51
becoming a stay at home mom
1:16:53
and two Thousand and Six and
1:16:55
preparation for the adoption of three
1:16:57
siblings and two thousand and six.
1:16:59
The children were named Marquees Hannah
1:17:01
and Abigail. Ah markets are. Marcus
1:17:03
I'm sorry Susie Marcus. In two
1:17:05
thousand and eight, they adopted three
1:17:07
more children also siblings divots age
1:17:09
Jeremiah. And Sierra. These. Are
1:17:12
all young black children ranging in age from
1:17:14
two to six. Years old at the time of
1:17:16
their adoption. And it is relevant
1:17:18
to. Acknowledge of the children that the
1:17:20
children were black and the adoptive mother's
1:17:22
white because racism is very much involved
1:17:24
in this case, Is. Also insidious
1:17:27
and. Ever presence and. Will
1:17:30
get the how it pertains here. So the
1:17:32
now family of. Eight move
1:17:34
to Woodland Washington. Where
1:17:36
Sarah takes a job as manager.
1:17:38
At the local polls. There's eight
1:17:40
of them because the child that they
1:17:42
were fostering was not adopted. By
1:17:45
them which will get to So they adopted six. Children.
1:17:47
As the two of them, the eight
1:17:49
of them moved to Woodland Washington. So
1:17:51
one of the siblings. Know.
1:17:54
That the first. Child: The sixteen
1:17:56
year old girl that they were a
1:17:58
loss rain with.a sibling? Okay, And.
1:18:00
They did not adopt her other. But.
1:18:02
They adopted two sets of siblings three
1:18:04
and three from two separate family that
1:18:06
it okay still devoted to becoming legally
1:18:08
married, but not able to do so
1:18:10
in Washington at that time. The entire
1:18:13
family traveled together to Connecticut for Sarah
1:18:15
and Jan to wed and two thousand
1:18:17
and nine at that point they have
1:18:19
been together for ten years. They then
1:18:21
returned home to Washington and life continues
1:18:23
on. But folks in their community. Started.
1:18:25
To notice some red flags in their parenting
1:18:28
style? According to a child welfare report
1:18:30
from Oregon, Jen is strange
1:18:32
yourself. From those who criticize or commented
1:18:34
on her parenting and Sarah followed suit.
1:18:37
Quote. Jen wouldn't have anything to do with
1:18:39
you if you disagreed with her said one relative.
1:18:41
But to get a clear picture of what exactly
1:18:43
these red flags were, we need to back up.
1:18:46
And start with their foster child. So.
1:18:49
Prior to adopting. The. Hearts
1:18:51
had fostered a fifteen year old girl in the
1:18:53
summer of two thousand for the foster that had
1:18:55
brought so much joy and confirmed they wanted to
1:18:58
adopt a family. Well, according to a
1:19:00
coworkers last friend. They. Immediately started
1:19:02
complaining about this child. A fifteen year
1:19:04
old foster child. Like things are not
1:19:06
going well for that kid. Ah, If.
1:19:09
You are in the system at all but
1:19:11
like. Imagine the trauma that
1:19:13
that poor child brought into their household
1:19:15
and these parents. Are foster
1:19:17
parents are just bitching about her?
1:19:19
Say things like quote sees the
1:19:21
worse. And. Saying that she would
1:19:23
eat food out of the garbage which is
1:19:26
something that this little girl who is our
1:19:28
a woman denied ever happening. She was still
1:19:30
being fostered by the Hearts when they were
1:19:32
planning to adopt the first set of siblings.
1:19:35
And. According to her, the hearts had told her
1:19:37
that they would foster her until she aged.
1:19:39
Out at eighteen. And. Showed her
1:19:42
pictures of the children they were planning on
1:19:44
adopting talking about how she would be a
1:19:46
big sister and she would need to said
1:19:48
a good example for them She and it
1:19:51
was not excited. Yeah it was very exciting
1:19:53
for this child who is looking forward to
1:19:55
having allies in her home and having family
1:19:57
in the form of siblings. And
1:20:00
a week before their first three children
1:20:02
were due to arrive, the heart dropped
1:20:04
this girl off at a therapist appointment
1:20:07
and never picked her up. Oh My.
1:20:09
God are they left her there! That
1:20:12
is. So. Cruel.
1:20:15
That. They had the therapists
1:20:17
tell her that. The. Hearts
1:20:19
would not be coming back for her and
1:20:21
when she was transferred to another foster home,
1:20:23
her belongings were already there, making clear that.
1:20:26
The. Hearts had planned this out and
1:20:28
just not told her oh my god
1:20:31
that is So Sox. It's so cruel.
1:20:33
It's so cruel. Oh My. God. She
1:20:36
would later tell the Seattle Times about
1:20:38
feeling abandoned and devastated. She had lived
1:20:40
with the hearts for less than a
1:20:42
year and was told that she'd be
1:20:44
saying and getting siblings and they that
1:20:47
within her last stop before she aged
1:20:49
out. Yep! This is this,
1:20:51
is fucking heartbreaking and bubbles. Up like
1:20:53
a rage in made I. Can't.
1:20:56
Put. Into words how. Some.
1:20:59
People just treat children like they're
1:21:02
disposable. And these are the most vulnerable.
1:21:04
Children among us and need to
1:21:06
be taken. It was so much
1:21:08
care and of competence. And
1:21:10
commitment and not be further victimized like
1:21:13
that. Yeah, and you dumped her out
1:21:15
a therapists office? And transferred up.
1:21:17
Sent Oliver sit to a new foster home. That's.
1:21:19
A little off all it is Macys a system.
1:21:22
I fucking some. It's. The.
1:21:24
First three siblings adopted were marked as
1:21:26
who is eight, Hannah who was for
1:21:28
and Abigail who was two and two
1:21:31
thousand six from Colorado County in Texas.
1:21:34
Their. Placement came on March four, two
1:21:36
thousand and Six and they were adopted
1:21:38
that same September. So September of Two
1:21:40
Thousand Six, they were legally adopted. The
1:21:43
second three siblings to be adopted were
1:21:45
Us Sierra, Jeremiah, and of Aontais. Sierra
1:21:47
was three. Jeremiah was for advance A
1:21:49
was six and they were from Houston,
1:21:52
Texas. So their biological mother, the biological
1:21:54
mother of the second set of siblings
1:21:56
had lost custody due to substance abuse
1:21:58
issues in August. The two Thousand Six. The.
1:22:01
Children were initially place with
1:22:03
their aunts, Priscilla Celeste, seen
1:22:05
under the condition that they
1:22:07
not have contact with their
1:22:09
biological mother, Priscilla. Loved. These.
1:22:12
Children. She Wanted. These children. She moved
1:22:14
into a five bedroom apartment in Houston
1:22:16
to accommodate them all. But
1:22:19
she was also. Taking on
1:22:21
the role of a single mother as she was. Had
1:22:23
to work full time to. Support.
1:22:26
These kids. As. You that a
1:22:28
desperate situation? And got called into work.
1:22:31
As she found herself in a
1:22:33
bind for childcare and have their
1:22:35
biological mother who was in recovery
1:22:37
and not using Come In and
1:22:39
Baber babysit. but this coincided with
1:22:41
a visit from a case worker.
1:22:43
It was just like totally random
1:22:45
that a caseworker showed. Up while the
1:22:47
biological mother was there. That. So
1:22:49
sad when shit like that happens and it's
1:22:52
like walking tragic. I. It and
1:22:54
so I understand and appreciate that there
1:22:56
are caseworkers involved and stuff like that,
1:22:58
but it's like she's as the wrong
1:23:00
place wrong time that really set it
1:23:03
really sucked set up in they've really
1:23:05
fuck shit up. And I
1:23:07
obviously it at that Children's
1:23:10
best interests will always be
1:23:12
is. Always needs to be
1:23:14
the priority. And I think
1:23:16
it can be argued that the children
1:23:19
having contact with their biological mother. Who
1:23:21
is actively in recovery and
1:23:24
working on you know, sweaty
1:23:26
never her substance use disorder.
