Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
This is the BBC. This
0:03
podcast is supported by advertising outside
0:05
the UK. Acorn
0:11
TV is crime's new home,
0:13
says Radio News. I'm not a good man.
0:16
An absolute must for hard-hitting stories, according
0:18
to The New York Times. You've
0:20
got a funny kind of curiosity. From
0:23
gritty mysteries... Guys are crying! ...to
0:25
sinister suspense. How?
0:28
Acorn TV is bloody entertaining.
0:30
Visit acorn.tv for a 30-day
0:32
free trial with promo code
0:34
BBC24. Acorn
0:37
TV. Brilliant. BBC
1:00
Sounds. Music, radio, podcasts.
1:28
In History Corner, she's Professor of Medieval Literature and
1:30
the Director of the Centre for Medieval Studies at
1:33
the University of York. She specialises
1:35
in the literary culture of England from the 9th
1:37
to the 12th century. She's particularly interested in medieval
1:39
English queens. It's Professor Elizabeth Tyler.
1:41
Welcome, Elizabeth. Hi, thanks for having me. It's great to be here.
1:44
Oh, we're delighted to have you here. And
1:46
in Comedy Corner, she's a stand-up comedian, actor and writer.
1:48
You'll have seen her on all the telly shows, including
1:50
Live at the Apollo, Mock the Week, Frankie
1:52
Boyle's New World Order, perhaps you've seen her on tour,
1:55
or read her hilariously honest memoir, The
1:57
Other Mother, about the challenges of... I've
2:00
got the audiobook. It's excellent. It's Jen Brister.
2:02
Welcome to the show, Jen. Oh, Greg,
2:04
it's an absolute pleasure. I have
2:06
to do the contractually obligated question with
2:09
Baited Breath. Do you like history? I
2:11
do, actually. I'm intrigued by history. Like when I was
2:13
young, I was like, oh, what's the point? Why
2:16
are we learning about things that have happened? And
2:18
I'm thinking, maybe we should go back. Let's delve
2:20
back and see what we can learn from
2:22
history. Yeah. What about medieval history? I
2:25
know zero. Now,
2:28
I did study it. I mean, I say study. Do
2:31
you be studying when you're at primary school? I did
2:33
sit in a room while someone talked at me about
2:35
medieval history. OK. You know
2:37
the usual, the William the Conqueror and the
2:39
Battle of Hastings and all of that. But
2:42
I think it really started and ended there. So,
2:45
what do you know? This
2:51
is where I have a go at guessing
2:53
what you, our lovely listener, will know about
2:55
today's subject. And when I say Emma of
2:57
Normandy, I think everyone's going to be thinking,
2:59
Emma who? You've possibly heard of her son,
3:01
King Edward the Confessor? His death
3:04
in 1066 led to the Little Cuffuffle, known
3:06
as the Norman Conquest and the Baya Tapestry,
3:08
which, of course, is what our artwork is
3:10
based on. But Emma herself, absolute
3:13
tumbleweed. But who is this
3:15
fairly unknown medieval English queen? How did she
3:17
end up being Queen of England not once,
3:19
but spoiler alert, twice? And
3:21
what was the dating scene like for royal women
3:24
in the 11th century? Let's find out. Let's
3:26
start with some historical context because this is
3:28
complicated stuff. So, we often define the medieval
3:30
period on this show as lasting 1,000 years,
3:34
from the fall of the Western Roman
3:36
Empire to the Protestant Reformation. When
3:39
in that 1,000 years do we find
3:41
Emma? Where does she pop up? She was born probably
3:43
985 and died in 1052. And
3:47
then we're talking here about Normandy. So,
3:50
Jen, what do you know about medieval Normandy? Well,
3:53
I'm assuming it's France. Is
3:55
that not what France was known as as Normandy?
3:57
Am I completely... You're looking at me like, no,
3:59
done. whole
10:00
lot of Danes in 1002, so that
10:02
raid on Exeter might also have been
10:04
in retaliation for that.
10:07
Things get even more complicated now, you won't
10:09
believe this, but Ethelred's first wife had
10:11
been called Elf-Gee-Voo. Ethelred
10:14
had been married before. And
10:16
he made Emma change her name to
10:18
Elf-Gee-Voo. Elf-Gee-Voo. It's not as catchy.
10:20
So his first wife dies, he's got a
10:23
second wife, a young wife, Emma. Her name
10:25
is quite clearly Emma, he's introduced her as
10:27
Emma, she's very much named Emma. And he's
10:29
like, do you know what? How about Elf-Gee-Voo?
10:33
Elizabeth, Emma has done her duty of marrying Ethelred,
10:35
the unready or the not yet ready or
10:37
the yet to be unready, I don't know whether
10:39
he's been named yet. And her job
10:42
I suppose is to have children, to have an
10:44
heir, that's what queens are for. Does she manage
10:46
this, you know, does she pop out of Prince?
10:48
Oh yes, she does. And pretty quickly.
