In Supernatural's classic "Rashomon" episode, Dean and Sam investigate a series of weird attacks on a college campus, leaving two professors dead and one frat boy traumatized by an apparent alien abduction. The Winchesters call Bobby for help w

2.14 Born Under a Bad Sign

Jan 29th, 2021 50m 29s

Sam goes missing for a week, leaving Dean frantic. He turns up covered in blood, with no memory of whose it is or how it got there. Dean's search for answers takes a deadly turn when "Sam" takes Jo hostage after tormenting her with intimate det

2.13 Houses of the Holy

Jan 22nd, 2021 48m 7s

Sam and Dean investigate a series of murders in which the perpetrators claim they were instructed to commit the crime by an angel. Sam fervently believes angels are real, especially after the angel tells him he needs Sam to stop a bad guy. Dean

2.12 Nightshifter

Jan 15th, 2021 58m 4s

Sam and Dean get in "squeal-like-a-pig trouble" when they encounter Ronald Reznick, a crazy security guard who survived a robbery and is now convinced that only he can bring the "mandroid" thief to justice. He takes a bank full of customers and

2.11 Playthings

Jan 8th, 2021 23m 54s

Dean and Sam work a case at an old-school haunted hotel to take Sam's mind off the unsuccessful search for Ava. Sam turns out to be a pretty miserable drunk who extracts an impossible promise from Dean. Dean fails to notice many obvious referen

Holiday Update

Dec 22nd, 2020 5m 11s

No new episode this week, sorry. Just an update with some scheduling information and a heartfelt plea to our fans. See you next year! Happy holidays and I hope for all our sakes that 2021 is better than 2020. Contact us! Email: plushienatural@g

2.10 Hunted

Dec 15th, 2020 29m 26s

Sam makes a new friend, fellow Psychic Kid Ava, when her vision tips him off that an old "friend," fellow hunter Gordon Walker, is trying to kill him before he becomes the Boy King of Hell. Dean 🧸 does the Plot Recap, his put-upon cohost Aman

2.09 Croatoan

Dec 8th, 2020 34m 38s

Another death vision of Sam's leads the Winchesters to a small town in Oregon that seems to be experiencing a pandemic. (Because that's what we want to watch as escapism in December 2020, right?) A demonic rage virus is causing townspeople to a

Thanksgiving Week Update

Nov 24th, 2020 1m 51s

There's no new podcast episode this week. Sorry. Thanks for listening to this short announcement. If you're in the US, happy Thanksgiving from Dean🧸, Amanda, and Sammy 🧸.

2.08 Crossroad Blues

Nov 17th, 2020 47m 42s

This week, Supernatural introduces an important creature to the mytharc: the Crossroads Demon. These red-eyed demons make deals with humans--the human can have whatever they want as long as they allow the demon to collect their soul in ten year

2.07 The Usual Suspects

Nov 10th, 2020 27m 16s

Special Guest Star Linda Blair (The Exorcist) plays a tough-as-nails police detective investigating Dean for murder (AGAIN) who ends up needing their help when she runs afoul of the vengeful spirit Sam and Dean are hunting. Dean 🧸 gives the P

2.06 No Exit

Nov 3rd, 2020 34m 21s

This week, we're talking about season 2, episode 6, "No Exit." Jo decides she wants to hunt and runs away to Philadelphia to work a case. Dean and Sam get involved when Jo can't handle it on her own. She gets captured by the restless spirit of

2.05 Simon Said

Oct 27th, 2020 35m 6s

It's Ben Edlund's first Supernatural episode, which means the freaks have come out to play. This week's freaks--I mean, Special Children--are Andy Gallagher, a lovable stoner with the power of psychic mind control and a seriously awesome van, a

2.04 Children Shouldn't Play with Dead Things

Oct 20th, 2020 26m 54s

Sam and Dean stumble onto yet another case in Lawrence while they’re visiting Mary’s (empty) grave. The case involves an undead college student and the pathetic TA who brought her back with Ancient Greek necromancy. It’s a case that causes bo5h

2.03 Bloodlust

Oct 14th, 2020 23m 58s

Sam and Dean run into a fellow hunter, Gordon Walker, on a vampire case who turns out to be Real Bad News. Join us for a deep dive into the psychology of Gordon Walker, played by the amazing Sterling K. Brown before he won his first Emmy, and D

2.02 Everybody Loves a Clown

Oct 6th, 2020 20m 9s

Season Two gets underway by introducing a new location, the Roadhouse, with its own cast of recurring characters, including crusty bartender Ellen, her daughter Jo, and Ash, an MIT dropout with a mullet straight out of Joe Dirt. Sam and Dean ta

S2E1 In My Time of Dying

Mar 21st, 2020 49m 19s

We've made it to Season 2! In this episode, we see the fallout from the car crash cliffhanger that ended Season 1. Dean's in a coma and almost dead, John's a lying liar who lies, and Sam's making really unsubtle metaphors involving the totaled

SPNDC Con Recap Special

Feb 17th, 2020 42m 18s

Plushienatural hosts Amanda and Dean attended Creation Entertainment's Supernatural convention in the Washington, DC area from November 1-3, 2019. In this special preseason episode, they recap the con panels as well as their adventures in kara

S1E22 Devil's Trap

Oct 22nd, 2019 1h 6m

We made it! It's the end of the first season of Supernatural in episode 22, "Devil's Trap." Longtime Winchester ally Bobby Singer is introduced, the demon possessing Meg is exorcised, killing her body in the process, the boys help John escape t

S1E21 Salvation

Oct 15th, 2019 38m 50s

The Winchesters are in a tough spot this week in Season 1, Episode 21, "Salvation." Meg's killing John's friends in order to get him to hand over the Colt, which Sam and Dean need in order to kill the Yellow-Eyed Demon, who's planning to attack

S1E20 Dead Man's Blood

Oct 8th, 2019 46m 1s

We're in the home stretch! This week we're kicking the Season 1 mytharc into high gear with Episode 20, "Dead Man's Blood," in which the death of John's hunter friend at the hands of vampires allows the Winchesters to obtain a weapon that can a

S1E19 Provenance

Oct 1st, 2019 48m 2s

This week's episode is a Goth's dream. Season 1, episode 19, "Provenance" features a creepy painting, a creepy doll, and an incredibly creepy little girl whose favorite pastime is giving Colombian neckties. It also has the first potential love

S1E18 Something Wicked

Sep 19th, 2019 37m 50s

It's a Weechester flashback fiesta this week in Season 1, episode 18, "Something Wicked," in which Dean goes to a small town in Wisconsin at John's insistence to finish a literal witch hunt that John abandoned 16 years prior for reasons we don'

1.17 - Hell House

Sep 17th, 2019 51m 14s

This week, Amanda and the Winchestbears tackle one of her very favorite episodes, Season 1, episode 17, "Hell House." This episode introduces the longest-living characters in the history of Supernatural, a divisive pair who come to be known as

S1E16 - Shadow

Sep 10th, 2019 30m 12s

It's one Hell of an episode this week as we discover the truth about Meg Masters from Andover, MA and her connection to the Monster of the Week. We've also got a bit of a format change, as Dean does the Plot Recap and Amanda does a Feels Recap