1:23:29
Is. In the children's best interests
1:23:31
I think sometimes. The courts as
1:23:33
don't. Have the capacity for
1:23:35
nuance in these situations.
1:23:38
And now because. They
1:23:40
are biological mother came to baby
1:23:42
sit. For. A few hours.
1:23:45
And. Yelling knowing what we
1:23:47
know happens in this case
1:23:49
I'll is it's just sit.
1:23:51
It's fucking sad. It's a
1:23:54
fucking sad So. Because
1:23:56
of this visit. That. Shoulder
1:23:58
or removed from. Mccullough.
1:24:00
Scenes Care. And. This
1:24:03
prevented Priscilla so a scene from
1:24:05
obtaining permanent custody of the children.
1:24:07
They couldn't even be adopted. By.
1:24:10
A sable member of their family who
1:24:12
wanted them. And they
1:24:14
had been with her for only six months. And
1:24:17
then in another six months they would be
1:24:19
moved across the country to start living in
1:24:21
Minnesota with the hearts strangers white women. Would.
1:24:23
Have never met. Yeah Priscilla continue to
1:24:25
fight for the children for three and
1:24:28
a half years but with stymied at
1:24:30
every turn. She thought the help of
1:24:32
attorney Saw the Jones who after reviewing
1:24:34
and taking her case felt strongly that
1:24:36
racism in the foster system was playing
1:24:38
a role here. with the Powers that
1:24:40
be ultimately decided that to progressive white
1:24:42
mothers in Minnesota Us would give these
1:24:44
kids have better life than any of
1:24:46
their black family members. Quote. I
1:24:48
don't believe that Missile A Scene had ever
1:24:50
had as much as a traffic ticket. She
1:24:52
went to work, home, and church. She says.
1:24:55
The. Court seem to have had a complete
1:24:57
disregard for her. Sherry David, the children's
1:24:59
birth mother who had been cleaned from
1:25:02
her cocaine addiction for eight years said
1:25:04
quote there so quick to sas children
1:25:06
from people like us She said, but
1:25:08
once they're adopted, they don't even check
1:25:10
on the children and this case highlights
1:25:12
serious problems in the child welfare system
1:25:14
with the sammich racism playing a huge
1:25:16
role and lack of ongoing care playing
1:25:18
another. So posts in our system. Once
1:25:20
a child is adopted, we equate it
1:25:23
with success and there's very little follow
1:25:25
up. Said University. Of Michigan Law professor
1:25:27
of Civics on Peron who advocates
1:25:29
for children's rights. Quote. We
1:25:31
actually know very little about the
1:25:34
well of how kids from foster
1:25:36
care do after their adoptive. That
1:25:38
is to true. And. Release
1:25:40
Theory. So. Couple that
1:25:42
lack of follow up with like white
1:25:44
privilege and things that are bound to
1:25:47
fall through the cracks. And.
1:25:50
We. Get. Into a situation
1:25:52
like this. Quote for the
1:25:54
hearts: It seems likely that their
1:25:56
whiteness netted them multiple passes despite
1:25:58
all the warnings. Rob Michigan.
1:26:00
State University professor Cc Patton in The
1:26:03
Washington Post another an issue in this
1:26:05
case, And my god, there are so
1:26:07
many. Was. The agency that
1:26:09
shoulder were adopted through. Some
1:26:11
months after the adoptions are finalized,
1:26:13
september of two thousand and nine
1:26:15
a private adoption agency was has
1:26:17
called Permanent Family Resource Center located
1:26:19
Fergus Falls, Minnesota. With. Cited
1:26:21
for dozens of violations including failures
1:26:23
to conduct adequate Home studies in
1:26:26
September of two thousand and nine
1:26:28
the split the state put P
1:26:30
F R C is operating license
1:26:32
on the to your conditional status
1:26:34
and action. That quote indicates repeated
1:26:36
and serious violations of licensing. Sanders.
1:26:38
According to a spokeswoman for the Minnesota Department of Human.
1:26:40
Services. And then and twenty
1:26:43
twelve p Frc was shut down entirely.
1:26:45
For dozens more such violations.
1:26:47
Jesus and this is the agency
1:26:49
that the Heart family was working
1:26:51
with. So.
1:26:53
So much stuff just got overlooked. They
1:26:55
just didn't care now. If you
1:26:57
haven't already been thinking this, You
1:27:00
might be wondering how did this family afford six
1:27:02
children with Sarah being the only one with a
1:27:04
job. Working now and polls. As.
1:27:07
An assistant manager and. Or. In Iran forty five
1:27:09
grand a year while Jan was a stay
1:27:11
at home, parent allegedly home schooling the children.
1:27:14
Will Sarah and then appeared to bring
1:27:16
in as much as forty one thousand
1:27:18
additional dollars a year from various payments intended
1:27:20
for the children's. Well being through
1:27:22
various programs. The family received
1:27:24
two thousand dollars a month in
1:27:26
unspecified quote adoption assistance. Had.
1:27:28
Collected approximately two hundred and seventy
1:27:30
thousand dollars from the state of
1:27:32
Texas. And. To of the children yielded
1:27:35
about eleven thousand a year from the. Children's.
1:27:37
Quote stepfather who is still paying
1:27:39
child support so Texas allegedly early
1:27:41
said this time holds parents responsible
1:27:43
for children in foster care, but
1:27:45
it's unclear why these payments continued
1:27:48
after adoption. There. Seem to be
1:27:50
endless systemic missteps in this case that.
1:27:52
Just a loud. The.
1:27:54
Hearts to continue. Not only.
1:27:57
Profiting. Off of the children it seemed.
1:28:00
It seems very clear to me. That.
1:28:03
The money was an incentive
1:28:05
and they continuously sought. Adoption.
1:28:08
Through this sketchy agency
1:28:10
in Minnesota that with
1:28:12
source children essentially through
1:28:15
Texas has had these
1:28:17
lucrative kickbacks. That. Is
1:28:19
so creepy. Like I underlined why
1:28:21
there are incentives to foster and
1:28:23
adopt a dead horse of cares
1:28:25
that support is is necessary. But
1:28:27
ah, there are a lot a
1:28:30
lot of people who just use
1:28:32
it as like of Saucer Farm.
1:28:34
Will. right? And it's just
1:28:36
another points of. Frustration
1:28:39
and anger that
1:28:41
we have this
1:28:43
trope created. About the
1:28:45
quote: unquote Welfare Queen. About
1:28:48
specifically black and brown people
1:28:51
abusing state and federal support
1:28:53
systems and cheating the system.
1:28:55
While the hearts to what
1:28:57
you know affluent nice white
1:28:59
ladies are fucking doing this
1:29:01
in a really damaging way.
1:29:03
Yeah, right under the noses
1:29:06
of all of these systems
1:29:08
and no one even fast
1:29:10
and I about it it
1:29:12
says that the that this
1:29:14
disparity is. So obvious
1:29:16
in this case. And highlights
1:29:19
so many issues. It's
1:29:21
hard to a fuckin' clock all of them and
1:29:23
I know that I will miss them because. I'm.
1:29:27
Also. A white woman. But it's it's
1:29:29
like it's important to look at this shit.