10:50
So Edward, that's our Edward the Confessor
10:53
who's going to turn up later, was
10:55
born sometime between 1003 and 1005. And then she
10:57
has another son, Alfred,
11:00
so she's got two, an heir and a spare, and
11:03
a daughter God-Gee-Voo. Gift of
11:05
God. God-Gee-Voo. Oh, that's
11:07
a lot to live up to, isn't it? Yeah.
11:10
Oh, you think you're God's gift. That's not my fault, it's
11:12
my name, mate. You shut up. She has an
11:14
heir and a spare, Emma. They
11:16
are Alfred and Edward. I mean, I guess that
11:18
gives her a bit more stability and power. Absolutely.
11:20
She's called Con La Torana Regis, which
11:22
means she who is at the king's
11:25
side. We're going to watch out for
11:27
that because she's learning a lot about
11:29
how to be King of England, which
11:31
she's going to teach someone else later.
11:34
Interesting. Let's just drop that
11:36
little hint. Okay. So this cozy
11:38
family scene that we've established, it's
11:40
disturbed quite dramatically in the year
11:44
So if we jump forward 10 years, Jen, we
11:47
get another surprise Danish invasion and they
11:49
don't just trash Exeter this time. They
11:51
steal the entire kingdom. Oh my goodness.
11:53
Yeah. Ethelred is booted off the throne.
11:55
He loses his throne. The new King
11:57
of England has a fantastic name. He's
11:59
called Swain Forkbeard. He
12:02
also has Denmark and Norway so this is
12:04
his third kingdom and guess
12:07
how long this new mighty imperial
12:09
king Swain Forkbeard rules England for
12:12
Jen? Three years. Five
12:14
weeks. Yeah
12:21
he drops dead immediately. The crucial question is
12:23
Ethelred is not being killed. So he's still
12:25
hanging around. He's still hanging around. Has he
12:27
done a runner? Where is Emma? Where are
12:29
her kids? Where is Ethelred at this point?
12:31
So Emma and the kids go straight to
12:33
Normandy and Ethelred follows and
12:36
it's hard to know if this
12:38
was a temporary tactical retreat. I mean
12:40
it couldn't have been fun hanging out
12:42
in Normandy for Ethelred but after Swain's
12:44
sudden death the question arises could he
12:46
make a comeback or is
12:49
Swain's son Canute going to succeed him?
12:52
You would think with that kind of absolutely
12:54
apopleptic shame of being knocked off by Forkbeard
12:56
that you'd be like listen I've got to
12:58
hide under a bin for a girl. I'm
13:00
going to come out again and show my
13:02
face. Does he go no? I'm
13:06
going back. So Ethelred does come
13:08
back keen to get away from
13:10
his in-laws but the Danes have
13:13
chosen Canute who's Swain's son so
13:15
there's a whole tussle between Canute
13:17
and Ethelred and Ethelred comes out
13:19
on top temporarily in 1014 but
13:22
then he dies in 1016. Meanwhile
13:25
Emma's oldest son Edward he's only 11
13:27
or 12 so he's got
13:29
no hope of being the candidate chosen to
13:32
take on the Danish fleet and
13:34
all this time we're not actually sure where
13:36
Emma is. Is she in London? Is she
13:38
in Normandy? And what role
13:40
she played in opposing Canute?
13:42
And this then leaves Emma
13:45
exposed because her
13:47
husband is dead, her children are threats,
13:51
she's a threat. So is
13:53
that something that Canute is worried about? I've
13:56
heard of this guy. I've heard of King Canute.
13:58
I've got a feeling he's not a guy to be
14:00
messed with. I'm hoping you're
14:02
going to tell me, Elizabeth, that Emma
14:04
goes gone blazing and takes her 12-year-old
14:06
son and points him under
14:08
her armpit and away they go
14:10
and takes on King Canoe. Is that
14:13
what happens? No, they go off to
14:15
hide out in Normandy. Oh, what? So
14:17
Edward and his little brother Alfred head
14:20
off to Normandy. Canoe is trouble because
14:22
what he does is he murders
14:24
another prince named Eadwig, whose Ethelred's last
14:26
remaining son with Elkifu I. So
14:29
he's trying to get rid of all these people.
14:32
What do you think Emma does next, Jen?
14:34
Her husband is dead. The man who defeated
14:36
her husband is dead. The son of that
14:38
man is now the King of England. What
14:40
do you think she does? Well,
14:42
I imagine she tries to find an
14:45
alliance. And maybe
14:47
she tries to find an alliance
14:49
by marrying somebody that could help
14:51
her get her son on the
14:53
throne. So who does it? She
14:58
doesn't marry Canoe, does she? She
15:00
does. What is happening? Oh
15:03
my goodness, this soap opera
15:05
is dramatic. Yeah, she
15:08
marries Canoe. He sounds very rugged. Is
15:12
this a marriage of, again, so I imagine
15:14
this is a marriage of convenience, but is
15:16
it also a marriage of anything more? It
15:18
doesn't start out that way. She
15:21
marries Canoe. And there's
15:23
two different accounts of that. The
15:25
Anglo-Saxon Chronicle just says very unceremoniously,
15:28
Canoe had her fetched to
15:31
be his bride. Anglo-Saxon Chronicle. Indeed.