1:29:31
Most families who adopt children how to foster
1:29:33
care from Texas get monthly payments that ranged
1:29:36
from four hundred five hundred, Forty five dollars
1:29:38
per child to help cover care costs until
1:29:40
the tell turns eighteen, which is likely why
1:29:42
all six or a doctor from. Texas. They
1:29:44
weren't exactly raking in cash from these
1:29:47
adoptions, but the hearts did have debts
1:29:49
and some financial troubles and these financial
1:29:51
incentive kept. Them afloat so.
1:29:54
The systemic red flags have been glaring.
1:29:56
But. Alongside all this
1:29:58
so worthy per. Red flags
1:30:00
with the hearts specifically Jen. In
1:30:03
a two thousand C was like be obsessed
1:30:05
with social media and a two thousand six
1:30:07
am. and that. The Ass. and
1:30:09
yeah, and it's you. The other
1:30:11
six Facebook posts. Jan dramatically described
1:30:13
her first night as a mother
1:30:16
of three. Saying. Abigail urinated
1:30:18
everywhere and gas search and
1:30:20
falling down the stairs. Hannah
1:30:22
smeared feces on the walls
1:30:24
and gorge yourself with food
1:30:26
until she needed the heimlich,
1:30:28
resulting in episodes of projectile
1:30:30
vomiting. Market. She said hit
1:30:32
his head on a closet wall and
1:30:35
in multiple voices claim to be possessed
1:30:37
by demons. Yes, see and Sarah, We're
1:30:39
committed to healing the kids over time.
1:30:42
Quote: if not us who she wow
1:30:44
my god over the years and we
1:30:46
have no way of knowing if fucking
1:30:49
any of that happens like sure. Maybe
1:30:51
they had a rough night the first
1:30:53
like not burn and and your first
1:30:55
night as a mother. Of. Six.
1:30:59
Yeah. He. To.
1:31:01
How easy to do. Think
1:31:03
it was gonna be right,
1:31:05
but like it's pretty well
1:31:07
understood that see fabricated. A lot
1:31:10
of sit on Facebook to pay to
1:31:12
a very specific. Picture.
1:31:14
Of a white savior couple who
1:31:16
had taken in these black children.
1:31:19
If and they were so
1:31:21
rumbles. Yup. And. Their.
1:31:23
Overcoming and ceiling them it's at I
1:31:26
want to fuck unwra my hero. It's
1:31:28
so gross. Over the
1:31:30
years, Jen and cultivated a
1:31:32
carefully curated social media presence
1:31:34
that portrayed her family as
1:31:36
socially conscious and most importantly,
1:31:38
Happy and healthy. quote a
1:31:40
try. But yeah, that wouldn't
1:31:42
be broken apart by an
1:31:44
uncaring world filled with prejudice.
1:31:47
Her. Social media posts were filled with
1:31:49
photos and videos of the family on
1:31:51
cross country adventures and at the various
1:31:53
festivals they attended as a cohesive unit.
1:31:56
One. Person referred to as and
1:31:58
hard as it yeah they like
1:32:01
took them the music festivals and
1:32:03
chef.parading around here legally older and
1:32:05
literally that's what these women are.
1:32:08
Do I hate it, is sick,
1:32:10
It's a city, is fucking racism.
1:32:13
Just the sort of or commodities to
1:32:15
them. One person referred to Jenn Heart
1:32:17
as a cult master poster her long
1:32:20
all mind diatribes filled with her thoughts
1:32:22
and feelings about raising a happy family
1:32:24
and the challenges of modern day society.
1:32:26
So now we've arrived at the famous.
1:32:28
Photo that I referred to at the top of the case as
1:32:30
in the is on the drives and I believe it will be
1:32:33
on the blog. And Twenty fourteen during
1:32:35
the protests in Portland. from the
1:32:37
Ferguson decision, which was following a
1:32:39
grand jury's decision, not. To indict the
1:32:41
white officer who killed Michael Brown and unarmed.
1:32:43
Black Man and Ferguson Missouri This
1:32:46
photo were. A. Photo of
1:32:48
the volunteers and twelve. Years old hogging
1:32:50
a white pop went viral and was labeled.
1:32:52
The hog felt around the world in
1:32:54
the photo advance. A is crying and
1:32:56
everyone assumed it was because of the
1:32:58
emotion of the protests and the impact
1:33:01
of this hug. And in
1:33:03
reality he was crying because. His
1:33:05
adoptive mother forced him to take
1:33:08
the photo against his will. He
1:33:10
didn't wanna do it. So.
1:33:12
That she could use per black children
1:33:14
for social media cloud. but she got
1:33:17
more than she bargained for. And
1:33:19
the children had our had are already being
1:33:21
abused at this point, so like that's already
1:33:23
going on behind the fucking scenes. Then she forces
1:33:25
him to take this. Photo and it's like. Imagine
1:33:28
that child. Who's.
1:33:31
In. Forced to embrace
1:33:33
someone that in a perfect. World.
1:33:36
He could tell what's happening.
1:33:39
And they could help him. Knowing.
1:33:42
Because. There had already been visits
1:33:44
and reports that. Came. To
1:33:46
nothing knowing that even if
1:33:48
he did, Try. To get
1:33:50
help from that officer in that moment, he
1:33:52
wouldn't fuck and done anything any didn't want
1:33:54
to take the fucking photo anyway. and the
1:33:56
context of just As Ferguson Riots and all
1:33:59
of that. Child and old enough
1:34:01
to know what the fuck is
1:34:03
going on. For. Us: It's
1:34:05
it's it's. The. Sell side.
1:34:07
My like, don't have, I don't have words for it.
1:34:09
It's horrifying. So Jen got more
1:34:12
than she bargained for Jen. She
1:34:14
had this like inner conflict with.
1:34:16
Wanting. To posts all the time but not wanted
1:34:18
to get too much attention so she didn't actually
1:34:20
likes the attention that this photo brought to her
1:34:22
family. And my theory is she. Doesn't want some
1:34:25
of eyes on her that the cracks will
1:34:27
show and the abuse of the children will
1:34:29
be revealed. Idea that's why had one all
1:34:31
the attention. Else would it be once
1:34:33
she wants to keep that social
1:34:35
media presence right on that line
1:34:37
so they can maintain the facade
1:34:39
without having too many people looking
1:34:41
at the family. Wow. So.
1:34:43
After this, he actually went on a social media
1:34:45
hiatus for about six months, and this prompted their.
1:34:48
Move from Minnesota to Washington. To
1:34:50
they were like to well known around here
1:34:52
in their community. After that photo the social
1:34:55
media shit so fucking cringe at service level
1:34:57
on it's own. But like knowing the abuse
1:34:59
of these shows were suffering behind closed doors
1:35:01
makes it that much slicker. There was. Like
1:35:04
I said before, there was a very strange
1:35:06
juxtaposition. Were. Jan. Seem to crave the
1:35:08
attention perhaps due to social media as
1:35:10
ability to curated to say exactly what.
1:35:12
She wanted and and put out this
1:35:15
image of her family mix with a
1:35:17
dislike of the spotlight. Like I said
1:35:19
breaths due to the public scrutiny. Tearing.
1:35:21
Apart. Social. Media lies.
1:35:24
As she kept putting them in the spotlight.
1:35:26
Like sickly. A house that
1:35:29
student fucking and they they possess holder
1:35:31
so much in the six black children.
1:35:33
And then I mean the third Sas
1:35:36
with maintaining this image of like white
1:35:38
Savior as a yeah, these white savior
1:35:40
isn't it. It
1:35:42
has taken over. Their
1:35:45
entire fucking. Life.
1:35:47
So they they appeared in the hugged
1:35:49
around the world they are in like
1:35:51
music, festival, photography there and local newspapers.
1:35:54
They were in the background of Bernie
1:35:56
Sanders speech when the bird. Sat.
1:35:59
On the pie. Yeah.
1:36:01
Oh My. God. A and the other all
1:36:03
in their Bernie t shirts and like he's
1:36:05
meeting them. And one of the photos. Oh
1:36:08
My. God. And he obviously had no
1:36:10
fucking idea for yeah, You
1:36:12
know, but like that this was the
1:36:14
image that they were putting out there.
1:36:16
All that blameless says little hair. Yeah
1:36:19
also Jen was one of
1:36:21
those fucking annoying online vegetarian
1:36:23
proselytizer that like would share
1:36:25
anecdotes about the families vegetarian.
1:36:27
Lifestyle online that yourself got
1:36:30
in there. Were right, it's like
1:36:32
you do you. But. I don't
1:36:34
don't force me to for to read about
1:36:36
it but in their woodland home. Ah so
1:36:38
like. Investigators had found
1:36:40
this after the fact. chicken Beef
1:36:42
pork filled a bunch of the
1:36:45
families for his. Part. County
1:36:47
investigators found the families. Fridge. Stocked with
1:36:49
hot dogs, ham, Large packs a ticket
1:36:51
breath. large roles of ground beef like
1:36:53
the freezer. had corn dogs frozen to
1:36:56
lobby a pizza sacral all the good
1:36:58
shit yell good shit. This is like
1:37:00
I know that this doesn't fucking matter
1:37:02
but it's just. One more layer of
1:37:04
house full of fucking shit. These women
1:37:06
were. Yeah. Like. You couldn't
1:37:08
believe that god damn word they said. Anzus.
1:37:11
The image that they're trying so hard
1:37:14
to put out there. Is
1:37:16
devastatingly predictable, Everything
1:37:19
she was posting with utter bullshit
1:37:21
including this gag inducing posts from
1:37:23
May Twenty thirteen. When the family relocated
1:37:25
from Washington to Oregon, And
1:37:27
see posted an announcement saying traded
1:37:29
in the television for the best
1:37:31
big screen available planet Earth. Ah,
1:37:35
Don't. Suck my
1:37:37
but. I know, but they had multiple Tv
1:37:39
that were recovered from their home so it's like
1:37:41
okay this. Whatever. I.
1:37:44
Is insufferable I can. She also wrote
1:37:47
more than once about the abuse of
1:37:49
world. That are children had left behind.
1:37:51
She. Described avant his birth. In early
1:37:54
childhood and twenty twelve. Same quote.
1:37:56
Born into a world of drug
1:37:58
pumping through his newly born. body,
1:38:00
weapons, and extreme poverty, one
1:38:02
would assume his future was
1:38:05
bleak. By the time
1:38:07
he was four, he had smoked,
1:38:09
consumed alcohol, handled guns, been shot
1:38:11
at, and suffered severe abuse and
1:38:13
neglect." Devontae's birth
1:38:15
family has since come forward and
1:38:18
denied all of these allegations. She
1:38:20
probably doesn't know jack shit about
1:38:22
what this- No! She fucking made it up!
1:38:25
Yes. She made it up! Attorney
1:38:28
Shonda Jones, again, who represented
1:38:30
their aunt Priscilla, said Hart's
1:38:32
account was completely false. False.
1:38:34
Quote, those are all lies that did
1:38:37
not happen. Devontae was not born on
1:38:39
drugs. I've never heard anything about him
1:38:41
being shot at or anything like that.
1:38:43
The adoptive mother fed a lie to
1:38:46
the public. She fed into a stereotype
1:38:48
that reinforced other people's racism. Yeah. Actually,
1:38:51
when you were reading her post, I was
1:38:53
thinking of that Elvis Presley song. In
1:38:55
the ghetto. Mm-hmm. It's a
1:38:57
beautiful song. Race is fucking shit. But the
1:38:59
lyrics are so gross. So fucking
1:39:01
racist! Yeah. Which, like, we've
1:39:04
talked about Elvis. I don't need to
1:39:06
read this Elvis. Many of
1:39:08
her posts touched on race, politics, and trips
1:39:11
that the family went on. Many felt that
1:39:13
the children were forced to perform for the
1:39:15
camera and had questions about what was happening
1:39:17
behind the scenes. One allegation
1:39:19
of child abuse from 2013 touched upon
1:39:21
Jennifer's use of Facebook, saying that,
1:39:24
quote, the kids pose and are
1:39:26
made to look like one big happy family. But
1:39:28
after the photo event, they go back to looking
1:39:30
lifeless. No. Which is so
1:39:33
awful. Lifeless. I mean, imagine
1:39:35
seeing that play out in a public space or
1:39:37
in any space. Yeah. Those kids
1:39:40
know. They know they're being
1:39:42
used as props. They absolutely knew. And that
1:39:45
compounds and is part of the abuse. Yeah.
1:39:47
Oh, yeah. Another person who
1:39:49
knew the family reported that Jennifer Hart liked
1:39:51
to, quote, parade the children around at music
1:39:54
festivals and staged them for photographs, but then
1:39:56
gave them little attention otherwise. Sarah
1:39:58
Hart also was described. In the document as
1:40:01
being quote very cold to the children. One.
1:40:03
Coworker of Sarah's told deputies that she
1:40:05
caused spoke very fondly of Jennifer by
1:40:08
another calls employee. Recalled how Sarah said
1:40:10
that the hard shoulder and her wife
1:40:12
emotional stress. And. That Jennifer Hussein
1:40:14
at home. While Thera works were often. Paul.
1:40:17
About the kids making her crazy and
1:40:19
arguing with them lose All these different
1:40:21
versions of like know we're doing great
1:40:24
Actually, Jennifer is. Lose on it and
1:40:26
can't We can't handle these. Kids. Like l all
1:40:28
these people are getting different. Versions of
1:40:30
events. Sick. They're just so full
1:40:32
of shit that you can't tell you what's true
1:40:34
and what's not. Right? Although very
1:40:36
active in the seeds world of
1:40:39
social media, the hearts kept actual
1:40:41
people like relationship at arm's length
1:40:43
in real life, including their own
1:40:45
families. They. Would make excuses or
1:40:48
cancel plans they'd move states are caught
1:40:50
people out at the slightest provocation. The
1:40:52
allegations of abuse followed them from state
1:40:54
to say, but I think that they
1:40:56
are a lot of the reasons why
1:40:58
they. Would move. Yeah. So
1:41:01
we're gonna go over these
1:41:03
allegations starting with Minnesota. Which is
1:41:05
where they were living when they adopted the children. So
1:41:07
they. Adopted. The first set of
1:41:09
three siblings in two thousand and six and then
1:41:11
I believe by two thousand and eight. They also
1:41:13
had the second set of sibling thought this time.
1:41:15
They would have had all six children in the hall. And
1:41:18
two thousand and eight a teacher observed a. Bruise
1:41:20
on Hannah. Than six year
1:41:22
old six years old, left arm. And.
1:41:25
Was told that Jan had hit her with a
1:41:27
belt. As mandatory reporters
1:41:29
the teacher called police and
1:41:31
they interviewed the parents. They.
1:41:34
Claimed Sirens and that they didn't know how
1:41:36
she got the bruise on her arm. By.
1:41:38
It said that she had fallen
1:41:41
down eight stairs in their home.
1:41:43
Maybe that's how that happens. Yeah,
1:41:45
maybe. Asked by a Minnesota investigator
1:41:47
about. Disciplinary. Action
1:41:50
in the Home quote that children
1:41:52
talked about: not getting supper, getting
1:41:54
sent to bed without food. Being.