15:33
Oh, please. I don't trust them.
15:37
But later, Emma has her own
15:39
account written about all that went
15:41
on. And she claims that Canoe
15:44
wooed her. But it's also
15:46
fun. Earlier, we were kind of squeamish
15:48
that Emma was so young when she
15:50
married the older Aethelred. Now the tables
15:53
are turned. Canoe is a teenager, and
15:55
she's in her 30s. What? She's
15:58
a cougar. presented
26:00
in that encomium that we've been talking
26:02
about, that account of Svein, Knut, and
26:04
Har the Knut, that she had
26:06
commissioned to protect her interests when it
26:08
all fell apart. And
26:10
we've been worrying that this has all
26:12
been about the men in Emma's life
26:14
and not about her. And
26:17
this was on her mind too, and she had something to
26:19
say about it. At the end
26:21
of the encomium, she's depicted as
26:23
co-ruling with Har the Knut and
26:25
Edward, not behind the scenes. And
26:28
indeed, if you look at the
26:30
illustration that comes at the beginning
26:32
of the encomium, it is
26:34
Emma sitting on the throne and Har the
26:36
Knut and Edward peeking out from behind a
26:38
curtain. But it gets better. The monk
26:41
who wrote the encomium was really
26:43
learned and his history is partly
26:45
based on Virgil's Aeneid. Emma can't
26:47
read Latin, but doesn't mean she
26:50
doesn't know the stories that are
26:52
in Latin texts. The encomium parallels
26:54
Knut to the mythical Aeneas who
26:56
sailed across the Mediterranean to found
26:58
Rome from the ruins of Troy
27:01
way back in the midst of time.
27:03
The encomium also compares Knut to Julius
27:05
Caesar, who conquered Gaul, made it to
27:08
Britain, defeated Antony and Cleopatra, but ended
27:10
up murdered by Brutus. But in all
27:12
of this, it's Emma who was the
27:14
survivor, and she's not left out of
27:17
this Aeneid business. The encomiest
27:19
compares her to Octavian, that
27:21
is Augustus, the first Roman
27:24
emperor, and the man Virgil
27:26
wrote for. While dead Knut and dying
27:28
Knut were all in the past, she
27:30
was the present and the future. And
27:33
all this is really interesting take. It's
27:35
Emma's take on what it meant to
27:37
be a wife and mother of kings.
27:40
And it definitely wasn't about being
27:42
the power behind the throne. The
27:44
encomiest wasn't bound by gender roles
27:47
in imagining her power. Emma is
27:49
mother and emperor. Fantastic.
27:51
Thank you, Elizabeth. I think it's interesting that
27:54
a woman of such influence has been forgotten. So
27:56
thank you for talking about her and bringing her
27:58
up. A
28:00
huge thank you to our guests in History Corner
28:02
from the University of York. We had the incredible
28:04
Professor Elizabeth Tyler. Thank you, Elizabeth. Oh, thank you
28:06
for having me. It was a blast. And in
28:08
Comedy Corner, we had the brilliant Jen Brister. Thank
28:11
you, Jen. Oh, Greg, thanks for having me. I've
28:13
really enjoyed it. And to you lovely listener, join
28:15
me next time as we fetch, or should that
28:17
be woo, another enticing historical topic. But for now,
28:19
I'm off to go and grow myself an awesome
28:21
fork beard. Bye. This
28:29
is a story about one of
28:31
Britain's most revered institutions and
28:35
the theft of ancient treasures that were sold around
28:37
the world. It felt like a real punch to
28:39
the stomach. My God, things are being stolen from
28:41
our museum. I'm Katie Rassell.
28:44
And from BBC Radio 4, this
28:46
is Thief at the British Museum. At
28:52
the heart of our tale is
28:54
an antiquities dealer turned amateur detective
28:56
thrown into the centre of a
28:58
global scandal. I was shocked.
29:00
I remember that thing that my hair stood on
29:02
in. Search
29:05
for Shadow World, Thief at the
29:07
British Museum, on BBC Sounds. Acorn
29:14
TV is crime's new home, says
29:16
Radio News. I'm not a good
29:18
bird. An absolute must for hard-hitting
29:20
stories, according to The New York
29:23
Times. You've got a funny kind
29:25
of curiosity. From gritty mysteries... Guys
29:27
are crying. ...to sinister suspense. How?
29:30
Acorn TV is bloody entertaining.
29:33
Visit acorn.tv for a 30-day
29:35
free trial with promo code
29:37
BBC24. Acorn
29:40
TV. Brilliant. Sooner
29:44
or later, you'll need to upgrade your
29:46
tech, but you don't have to pay
29:48
full price. We're Back Market, a leading
29:50
online marketplace for refurbished smartphones, laptops, tablets
29:52
and other tech, all up to 70%
29:56
Each device sold on BackMarket is tested
29:58
and restored to perfect working condition by
30:00
industry experts, and they all come with
30:02
a one-year warranty and 30 days to
30:04
change your mind. So never pay full
30:06
price for tech again. Visit the
30:09
BackMarket app or backmarket.com to
30:11
save up to 70% on your next device.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More