1:41:57
Made to say in bed all day or
1:41:59
sand and the. corner silent for a
1:42:01
long time. Being made
1:42:03
to stay in bed all day. Within
1:42:06
weeks of these allegations, all of the children
1:42:08
were pulled from public school for the rest
1:42:10
of the year by Sarah and
1:42:12
Jen. They're just hiding their bullshit. That's
1:42:14
correct. They
1:42:17
were re-enrolled the next fall, but Jen
1:42:19
later told a social worker that this
1:42:21
was a requirement of the adoption agency.
1:42:23
And from a legal standpoint, nothing
1:42:26
happens. Men being
1:42:28
pulled from school and then re-enrolled later
1:42:30
raises no alarm bells. The children are
1:42:32
not removed from their care. Cool. In
1:42:36
2010, Abigail said that she had quote,
1:42:38
owies on her back and stomach. And
1:42:41
there were bruises on the then six-year-old
1:42:43
across her sternum to her belly
1:42:45
button and from her mid-back down to the
1:42:48
waist of her jeans. Oh my god, her
1:42:50
whole body's bruised. Yeah, her whole like midsection
1:42:52
for sure. Oh my god. So,
1:42:54
in the end, Sarah, she had spanked the
1:42:56
child over the edge of the bathtub due
1:42:59
to behavioral issues. She
1:43:01
was charged with malicious punishment of a
1:43:03
child and misdemeanor domestic assault. She
1:43:06
pled guilty to misdemeanor assault involving
1:43:08
one of the children and was sentenced
1:43:10
to community service and one year of probation.
1:43:13
But they didn't take the kids away. Nope.
1:43:16
And this occurred four months after
1:43:19
a Texas appeals court turned
1:43:21
down on Priscilla Celestine's attempt to
1:43:23
adopt the children. Oh my
1:43:25
fucking god. Yep. When
1:43:28
authorities became involved, all children claimed
1:43:31
that they were spanked constantly and
1:43:34
deprived of food. Sarah
1:43:36
did take responsibility for this, calling
1:43:38
it a spanking that got out
1:43:40
of control and sentenced, like I
1:43:42
said, to that one year of community service. I think she had like a $300
1:43:44
fine. And
1:43:46
just of note, based on everything else we've learned,
1:43:49
it feels like it was probably Jen,
1:43:51
especially as that's what Abigail said.
1:43:54
But Jen was the one who was getting
1:43:57
money from these adoptions. So they didn't want
1:43:59
to jeopardize. That. Pay
1:44:01
our yeah and again gay marriage
1:44:03
wasn't recognize that this time. So.
1:44:07
The other one to of it all. Right?
1:44:09
And this is not to say that
1:44:11
Sarah is blameless I I. I.
1:44:14
They both engaged in this and
1:44:16
whether Sarah actually struck these children.
1:44:18
she allowed this to continue and
1:44:20
the matter. Albert for her wife.
1:44:22
It doesn't matter, they were both. They
1:44:24
are both at fault. Ah, but
1:44:26
bloodshed was a stay at home
1:44:28
parent Sarah with off and out
1:44:30
of the home and chance into what
1:44:32
be the one who was in
1:44:34
control of the whole family including
1:44:36
of Sarah. But again, I'm just
1:44:38
noting that because that's relevant to
1:44:40
this. To. The story. Of
1:44:42
this case, but they are both equally
1:44:45
fucking responsible for what. Is happening
1:44:47
and does happen to these children. In. Two
1:44:49
months time and late. Twenty Tan and
1:44:51
then early Twenty Eleven. Six additional allegations
1:44:54
were filed with Child Protective Services in
1:44:56
Minnesota. They. Said Abigail Heart was
1:44:58
spotted going through garbage at school and
1:45:00
was taking other students' food and Jennifer
1:45:02
Heart was accused of hitting Abigail head
1:45:05
against the wall. My. Gosh,
1:45:07
Hannah Hart had a small bruise on her
1:45:09
hand for being hit by Jennifer for lying.
1:45:11
And. Jennifer was hitting Hannah. Quote all the
1:45:13
time. Children and handed class
1:45:15
for giving her food. And
1:45:18
that she was approaching fellow students for
1:45:20
some asking for something to eat. They
1:45:22
work seeding this so much food insecurity
1:45:24
and isn't. This. Cannonballs The
1:45:27
So Young, They're so. Young Hannah
1:45:29
told the school nurse that she had
1:45:31
not eaten all day. Sarah. Said
1:45:33
that Hannah was Pope, playing the
1:45:35
food card or whatever the loving
1:45:37
fuck that means one of your
1:45:40
child is hunger your food card,
1:45:42
the food cart and suggested that
1:45:44
they just give Hannah some water.
1:45:46
Oh My. God. Yeah. God. Within
1:45:48
weeks of this happening at the
1:45:50
school, all six children are again
1:45:52
pulled from public schools and were
1:45:55
Coke. Home schooled from then on that they
1:45:57
moved out of the same directly from what
1:45:59
we know. Children were never enrolled
1:46:01
in school again and the family
1:46:03
never turned in required forms for.
1:46:05
Home. Schooling in Oregon or Washington.
1:46:08
So. If they were home schooling them in
1:46:10
Minnesota. Maybe they turned in a form just
1:46:12
to be able to pull them out of school,
1:46:14
but then they didn't even fucking try after they
1:46:17
moved. That didn't put them in school well, because
1:46:19
obviously at school. People. Are getting
1:46:21
ready and. Yeah. So by
1:46:23
twenty thirty and they've moved to Oregon.
1:46:26
Oregon. Authorities are notified of the
1:46:28
minnesota allegations and they open an
1:46:30
investigation. When. Interviewing family and friends
1:46:32
to friends stated that the children were forced
1:46:34
to raise their hands before speaking like in
1:46:37
their home of. That. They could
1:46:39
not wish each other a happy birthday. They.
1:46:41
Could not laugh at the dinner
1:46:44
table. A relative also
1:46:46
stated that Jan often erupted at
1:46:48
the children. The Quote: The
1:46:50
kids couldn't do anything. Without getting into trouble,
1:46:52
the relative said. If the kids did
1:46:55
anything that she thought was wrong, she would snap
1:46:57
your fingers and say get in. The Corner.
1:46:59
No food for you. Yeah,
1:47:01
a neighbor said quote, they wouldn't fight
1:47:04
or be silly. These children. They were
1:47:06
perfect kids. Which didn't seem normal to
1:47:08
me. It was like they were programs
1:47:10
all. Several. People recalled the
1:47:12
children walking around. Town and single file.
1:47:15
Other report stated that the. Children. Were small
1:47:17
for the raises and appeared underfed. Jan.
1:47:20
And Sarah told the doctor that they had
1:47:23
issues with food from before their adoption. And
1:47:25
insisted that the children had been small
1:47:28
their entire lives so the doctor express
1:47:30
no concern Now. Is
1:47:32
gonna take these white ladies at their word. What's
1:47:34
age range of the kids at this point. They
1:47:37
are into their like. tends
1:47:39
to. Teens early teens at this point
1:47:42
and say are tiny like whoa whoa kind
1:47:44
of get through it but I'm at least
1:47:46
one of the shoulder was like twelve and
1:47:48
she looked to be about seven because she
1:47:50
was so are my are so small guide.
1:47:52
Us yeah the women are countered
1:47:54
that they were under scrutiny for
1:47:56
quote being a vegetarian lesbian couple
1:47:58
married and had done. high-risk
1:48:01
abused children. According
1:48:03
to the Oregon investigation, it's like
1:48:05
you're just targeting us because we're
1:48:07
gay and we took in...
1:48:09
And we're vegetarians! And we're vegetarians
1:48:11
and we took in these troubled
1:48:13
kids. Oh my god. They
1:48:16
told investigators that they were harassed in
1:48:18
Minnesota by people who slashed their vehicle
1:48:20
tires, made threats, and egged their home.
1:48:23
They moved to Oregon in early 2013. None
1:48:25
of that happened. First of all, we're Minnesotans.
1:48:27
We're deviling those eggs. We're not wasting them
1:48:29
on your bullshit fucking house. Exactly.
1:48:33
Second of all, that's not
1:48:36
why you fucking left. You were being
1:48:38
harassed. You were being investigated for abusing
1:48:40
your children and you fucking ran to
1:48:42
Oregon. Jesus Christ. But they're claiming that
1:48:44
they moved there in early 2013 to
1:48:46
better fit in. Okay.
1:48:49
Despite the above, interviews of the children
1:48:52
revealed no new incidents of abuse and
1:48:54
they did not mention anything that happened
1:48:56
in Minnesota. Which like, duh, they
1:48:59
don't want to get further fucking
1:49:01
harmed by their mom. Right. According
1:49:03
to the investigation, the children provided
1:49:05
nearly identical answers to all questions
1:49:07
asked. Six children giving the same
1:49:09
answer. Weird. No red flags there.
1:49:11
Oh my god. And all
1:49:14
but Devontae showed quote, little emotion
1:49:16
or animation. The children disclosed no
1:49:18
abuse or withholding of food and
1:49:20
the social workers marked them as
1:49:22
safe. The case was then closed.
1:49:24
And like, why is the burden
1:49:26
on literal children who are
1:49:28
being abused and under the control
1:49:30
of these adults when other
1:49:32
adults are telling authorities
1:49:34
that they've like gotten a
1:49:36
peek behind the curtain and they're seeing what's happening
1:49:39
here. Yeah. But the kids said
1:49:41
it's fine. In the exact
1:49:43
same language. In the exact same
1:49:45
words with faces devoid of emotion
1:49:47
or any kind of curiosity or
1:49:50
animation. Oh boy. Check that safety
1:49:52
box. Everything's fine here. Nothing to
1:49:54
see. God. It's
1:49:57
just fucking infuriating. They moved to Washington.
1:50:00
in 2017 after several years
1:50:02
of living in Oregon, likely in response to
1:50:04
the Oregon abuse allegations, even though the case
1:50:06
had been closed, but the heat was on
1:50:08
them. Because they were moving back
1:50:10
to Washington? I think
1:50:12
there had been kind of a back-and-forth, or maybe
1:50:14
they went from Minnesota to Oregon and then to
1:50:16
Washington, and that's where they kind of landed. They
1:50:19
purchased a 375,000 three-bedroom
1:50:22
home situated on 2.2 acres
1:50:24
of pasture land. Three-bedroom home? Yeah,
1:50:27
for six kids. For six kids. Yep,
1:50:29
and you know they had their own room. Cool.
1:50:32
And we'll kind of get to the room, but
1:50:34
this is where they spent the last 10 months
1:50:37
of their lives. Three
1:50:39
bedrooms for eight people is tight, but it's
1:50:41
worse than that. I mean, we all
1:50:45
can completely understand,
1:50:47
especially in today's housing market, not
1:50:49
being able to afford the luxury of
1:50:51
all of your children having the same
1:50:53
bedroom, kids sharing rooms. That's not, we're
1:50:56
not judging that by any fucking stretch
1:50:58
of the imagination. No, but
1:51:00
in this particular context... They're
1:51:02
not accommodating their children. Yeah.
1:51:05
Police, during an investigation
1:51:07
after the shit we're gonna get to
1:51:10
goes down, concluded that one bedroom belonged to the
1:51:12
parents. One bedroom contained
1:51:14
a single twin bed surrounded
1:51:16
by remodeling supplies. What?
1:51:19
And the third bedroom held two foam
1:51:21
love seats and a small mat that the
1:51:24
children may have slept on. That
1:51:26
the six children may have slept on. Yep.
1:51:29
So they don't even know for sure where these kids were sleeping.
1:51:32
They had no idea. There were
1:51:34
also no keepsakes, posters, personal objects,
1:51:36
or anything that indicated the children
1:51:38
lived in the home
1:51:40
or slept in the bedroom. They
1:51:43
could have slept in the yard for all they know. For
1:51:45
all we fucking know. The police said
1:51:47
the house was orderly to the point of
1:51:49
seeming sterile. Quote, none of the rooms were
1:51:51
personalized for the children or showed the supporting
1:51:54
elements that children lived in the residence. Oh
1:51:56
my. In August of 2017, Hannah jumped
1:51:58
out of her
1:52:00
second-story bedroom around 1.30 a.m.
1:52:02
and knocked on a neighbor's door.
1:52:04
The neighbors had never seen Hannah
1:52:06
before. She was small and
1:52:08
wrapped in a blanket with her two front
1:52:10
teeth missing. Although almost 16
1:52:13
years old, she looked to be around 7. Oh
1:52:16
my god. According
1:52:18
to the neighbors, when they answered the door,
1:52:20
Hannah darted inside and ran upstairs pleading, Don't
1:52:22
make me go back, they're racist and they
1:52:25
abuse us. Oh my god. When
1:52:27
they saw the whole family outside with flashlights
1:52:30
looking for her and calling her name they
1:52:32
shouted out to let them know that Hannah was
1:52:34
inside. I have conflicting feelings about
1:52:36
this. They
1:52:39
obviously don't know what we know and
1:52:42
obviously I also don't fucking trust the
1:52:44
police but I feel like I'd be
1:52:46
calling the police in this situation. Yeah.
1:52:48
Regardless, to report something,
1:52:50
I don't know.
1:52:53
I don't know. It's just so fucking
1:52:55
upsetting knowing what happens. But
1:52:57
eventually an adult child of
1:53:00
the neighbors that Hannah ran to
1:53:02
did call police. So
1:53:05
this happens with Hannah. The family
1:53:07
that lives in that house returns
1:53:10
Hannah to the hearts. Their
1:53:12
adult child who doesn't live at home is
1:53:14
visiting with them in the coming days and
1:53:17
they tell their kids this story and their
1:53:19
story is like, the kid is
1:53:21
like, we have to fucking call the police. Yeah. And
1:53:24
they said, quote, I just can't sit with this.
1:53:26
I believe those kids are being highly abused. Someone
1:53:28
from the county sheriff's office called the neighbors back
1:53:30
to ask whether there had been more incidents
1:53:33
and they said the kids were
1:53:35
almost always indoors. And
1:53:37
she remembers being told, quote, it's not illegal
1:53:39
to keep kids inside. And there was
1:53:41
no other follow up. There are so many
1:53:43
failures all over the place here. It's
1:53:45
consistent. It's just failure at every fucking
1:53:47
turn. March or 2018, the neighbors only
1:53:50
saw any of the children again when Devontae
1:53:52
would knock on their door asking for food,
1:53:55
but begging that Jen and Sarah not be
1:53:57
told saying they weren't being fed.
1:54:00
as punishment and also asking them
1:54:02
not to call the police because they would all be
1:54:04
split up. Oh. Yeah,
1:54:06
he would, I know, I know. He
1:54:09
would ask for bread, tortillas, peanut butter,
1:54:11
cured meats, things that were shelf stable.
1:54:14
And he had a little box that
1:54:16
would be hidden near the fence between the
1:54:18
two, the neighboring properties so
1:54:20
that his siblings could sneak out and get food
1:54:23
and they could refill the food from the neighbor's
1:54:26
box. Oh my God, they had their own
1:54:28
little food bank. Yeah,
1:54:30
he was asking for food nearly three times
1:54:33
a day and disclosed to the neighbors that
1:54:35
everything Hannah had told them was true. They
1:54:37
called CPS again. CPS showed
1:54:39
up to check on the Hart family on
1:54:41
March 23rd, but they did
1:54:43
not get a response at the door. About
1:54:46
45 minutes later, Sarah's Yukon
1:54:48
SUV came screeching into the drive.
1:54:51
The CPS visit clearly put them in panic
1:54:53
mode. And by the next day, the Yukon
1:54:55
was gone, bringing us to
1:54:57
the tragic end of this case. So I
1:54:59
wanna clear that up. CPS came, no one
1:55:01
was home, CPS left. The
1:55:04
neighbors are the ones who reported that
1:55:06
like 45 minutes later, Oh, okay. the
1:55:08
car comes screeching into the driveway. So
1:55:10
what we believe to be true is
1:55:13
that at least some
1:55:15
of the children were in the home and
1:55:17
had been instructed not to answer the door
1:55:19
for anyone if Sarah and Jen weren't
1:55:21
home. And one of the
1:55:23
children probably let them know, somebody came
1:55:25
to the door. Yeah. And
1:55:27
Sarah came rushing home from work. On
1:55:30
March 24th, so the day after that
1:55:32
last CPS visit, Sarah had been scheduled to
1:55:34
open the store where she was working.
1:55:36
I'm not sure if at this point it was also a
1:55:38
Kohl's. I think they had transferred her, but she was like
1:55:40
a manager at another department store. But at
1:55:42
3 a.m., she sent a text to coworkers saying
1:55:45
she was too sick to come in. That
1:55:47
same morning, the neighbors noticed that their Yukon
1:55:49
was no longer in the driveway and the
1:55:51
bright red kayak that was always attached to
1:55:53
the top of it had been removed. Cinder
1:55:56
blocks littered the driveway, suggesting that the
1:55:59
family had cracked. into a retaining
1:56:01
wall on the property in their rush to
1:56:03
leave. Oh my god. Yeah. Calm
1:56:06
down. So the same day,
1:56:08
March 24, 2018, the Hart
1:56:10
family are in or around Newport, Oregon
1:56:12
around 835 a.m. They
1:56:15
then continue to travel south. They reach Fort
1:56:17
Bragg around 8 p.m. where they remain for
1:56:20
the day. So they're in California now? Yep,
1:56:22
they've gone from Oregon down to California. March
1:56:25
25, 2018, Jen Hart
1:56:27
is seen shopping at a Safeway in
1:56:30
Fort Bragg as she bought bananas, carrots,
1:56:32
wheat bread, cereal bars, saltines, and Chef
1:56:34
Boyardee ravioli, which I don't know
1:56:36
if she got vegetarian or meat. Haha,
1:56:38
do they have non-meat raviolis? I don't
1:56:40
know if they do. I don't think
1:56:42
they do. Mm-hmm. It's
1:56:45
also reported and then later determined
1:56:47
that she was
1:56:50
intoxicated. At the store? Yeah.
1:56:53
March 26, friend and coworker
1:56:55
of Sarah, who had
1:56:57
gotten that 3 a.m. I'm too sick to
1:56:59
come in text but then she didn't ever
1:57:01
come back to work in the coming days, called
1:57:04
911 for a wellness check because no
1:57:06
one had been able to contact Sarah or Jen
1:57:08
since the text that she was that Sarah
1:57:10
wasn't coming into work. She hadn't come
1:57:12
in or communicated with work since. And
1:57:15
there's probably fucking rumors that of all
1:57:17
this stuff, everyone around
1:57:19
is like extra no concern. Yep.
1:57:22
Wow. On March 26, 2018,
1:57:24
a welfare check is conducted but the home
1:57:26
is empty. Empty of people or empty of
1:57:28
staff? Empty of people.
1:57:30
Miles away, Jennifer drove
1:57:33
the GMC Yukon XL
1:57:35
over a 100-foot cliff on
1:57:38
California State Route 1 in Mendocino County
1:57:40
with Sarah and, as far
1:57:43
as we know, all six of the children inside
1:57:45
the car. Jesus Christ. It landed
1:57:47
upside down and was discovered by some like
1:57:49
German tourists who were hiking along the beach.
1:57:52
Jen and Sarah were both found deceased
1:57:55
inside of the SUV. Marcus,
1:57:57
Jeremiah, and Abigail were... Ah,
1:58:01
Found nearby. Ah, it sounds
1:58:03
like the way the car
1:58:05
landed. Was. Close enough
1:58:08
or partially in the water. And
1:58:11
so and it's a
1:58:13
pretty. Clear that the children didn't
1:58:15
have their seatbelts on. Which
1:58:18
was likely instructed by Sarah
1:58:20
engine take your seatbelt off
1:58:22
oh my God arm and
1:58:25
so remains were found nearby
1:58:27
that were likely moved. Due
1:58:29
to ties like this is
1:58:31
Rocky Shore Line that the
1:58:33
vehicle had been driven off
1:58:35
abigail body was. Also.
1:58:37
Covered in bruises that indicated past
1:58:39
abuse, Sierra. Wasn't sound
1:58:42
for ten days. My god.
1:58:44
Other remains were also found
1:58:46
and dna testing on a
1:58:48
foot. That was found
1:58:50
would prove to belong to Hannah
1:58:52
in January of twenty nineteen months.
1:58:55
Later My God. as. To. Volunteer
1:58:57
remains were never found. Angela
1:59:01
had. A. Subway in this hotel. Yes,
1:59:03
And one of the oldest boys and
1:59:05
seem to be treated as like the
1:59:08
favorite in the family. So. While.
1:59:11
I. Don't think that this is
1:59:13
an appropriate situation to be
1:59:15
discussing any kind of theories
1:59:17
He he has since been
1:59:19
pronounced dead at, but there
1:59:21
are. Still like
1:59:23
wanted or I'm. Searching.
1:59:25
Posers. Potentially. Looking
1:59:28
for him if in the event
1:59:30
that the hearts let him out
1:59:32
to let him out before. Annihilating,
1:59:36
The rest of the family. And that and.
1:59:38
I mean, maybe it's just me wanting
1:59:41
to believe that. They are
1:59:43
not all gone out on arms getting really
1:59:45
emotional, but. I'd I'd oh no I
1:59:47
don't know what I believe I I. I
1:59:49
personally don't. Think that these
1:59:52
women. Would. Have done that
1:59:54
even for their favorite kid in the fucking
1:59:56
family. I don't think they loved any
1:59:58
of them. know. And I I, I. It gets
2:00:00
us one of those things where some
2:00:02
of the remains of these children were
2:00:04
found for a while and they're right
2:00:07
on the water and. There. Are
2:00:09
you know? animals? In the
2:00:11
water and I don't know but ah,
2:00:13
Yeah. At it's not like an idol
2:00:15
judge what anybody chooses to believe in this
2:00:18
situation, I don't. I don't blame anyone for
2:00:20
wanting to cling to the idea that Avanti
2:00:22
could still be alive and just. Somewhere.
2:00:25
Saying. Out. Of
2:00:27
the public eye and not wanting to engage
2:00:30
with any of this and just. Living.
2:00:32
His life. I mean, That. Would
2:00:34
be a miracle but. We
2:00:36
don't have any evidence to
2:00:39
indicate. That. So
2:00:41
he was, I believe he was
2:00:43
pronounced dead by like twenty nineteen.
2:00:46
So. Obviously it. Initially
2:00:49
folks. Are like oh my god
2:00:51
tragic accident. But
2:00:53
these are modern vehicles that
2:00:55
have essentially like a black
2:00:57
box. So just keep that in
2:01:00
fuckin' mine. Anyone listening whose thinking
2:01:02
about committing a crime. At a car?
2:01:04
Yeah. There's. Data about
2:01:06
acceleration, airbag deployment, all kinds
2:01:08
of shit. So the
2:01:11
Su these internal airbag deploying computer
2:01:13
showed that the Yukon had gone
2:01:15
from a standing stop, accelerated twenty
2:01:17
mph in three seconds with the
2:01:19
thrall press at one hundred percent
2:01:21
like paddles of the medal. For.
2:01:23
About seventy feet before going off the cliff and
2:01:26
there were no skid marks. He did not attempt
2:01:28
to saw see. What is out in
2:01:30
the car a that decision and said
2:01:32
it yet see position to the car.
2:01:35
In. Front of that area that wouldn't have
2:01:37
been. Walled. Off and put
2:01:39
the pedal to the metal. And. Drove off the
2:01:41
cliff with her family. Like some and Lilies
2:01:44
sale but does. Taking. So his
2:01:46
children down with him. Exactly. But
2:01:48
those. Women are cel second delusional.
2:01:50
They probably had some sense of like
2:01:52
nobility like will Were all gone down
2:01:55
to gather some rain. i mean
2:01:57
the at these women were fucking sick
2:01:59
so bad knows what's going. I
2:02:01
mean, I cannot even trying
2:02:04
to go to the darkest of places put
2:02:06
myself in their minds. I
2:02:09
can't understand. I can't wrap my fucking
2:02:11
head around it. It's too much. Nor should you. Yeah,
2:02:14
bad place to go. Yeah. So
2:02:16
the toxicology reports showed that
2:02:18
Jen's BAC was over the
2:02:20
legal limit. It was at
2:02:22
about point one, which indicates around five
2:02:24
drinks that she would have
2:02:26
consumed before driving off the cliff. Sarah
2:02:29
and at least three of the
2:02:32
children had generic Benadryl in their
2:02:34
systems. I don't know
2:02:36
which children, if any,
2:02:38
didn't have any drug in their system.
2:02:41
It's possible that the tests might have been
2:02:43
inconclusive. Well, I really hope that they were
2:02:45
knocked the fuck out for all of this.
2:02:48
Right. Sierra and Hannah's remains were
2:02:50
also found too late to
2:02:52
be able to make a determination about Benadryl
2:02:55
levels and Devontae's remains
2:02:58
were not found. So we only know
2:03:00
that for sure three of them had
2:03:03
Benadryl in their system. Personally,
2:03:05
I pray to God all of them did
2:03:08
because if they were maybe
2:03:10
asleep, I mean, I'm just like leaping
2:03:13
at anything to alleviate
2:03:16
some of the fear and horror and
2:03:18
trauma for these kids at this last
2:03:20
moment. And it's not like this
2:03:22
is even all that fucking
2:03:24
helpful. But by the grace of God, maybe they
2:03:27
just didn't feel a thing and they were asleep.
2:03:29
Sarah herself had a toxic level of Benadryl
2:03:31
in her system. She had 42 doses and
2:03:34
both liquid form and capsules were found
2:03:36
in the car. The children's
2:03:38
toxicology levels were not toxic,
2:03:41
but they were high enough
2:03:43
to be drowsy or
2:03:45
incapacitated because they received as many as
2:03:48
about 19 doses of
2:03:50
Benadryl according to the toxicology. And
2:03:53
the coroner report did say that the
2:03:55
children were likely unconscious or asleep based on
2:03:57
the level of drugs that were found
2:03:59
in their system. them. Sarah also
2:04:01
had Google searches on her phone that
2:04:03
included how easily can I overdose
2:04:06
on over-the-counter medications, can
2:04:09
500 milligrams of Benadryl kill
2:04:11
a 125 pound woman, and how long
2:04:14
does it take to die from hypothermia
2:04:16
while drowning in a car? Well,
2:04:18
are you drowning or are you dying of hypothermia?
2:04:21
I think she's like trying to
2:04:23
make sure that nobody
2:04:25
survives. And
2:04:28
yeah, and potentially are killed
2:04:30
quickly. And
2:04:34
that is my case. Oh
2:04:38
my God. Oh my God. I'm
2:04:41
looking at the diagram of the cliff. That is just a cliff.
2:04:43
Yeah. It's like a
2:04:45
scenic bypass. It's like a, you can
2:04:47
pull off like an overlook. Yeah.
2:04:50
It's fucking wild. Boy. Yeah.
2:04:53
It's, uh, it's too much. And yeah, you
2:04:55
can see on that photo how there's
2:04:57
not really, when the tide's up, there's
2:04:59
like no beach at all. It's just,
2:05:01
it's just waterfront cliff and rock. So
2:05:04
they easily could have been washed away, especially without
2:05:06
their belts on. Right. Yep.
2:05:09
But, you know, if you
2:05:11
pray, pray for those children and wherever
2:05:14
they are, they're so sweet looking.
2:05:16
He's in that cute little hat in
2:05:18
every photo. I know. I
2:05:20
know. But yeah, it's a,
2:05:23
it's a really. Horrifying story
2:05:26
and it's real. And
2:05:28
it just, I don't know. It's just,
2:05:30
it's so wrong
2:05:33
knowing how viral that photo went without
2:05:37
people knowing what was happening. And
2:05:40
then within a couple years of that picture being
2:05:42
taken, all of these children are gone. Well,
2:05:46
uh, thank you for this
2:05:48
Mother's Day gift. You're
2:05:51
so welcome. I don't really have
2:05:53
anything else to say. I
2:05:56
don't either. I
2:05:58
need to. go take
2:06:01
medication for my brain. I
2:06:03
might, I might go have a
2:06:05
glass of wine. I'm at the end of my mind
2:06:07
now. Yeah, and a good cry. Yeah. Anyway, thanks
2:06:10
for listening. It's an important case to cover.
2:06:13
I'm glad we covered it. Yes. Yes.
2:06:16
You know, there are people who know
2:06:18
like bits and pieces of it. I
2:06:20
obviously in this format can't cover every
2:06:22
single detail, but we covered a lot.
2:06:25
Mm hmm. And now you have
2:06:27
a full picture of this
2:06:30
situation. Exactly what I needed.
2:06:33
Yep. Well, yep. Thank
2:06:35
you for listening and happy Mother's
2:06:39
Day. So sorry.
2:06:41
All the moms out there. Stay
2:06:44
on the road. Don't drive off a cliff. If
2:06:46
you're, if you're getting those thoughts,
2:06:48
talk to a professional. Get help.
2:06:51
Lot of, lot of mental health in this
2:06:53
episode. Mm hmm. Well, yep.
2:06:56
All right. Bye guys.
2:06:58
Thanks for listening. Thanks
2:07:02
for listening to wine and crime.
2:07:04
Our cover art is by Danielle
2:07:06
Sylvan music by Phil young and
2:07:08
Corey Wendell editing by Jonathan camp.
2:07:10
Our production manager is Andrea Gardner
2:07:12
for photos and sources. Check out
2:07:15
our blog at wine and crime
2:07:17
podcast.com. You can follow us on
2:07:19
all the socials at wine and
2:07:21
crime pod. If you have questions,
2:07:23
answers, or recommendations to share email
2:07:25
us at wine and crime podcast@gmail.com.
2:07:28
Episodes are available on Apple podcasts,
2:07:31
Spotify, wherever you get your podcasts. If
2:07:33
you like the show, please rate, review,
2:07:35
and subscribe on Apple podcasts. It is
2:07:37
the best way to spread the word.
2:07:39
If you'd like to show your support
2:07:41
and get access to all sorts of
2:07:43
wine fueled bonus content, visit our Patreon
2:07:46
page. Cheers. Mm
2:07:51
hmm. ly,rinea-
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More